SPECIAL COVERAGE

CHANDIGARH

LUDHIANA

DELHI



THE TRIBUNE SPECIALS
50 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE

TERCENTENARY CELEBRATIONS
punjab
P U N J A B
Top stories | Politics | Community | Courts

TOP STORIES

Finally, work to clean Budha Nullah begins
Ludhiana, December 4
After remaining on paper for more than 20 months, the bio-remediation project to clean the Budha Nullah has finally begun. About 70 tonnes of microbial culture were released into the drain near Jainpur village today.
Officials release microbes into the Budha Nullah in Ludhiana on Tuesday. Officials release microbes into the Budha Nullah in Ludhiana on Tuesday. Photo: Inderjeet Verma

Draft of Contract Farming Act ready
Chandigarh, December 4
The state government is ready with the draft of the Contract Farming Act that will be discussed at a Cabinet meeting here on December 8, say sources. The Act is likely to be passed by the Vidhan Sabha which is to meet later this month.



YOUR TOWN
Amritsar
Chandigarh



EARLIER STORIES



Four officials indicted in garbage land scam
Fatehgarh Sahib, December 4
The special investigation team (SIT) probing the Rs 2.53 crore garbage land scam by officials of the Mandi Gobindgarh Municipal Council has submitted its report to the Sub- Divisional Magistrate, Amloh.

Adopt new technology for agri growth: Sukhbir
Chandigarh, December 4
Farmers need to understand new technologies and processes in order to propel agriculture growth in the state. Punjab with just 1.5 per cent of the total agricultural area in the country had been contributing more than 55 per cent to the nation’s food kitty.





 

POLITICS

Haryana CM questions Punjab Police security to Chautala
Maine (Patiala), December 4
Haryana Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda today questioned the security cover provided to his predecessor Om Parkash Chautala saying the Punjab Police would have to answer as to why it had provided security to him.

COMMUNITY

VB to probe wheat embezzlement scam
Moga, December 4
The Vigilance Bureau would now be probing the alleged wheat embezzlement scam that had come to light in Baghapurana area of the district last year.

Promotion for 23 Faridkot policemen raises eyebrows
Faridkot, December 4
The state government has given out-of-turn promotions to 23 policemen despite the Faridkot police having been under attack for allegedly shielding the accused in the Shruti abduction case.The Faridkot police has been praised for its “extraordinary feat” in cracking the case by arresting all the accused persons and recovering the abducted girl.

Government prepares to outsource selective works
Chandigarh, December 4
The Punjab Government has initiated concrete steps on outsourcing selective tasks to the private sector keeping in mind the cost and quality factors.

Suspected honour killing
Parents of Samana girl booked for murder
Samana, December 4
The Sangrur police has registered an FIR pertaining to the alleged murder of 15-year-old Manpreet Kaur against four persons, including her parents. No arrest has been made so far.

‘Pinni parshad’ a hit at Golden Temple
Amritsar, December 4
Within a couple of months of its launch, “Pinni parshad” has become a huge hit among devotees visiting the Golden Temple. It has recorded a sale of around Rs 40 lakh in the past 25 days. Darbar Sahib manager HS Malhi said: “Pilgrims from far-off places used to complain that they could not take ‘parshad’ from the holy shrine for their near and dear ones which prompted us to launch the facility on the birth anniversary of Guru Ram Das on October 8”.

Sikh pilgrims return from Pak
Pilgrims at Amritsar railway station on Tuesday. Amritsar, December 4
Scores of Sikh pilgrims, including the 889-member SGPC jatha, today returned from Pakistan in three special trains after celebrating the Guru Nanak Dev’s birth anniversary. However, Amritsar resident Kulwant Singh could not return home as his passport got stolen in Lahore.
Pilgrims at Amritsar railway station on Tuesday. Photo: Vishal Kumar

Jail inmates examined at medical camp
Patiala, December 4
As many as 680 inmates lodged in the Central Jail, Patiala, were examined today in a medical checkup camp on the jail premises. Punjab ADGP (Jails) RP Meena said medical checkup camps would be made a regular feature inside all jails of the state. Meena said doctors from government hospitals would be allowed to hold such camps in collaboration with the jail staff.

COURTS

Waraich’s appointment as NIPER registrar quashed
Chandigarh, December 4
Setting aside his appointment as the registrar of National Institute of Pharmaceutical Education and Research (NIPER), Mohali, the Punjab and Haryana High Court has ruled that the appointing authority was misled while considering the service career of Wing Commander (retired) PJP Singh Waraich.


