SPECIAL COVERAGE
CHANDIGARH

LUDHIANA

DELHI



THE TRIBUNE SPECIALS
50 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE

TERCENTENARY CELEBRATIONS
H A R Y A N A   E D I T I O N

Prevention of Money Laundering Act
ED summons Chautalas

Chandigarh, December 21
Leader of the Opposition and INLD president Om Prakash Chautala and his sons , Ajay Singh and Abhay Singh, have sought time till December 26 to furnish documents and information sought by the Enforcement Directorate, New Delhi.

Anti-defection Law
HJC MLAs’ case may help clear grey areas
Chandigarh, December 21
Haryana has been the leader in the field of political defections. After all Haryana is the land, which prompted the then Union Home Minister YB Chavan to add a new phrase, “Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram”, to the political lexicon of the country.

Centre raps state for delay in forming HR commission
Chandigarh, December 21
The state government has earned the ire of the Congress-led UPA Government at the Centre for alleged indifference in setting up the human rights commission. Union Minister of State for Home Jitendra Singh informed the Lok Sabha yesterday that Haryana was among the eight states which had not constituted human rights commissions “despite repeated requests”.


YOUR TOWN
Chandigarh


EARLIER STORIES



Departing from tradition

Sonia of Ramganj Mohalla in Bhiwani carries her father Brij Lal’s body for cremation on Wednesday
Sonia of Ramganj Mohalla in Bhiwani carries her father Brij Lal’s body for cremation on Wednesday. Photo: Manoj Dhaka

Oppn seeks CM’s resignation on ‘moral grounds’
Chandigarh, December 21
The Opposition parties today sought Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda’s resignation on “moral grounds” while seeking the removal of the “defector” MLAs from the government posts.

MC adamant on CLU charges
Faridabad, December 21
The Municipal Corporation Faridabad (MCF) is determined not to give in to a demand of owners of houses-cum-shopkeepers to collect the Change in Land Use (CLU) charges for their residential premises in instalments.

Market, rural development fund fees halved
Chandigarh, December 21
Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda today announced a major relief to farmers by reducing by half the market fee and Haryana Rural Development Fund (HRDF) fee on potatoes for this year.

Irate villagers lock school gate
Sirsa, December 21
Irked at the failure of the authorities concerned to upgrade the government middle school, residents locked the main gate and sat in dharna outside the school building at Jogiwala village in this district today.

Man found murdered in Jhajjar village
Jhajjar, December 21
Tara Chand (55) was found murdered in his room at Luhari village here today. The reason behind the murder is yet to be ascertained. The police has started investigations after registering a case of murder against unidentified killers on the compliant of the deceased’s son, Jai Prakash.

Cyber cafés told to get identity details
Hisar, December 21
The police has made it mandatory for cyber café operators to record the details of all customers using their services in a register. In a statement issued here today the police said the number of cyber cafes and their customers had risen sharply in the recent past.

Man’s murder
Wife held for complicity
Rewari, December 21
The Dharuhera police has arrested Kavita for her alleged complicity in the elimination of her husband, Sharwar Kumar, by Rishipal and his colleague, Pravesh. She was today produced in the court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, who remanded her in judicial custody.

Attack on Dera follower’s house, 11 Sikhs convicted
Sirsa, December 21
A fast track court today convicted 11 Sikhs for an attack on the house of a Dera Sacha Sauda follower at Mallewala village in Sirsa on July 24, 2007. The Sikhs, including Sher Singh, manager of the Dasham Patshahi Gurdwara, Sirsa, were accused of having attacked the house of Jeet Singh, who they alleged was organising “naam charcha”.

Notice of motion to Chief Secy, vigilance chief
Chandigarh, December 21
The Punjab and Haryana High Court today issued notice of motion to the Union Ministry of Environment and Forests, Haryana Chief Secretary and the State Vigilance Bureau director on a petition alleging funds embezzlement in the Hisar forest region.

