Wednesday, July 11, 2001,
Chandigarh, India






THE TRIBUNE SPECIALS
50 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE

TERCENTENARY CELEBRATIONS
image
N A T I O N

Pervez coming with 19-member team
New Delhi, July 10
Pakistan President Pervez Musharraf is arriving here on July 14 with a 19-member official delegation.

USA ‘setting agenda’ for summit
New Delhi, July 10
The two Left parties are going to seek answers to their strong apprehensions that Washington was indeed setting the agenda for the Indo-Pakistan summit in Agra this week when their leaders meet Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee this evening.

Release PoWs, Bitta urges Pak
New Delhi, July 10
Though three decades have passed still many 1971 Prisoners of War are languishing in Pakistan prisons. They should be released immediately, the head of the All-India Anti-Terrorist Front, Mr M.S. Bitta said here today.


Members of the All-India Anti-Terrorist Front and family members of Indian prisoners of war (POWs), shout slogans during a demonstration in front of the Pakistani Embassy in New Delhi on Tuesday. Members of the All-India Anti-Terrorist Front and family members of Indian prisoners of war (POWs), shout slogans during a demonstration in front of the Pakistani Embassy in New Delhi on Tuesday. Nearly 100 protesters demanded Islamabad release Indian prisoners of war ahead of this weekend’s summit between the two countries. 
— Reuters photo

Pervez escapes unhurt in mishap
New Delhi, July 10
Pakistan President Pervez Musharraf escaped unhurt in a road accident while his gunman and the driver of an escorting car sustained injuries when a car smashed into their vehicle near Islamabad airport, ‘The Dawn’ said today.


Sculptors work at the feverish pitch to complete the statues of Lord Ganesh before the start of the Ganesh Chaturthi festival next month.
Sculptors work at the feverish pitch to complete the statues of Lord Ganesh before the start of the Ganesh Chaturthi festival next month. — PTI

EARLIER STORIES

 
Amitabh Bachchan at the launch of "Crusade against Cancer" in Mumbai on Sunday.
Amitabh Bachchan at the launch of "Crusade against Cancer" in Mumbai on Sunday. — PTI

Security personnel patrol the Yamuna in front of Taj Mahal in Agra, on Tuesday, ahead of the Indo-Pak summit.
Security personnel patrol the Yamuna in front of Taj Mahal in Agra, on Tuesday, ahead of the Indo-Pak summit. — Reuters

 
Former Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M. Karunanidhi coming out of the corporate Apollo Hospitals in a wheel chair in Chennai on Monday after his discharge.
Former Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M. Karunanidhi coming out of the corporate Apollo Hospitals in a wheel chair in Chennai on Monday after his discharge. — PTI

Kasravad: Noted social worker Baba Amte on dharna for Narmada Satyagraha against big dams on Monday.
Kasravad: Noted social worker Baba Amte on dharna for Narmada Satyagraha against big dams on Monday. — PTI

Musharraf’s presidency challenged in SC
Islamabad, July 10
Pakistan military ruler Gen Pervez Musharraf’s last month’s decision to declare himself President has been challenged in the Supreme Court.

Crew of sinking Vietnamese ship rescued
Kolkata, July 10
Most crew members of the Nepal-bound Vietnamese ship, sinking in the Bay of Bengal after developing a leak in its hold, have been rescued and the vessel abandoned near the Sandhead, about 230 km from here.

Naga Cong leaders meet Advani
New Delhi, July 10
A day after Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee announced a review of extension of the Centre-NSCN (I-M) ceasefire beyond Nagaland, a 12-member Nagaland Pradesh Congress Committee delegation today met Union Home Minister L. K. Advani.

UTI fiasco: CPI asks Sinha to quit
New Delhi, July 10
The CPI today demanded the resignation of Union Finance Minister Yashwant Sinha for the UTI fiasco.

Cabinet discusses arrest of ministers
New Delhi, July 10
The recent arrest of two Central ministers, Mr Murasoli Maran and Mr T.R. Baalu, in Tamil Nadu figured at the Cabinet meeting today with several members suggesting that steps be taken to ensure that ministers are treated with respect all over the country.