Top




















 

Finally, work to clean Budha Nullah begins
Cost-effective bio-remediation system being used to clean Ludhiana’s ‘drain of sorrow’
Puneet Pal Singh Gill
Tribune News Service

Ludhiana, December 4
After remaining on paper for more than 20 months, the bio-remediation project to clean the Budha Nullah has finally begun. About 70 tonnes of microbial culture were released into the drain near Jainpur village today.

(Left) Solid waste segregation point on the Budha Nullah and (right)V-shaped green bridge where microbes will be dropped
(Left) Solid waste segregation point on the Budha Nullah and (right)V-shaped green bridge where microbes will be dropped

Bio-remediation is a cost-effective cleanliness process as compared to conventional methods. The system is easy to execute and it does not require highly skilled manpower or even electricity. It entails eco-technological horizontal filtration, comprising different physical and biological filters. It removes suspended and dissolved impurities.

The project was inaugurated by the then Union Environment and Forests Minister Jairam Ramesh by releasing four pots of microbial culture into the nullah on April 23 last year.

The drain, which flows into the Sutlej, has been a source of pollution and several diseases in Ludhiana and its vicinity.

The microbial culture was released today into the drain in the presence of officials from the Central Pollution Control Board, Punjab Pollution Control Board, Ludhiana Municipal Corporation, Punjab Water Supply and Sewerage Board and the state Irrigation Department. Besides, officials from Green Technologies, the firm that is working on the project, and Shrishti Eco-Research Institute, which has developed the technology, were also present.

Once completed, the project is expected to bring down the pollution level in the nullah by 50 to 80 per cent.

Shrishti institute director Sandeep Joshi said five “green bridges” will be constructed at a distance of 500 metres from each other on the nullah downstream from Jainpur village. But ahead of these green bridges, a segregation point to take out solid waste manually from the water has been prepared where a four-member team will work round the clock.

“Microbes will be released in the area covered by these V-shaped green bridges. As water passes through these bridges, microbes will consume all pollutants present in the water. Enclosures have been prepared and the microbes will remain there for a long time once released,” said Joshi.

Green Technologies owner Probir Sinha said the bioremediation project functions like kidneys in a body, which purify blood. “Once installed, microbes keep working automatically. We will install filters at the five green bridges by March next year and these filters will reduce biochemical and chemical oxygen demand by aerobic degradation and formation of the ecological chain. Later, the project will be regularly monitored for a period of five years,” he said.

Pollution Board chairman Ravinder Singh said the project got delayed due to the monsoon season. “But now that it has started, we will ensure it functions smoothly. Once the project gets going on full scale, pollution level in the nullah will certainly decline and only clean water will flow in the nullah,” he claimed.

About the project
Bioremediation is a cost-effective cleanliness process as compared to conventional methods. The project is easy to execute and it does not require highly skilled manpower or even electricity. The system entails eco-technological horizontal filtration, comprising different physical and biological filters, which removes suspended and dissolved impurities. It was inaugurated by the then Union Environment and Forests Minister Jairam Ramesh on April 23 last year. The drain has been a source of pollution and several diseases in Ludhiana and its vicinity. Once completed, the project is expected to bring down pollution level in the nullah by 50 to 80 per cent.

How it will work
Step 1: A four-member team will work round the clock at a certain point on the nullah to segregate solid waste manually from the water

Step 2: Once solid waste is removed, five V-shaped “green bridges” will be constructed downstream the nullah

These bridges will be at a distance of 500 metres from each other; the first one will come up at Jainpur village

Step 3: Microbes will then be released in these ‘V’-shaped green bridges

As water passes through these bridges, microbes will eat all pollutants present in the water

Special enclosures have been prepared to ensure that the microbes remain there for a long time after being released

The bio-remediation project is expected to clean the nullah in a similar way as kidneys purify blood in a human body

Step 4: By March next year, filters will be installed at these five green bridges

These filters will reduce biochemical and chemical oxygen demand in the nullah water and, thereby, check the formation of ecological chain, which will, in turn, reduce pollution

Top

 

Draft of Contract Farming Act ready
Sarbjit Dhaliwal
Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, December 4
The state government is ready with the draft of the Contract Farming Act that will be discussed at a Cabinet meeting here on December 8, say sources. The Act is likely to be passed by the Vidhan Sabha which is to meet later this month.