Cold claims man’s life
Sirsa, December 21
Chilly weather claimed the life of Krishan Kumar (33), a local resident, last night. The police received information about a man lying near a private bank in the Mela Ground on Begu Road this morning.





Top








 

Prevention of Money Laundering Act
ED summons Chautalas
Yoginder Gupta
Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, December 21
Leader of the Opposition and INLD president Om Prakash Chautala and his sons , Ajay Singh and Abhay Singh, have sought time till December 26 to furnish documents and information sought by the Enforcement Directorate, New Delhi.

The directorate is making investigation against the Chautalas under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002.

Earlier, the Directorate had issued summonses to the elder Chautala and his sons, Ajay Singh and Abhay Singh, to submit certain documents along with information before Deputy Director Rajeshwar Singh either personally or through an authorised representative.

The Chautalas sent a chartered accountant, Rahul Bishnoi, to the directorate, who said that the documents and information sought from his clients were in the process of being collected. He sought time till December 26.

The directorate had asked the Chautalas to submit their passports; details of their family members and their sources of income, if any, along with copies of their PAN cards and details of all bank accounts maintained in their names or in the names of their family members in and outside India.

The directorate also wanted to know from the Chautalas the names and addresses of the companies/firms in and outside India in which they and their family members are director/partner/proprietor/shareholder since July 1, 2005, along with audited balance sheets.

It also sought details of all investments made by them or their family members in immovable and movable assets on or after July 1, 2005.

The summonses also asked the Chautalas to submit copies of income tax returns filed by them and their family members since the 2005-06 financial year along with all enclosures.

Top

 

Anti-defection Law
HJC MLAs’ case may help clear grey areas
Yoginder Gupta/TNS

Chandigarh, December 21
Haryana has been the leader in the field of political defections. After all Haryana is the land, which prompted the then Union Home Minister YB Chavan to add a new phrase, “Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram”, to the political lexicon of the country.

Even the case of five former HJC MLAs, who were yesterday declared ‘unattached’ by the Punjab and Haryana High Court, promises to be a landmark case in the history of anti-defection law, if the issues goes to the SC, which in all probability would go. There are many grey areas in the law enacted when Rajiv Gandhi was the PM and even after the NDA government amended it.

These grey areas had been waiting for interpretation by the SC all these years. Till the judiciary held that “merger”, which allows mass-scale defection of legislators from one party to another under law, has to be the merger of one political party with another, it was presumed that the law allowed the merger of the legislative wings of two parties, particularly so because the power to decide the disqualification petitions vested with the Speaker, who can deal only with the legislature parties inside the House and not with organisational wings of political parties.

The Haryana case may prompt the SC to define a timeframe within which a Speaker has to decide a disqualification petition. At present, the law has no such time limit. Even the SC had been saying that a Speaker is expected to dispose of a disqualification petition as expeditiously as possible. But what is “as expeditiously as possible” is not defined in so many words. Since the proceedings are conducted before the Speaker within the broad contours of the CPC, the process can genuinely be lengthy even if the intentions of the presiding officer are honourable.

So far there is no methodology available to a Speaker to determine if a political party has merged with another party. It is easier to do so in case of the legislature wing of a political party but not the organisational wing. Then it is not yet clear if in case of a national party, its state unit can merge with another party in that state or the merger has to be in reference to the entire national party.

Even Satya Pal Jain, chairman of the legal cell of the BJP and who has contested several anti-defection cases, says that he would welcome if the issue goes to the SC, where many ambiguities of the law might be cleared.

The HC judgement has surprised many legal experts. The issue before the Division Bench was whether the court could direct the Speaker to decide the disqualification petitions within a certain time limit. The petitioners were opposing it, while the respondent (Kuldeep Bishnoi) was in favour of it. The court, however, went to the extent of saying that prima facie there was no merger and the five former HJC MLAs would be treated as “unattached” members till the Speaker’s decision.

