|
Serious journalism must
remain part of democratic dharma High drama
and low comedy |
|
|
On
Record
Profile Reflections Diversities
— Delhi Letter
|
High drama and low comedy DURING the last few days there has been a plethora of events — some of them yet tortuously proceeding towards their denouement — that have produced high drama, low comedy and an element of tragedy, altogether adding up to a situation that cannot make anyone happy. The latest of these episodes was the belated delivery of the full judgment of the Supreme Court on the Bihar Assembly dissolution case. Though not unexpected, the full judgment was shocking. It held the Bihar Governor, Mr Buta Singh, guilty of “mala fides” and regretted the Centre’s failure to verify the Governor’s “flight of fancy” before acting on his advice. But, true to form, Mr Buta Singh was defiant and refused to resign. However, after taking the salute at the Republic Day, on which he was insistent, he did put in his papers. All through this interval, in New Delhi, there was the usual dithering. Detailed comment on the monumental mess about the appointment of governors and their conduct must wait. For the present, notice has to be taken of events like the Congress party’s plenary session at Hyderabad that turned out to be a mixture of a tamasha — with a lot of well-orchestrated noise hailing the 36-year-old Mr Rahul Gandhi as the party’s only messiah — and undisguised depression over the grim developments in Karnataka. The most significant message to emerge from Hyderabad was that coalition dharma — desperately needed in our times — is conspicuous by its absence. Having had to swallow strident demands and stern warnings from its allies, especially the Leftists, for 20 months, the Congress has at last hit back with surprising vigour. It has even conjured up visions of the party winning a majority in the Lok Sabha on its own — a hope that must have been whetted by a TV channel’s public opinion poll. However, the Congress party’s appeal to its allies to realise that there was “such a thing as collective responsibility” means little when there is no collectivity even among the Congress ministers in the United Progressive Alliance government, nor the requisite synergy between the Prime Minister’s Office and the Congress party establishment. The Leftists are not the only source of trouble for the Congress. Even smaller allies, representing regional parties, give it headache. The government’s Sri Lanka policy, for instance, has become victim of the petty politics played by Tamil Nadu allies. Ms Sonia Gandhi is perhaps right in believing that despite the internal strife within the UPA, the ruling coalition would not collapse any time soon. But she skates on thin ice when she claims that “contradictions” within the UPA are, in fact, a sign that “national challenges” are being met with “national responses”. For, the reality is that the UPA’s raison d’etre — to keep the BJP at bay — is already eroded. The saffron camp is no longer as untouchable as it was in May 2004. First, Mr Nitish Kumar in Bihar, as secular a leader as you can find, had no compunction to capture power with the BJP as his ally. Now, Mr Deve Gowda, calling his party Janata Dal (Secular) has delivered an even more shattering blow to the secular-versus-communal doctrine. After shedding crocodile tears over his son, Mr H.D. Kumaraswamy’s masterstroke of charting a path to become Karnataka Chief Minister by joining hands with the BJP, the former Prime Minister is playing both ends of the street. Few have any doubt that Mr Gowda and his over-ambitious son are acting in concert. Indeed, wags are saying that, as in other parties, so in Karnataka’s JD (S), it is a question of “sonrise”. The Karnataka Chief Minister, Mr Dharam Singh, who resigned on Saturday, may be as good or bad a chief minister as any. But his weighty presence reminds one of what Jawaharlal Nehru said of a British Viceroy, “Heavy of body, slow of mind, firm like a rock and with a rock’s understanding”. This might explain his maladroit attempts to cut the ground from under Mr Gowda’s feet. About the constant chants at the Congress plenary for giving greater responsibility to Mr Rahul Gandhi — described by many delegates at Hyderabad as their “greatest hope” — the only saving grace was the young man’s own sensible intervention in the debate to tell the shrieking horde that leadership had to be built brick by brick, not conferred on anyone. The real tragedy about the dramas at Hyderabad and Bangalore is that these have diverted attention from three simultaneous and alarming happenings that symbolize everything that is eating into the country’s vitals. The suspension of the Mumbai police officer, once considered a hero and now alleged to be the worst villain, only underscores how irremediable the scourge of corruption in the Indian system has become. Far more shocking and representative of the all-round rot