The legislation envisages a four-member Contact Farming Regulatory Commission, to be headed by a Chief Secretary-level officer, with two legal luminaries and an agricultural expert as members.

It would have the authority to hear complaints with regard to violation of the Act.

Sources said the Finance Department had okayed a proposal for Rs 40 lakh to create the requisite infrastructure to implement the Act this fiscal year. For next fiscal year, a sum of Rs 2 crore had been sought.

The legislation would enable farmers to enter into a contract with sugar mills, rice mills and the food packaging industry to sell their produce.

If a sugar mill owner signs a pact with farmers that he would purchase the entire cane stock produced by them, it would become legally binding on him to do so. In case he violated the pact, he would have to pay a penalty besides the production cost. On the other hand, the farmers would have to fulfill the

commitment made by them to the mill owner. In the absence of any legislation, many companies have duped farmers in the past. Repeatedly let down by cooperative sugar mills, farmers in the state had stopped growing cane because of which many cooperative mills had to be shut down.

Whereas the legislation would benefit the farmers and ensure a market for their produce, it would guarantee availability of raw material to the agro-based industry.

As of now, the entire agricultural produce is sold under the Punjab Agriculture Produce Marketing Act. Private firms buying farm produce have to abide by the Act.

The proposed Contract Farming Act would now provide an additional marketing channel for selling and buying agriculture produce.

The Centre has been pressing various state governments to promote direct marketing and eliminate the middlemen.

Decoding the proposed legislation
The legislation would benefit farmers by ensuring a market for their produce
It would guarantee availability of raw material to agro-based industries
It would provide an additional channel for selling and buying agricultural produce
The Centre has been pressing state governments to promote direct marketing and eliminate middlemen

Top

 

Four officials indicted in garbage land scam
Sanjay Bumbroo
Tribune News Service

Fatehgarh Sahib, December 4
The special investigation team (SIT) probing the Rs 2.53 crore garbage land scam by officials of the Mandi Gobindgarh Municipal Council has submitted its report to the Sub- Divisional Magistrate, Amloh.

Reliable sources say the SIT had indicted four officials, including Dharampal, former president of the Municipal Council (MC), and Charanjit Singh, former Executive Officer (EO). The former EO and MC chief were accused of pocketing Rs 2.53 crore in a deal to purchase five acres of land for dumping garbage.The land was allegedly purchased by three middlemen in connivance with the MC officials for Rs 53.10 lakh on February 14, 2011. The same was sold to the MC for Rs 3.061 crore the following day.

The matter was brought to the notice of Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal who marked an inquiry to the Vigilance Bureau which submitted a report on July 31, 2012 following which three persons- Sukhdev Singh of Beer Bhamarsi, Harbans Singh of Salani and Balkar Singh of Bassi Pathana- were arrested.

Later, acting on a plea by councillor Om Parkash Gupta and others, the Punjab and Haryana High Court, sought the views of Deputy Commissioner Yashvir Mahajan, who is chairman of the rate fixing committee.

The Deputy Commissioner in his affidavit to the court stated that the committee members had misled him on the land deal and requested that a fresh inquiry be ordered.

Raising a stink
A former Executive Officer and Mandi Gobindgarh Municipal Council chief were accused of pocketing Rs 2.53 crore in a deal to purchase a dumping site
The land was allegedly purchased by three middlemen in connivance with MC officials for Rs 53.10 lakh on February 14, 2011
The same was sold to the municipal council for Rs 3.061 crore the next day

Top

 

Adopt new technology for agri growth: Sukhbir
Four-day Agro Tech fair concludes, registers 75,000 visitors
Tribune News Service

A huge rush of visitors at Agro Tech fair in Chandigarh on Tuesday.
A huge rush of visitors at Agro Tech fair in Chandigarh on Tuesday. Tribune photo: Manoj Mahajan

Chandigarh, December 4
Farmers need to understand new technologies and processes in order to propel agriculture growth in the state. Punjab with just 1.5 per cent of the total agricultural area in the country had been contributing more than 55 per cent to the nation’s food kitty.

In the process of making India self-sufficient, Punjab has been losing out on soil nutrients and groundwater. This was stated today by Deputy Chief Minister Sukhbir Singh Badal on the concluding day of the Agro Tech 2012, organised by the CII, here.

“We must thank the CII for bringing all the stakeholders — companies, farmers and the government — on one platform,” he said.

