SPECIAL COVERAGE
CHANDIGARH

LUDHIANA

DELHI



THE TRIBUNE SPECIALS
50 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE

TERCENTENARY CELEBRATIONS
O P I N I O N S

Editorials | Article | Middle | Saturday Review

EDITORIALS

No reason to fear
Misinformation spreads panic
Indians from various parts of the country live and work all over the nation. They sometimes move from home to go to boarding school in another part of the nation, and many work and raise families wherever they find better prospects. There is no doubt that India is home to many ethnic groups, it is also a nation in which many languages are spoken, and people follow different faiths.

Going back to work
Maruti operations need a re-look
M
aruti Suzuki will resume production at its troubled Manesar plant on August 21—a day ahead of the Chairman, Osamu Suzuki’s visit to India for the company’s general body meeting. The management needs to do an honest introspection about what went wrong at Manesar on July 19 and before that last year.



EARLIER STORIES

Stuck with reforms
August 17, 201
2
Baba’s second show
August 15, 201
2
Good, but not good enough
August 14, 201
2
Look beyond relief
August 13, 201
2
Divided in merger
August 12, 201
2
Caste-based promotions
August 11, 201
2
Storm in a tea cup
August 10, 201
2
Rare honour for Ansari
August 9, 201
2
Pranab irritants dumped
August 8, 201
2
Company Hooda keeps
August 7, 201
2
Combating rain shortfall
August 6, 201
2
The power Gridlock
August 5, 201
2


Shocking gender crimes
Weak law and order responsible
W
hat makes young men bold enough to carry out their fancies? Only, in terms of stalking young women and making their life miserable. An absolute lack of fear for the consequences of their actions, for there is almost no fear of the law. This gives them a false sense of power over women, they think, they can control. Else, how could three young men enter a house in Mohali in broad daylight and slash a girl’s face and arms, along with that of her mother’s. The girl’s mother had only reprimanded the boys for stalking her 16- year- old daughter, who was being harassed by these young men.

ARTICLE

From JP to Anna Hazare
How to save a movement against corruption
by Kuldip Nayar
I
T is not the first time that the Comptroller and Auditor-General (CAG) of India has disclosed the government’s involvement in a scam. What is disconcerting this time is that Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has been accused of keeping away the CAG report from Parliament on coal bungling, running into Rs. 1.45 lakh crore.

MIDDLE

True life hero
by Simrita Dhir
T
o him, the gurdwara was more than just a haunt where the community congregated to worship. It was the most sacred aspect of his being, an aspect that he cherished and honoured. In founding and establishing that gurdwara, he had espoused his most pulsating impulse, the impulse to serve, without discrimination and without the expectation of acknowledgement. And on the fateful day of August 5 during the mass shooting at that gurdwara in Milwalkee, Wisconsin, the site which was his life and his passion became his final battlefield where he attained martyrdom.

Saturday REVIEW

CINEMA: NEW Releases
Tiger growls, lacks bite
Nonika Singh
W
hen the film is titled Ek Tha Tiger, you expect a once-upon-a-time riveting tale of a man who is brave and brawny and whose exploits will keep you glued to the screen. And the first scene promises to take you into the world of intrigue, the undercover machinations of RAW and ISI. But move over.

Movies on TV

 







Top








 
EDITORIALS

No reason to fear
Misinformation spreads panic

Indians from various parts of the country live and work all over the nation. They sometimes move from home to go to boarding school in another part of the nation, and many work and raise families wherever they find better prospects. There is no doubt that India is home to many ethnic groups, it is also a nation in which many languages are spoken, and people follow different faiths.

India has always shone because of its unity in diversity and thus it is strange that suddenly there is a degree of tension in people hailing from the North-East who now reside in various cities, away from their place of origin. A sense of panic, which has led to many people leaving cities and boarding trains back home, can’t quite be explained in the light of any immediate happenings, even the incident in which students from the region were attacked in Pune last week. There is, however, a sense of alienation which people from the North-East felt in other parts of the country, which has simmered for long, but not been addressed. This partially explains why bulk SMSes and other means of communication effectively spread panic even in cosmopolitan cities like Pune, Hyderabad, Mysore, Chennai and Bangalore.