Maran, Baalu assaulted police: Jaya
Chennai, July 10
Tamil Nadu Chief Minister J. Jayalalitha today reiterated that Union Ministers Murasoli Maran and T.R. Baalu had ‘abused and assaulted’ police personnel during the arrest of DMK President M Karunanidhi and asserted that sufficient ground exist for their dismissal from the union Government on the basis of complaints from the affected police personnel.

Omar sent as PM’s emissary to Libya
New Delhi, July 10
Mr Omar Abdullah, Minister of State for Commerce and Industry, has been sent to Libya as a special emissary of the Prime Minister, Mr Atal Behari Vajpayee, to explain India’s position on Kashmir before the scheduled Indo-Pakistan summit.

SC’s ruling on dying declaration
New Delhi, July 10
The Supreme Court, while streamlining the law on dying declarations as admissible in evidence for the basis of conviction, has maintained that a singular dying declaration, not suffering from any infirmity and found worthy of being relied on, may form the basis of conviction.

Prabhakar’s remand extended to July 21
Dehra Dun, July 10
Former Test cricketer Manoj Prabhakar’s judicial custody in the chit fund scam has been extended up to July 21.

Ball in Centre’s court: Enron, Maharashtra
Mumbai, July 10
The Enron Corporation and the Maharashtra Government today threw the ball in the Centre’s court by seeking its “greater participation” to solve the imbroglio between the multinational and the State Electricity Board (MSEB) over the USD three billion power project in Dabhol.

Trial run of India-B’desh train service today
Kolkata, July 10
The passenger train service between India and Bangladesh will have its trial run tomorrow with regular service expected after the General Elections in the neighbouring country around October next.

Panel too holds doctor guilty
Sriganganagar, July 10
The Rajasthan State Consumer Redressal Commission has upheld the decision of the District Consumer Redressal Forum holding a doctor responsible for “negligence” in the treatment of an infant in 1991, which subsequently resulted in mental retardation. However, another doctor was absolved of all charges by the commission.
Top






 

Pervez coming with 19-member team
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, July 10
Pakistan President Pervez Musharraf is arriving here on July 14 with a 19-member official delegation.

A spokesman of the Ministry of External Affairs Nirupama Rao said the Pakistani side had conveyed the list of official delegation.

In a communication to the Ministry of External Affairs, Islamabad has communicated the names of the 19-member delegation which has Pakistan Foreign Minister Abdul Sattar in it, the spokesperson said. In addition to it, there would be security personnel and others, she said.

Asked if the list also had the name of Pakistani Minister of Commerce, Mrs Rao declined to comment saying that she do not have further details.

Mrs Rao did not say whether the Pakistani President would be accompanied by a business delegation.

Meanwhile, reports from Islamabad said that General Musharraf would be leading a 24-member delegation.

Besides Mr Sattar, other members of the delegation include Foreign Secretary Inamul Haq and General Musharraf’s spokesman Major General Rashid Qureshi.

Asked if Mr Sattar was coming to New Delhi before the summit, the spokesperson replied in negative.

To a question what would be the nationality of Kashmiris from the Pakistan occupied Kashmir (PoK) in their passports once they visit Jammu and Kashmir upon the opening of checkpost at the international border and Line of Control in Jammu and Kashmir, Mrs Rao avoided a direct reply saying “they will be carrying normal identification and travel documents”.

The question on what kind of passports was in reference to the Parliament resolution of February 22, 1994, which declares entire Jammu and Kashmir to be an integral part of India.

Whether India was not converting LoC into an international border, Mrs Rao said “we are not conferring on LoC any other status but which exists at present. We are just establishing administrative convenience for the people of both sides”.

In response to another question, she said there was no limit on agenda and it was for the two leaders to decide on the agenda.