Giving a call for diversification in agriculture sector, Sukhbir said the farmers would have to come out of the vicious cycle of wheat and paddy and focus on low water-consuming cash crops. He said the Punjab Government was seeking investments from entrepreneurs in the area of diversification of agriculture sector, food processing and conservation of water.

Sukhbir said farmers would have to turn smart marketers to be able to adjust their product portfolio according to the fast-changing demand and supply equation in the international food market.

He said opening up of the Wagah border and giving it the status of a dry port by allowing export of 6,000 goods could be a game changer for the entire north India.

While addressing the gathering, Finance Minister Parminder Singh Dhindsa called upon entrepreneurs to come out with technology for small and marginal farmers, which would help increase farm yield.

During the four-day fair, 75,000 visitors, including 35,000 farmers from various states, showed up. The Agro Tech also saw farmers’ delegations from Afghanistan, Australia, Nepal and The Netherlands.

Top

 

Haryana CM questions Punjab Police security to Chautala
Tribune News Service

Maine (Patiala), December 4
Haryana Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda today questioned the security cover provided to his predecessor Om Parkash Chautala saying the Punjab Police would have to answer as to why it had provided security to him.

Punjab Pardesh Congress Committee (PPCC) president Captain Amarinder Singh had earlier questioned the security provided by the Punjab Police to persons outside the state a few days back. Speaking on the sidelines of the Asian Shotgun Championship, where he was the chief guest, Hooda said Chautala was given maximum security by the Haryana Police.

“If the Punjab Police has given him personnel, you should ask the Punjab government why it has done so. We had provided security cover according to the threat perception,” Hooda said. He claimed that there was no threat to anyone in Haryana and a proper protocol was followed before anyone was extended a security cover.

Hooda said the relations between Haryana and Punjab were strong as ever. “Both the states are like brothers as were carved out of a single state,” he said. Hooda showed keen interest about the facilities given to shooters during the event.

He further said his state always backed sportspersons and had done enough to ensure that the sportsmen in Haryana were rewarded.

Top

 
 

VB to probe wheat embezzlement scam
Kulwinder Sandhu
Tribune News Service

Moga, December 4
The Vigilance Bureau would now be probing the alleged wheat embezzlement scam that had come to light in Baghapurana area of the district last year.

Valued at Rs 2 crore, 28,000 bags of wheat belonging to Punsup, a state-owned procurement agency, had gone missing from two storehouses located on Mudki road and Jai Singh Wala road at Baghapurana.

After getting a departmental probe conducted, senior Punsup officials had written to the Punjab Vigilance Bureau for an inquiry and recovery of the losses incurred by the agency.

The probe had held Ludhiana regional manager and former Moga district manager Sher Singh accountable for the missing wheat. Punsup inspector Daljit Singh and clerk Amarjit Singh too were found guilty. While Daljit Singh was recently suspended from service, the retirement benefits of Amarjit Singh have been held back, a senior official of the procurement agency said.

A senior Vigilance Bureau official confirmed that they had received instructions to inquire into the scam.

“We have summoned the official record from Punsup and are looking into the facts and figures to find out the exact quantity of wheat missing from these storehouses,” the official said.

It has also been learnt that the accused officials, during the first physical verification held last year, had also tried to mislead the verification team by bringing in poor quality wheat from another storehouse to escape from the detection of the fraud. But the information about it got leaked from internal sources, which led to the detection of the scam.

Top

 

Promotion for 23 Faridkot policemen raises eyebrows
Balwant Garg
Tribune News Service

Faridkot, December 4
The state government has given out-of-turn promotions to 23 policemen despite the Faridkot police having been under attack for allegedly shielding the accused in the Shruti abduction case.The Faridkot police has been praised for its “extraordinary feat” in cracking the case by arresting all the accused persons and recovering the abducted girl.

The promotions have shocked members of the Joint Action Committee (JAC), which has been fighting for justice for Shruti. It has also created bad blood among members of the police force as for some it is the second promotion in a year while others have not been elevated for more than a decade.

Among the promoted police officials are those who had allegedly pressured the abducted girl to give a statement in favour of the key accused.

“A Sub-Inspector (SI), who has been granted the local rank of Inspector for his ‘commendable’ job in the abduction case, put a lot of pressure on the girl to obtain her statement favouring the accused.

He even held out the bait of transferring some land owned by the accused to the victim girl’s name as a part of this deal,” reads a complaint submitted to the Senior Superintendent of Police (SSP), Faridkot, GS Toor, by the JAC.