After the court has held that prima facie there was no merger, what has been left for the Speaker to decide? In a Tamil Nadu case of 1996, the SC had not recognised the concept of “unattached” members. It said there could be only three categories of legislators -either they would belong to a political party, or they would be Independent, or they would be nominated.

Top

 

Centre raps state for delay in forming HR commission
Pradeep Sharma
Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, December 21
The state government has earned the ire of the Congress-led UPA Government at the Centre for alleged indifference in setting up the human rights commission. Union Minister of State for Home Jitendra Singh informed the Lok Sabha yesterday that Haryana was among the eight states which had not constituted human rights commissions “despite repeated requests”.

“The government and the NHRC have been requesting all those states which have not yet constituted their human rights commission to do so at the earliest, he said.

Following uproar in the wake of large-scale human rights violations, Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda publicly announced the formation of the human rights commission in the state last year. A three-member committee headed by Justice IP Vashisht was formed early this year to work out modalities for the commission’s formation and assist the Chief Minister in recommending the names of the chairperson and members to the Governor.

However, the committee is yet to finalise its report. Under the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, the Chief Minister headed a high-level committee comprising the Speaker and the Leader of the Opposition, which recommended the names of the chairperson and members to the Governor.

In reponse to a petition filed by People’s Union for Civil Liberties(PUCL) for the setting up the human rights commission in Haryana in the Punjab and Haryana High Court, the state government said in 2007 it did not feel the need for the commission as adequate mechanism existed to deal with people’s grievannces.

However, human rights activists argued that in view of upsurge in the crime graph, including honour killings, atrocities on Dalits and minorities, Haryana was a fit case for having a human rights commission. Besides, according to the “Crime in India-2010” report released by the National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB) of the Ministry of Home Affairs in New Delhi, Haryana is the 12th most criminal state in India with 80,895 cases .

While all neighbouring states, including Himachal, Punjab, Rajasthan, UP and New Delhi, have human rights commissions, Haryana has the dubious distinction of being among small states-Arunchal Pradesh, Goa, Meghalaya, Nagaland, Tripura, Mizoram and Uttarakhand-which did not have the rights commissions.

Top

 

Oppn seeks CM’s resignation on ‘moral grounds’
Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, December 21
The Opposition parties today sought Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda’s resignation on “moral grounds” while seeking the removal of the “defector” MLAs from the government posts.

Addressing separate press conferences, the BJP-HJC combine and the INLD termed high court order in the MLAs’ defection case as “historic”, adding that they would approach Governor Jagan Nath Pahadia to seek “dismissal” of the government.

Satya Pal Jain, who heads the BJP legal cell, said following the high court order , the “defector MLAs” should have either sent their resignations from their respective posts or the Hooda government ought to have asked them to step down.

“The orders became effective from the moment they were passed. However, it has been 24 hours and the MLAs as well as the government seem unfazed. If they continue to function in their positions, their action is not only illegal but it tantamounts to insulting the court. We will await government action for a few days and then file a contempt petition ,” Jain said.

Maintaining that the order states that they are “unattached” MLAs only for the purpose of attending the House, implying thereby that they would have no voting rights. Jain said the Speaker seemed to be dragging his feet on the petitions against the five “defector” MLAs as also against the seven Independents, who were “virtually functioning as Congressmen”.

“The Speaker has not fixed a single date of hearing our petition seeking the disqualification of Independent MLAs who are functioning as Congressmen in the past 10 months. We will move the court in this regard in January next year,” Jain added.

Stating that the court had made some adverse observations about the functioning of the Speaker who had not been able to honour his commitment of holding four hearings a month in the case , Jain said: “I hope the Speaker will rise above party considerations and give his decision though he is yet to give up his membership of the Congress. ”

Stating that the “merger” argument of the defecting MLAs did not hold good, Jain said if a merger had happened, like they claimed, the Election Commission would not have permitted candidates to contest the Hisar parliamentary seat and the Ratia and Adampur Assembly seats on the HJC ticket.