Meanwhile, it is learnt that General Musharraf would have a close door meeting with six members of the All-Party Hurriyat Conference executive on July 14 at the Tilak Marg residence of Pakistan High Commissioner Ashraf Jehangir Qazi. Mr Sattar would also be present at the meeting. Apart from JKLF member Yasin Malik who is away to London, all other six member of the Hurriyat Executive would attend the close door meeting.

When confronted with the news of meeting between the Hurriayt leaders and the Pakistani President, the official spokesperson reiterated India’s stand.Top

 

USA ‘setting agenda’ for summit
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, July 10
The two Left parties are going to seek answers to their strong apprehensions that Washington was indeed setting the agenda for the Indo-Pakistan summit in Agra this week when their leaders meet Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee this evening.

Even while the Left parties extended their support to Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee’s invitation to Pakistan President Pervez Musharraf for summit talks in Agra at yesterday’s all party meeting, the Left parties along with the main opposition party failed to get enlightened over the agenda of the talks between India and Pakistan.

Talking to The Tribune, CPI leader D. Raja said “we apprehend that Washington was pulling the strings from behind forcing India and Pakistan to talks on the US agenda”.

Mr Raja said the CPI would like to know from the Prime Minister about the agenda for talks.

Participating in a seminar “India-Pakistan: people, policies and government”, organised by the Forum of Public Affairs, CPM Politburou member Sitaram Yechuri today said that the government did not present any structured agenda at the all-party meeting as maximum time of the three-hour-long meeting was taken by the issue whether the parties should attend the Pakistan High Commission’s much publicised tea party, in which Hurriyat leaders were invited, or not.

Mr Yechuri said it appeared that the agenda for talks was being set by the USA which continued to have strategic interest in Jammu and Kashmir.

Referring to former US President Bill Clinton’s recent revelation that he had made former Pakistan Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif withdraw Pakistani troops to their side of Line of Control during the Kargil conflict for which he (Sharif) had to pay a heavy price, Mr Yechuri said it was an important information to us as till then we believed Vajpayee government’s claim that the Indian troops had forced Pakistani armies to withdraw.

The government has not yet denied Mr Clinton’s claim, Mr Yechuri pointed out.

Even inviting General Musharraf for talks and terminating ceasefire was incomprehensible to us as till then the Vajpayee government was maintaining that India would not to talk to Pakistan as it would mean giving legitimacy to a military government, the CPM leader said.

The government officially told us further that until Pakistan ceased its support to militant organisation and shunned cross-border terrorism we would not talk to Islamabad, Mr Yechuri said.

Sudden abandonment of the officially stated position and inviting General Musharraf was something which we find difficult to swallow, the CPM leader said adding that the government had no satisfactory answers to our queries which gives rise to our apprehension that some other force was dictating the policy towards Pakistan.

Earlier, former Indian Youth Congress President Manish Tewari said one had to be very careful while talking to Pakistan as the historic Lahore bus trip had proved.

Mr Tewari said the best way to deal with Pakistan was to surmount the wave of emotions that usually engulf such events and to get out of the long-lost brother syndrome.

It would be better to talk to Pakistan in a pragmatic and hard nose manner laying down our priorities and national obejctives in a straightforward manner, Mr Tewari said adding that if this was not adhered to then “I am afraid this summit would meet the same fate as the bus to Lahore that lies overturned in Kargil and Kandahar”.

Echoing the same sentiments, Congress leader Salman Khurshid accused the government of going to talks without any homework saying that this was the reason that this government has no agenda for the talks for the Agra summit.

Mr Khurshid, who was the Minister of State for External Affairs in the Narasimha Rao government, said while the government was saying that the Kashmir issue would be discussed at the summit but there seems to be no Kashmir policy of this government.Top

 

Pak urged to discourage militancy
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, July 10
The Indo-Pak conference of social scientists has recommended that to improve security environment in South Asia, Pakistan should take steps to discourage the cross-border movement of militants and the two countries should work towards demilitarising the Line of Control. Calling for a sustained dialogue on Kashmir, it said India should take adequate steps to improve human rights situation in the valley.