Political leaders in both Houses of Parliament spoke in one voice to assure the people of the North- East that they are safe anywhere in the country. They asked them not to panic on the basis of rumours and urged them to go back to their places of work and educational institutions they study in. The Chief Ministers of the affected states have given reassuring statements, various NGOs have intervened, some steps have been taken to stop bulk SMSes and various government agencies are tracking down people who could be responsible for spreading such malicious rumours. To paraphrase the words of US President Franklin D Roosevelt, “The only thing we have to fear, is fear itself!” Misinformation should not be the basis of decision-making. People from the North-East are very much a part of the Indian mainstream; the government and the people of India must make the extra effort to make them feel safe and secure, no matter which part of the nation they are in.

Top

 

Going back to work
Maruti operations need a re-look

Maruti Suzuki will resume production at its troubled Manesar plant on August 21—a day ahead of the Chairman, Osamu Suzuki’s visit to India for the company’s general body meeting. The management needs to do an honest introspection about what went wrong at Manesar on July 19 and before that last year. It should ask: why are frequent labour troubles causing such heavy financial losses to the company? Japanese management practices and cordial employer-employee relations are world famous. It is time to find out whether those at the helm at Maruti Suzuki followed them or there is something wrong about Indian labour, unions and laws.

According to one estimate, the Manesar plant, which produces some of the best-selling Maruti cars, is set to suffer a loss of Rs 2,000 crore during the shutdown. Last year it lost Rs 2,500 crore due to worker-management disputes. This is a huge loss for any company. The Maruti Suzuki management, perhaps, could have avoided the human and financial bloodshed had it done earlier what it is planning to do now: paying the regular and contract employees the same salary. The company has decided not to depend on contractors for hiring workers and it will start recruiting its own staff from September 2. For short-term gains, the company resorted to unethical, if not illegal, practices and ended up paying a heavy price.

The union leaders and workers who burnt to death a manager and beat up others, and set the office property on fire deserve no sympathy and the management has shown none. It has issued termination notices to 500 of its 1,500 regular workers, including 154 of those in police custody. Production will resume in phases under heavy security provided by the management and the Haryana government. Since Suzuki is a global name, any trouble at its Indian plant is widely noticed. This sends a wrong signal about India in general and Haryana in particular.

Top

 

Shocking gender crimes
Weak law and order responsible

What makes young men bold enough to carry out their fancies? Only, in terms of stalking young women and making their life miserable. An absolute lack of fear for the consequences of their actions, for there is almost no fear of the law. This gives them a false sense of power over women, they think, they can control. Else, how could three young men enter a house in Mohali in broad daylight and slash a girl’s face and arms, along with that of her mother’s. The girl’s mother had only reprimanded the boys for stalking her 16- year- old daughter, who was being harassed by these young men.

Thankfully, India does not have a Taliban-like outfit. Girls can move freely and do whatever they wish to. The Indian Constitution accords them equal rights. But, a complete lack of fear of the law is creating a situation where young men have begun to think they can get away with any crime that involves women. Raksha Sharma committed suicide because she was harassed by some boys on the social networking site. A little confidence in the law machinery would have made her seek protection from the law rather than lose her life.

It is unfortunate that a grown-up girl of sixteen needs to be chaperoned by her mother in a city like Chandigarh, at all the time, as the mother of the young woman from Mohali was forced to do. Even after lodging a complaint with the Chandigarh Police, the mother and the daughter had to suffer, because the Chandigarh Police failed to inform the Mohali police about the registration number of the bike the boys were riding. From the very powerful to the very ordinary, something about our social reality makes men feel empowered. And women are getting marginalised, despite all their strengths. Now, they are not safe even inside their homes.