is the deplorable role that the already much-disgraced Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) has played in the most squalid Ottavio Quattrocchi affair. It first accepted full responsibility for sending a law officer to Britain to enable the Italian businessman, still a prime accused in the unending Bofors case, to get away with his frozen funds amounting to nearly six million dollars. And now it has the temerity to tell the Supreme Court that it would continue to strive for Mr Quattrocchi’s “extradition” to India! Sadly, this is entirely in keeping with its dubious conduct in the cases relating to the demolition of Babri Masjid, involving Mr L.K. Advani and other BJP leaders; to the Taj corridor in which Ms. Mayawati, the leader of the Bahujan Samaj Party (BSP), is impugned; and the St. Kitts affair in which that curious combination of a “godman” and a “godfather”, Chandraswami, was allowed to go scot-free because of the agency’s failure to produce easily available evidence. What is in common in all these cases is that the CBI has acted at every stage and at every step strictly in accordance with its crass calculations about the prevailing political wind. Under these circumstances, is it any surprise that the third and the horrifying development — the escalation of vicious violence by insurgent groups in Assam and elsewhere — has gone almost completely
unnoticed? |
On Record
Professor Dr
Tahir Mahmood, Member of the National Commission for Religious and
Linguistic Minorities, Government of India, is the Founder-Chairman of
the Amity University Institute of Advanced Legal Studies. A specialist
in the laws on religion, religious minorities and human rights, he has
42 years of experience in teaching and research and has authored a
large number of books to his credit. Excerpts: Q: What about
the functions of the National Commission for Religious and Linguistic
Minorities? A: This is a short-term and non-statutory Commission
to report on the minorities’ demand for reservation in government
employment and educational institutions. The issue of exclusion of
Christian and Muslim Dalits from the exorbitant benefits
accorded to the Scheduled Castes has also been referred to this
Commission. We have to submit the findings by April 30. Q: Why
don’t we have an independent and apolitical watchdog group? A: Statutory
bodies like the NHRC, NCM and NCW are meant to be "apolitical
watchdogs". It depends on how those who man them fulfil their
statutory obligations. These bodies must be in independent and
non-political hands. Q: What about the demand for a uniform civil
code? A: An innocuous constitutional provision for a possible
uniformity in civil laws has been gravely misunderstood and is being
exploited by vested interests. It has to be seen in its true
perspective and must be kept off politics. Q:
Counter-reactionaries (groups or individuals) have come up in minority
communities? Why? A: Lack of legal literacy and proper
information about the issues have led to such a phenomenon. The remedy
lies in effectively educating the masses, including the minorities
about their real problems and the actual issues. Q: If the Muslims
had a leader like one in yesteryears, would their problems have been
better dealt with? A: I am against denominational leadership. All
national leaders represent India as a whole, not of particular
communities. All of them must be equally concerned about the
minorities rights. Q: Communal biases and rigidities in each
community have increased in recent years, especially among the
educated? Why? A: Surely, the condition of 140 million Indian
Muslim citizens should have been far better today. Whatever
"communal biases and rigidities" exist in various
communities must be eradicated. Nobody should be allowed to doubt
anybody else’s patriotism, and the constitutional principle of
absolute equality of all citizens must be respected by everyone in
belief and practice. |
Profile The
architect of Infosys Technologies, Nandan Nilekani was in distant Davos when he was conferred with the Padma Bhushan, the country’s third highest honour, planning India’s strategy at the World Economic Forum. Of all things, he did not expect the Padma Bhushan. His first reaction was of dismay: “What? Wonderful !”