The 10 groups which deliberated on themes ranging from security issues to economics and civic and gender issues during the two-day conference here, recommended setting up a SARRC parliament in Karachi, free trade between India and Pakistan, easing visa regulations and keeping politics out of sport.

Prof M.L. Sondhi, chairperson of the ICSSR, announced that on the directions of Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee, ICSSR Member-Secretary Bhaskar Chaterjee would proceed to Islamabad to put in place an institutional mechanism that would build upon the exchanges between the intellectuals in New Delhi. The recommendations of the conference are likely to be presented to both Mr Vajpayee and Mr Musharraf before the Agra summit.

The group on security issues, whose recommendations have special relevance in view of the past bitterness between India and Pakistan, has suggested that India and Pakistan should set up a Joint Working Group on issues related to cross-border terrorism.

It said that both countries should review the 1989 agreement on Siachen and take measures for greater interaction with people specially in the areas across LoC. The group also emphasised the right of Kashmiri Pandits to return to the valley.Top

 

I was not consulted: Gowda
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, July 10
Four days before the historic Agra summit, former Indian Prime Minister Deve Gowda today struck a note of dissent, while welcoming the India-Pakistan talks, as it would reduce tensions between the two countries.

“The talks between Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee and Pakistan President Pervez Musharraf might not solve the contentious issues between the two countries. However, it would reduce tensions,” Mr Gowda said here today.

Stating that the invitation to General Musharraf as a “good move”, the former Prime Minister appeared to be disenchanted with Mr Vajpayee as he had not been consulted on such an important issue.

“I have read from media report that Mr Vajpayee had called a meeting with the former Prime Minister and sought their views. I have not received any such invitation,” Mr Gowda told The Tribune.

Asked whether the talks were being held under the US pressure, Mr Gowda said, “This is not the right time to comment on such issues. We have our own views on the declaration of unilateral ceasefire, its withdrawal, and other recent decisions of the government.”

Mr Gowda, also the president of the Janata Dal (secular), which concluded its two-day national executive today, in its resolution on the Indo-Pak talks said “the process will inevitably be a continuing one and in assessing the outcome of the talks, it is advisable to eschew over optimism as well as undue pessimism.”

On the Manipur crisis, the resolution said “the Union Government has shown a total lack of foresight and broad perspective in handling the issue of extending the ceasefire to Manipur. It has not only provoked the people of Manipur but has led to the destabilisation of the democratic structure.”

Describing the political developments in Tamil Nadu as a battle of revenge between the two major political formations, the Janata Dal (secular) resolution came down heavily on the Centre in handling the crisis.Top

 

Release PoWs, Bitta urges Pak
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, July 10
Though three decades have passed still many 1971 Prisoners of War (PoW) are languishing in Pakistan prisons. They should be released immediately, the head of the All-India Anti-Terrorist Front, Mr M.S. Bitta said here today.

Activist of the AIATF today, held a demonstration in front of the Pakistani Embassy here demanding that President Pervez Musharraf should bring along with him all PoWs languishing in Pakistan jail.

The demonstrators included the family members of the PoWs who have been eagerly waiting for the return of their loved ones.

“It would be a great gesture on your (Musharraf) part if the PoWs were brought along with your delegation to India,” Mr Bitta said, adding that some of the issue hang like iron curtain between the cordial relations of the two countries.

He also demanded that the handover of the terrorists responsible for hijacking the Indian Airlines plane from Nepal in December last so that they could be tried in accordance with the Indian laws.

The AIATF also demanded that the dreaded terrorists of Punjan and Kashmir who are holed up in Pakistan should be apprehended and handed over to the Indian Government.Top

 

Pak people pin hopes on summit
Prashant Sood
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, July 10
There is an air of hope and optimism among the people of Pakistan regarding the Vajpayee-Musharraf summit; Pakistan’s President Pervez Musharraf has the backing of the establishment and people to move forward. While it would be unrealistic to expect the summit to thrash out 50-year old problems, the two countries must evolve mechanism to keep talking to each other.