“In fact, delays in deciding defection cases have come up across the country. In my opinion, the Constitution should be amended to take away this power of the Speaker and vest it in the Election Commission or an independent agency. The idea in giving this power to the Speaker was to enable faster decisions since the courts are already overburdened but it is proving to be the other way round with the delay much longer at the Speaker’s end,” he said.

Anil Vij, leader of the BJP legislature party, said they would meet the government on December 23 to seek the “minority” government’s dismissal.

Ajay Chautala, INLD secretary-general, said the court order in the case of the “defector” MLAs had proved that the government had cobbled its numbers by horse-trading. “The fact that they were accommodated as the ministers and the CPS makes it clear that the Congress ‘bought’ the MLAs to form the government even though the public gave a mandate against them in the 2009 elections,” Chautala said.

Stating that the CM should step down on “moral grounds”, he said the MLAs should be divested of their offices with immediate effect. About the Speaker’s role, Chautala said his role seemed to be only to delay the inevitable.

Top

 

MC adamant on CLU charges

Faridabad, December 21
The Municipal Corporation Faridabad (MCF) is determined not to give in to a demand of owners of houses-cum-shopkeepers to collect the Change in Land Use (CLU) charges for their residential premises in instalments.

Ravi Singla, Additional Senior Town Planner, MCF, said the rates had been determined by the government and notices had been issued to house owners to procure the CLUs for their establishments. “They will have to comply with the rules failing which the MCF will initiate punitive action against them,” he said.

Official sources said 5,000 house owners had been issued notices. Only about 100 of them had so far responded even though the deadline for many was over.

Jagdish Bhatia, president of Faridabad Vyapaar Mandal, claimed that paying the entire amount at one go would be a big burden on the owners of house-cum shopkeepers,” he said. “The MCF in a meeting held on May 5 had passed a resolution in favour of the CLU rates. The resolution also specifically mentions that the total amount will be collected in easy instalments. In addition, the house owners will have to pay 25 per cent more on the CLU rates as compounding fees.” According to a rough estimate, about 14,000 units had to pay the CLU charges. — TNS

Top

 

Market, rural development fund fees halved

Chandigarh, December 21
Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda today announced a major relief to farmers by reducing by half the market fee and Haryana Rural Development Fund (HRDF) fee on potatoes for this year.

The market fee for potatoes has been reduced to 1 per cent from 2 per cent and the HRDF fee has also been slashed to 1 per cent from 2 per cent. The fee has been reduced up to March 31, 2012.

It has also been decided in principle that the government would provide transportation subsidy for export of potatoes and facilitate potato growers in exporting their produce. The modalities of transportation subsidies would be decided soon. Hooda directed the Haryana State Agriculture Marketing Board to tie up with retail chains so that farmers could be given remunerative prices for potatoes and other vegetables. The HSAMB would organise a programme under which exporters and companies like Walmart, Metro, Reliance, REI, Mother Diary and Nafed would purchase potatoes at better prices. — TNS

Top

 

Irate villagers lock school gate
Tribune News Service

Sirsa, December 21
Irked at the failure of the authorities concerned to upgrade the government middle school, residents locked the main gate and sat in dharna outside the school building at Jogiwala village in this district today.

Villagers alleged that their children had to go to other villages for studies after completion of their middle standard.

Some children even have to leave their studies midway due to this.

The villagers alleged that they had brought this problem to the notice of senior officers of the Education Department several times but to no avail. The protesters maintained that they would not allow the school to function until the authorities conceded their demand.

Balwan Singh and Om Parkash, headmasters of government schools in Chaharwala and Kagdana villages, respectively, who were sent by the authorities to pacify the villagers, failed to break the imbroglio. They maintained that the school could not be upgraded because the number of students was lower than the minimum enrolment specified by the Education Department.