Top

 

Thought for the Day

One lives in the hope of becoming a memory. — Antonio Porchia

Top

 
ARTICLE

From JP to Anna Hazare
How to save a movement against corruption
by Kuldip Nayar

IT is not the first time that the Comptroller and Auditor-General (CAG) of India has disclosed the government’s involvement in a scam. What is disconcerting this time is that Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has been accused of keeping away the CAG report from Parliament on coal bungling, running into Rs. 1.45 lakh crore.

The Prime Minister told Parliament on May 23 this year that the CAG report was only a draft while the fact which has come to light is that the final report was received on May 11 both by the government and the President’s office. It means that there is nothing sacrosanct for the Congress-led coalition, even Parliament’s privileges, much less transparency that one expected from a government headed by Dr Manmohan Singh.

The government is only a forwarding agency as far as reports by the CAG are concerned. He directly reports to Parliament through the government as he did in the case of corruption in coal, a portfolio directly under the Prime Minister. How he rationalises the delay — he is a master in doing so — will be something which I await. Yet the corruption part is really serious. Certain private parties and individuals are said to have been given benefits. They must have rendered service in kind and cash to the ruling party.

The sad part is that when a movement against corruption was needed the most, Gandhian Anna Hazare, leading it, changes his strategy and thinks about contesting elections in 2014. Although he looked reluctant and expressed doubts in public, he seemed to have been prevailed upon by those who have always focused their eyes on the electoral politics. Some of them may well be members of the team which Hazare has now disbanded.

Yet abandoning a movement which had come to ventilate the resentment of civil society was leaving a job in the middle. True, the government was obtrusive and did not want to give a strong Lokpal (Ombudsman). Equally true, the opposition parties were indifferent. This was all the more reason why the movement for a Lokpal needed to be intensified.

The failing health of some members who went on fast was one reason why the movement had to be restructured to give an excuse for dropping the fasts. In fact, fasts are a wrong strategy to begin with. Mahatma Gandhi’s fast was never against anybody. They were always positive in their nature and he was engaged in wresting freedom from the unwilling hands of the British.

With no immediate challenge on corruption, the government has blessed the move of the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) not to go in appeal on the rejection of disproportionate assets case against former UP Chief Minister Mayawati. Even her 21 votes in the Lok Sabha are important for the Manmohan Singh government to show a majority in Parliament.

And it seems obvious that the Congress will stick to office for the rest of the term, roughly 22 months, even if it has to play false as it has done in the case of the CAG report on coal and even if it has turned a blind eye to Mayawati’s assets which are unexplainable. She has reportedly amassed a wealth of Rs 116 crore since 2003.

Indeed, this is the best time for Anna to enter the political field. But can a party rise from the ashes of a movement which had swept the intelligentsia off its feet and had kept the media focused for 18 months? In concrete terms, the movement has nothing to show. But the awakening of civil society is itself an achievement of sorts.

Whether Anna can convert the awakening process into a voting process is yet to be seen. One thing which is in his favour is that he is being associated with an alternative to the Congress and the BJP, the two main political parties. People generally want a change and not either of the two at the helm of affairs again.

Gandhian Jayaprakash Narayan (JP) was forced into a similar situation but accepted the Jana Sangh, the predecessor of the BJP, after the Jan Sangh promised him to cut off relations with the RSS. He was betrayed but in the process the Jana Sangh got the credibility of a non-communal set-up.

A similar situation faces Anna when Baba Ramdev wants the two of them together. Secularism and parochialism do not mix well. JP made the mistake and parochial forces gained from it. Anna should not traverse the same path. He has to stand alone when Baba Ramdev and his musclemen try to make a united stand. Their culture is different and civil society is not willing to accept them.

The mantle of JP has fallen on Anna. But JP travelled throughout India to awaken people to the need to have an alternative and defeat the rulers who have mutilated the very system to serve their purpose and sustain the status quo which gives them power and unfettered control.

I am not against Anna taking part in elections. He himself is having second thoughts. Yet it would have been far better if he had held wider consultations with activists like Medha Patkar and Aruna Roy. Such consultations did take place before Anna had begun his stir against corruption. He must string together the various movements, however small, which are visibly working at the grassroots level. These activists will provide grist to the mill of change that Anna is contemplating.