Social scientists, journalists, academicians and businessmen from Pakistan, who are here to attend ICSSR-organised conference, may have differing perception about the reasons for bitterness in the Indo-Pakistan relations but all of them look to the Vajpayee-Musharraf summit as a historical opportunity to make amends and chart a new course for future.

Dr Rifaat Hussain, Chairman, Defence and Strategic Studies, Quaid-I-Azam University, Islamabad, feels that the summit would mean a reconnection with the Lahore Declaration. “However, lot of groundwork is being done for this summit unlike Lahore,” he adds. Describing General Musharraf as one of the most powerful persons in the history of Pakistan, Dr Hussain says that the General had himself talked about the possibility of history being created.

Maintaining that Pakistan’s December 2, 2000 announcement about LoC restraint went a long way in addressing Indian apprehensions about talking to Pakistan, Dr Hussain denied that things were moving under international pressure. Emphasising that the Pakistan President had the backing of major constituents home, he says that factions of the PPP and Nawaz Sharief’s Muslim League had also supported his moves to engage with India.

Asserting that there was far more at stake than the summit being put in jeopardy over the issue of Hurriyat’s proposed meeting with General Musharraf, Professor Mohammed Wasim, Chairman, International Relations of the Quaid-I-Azam University, Islamabad, says that India and Pakistan should at least announce confidence-building measures after the summit. “It is important to keep talking. Kashmir can wait but talking cannot,” he emphasises. The Professor says that instability in South Asia had affected growth of democracy in Pakistan. Lauding India’s “peace-offensive”(scholarships, fellowships), he said that Pakistan government was also taking some reciprocal measures.

Mr Hamid Haroon, Publisher and Editor of the Dawn, says that Kashmir continued to be the major sore point in Indo-Pakistan relations, he says that the issue had to be addressed squarely but without bitterness of the past. “Absence of an agreement on the issue will make life difficult both for India and Pakistan,” he says.

Referring to the problems plaguing Pakistan economy, Mr Fahim Zaman Khan, a Karachi-based columnist, says that both India and Pakistan should have vested interest in normalising relations. “For a start, the two countries can lose travel restrictions, de-militiarise Siachen, promote greater people-to-people exchange and reduce hostilities,” he suggests.Top

 

Pervez escapes unhurt in mishap

New Delhi, July 10
Pakistan President Pervez Musharraf escaped unhurt in a road accident while his gunman and the driver of an escorting car sustained injuries when a car smashed into their vehicle near Islamabad airport, ‘The Dawn’ said today.

The accident occurred yesterday when a private car smashed into the car escorting the VVIP convoy near the entrance gate of the Islamabad International Airport, the paper reported quoting the police sources.

As a result, the driver of the escorting car and General Musharraf’s gunman sustained injuries and their car was damaged. UNI
Top


 

Musharraf’s presidency challenged in SC

Islamabad, July 10
Pakistan military ruler Gen Pervez Musharraf’s last month’s decision to declare himself President has been challenged in the Supreme Court.

Court officials said that the petition, filed by an advocate from Rawalpindi challenging the “self-induction” of Gen Pervez Musharraf as President and removal of the elected President Rafiq Tarar and dissolution of the National Assembly, was received yesterday and could be listed for hearing during the course of the week.

General Musharraf, in a surprise move on June 20, took over as President and the decision was condemned by major political parties as unconstitutional and illegal.

The Lahore High Court, however, had rejected a petition challenging the self-appointment.

The new petition has evoked curiosity here as Supreme Court Chief Justice Irshad Hassan Khan had lent credibility to the appointment by administering oath of office to General Musharraf.

He was widely criticised by the political parties and former judges for this action. PTI
Top

 

Crew of sinking Vietnamese ship rescued

Kolkata, July 10
Most crew members of the Nepal-bound Vietnamese ship, sinking in the Bay of Bengal after developing a leak in its hold, have been rescued and the vessel abandoned near the Sandhead, about 230 km from here.