Three Sub-Inspectors (SIs) have been awarded the local rank of Inspector, one Assistant SI has been promoted SI, five Head Constables have been made Assistant SIs and 14 constables made Head Constables.

Shruti Case
Among the promoted police officials are those who had allegedly pressured Shruti Sachdeva to give a statement in favour of the key accused.

The Elevated
Three Sub-Inspectors have been awarded the local rank of Inspector, one Assistant SI has been promoted SI, five Head Constables have been made Assistant SIs and 14 constables made Head Constables.

Top

 

Government prepares to outsource selective works
Sanjeev Singh Bariana/TNS

Chandigarh, December 4
The Punjab Government has initiated concrete steps on outsourcing selective tasks to the private sector keeping in mind the cost and quality factors.

To chisel the manpower flab, the government has decided not to give a year's extension in service to those aged above 58 years in departments where there is little work. For instance, a number of those appointed for the SYL project are now without work.

The government has commenced the process of outsourcing appointments after a comparative market study. A detailed analysis of works in sectors like sanitation and data entry is being undertaken. The cost factor coupled with the expected quality within a specific time-frame is being studied to decide on allotting projects to “deserving” private parties.

As a first step, the government has sought information from department heads, the Registrar of the Punjab and Haryana High Court and Deputy Commissioners on the pay scales of employees, the annual increments, educational and professional qualifications for various posts and the nature of job being handled.

In an attempt to downsize its staff and to do away with needless posts, the state government will not give extension in service to employees aged above 58 in departments not involved in any project. The government had recently decided on a year's extension to its employees aged above 58. It has now modified the policy.

In a communication to department heads, the office of the Financial Secretary has stated that in "an amendment to the Punjab Civil Services rules (Part I, Rule 3.26), officials working in departments where they are sitting idle without any work being underway, will not be given any extension in service, even by a year’.

It has also been stated that certain service cadres which had been declared "diminishing cadres" will not get any extension in case of any vacancy that arises because of retirement, voluntary retirement, resignation or death.

A senior clerk said: “I am not aware about any such orders.The government can’t retire one employee and allow another to continue if they have joined the services on the same date.”

Cutting the flab
Govt decides to downsize staff and to do away with needless posts
It will now not give extension to employees aged above 58 in departments not involved in any works
The government had only recently decided on a year's extension to its employees aged above 58
Certain service cadres that have been declared 'diminishing cadres' will not get any extension in service

Top

 

Suspected honour killing
Parents of Samana girl booked for murder
Tribune News Service

Samana, December 4
The Sangrur police has registered an FIR pertaining to the alleged murder of 15-year-old Manpreet Kaur against four persons, including her parents. No arrest has been made so far.

Sources said the girl was allegedly killed by her family members after she refused to sever ties with a boy.

The police said a case under Sections 302, 120-B and 201 IPC had been registered against the girl’s parents Amrik Singh and Paramjit Kaur and relatives Malkit Singh and Chinder Kaur. The FIR states all the four accused allegedly conspired to kill Manpreet and later cremated her in Gujran village without informing anyone. The sources said the breakthrough in the case came after questioning of the victim’s brother Sukhwinder Singh. Sangrur SSP HS Bhullar said the police was conducting raids to nab the accused.

Top

 

‘Pinni parshad’ a hit at Golden Temple
Tribune News Service

Amritsar, December 4
Within a couple of months of its launch, “Pinni parshad” has become a huge hit among devotees visiting the Golden Temple. It has recorded a sale of around Rs 40 lakh in the past 25 days.

Darbar Sahib manager HS Malhi said: “Pilgrims from far-off places used to complain that they could not take ‘parshad’ from the holy shrine for their near and dear ones which prompted us to launch the facility on the birth anniversary of Guru Ram Das on October 8”.

The SGPC has opened separate counters for “pinni parshad”. Now, the devotees have two options. They can either take home “pinni parshad” and a “siropa” for Rs 151 or they can get a packet of 80 gm of “pinni parshad” for Rs 20.

There is a sale of around Rs 2 lakh daily at the “pinni parshad” counter. The manager said the practice of giving a “siropa” along with “patasha parshad”

to the devotees offering Rs 100 and above inside the sanctum sanctorum was also on. “But, at times some devotees fail to receive ‘siropa’ and ‘parshad’ due to the rush inside the shrine and the ‘pinni parshad’ counter gives them an option to collect the same from the ‘parikarma’”, he said.