Maybe, a political platform, instead of a party, may serve a wider purpose. Some can work with the people’s movements and some contest elections. They will help each other and together they will be a force to reckon with. Mahatma Gandhi had separated constructive workers from those engaged in the legislative field.

JP did not form the party till after winning at the polls. Yet he saw to it that his, candidates would fight on one symbol. What proved to be his Achille’s heal was the wrong candidates he chose. They were not the people to effect changes. They used the system to benefit themselves. And then JP’s health failed and he could not reach out to the people.

Anna should be careful about his health and slowly but relentlessly harness support among those close associates who have the commitment and faith in basic values. He should take time. But he cannot afford to fail for the second time. Politics is not bad. Those who dominate it at this time have given it a bad name.

Top

 
MIDDLE

True life hero
by Simrita Dhir

To him, the gurdwara was more than just a haunt where the community congregated to worship. It was the most sacred aspect of his being, an aspect that he cherished and honoured. In founding and establishing that gurdwara, he had espoused his most pulsating impulse, the impulse to serve, without discrimination and without the expectation of acknowledgement. And on the fateful day of August 5 during the mass shooting at that gurdwara in Milwalkee, Wisconsin, the site which was his life and his passion became his final battlefield where he attained martyrdom.

When Satwant Singh Kaleka heard gun shots and saw a gunman marching towards the gurdwara he did not have to ponder over his course of action. He quickly grabbed a butter knife from the gurdwara kitchen and marched headstrong towards the gunman because there was “no way” that he could let anyone harm the innocent, least of all that peaceful, meditating community inside his beloved gurdwara.

Unmindful of his life, he grappled with and attacked the gunman as multiple bullets pierced him from close range. He managed to deter the gunman for a period allowing the crowds to run for cover, thereby saving the lives of a large number of devotees and in so doing he gloriously uplifted the Sikh tradition of “Kabhi na chhore khet”, which implies that never give in, irrespective of the odds.

Kaleka came from a family known for its extraordinary valour. His father, Major Pritam Singh Kaleka, was honoured with five medals for exemplary bravery during his service and his brother, Captain Amarjit Singh Kaleka, won the Gallantry Award during the 1965 Indo-Pakistan war. By going down in a blaze of glory on that gory summer morning in Milwalkee, Kaleka continued his family’s tradition of heroism. His courageous act of righteousness has sparked acclaim from global leaders.

While Kaleka’s sacrifice beautifully delineates all that he stood for, even his life was a brave testimonial of service to his faith. Born in village Duggal in Patiala district, he had immigrated to the United States in 1982. Armed with his faith and the will to work, he found success as an entrepreneur. In his everyday life, he was inspired and motivated by Nishkam Seva, Sikhism’s shining premise, that advocates selfless service without discrimination. The lives of numerous new immigrants were touched by his amazing generosity of spirit.

Sustained by the faith, Kaleka and his wife raised their two boys to become men of reckoning. Their elder son went on to become a Milwalkee police officer and the younger an Emmy Award winning documentary film maker.

In embracing death on that blood-soaked morning this August, Satwant Singh Kaleka valiantly elevated the Sikh ethos of giving up one’s life for the sake of truth and dignity that has been celebrated in the Sikh lore for 500 years. His life is an example of how each of us can rise above our ordinariness in extraordinary times by finding the strength to put up a fearless fight. He will forever be an enduring manifestation of a life and a purpose fulfilled.

Top

 
SATURDAY REVIEW

CINEMA: NEW Releases
Tiger growls, lacks bite
Nonika Singh

RATINGS: *****Excellent ****Very Good  ***Good **Average *Poor

When the film is titled Ek Tha Tiger, you expect a once-upon-a-time riveting tale of a man who is brave and brawny and whose exploits will keep you glued to the screen. And the first scene promises to take you into the world of intrigue, the undercover machinations of RAW and ISI. But move over.