Official sources said personnel of the Coast Guard, Dredging Corporation of India and Kolkata Port Trust were engaged in the operation to rescue the crew of the ship, sinking since last night. 

Captain of “Lucnan” Binh Le Quoc said all 30 crew members of the ship, owned by the Vietnamese Oceanic Shipping Company, were safe.

The ship, heading for Haldia Port and carrying 13,000 tonnes of fertilisers from China, sunk more than 10 feet at the confluence of the Hooghly and the Bay of Bengal after water rushed through the hold.

The crew tried to pump out the water but the leak could not be plugged, the sources added. UNITop

 

Naga Cong leaders meet Advani
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, July 10
A day after Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee announced a review of extension of the Centre-NSCN(I-M) ceasefire beyond Nagaland, a 12-member Nagaland Pradesh Congress Committee (NPCC) delegation today met Union Home Minister L. K. Advani and demanded that the ceasefire not be reviewed or revoked.

The delegation, led by senior Nagaland Minister P. Enyei Konyak, expressed their resentment against the review of the ceasefire extension beyond Nagaland.

According to sources, they drew the attention of the Home Minister to Clause 13 of the 16-point agreement reached between the Naga People’s Council and the Centre in 1960, which states that those Nagas living in Naga inhabited areas should be allowed to join Nagaland if they so desire and pointed out that this clause had not been fulfilled.

They emphasised that the extension of ceasefire beyond Nagaland was a step forward in implementing the clause and thus the ceasefire extension should not be reviewed or revoked.

The other members of the delegation were K V Pusa, Toeheho Yepthomi, H Chuba Chang, Naipa Ndang, I Imkong, Zachilhu Vadeo (all ministers), C Apok Jamir, K Asungba Sangdam (all MPs), V C Kanito, MLA, Shilo Sangtam, NPCC general secretary and Imkong L Imchen, NPCC vice-president.

Earlier, the delegation also met senior AICC members and handed over the resolution for Congress President Sonia Gandhi.

They had yesterday met Minister of State for Home I D Swami and are planning to meet Mr Vajpayee.Top

 

Congress flays govt on Naga truce
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, July 10
The Congress today accused the Vajpayee government of creating a mess in Manipur and other north-eastern states and on the Naga ceasefire issue.

“It is clear that the present government has no perception, comprehension or understanding of the sensitivity of people of Manipur, Assam and Nagaland. This mess has been created by an inconsistent flip-flop approach of the Union Government,” Congress spokesman Anand Sharma told newspersons here.
Top

 

UTI fiasco: CPI asks Sinha to quit
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, July 10
The CPI today demanded the resignation of Union Finance Minister Yashwant Sinha for the UTI fiasco.

“The Finance Minister should quit, criminal proceedings be started against the guilty, the government should take immediate steps to restructure and rehabilitate this institution and the interest of the small investors be effetely protected,” the CPI demanded in a statement.

Mr Sinha has ruled out any move to step down from office.

The UTI, having mobilised funds from lower middle class and middle class population have never formulated a transparent investment policy.

What it did was to favour large industrial houses with private placement, incurring huge losses. It even invested heavily in the secondary market to rescue the sensex on the instructions of the Finance Ministry, ignoring the economic fundamentals, the CPI said.

The Union Finance Ministry’s move to institute a probe into the UTI fiasco was today described by the CPI as a “shrewd attempt to cover up the entire fiasco.”

“The inquiry into the UTI fiasco is a shrewd attempt to cover up the entire fiasco,” the CPI said.

The Left party asked “how can the Finance Ministry plead ignorance when a representative of the RBI is on the board? The issue was raised in Parliament earlier, even the Joint Parliamentary Committee on Security Scam in 1992-93 referred to the condition prevaling in UTI.” The party alleged that Mr Sinha was aware of the situation.Top

 

Cabinet discusses arrest of ministers
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, July 10
The recent arrest of two Central ministers, Mr Murasoli Maran and Mr T.R. Baalu, in Tamil Nadu figured at the Cabinet meeting today with several members suggesting that steps be taken to ensure that ministers are treated with respect all over the country.