. He then paused and uttered just a few words: “It’s a tremendous honour…it feels really good”. At Davos, Nilekani has been conceptualising “India Everywhere” — a systematic and holistic strategy to create a positive environment about India. The plan is to project India as the biggest market democracy. Currently holding the post of Chief Executive and Managing Director of Infosys, Nilekani is turning out to be a prodigy in the sphere of Information Technology and management. A graduate of the Indian Institute of Technology (IIT), Mumbai, he does not hold any ceremonial management degree. Yet, he has demonstrated superb managerial skill. He, along with N. R. Narayan Murthy, received the Fortune magazine’s “Asia’s Businessmen of the year 2003” Award. According to a survey conducted by the Financial Times, Nilekani is regarded as one of world’s most respected business leaders. Nilekani is only 49. How did he reach the dizzy heights of success in such a short span? Hard work, time management and team work have been his key words to success. “I believe that meritocracy and hard work are the foundation of all successful individuals and institutions. I would advice all young men and women to recognise, learn and assimilate changes and have the ability work as part of a team, submitting individual glory to team achievement”, he says. For a man who started off as a software engineer and became head of one of India’s most admired companies, it has been a long journey in shortest possible time. He has indeed come a long way. When Nilekani entered the IIT campus in the summer of 1973, he was a common 18-year-old youth from a small town, unused to the life of a big, sophisticated city like Mumbai. When he graduated five years later, he felt he had the experience and confidence to face the world. One fine morning after graduation, Nilekani walked into the cabin of Narayna Murthy — then head of the software group at the Mumbai-based Patni Computer Systems — to seek a job. Their chemistry clicked and Murthy hired the young engineering graduate right away. Neither of them realised at that time that the relationship would last long and go down in India’s corporate history. Three years later in 1981, seven young enthusiasts, led by Nilekani, decided to start their own outfit — Infosys Technologies. The ‘Magnificent Seven’, as they have come to be known, began work in a small flat in Pune owned by Narayan Murthy and with this rewriting the history of domestic software industry of India also began. Later in 1983, they decided to shift the Infosys headquarters to Bangalore which had better infrastructure and better housing facilities. Nilekani works 12 to 14 hours a day and also associates himself with social work. One of his objectives is to raise the level of public governance in India. Currently he chairs an organisation named the Bangalore Agenda Task Force which is a mixture of public and private partnership dedicated to make Bangalore a better city. Outside Bangalore, he is involved in projects involving the improvement of 56 cities in Karnataka apart from e-governance and municipal governance. He is also involved in various initiatives of the Central and state governments. He was Chairman of the Central Government’s IT Task Force for the power sector. Nilekani travels a lot — three to four times a year and, perhaps, thrice a month within the country. He prefers to spend his free time at home with the family. His wife is a writer and novelist in English and the couple has two children — daughter and son. Nilekani looks to Nelson Mandela as a role model. “Mandela’s life has been a great source of inspiration to me. His determination and perseverance in the midst of extreme adversity is truly motivating”, he says. He has steered Infosys to its first billion-dollar revenue in 2003. His company donated $22 million to a charity founded by his wife that focuses on water issues, such as purification, rainwater harvesting and getting supplies to the poor. One of Nilekani’s mantra of management is transparency. “When in doubt, disclose” is one of Infosys’ corporate governance philosophy. Politicians and businessmen do not get proper sleep and some keep awake night. When someone recently asked Nilekani what is the key to sound sleep, his prompt reply was: “The softest pillow is a clear
conscience”. |
Reflections If
we want cities safe for all we will have to do better ‘quality’ and ‘quantity’ policing. Briefly said, it needs to be more ‘people-policing’ in content and approach. This would imply specific, sustained, comprehensive and collective crime prevention measures. Policing would necessarily have to involve all sections of society — men, women, young, elders, poor or rich, urban or rural, educated or not. It must also engage all organised sections of society, including the influential individuals. ‘People-policing’ means collective and mutually supportive policing which is widespread in all residential and business areas comprising rich who do provide for their own security through watchmen or trained personnel hired from private security agencies. It must equally provide for the ‘iron grilled’ middle classes and ‘not so grilled’ lower classes, villages and the ever sprawling open street slums. Some of the measures which would be required to be practiced by all sections of society are:
Safety and security of women in society cannot be provided in isolation. (Which is why it is not in control!) It can best exist through a sustained and closely led system of people-policing equally in participation as well as themselves. Or else it could always go the Meerut way. None of the above ideas are abstract. Wherever these were practiced they yielded results. The only condition is, it has to be ‘people’-policing and not ‘piece-meal’