Scene two, a long action-packed chase picturised in Iraq involving who else but the superstar Salman Khan (no prizes for guessing he is the Tiger, a RAW agent), establishes the tone and temper of the movie. Not to be taken seriously, here is a film that is no more no less than a showcase of the superstar on whose cult status the movie rides. So what makes Tiger special is that he is Salman, not because he is a well-delineated, well-researched or even well-nuanced character. So facts like he has been on continuous 12 dangerous assignments are mere trivia not character enhancing traits.

Salman Khan and Katrina Kaif
Striking chemistry
: Salman Khan and Katrina Kaif
Action drama: Salman packs a punch
Action drama: Salman packs a punch

No wonder few scenes into the movie as Tiger returns home, you know where the film is going. His informal interaction with his boss Girish Karnad (over a baati of dal) reminiscing how he let duty win over his love isn't a red herring but a dead giveaway that even a mentally challenged person can grasp. And good enough, soon Katrina Kaif makes her entry as Zoya settled in Ireland which is where Tiger is sent on yet another mission. Their falling in love is a forgone conclusion. Now cross-border love stories have been the leitmotif of many a film. Yash Raj banner who has produced Ek Tha Tiger did give us a memorable one. Veer Zaara was one such epic love story. Yet what you get here is a sloppy love story whose singular twist adds a little zing but no depth.

Moving on three tangents, love, action and thriller, there is little poignancy or pathos in the love story. The storyline despite surprise elements here and there is limp if not outright ludicrous. Humour surfaces every now and then albeit works at a very basic level. In fact, the only intelligible thing in the movie supposedly about intelligent intelligence agents lies in the dialogue — how many countries are there in the world? Beyond that it's an amalgamation of incredible action sequences enacted by Sallu bhai with aplomb.

Salman is, well, Salman. Both superstar and superman, who can climb pipes, jump buildings, take on a dozen armed men at a time and, of course, romance with his lady love. Minus the buffoonery, here he is a bit vulnerable too, when it comes to Katrina’s character with whom his chemistry is unmistakable. Katrina looks good, better in the second part, in which she incidentally matches former boyfriend in the action department too. Ranvir Shorey as Salman's confidante- cum-colleague is competent and our Punjabi actor Gavie Chahal as the ISI agent, despite a brief role makes his presence felt.

In the second half, the pace and action keep you engaged, even though the storyline remains tardy. Where director Kabeer Khan scores is that he has kept the length just right. No unwanted flashbacks, no excess baggage and the cat and mouse chase in the climax is suitably handled. Picturesque locations are in sync with Yash Raj signature style. But production values and action alone don't make a movie. At no point do you fall in love with the love story that has twist and tang but no emotive power.

Strictly for Salman Khan fans or not, they would, anyway, love it. In case, you fall in the minority of not being one, tone down expectations and you may find it watchable. If for nothing else, watch it to know what makes a film collect a whopping Rs 32 crores in a single day.

Watch out for

Shirin Farhad Ki Nikal Padi

It’s an unusual romantic-comedy film with Boman Irani and Farah Khan in the lead roles. Farhad Pastakiya (Boman Irani), is a 45-year-old Parsi bachelor who works as a lingerie salesman. He has not been able to find the love of his life and people around him have lost hope of his doing so. The only women who call the shots in his life are his mother Nargis and doting grandmother Siloo. One day, Shirin (Farah Khan) walks into his shop and their love story begins. The film promises to be a fun ride and is expected to release on August 24.

Joker

It’s a fantasy film directed by Shirin Kunder. The film is about aliens who come visiting to a small village. Joker is the story of Agastya (Akshay Kumar), a researcher who tries to find the existence of aliens in the universe. In the process, he returns to his village with his wife Diva (Sonakshi Sinha). This is the lead pair’s second film together after the successful Rowdy Rathore. The out of luck Agastya takes it upon himself to put his crazy village on the global map and continues with his alien exploration from there. Chitrangada Singh has also performed an item number in the film, titled, Kafirana. The film is slated to hit the theatres on August 31.