Malhi said they used “desi ghee” in preparing “pinni parshad” which was made as per the Sikh traditions and packed after performing the “ardaas”.

The manager said the new facility didn’t take any toll on the offerings made inside the sanctum sanctorum, which had rather increased. The offerings made at the shrine in the last month were a whopping Rs 1.5 crore, he added.

Top

 

Sikh pilgrims return from Pak
Tribune News Service

Amritsar, December 4
Scores of Sikh pilgrims, including the 889-member SGPC jatha, today returned from Pakistan in three special trains after celebrating the Guru Nanak Dev’s birth anniversary. However, Amritsar resident Kulwant Singh could not return home as his passport got stolen in Lahore.

Talking to mediapersons at Attari railway station, SGPC jatha head Jang Bahadur Singh said the Pakistan government had made elaborate security arrangements for the smooth movement of the pilgrims in view of the Taliban threat. The pilgrims paid obeisance at Gurdwara Nankana Sahib, Gurdwara Sacha Sauda, Gurdwara Panja Sahib, Gurdwara Rori Sahib, Gurdwara Dehra Sahib, Gurdwara Kartarpur Sahib and other historic Sikh shrines in Pakistan. However, the pilgrims lamented that they were at the receiving end of several theft incidents during their visit. Apart from an Amritsar resident whose passport was stolen on December 2, another pilgrim lost cash worth Rs 17,000 in a theft incident and he was later extended an aid of Rs 7,000 by Pakistan Sikh Gurdwara Parbandhak Committee.

Besides, they rued that they could not get proper accommodation in Lahore and they had to stay at a school, 11 km from Gurdwara Dehra Sahib.

Top

 

Jail inmates examined at medical camp
Tribune News Service

Patiala, December 4
As many as 680 inmates lodged in the Central Jail, Patiala, were examined today in a medical checkup camp on the jail premises. Punjab ADGP (Jails) RP Meena said medical checkup camps would be made a regular feature inside all jails of the state. Meena said doctors from government hospitals would be allowed to hold such camps in collaboration with the jail staff.

A team of doctors from the Government Rajindra Hospital examined the patients and urged them to pledge their organs for donation after death. Some of the inmates who were diagnosed with ailments were assured of free of cost surgery.

“We will ensure that health remains the primary focus in all jails of the state,” Meena said.

Top

 
 

Waraich’s appointment as NIPER registrar quashed
HC says he misled while furnishing details about his service
Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, December 4
Setting aside his appointment as the registrar of National Institute of Pharmaceutical Education and Research (NIPER), Mohali, the Punjab and Haryana High Court has ruled that the appointing authority was misled while considering the service career of Wing Commander (retired) PJP Singh Waraich.

The High Court Bench comprising Justice Rajesh Bindal said it emerged after studying the documents that the appointing authority was misled while considering the “23 years of service career” of the respondent as relevant experience and awarded the marks accordingly.

Justice Bindal observed that it was stated in the written statement that the respondent was having only 16 years of experience at a gazetted post. The record prepared at the time of scrutiny of the application shows that it was mentioned that the experience of the respondent was not okay as his experience certificate was not attached, he added.

“There was no experience certificate produced on record by the respondent till the date of interview. The selection was made to a post of accountability and hence no casualness was expected as is evident from the case,” the Bench said.

“There is no material placed even before this court except the bio-data submitted by the respondent himself. It cannot be considered that whatever claimed by the respondent in his application is true in absence of a certificate from the employer,” Justice Bindal said.

The ruling came on a petition filed by Dr Parikshit Bansal and another petitioner against the Union of India and other respondents through their counsel Kapil Kakkar. Arguing on the petitioner’s behalf, Kakkar contended that the selected candidate did not fulfill the criteria since it was a case of favourtism.

“There were other better qualified, meritorious candidates fulfilling the requisite qualifications but were ignored,” Kakkar argued. The counsel further argued that there was nothing on record to show that a conscious decision was taken to relax the qualification in favour of the selected candidate and the reason behind it.

what court said
The respondent had only 16 years of relevant experience at a gazetted post while it was shown as 23 years
No material placed before the court except the bio-data submitted by Waraich himself
No experience certificate produced on record by the respondent till the date of interview
Whatever claimed by Waraich in his application cannot be true in absence of a certificate from the employer

Top

 





HOME PAGE | Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir | Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs | Nation | Opinions |
| Business | Sports | World | Letters | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | Delhi |
| Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | E-mail |