policing. |
Diversities — Delhi Letter THE New Delhi World Book Fair
took off this weekend. The enthusiasm seems strong for the fair which would
remain open till February 4. Book releases and the accompanying cocktails and
celebrations at the Canadian and Austrian missions. The Afro-Asian Book
Council is focusing on electronic publishing on holding a seminar. Much more
will follow in the coming days as the books would begin unfolding. Let me
focus on a particular book. I am a tea addict, so even a pamphlet on tea
attracts my attention. A couple of days back, a full-fledged book on tea
landed. So you can well imagine the excitement I went through. Titled Tea
and Health — Science Behind The Myths (UBS PD), it is written by Dr
Nikhil Ghosh Hajra, who is the project director of the Darjeeling Tea Research
and Development Centre, Tea Board of India. So amazing are the health
benefits attributed to tea that you feel that the government should make tea
drinking compulsory. He has focussed on every possible ailment and disorder
including Alzheimer’s and together with that focused on the medical role
that tea leaves can play to combat illness of various hues and forms. All too
detailed with scientific and medical inputs. He has put all possible data and
his long years of experience in compiling this book. If only the editing and
layout was better, it would have been one of the best books on tea.
President Bush’s visit to IndiaWill the recent controversial remark of the US Ambassador to India be pushed into the background by March, the time when President George Bush is likely to visit here? Last fortnight during a visit to Hyderabad, I saw huge cutouts of George Bush with this caption in English and Urdu — ‘Bush: A Fool or a Leader’. It was the take-off poster of a new Urdu daily recently launched in that city when the Pravasi Diwas was in full swing. In the Capital, during last week’s meet on peace and earthquake relief operations in both parts of Kashmir, two references came up to President Bush’s visit. A former Pakistan Minister said that one should be careful during his visit. Another speaker reminded of the Chattisinghpora massacre in Kashmir during Clinton’s visit to India. He also made a subtle reference to Mr Bush’s visit. Not to overlook is the fact that any meet here on Iraq does not overlook the role played by the US. Journalists Siddarth Varadarajan and Praful Bidwai spoke not just of America’s intrusion into Iraq but India’s foreign policy vis-à-vis the US. They took on India’s weak stand in condemning the war crimes committed by the US Army. Both lamented that though white phosphorous was used by the invading army on the Iraqi civilian population in Fallojah, there has been no condemnation from any quarter of the world including the Government of India. Another speaker, former diplomat Hamid Ansari minced no words in stating that though America tried to use September 11 bombing as an excuse to intrude into Iraq, "America’s war on Iraq was a ‘conspiracy’ hatched prior to September 11". At this juncture, I cannot really say whether New Delhi’s socialite and management expert Suhel Seth will find an appropriate opportunity to present his full-fledged book on Bush humour which he had compiled and was published by Roli Books. A book full of PJs and more on George Bush. Seminar on GandhiUnion Human Resource Development Minister Arjun Singh is organising a seminar on Mahatma Gandhi on January 30 at Mavlankar Hall. The speakers would include Professor Bipan Chandra and Bollywood’s Farouque Shaikh. Several NGOs are also organising a day-long fast at Rajghat. They would like to focus on the human rights violations of the Kashmiris in the Capital. The organisers say that the Kashmiris are looked upon with suspicion and often subjected to humiliating questions. In
particular, those living in New Delhi are routinely harassed before every
Independence Day and Republic Day. |
Ahimsa means infinite love, which again means infinite capacity for suffering. — Mahatma Gandhi God is joy, unceasing joy. The joy of our senses is but temporal. — The Upanishads To the hasty being, administered reproofs are not pleasant. But the Buddha says, it will be better, not worse, for the one who follows the admonishes. — The Buddha He who himself is beguiled beguiles his comrades too. — Guru Nanak You are going in a hearse to the country of death, bound by hands of feet. — Kabir |
HOME PAGE | |
Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir |
Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs |
Nation | Opinions | | Business | Sports | World | Mailbag | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | Delhi | | Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | Suggestion | E-mail | |