Top

 

Movies on TV

Saturday August 18

Knight and Day

Star movies 9:00PM

Knight and Day is a 2010 romantic, action, comedy film starring Tom Cruise and Cameron Diaz. The film is directed by James Mangold. The film follows the adventures of Roy Miller (Tom Cruise), a spy on the run, and June Havens (Cameron Diaz), a car refurbisher. Miller is seen watching Havens, and he bumps into her a couple of times as they go through security at Wichita Airport.

FILMY

8:00AM Jai Maa 11:30AM Mawaali 3:00PM Mulzim 6:00PM Jurassic City, 9:30PM Pati Patni aur Woh

STAR GOLD

8:45AM Force 11:40AM Sivaji: The Boss 2:30PM Chup Chup Ke 18:00pm Taqdeerwala 9:00PM Singham

HBO

7:25AM Assassins 10:10AM Cats & Dogs: The Revenge of Kitty Galore 12:00PM Rush Hour 2:00PM Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1 5:00PM Doom 7:00PM Take Me Home Tonight 9:00PM The Mask 11:10PM Ong Bak 2

ZEE CINEMA

7:25AM Shagird 10:45AM Seeta Aur Geeta 2:35PM Aparichit: The Stranger 5:55PM Hungama 9:00PM Nayak

STAR MOVIES

6:44AM Air Force One 9:14AM The Legend of Zorro 11:49AM The Front Row with Anupama Chopra 12:19PM Rio 1:53PM Night at the Museum 2: Battle of the Smithsonian 4:07PM Pirates of The Caribbean: On Stranger Tides 6:45PM Knight and Day 9:00PM The Karate Kid 11:51PM Fantastic Four

MOVIES OK

6:00AM Sadak 8:30AM Fun2shh 11:30AM Tees Maar Khan 2:15PM Dil Hai Tumhaara 5:50PM Dulhe Raja 9:00PM Jaanbaaz Ki Jung 11:20PM Jaanbaaz Ki Jung

Sunday August 19

Patiala House

MOVIES OK 9:00PM
The movie is about Gattu (Akshay Kumar) who is living the life his father (Rishi Kapoor) chose for him. Gattu had been good at cricket and wanted to play for England, though his dad would never let him become a member of the British team. Gattu's girlfriend Simran (Anushka Sharma) and siblings convince him to give it a shot. The film is directed by Nikhil Advani.

MOVIES OK

6:00AM Vijaypath 12:20PM Maine Pyaar Kyun Kiya 3:30PM Barood - Man On Mission 5:50PM Patiala House 9:00PM Golimaar

ZEE CINEMA

7:30AM Do Ankhen Barah Haath 10:40AM God Tussi Great Ho 2:10PM Naseeb 5:50PM Mera Badla 9:00PM Hindustani Yodha

FILMY

8:00AM Jai Ganesh Deva 11:30AM Chhoti Bahu 3:00PM No Entry 6:00PM Chala Mussaddi: Office Office 9:30PM Darna Zaroori Hai 11:30PM Yaadon Aur Chaahaton Ke Darmiyaan

STAR GOLD

6:00AM Apne 9:40AM Bal Ganesh 11:55AM Kabhi Khushi Kabhie Gham... 4:20PM Main Balwan 6:45PM Hero No. 1 9:00PM Kahaani 11:40PM Star Box Office 11:50PM Kahaani

STAR MOVIES

7:58AM Big Daddy 9:58AM Hitman 11:58AM The Karate Kid 2:26PM Speed 4:48PM Fantastic Four 6:57PM Elephant White 11:31PM Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer

HBO

8:05AM Take Me Home Tonight 10:05AM Hop 12:10PM The Mask 2:25PM Doom 4:30PM Ong Bak 2 6:30PM Peter Pan 9:00PM Step Up 11:10PM
Rush Hour 3

Top

 





HOME PAGE | Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir | Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs | Nation | Opinions |
| Business | Sports | World | Letters | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | Delhi |
| Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | Suggestion | E-mail |