|
A step towards food security
Thalassaemic travails
Insuring domestic workers |
|
|
Lokpal and defence procurements
Satyagraha at home
DIVORCE BY MUTUAL CONSENT
|
A step towards food security
THE National Advisory Council has cleared the draft of the Food Security Bill for follow-up action by the government. It offers 90 per cent of all rural households and 50 per cent of urban households a legal right to subsidised food. It is a major step towards banishing hunger but falls short of expectations of experts like development economist Jean Dreze, who quit the NAC, saying government constraints leave no scope for effectively addressing the problem of hunger and under-nutrition. Providing food security to all is a national and global challenge but the government seems less than enthusiastic. Its intention became clear when it appointed a committee under C. Rangarajan to vet the NAC proposals, released earlier. Rangarajan suggested that 46 per cent of the rural population and 28 per cent of the urban population be covered under the Act, citing insufficient food availability as a reason. Procuring larger quantities of food grains, the committee argued, would “lead to lower availability of food grains for the open market, pushing up prices”. Some have questioned the proposal to provide subsidised food to APL (above poverty line) families. Rangarajan wants an inflation-linked price of food for the poor and an MSP (minimum support price)-linked price for APL families to cut the government’s financial burden. Besides, he favours a direct transfer of the food subsidy to the poor through smart cards usable in any store. If food is to be distributed through food stamps or smart cards, then there is no problem of higher procurements or food shortages in the open market pushing up prices. Challenges are numerous but not insurmountable if there is political will. These include financial constraints, raising food productivity and ensuring fool-proof distribution. Large quantities of food go waste due to unscientific storage and poor handling and transportation. The NAC proposals may not be “more of the same” or a case of missed opportunity to radically transfer India’s social policy — as Jean Dreze believes — they mark a step forward and the government has to make sincere efforts to fight hunger and malnutrition, which limit India’s overall growth.
|
Thalassaemic travails
MANY Indians are carriers of thalassaemia, an inherited blood disorder which leads to anaemia. If both parents are carriers of thalassaemia, then there is a possibility of some of their children being born as thalassaemic major. Sukhsohit Singh is one such person, and the Department of Personnel and Training has recently declared that he is unfit to join the Civil Services, in spite of his clearing all the requisite examinations. It is obvious that the rule of banning thalassaemic major patients from the Civil Services is based on the notion that they are not productive enough, given their affliction. In any thalassaemic major patient, there is an excessive destruction of red blood cells, which leads to symptoms like fatigue, growth failure, shortness of breath, etc. Obviously, the medical board at Safdarjung Hospital in Delhi took the decision without taking adequate cognisance of the advances made in the treatment of such cases. It is apparent that the candidate is a person of uncommon grit and focus, who has excelled in his studies, in spite of what could have been a debilitating disease. Thalassaemia occurs in many parts of India, especially in the western region, and the only effective way of eliminating the disease is to screen potential marriage partners. As long as two thalassaemic minors do not have children, the disease can’t spread. The Mediterranean region, especially Cyprus, where it was widely prevalent, has managed to curb the incidence of thalassaemia by making genetic screening of couples compulsory prior to the registration of their marriage. Cultural compulsions dictate enforcement of such a step legislatively, but the government must make every effort to raise public awareness about genetic disorders, and preventive steps must be taken against them. It is unusual that someone who is a thalassaemic major has done so well. For being accomplished in spite of such a disorder, Sukhsohit Singh should be cheered, not censored. |
|
Insuring domestic workers
THE Union Cabinet, in its wisdom, has approved extension of the Rashtriya Swasthya Bima Yojana (RSBY) to all the registered domestic workers in the country. As per their estimate, approximately 47.50 lakh domestic workers will benefit from this smart card based cashless health insurance cover, upto Rs 30,000 a year, in any of the empanelled hospitals, anywhere in the country. The scheme is populist, as it appears, and has been announced in haste. To begin with, by the admission of its own Minister of State for Labour and Employment, Harish Rawat, no authentic data is available on the number of domestic workers in India. The white-collared middle class in India is estimated to be around 3 crores, and a middle class family without a maid is a rare phenomenon. By these estimates, their number is far greater than the estimated 4.5 million. Secondly, how many maids go through the process of registration is anybody’s guess. Even in Delhi, where a public awareness campaign was launched to register domestic servants, in the wake of a rising crime rate, results were not encouraging. Most middle- class families do not feel obliged to part with information on their servants. The problem comes with live-in maids, the households keeping them continue to be a private space without any legislative intrusion, and rightly so. Then, what is the definition of a domestic servant, what about drivers, gardeners, ironing people, waterman, and the errand boy? What about the boys working at dhaba! Unlike the schemes meant for the rural populace, where panchayats can be involved in dissemination of the information, how does the National Social Security Board (NSSB), which looks at unorganised workers for targeted welfare schemes, plan to inform the beneficiaries, without a mechanism to register and enumerate them! If the government is serious about implementing schemes such as these, for a sector that needs it the most, it should first put a system in place to collect the required data, register the domestic servants, gather a report on their requirements and then announce a scheme, which might then be of some use to them.
|
|
Contentment is not the fulfilment of what you want, but the realisation of how much you already have. — Anonymous |
|
HOME PAGE | |
Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir |
Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs |
Nation | Opinions | | Business | Sports | World | Letters | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | Delhi | | Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | E-mail | |