Top

 

Man found murdered in Jhajjar village

Jhajjar, December 21
Tara Chand (55) was found murdered in his room at Luhari village here today. The reason behind the murder is yet to be ascertained. The police has started investigations after registering a case of murder against unidentified killers on the compliant of the deceased’s son, Jai Prakash.

The incident came to light this morning when Sunita went to serve tea to his father-in-law at a plot located adjacent to their house. She reportedly found Tara Chand murdered when she entered the room. Sunita informed the family members and other villagers about the incident.

Jai Prakash said her father as usual went to the plot to sleep after having his dinner last night and his wife used to go there every morning to serve him a cup of tea. “

The body bore multiple injuries marks that seem to be inflicted by some sharp-edge weapons. The deceased’s kin has not suspected anyone regarding the crime hence we are making investigations from various angles,” said a police official.

Notably, body of Tara Chand’s four-year-old grand daughter, Khusi, was recovered from a pond of the village in January 2010. The police are still clueless about the killers of Khusi. — OC

Top

 

Cyber cafés told to get identity details
Tribune News Service

Hisar, December 21
The police has made it mandatory for cyber café operators to record the details of all customers using their services in a register. In a statement issued here today the police said the number of cyber cafes and their customers had risen sharply in the recent past.

There was always a possibility of unscrupulous elements using the facilities for unlawful activity.

The operators had been asked to get the customers’ identity details recorded in the register in their own handwriting after establishing their identities through permissible legal documents.

Top

 

Man’s murder
Wife held for complicity
Our Correspondent

Rewari, December 21
The Dharuhera police has arrested Kavita for her alleged complicity in the elimination of her husband, Sharwar Kumar, by Rishipal and his colleague, Pravesh. She was today produced in the court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, who remanded her in judicial custody.

Spilling the beans during interrogation, she said after her husband learnt of her extra- marital relations with Rishi Pal, he started reprimanding her. She forced Rishipal to kill her husband.

Rishipal, along with Pravesh, eliminated her husband on the night of December 13. Both Rishipal and Pravesh have already been arrested.

Top

 

Attack on Dera follower’s house, 11 Sikhs convicted

Sirsa, December 21
A fast track court today convicted 11 Sikhs for an attack on the house of a Dera Sacha Sauda follower at Mallewala village in Sirsa on July 24, 2007. The Sikhs, including Sher Singh, manager of the Dasham Patshahi Gurdwara, Sirsa, were accused of having attacked the house of Jeet Singh, who they alleged was organising “naam charcha”.

Jeet Singh’s daughter, Devender Kaur, was hurt in the attack and the police had registered a case in this regard.

In a counter case, Sher Singh has also lodged a complaint against 10 Dera followers accusing them of abducting and attempting to murder his son, Sukhdev Singh. The court, however, did not find any truth in Sher Singh’s allegations. The court reserved its order on the quantum of sentence. — TNS

Top

 

Notice of motion to Chief Secy, vigilance chief

Chandigarh, December 21
The Punjab and Haryana High Court today issued notice of motion to the Union Ministry of Environment and Forests, Haryana Chief Secretary and the State Vigilance Bureau director on a petition alleging funds embezzlement in the Hisar forest region.

Three IFS officers, V K Jhanjharia, M M Joshi and M L Rajwanshi, have also been put on notice by the court on public interest litigation alleging large-scale bungling in the afforestation projects. The PIL alleged in one such case at Jui-Meethathal feeder, Hisar, six inquiries by different IFS Officers, confirmed embezzlement, but no action was taken. — TNS

Top

 

Cold claims man’s life

Sirsa, December 21
Chilly weather claimed the life of Krishan Kumar (33), a local resident, last night. The police received information about a man lying near a private bank in the Mela Ground on Begu Road this morning.

The police rushed him to the local General Hospital, where the doctors pronounced him brought dead. The police said the exact cause of the death would be ascertained only after the postmortem report. — TNS

Top

 





HOME PAGE | Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir | Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs | Nation | Opinions |
| Business | Sports | World | Letters | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | Delhi |
| Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | E-mail |