The issued was raised by Mr Maran and Mr Baalu at the meeting. They felt their arrests by the Jayalalitha government should be seen in a wider context and in a larger perspective.

According to a minister, it was indicated that the Union Home Ministry and the Law Ministry would sit together to formulate a convention which would ensure that proper procedures are followed to establish any guilt before arrests of ministers are made. This would not mean immunity but ensure that the Central Ministers are treated with respect, he added.

During the discussion on Tamil, Nadu, which lasted more than 45 minutes, various questions were raised regarding the state government’s failure to provide constitutional guarantee to an elected representative.

Several members took exception to the Tamil Nadu Government’s announcement to set up a one-man enquiry commission to look into the police excesses committed during the arrest of DMK chief M. Karunanidhi.

The Prime Minister, Mr Atal Behari Vajpayee, asked the two ministers from Tamil Nadu to have a meeting with their counterparts in the Ministries of Home and Law and Justice as part of the exercise to ensure that such incidents don’t occur in the future.Top

 

Maran, Baalu assaulted police: Jaya

Chennai, July 10
Tamil Nadu Chief Minister J. Jayalalitha today reiterated that Union Ministers Murasoli Maran and T.R. Baalu had ‘abused and assaulted’ police personnel during the arrest of DMK President M Karunanidhi and asserted that sufficient ground exist for their dismissal from the union Government on the basis of complaints from the affected police personnel.

In a ten-page statement, she said the arrest of Mr Karunanidhi was in accordance with the Indian Police Act 1861, which stipulated that a political leader of mass following should be arrested only late in the night to avoid any law and order problem.

She noted that Mr Karunanidhi and his wife Rajathi Ammal had cooperated well when the police went to their residence on June 30 to effect the arrest and the problem arose only after Mr Maran arrived at the scene.

The police officials had entered Mr Karunanidhi’s bedroom only after being invited by him, she said and dismissed as “pure lie,’’ the allegation that they had barged into his room.

The statement, giving the official version of the incidents, comes within a week after the Centre had issued a warning to the state government and directing it to take action against the police personnel for the “high-handedness’’ during the arrest of Mr Karunanidhi and later the Union Ministers. The Centre had also wanted a compliance report.

The Jayalalithaa government responded quickly by appointing the Justice Raman commission of inquiry to probe whether there was any excess while effecting the arrest and also whether the ministers had assaulted public servants while discharging their duties.

Mr Karunanidhi, earlier, had announced that his party would boycott the commission.

The Chief Minister’s statement was, however, silent on the much quoted Supreme Court directive on the procedures to be followed while effecting an arrest. UNITop

 

Omar sent as PM’s emissary to Libya
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, July 10
Mr Omar Abdullah, Minister of State for Commerce and Industry, has been sent to Libya as a special emissary of the Prime Minister, Mr Atal Behari Vajpayee, to explain India’s position on Kashmir before the scheduled Indo-Pakistan summit.

Sources said Mr Abdullah was carrying a letter from Mr Vajpayee addressed to the Libyan President, Mr M. Gaddafi. The letter was meant to explain India’s position on Kashmir since the matter had come up for discussions during the recent meeting of the Organisation of Islamic Conference (OIC) in Mali of which Libya was also a member.

These sources said Mr Omar Abdullah, son of the Chief Minister of Jammu and Kashmir, Mr Farooq Abdullah, was specially chosen for the mission because of his first hand knowledge of Kashmir.

Former Chairman of the All-Party Hurriyat Conference (APHC), Mirwaiz Omar Farooq had also attended the conference. He returned to the Capital yesterday.

Sources said the decision to send Mr Omar Abdullah to Libya was taken as Libya had become quite vocal over the Kashmir issue recently. The letter was meant to place things in the proper perspective.Top

 

SC’s ruling on dying declaration
Legal Correspondent

New Delhi, July 10
The Supreme Court, while streamlining the law on dying declarations as admissible in evidence for the basis of conviction, has maintained that a singular dying declaration, not suffering from any infirmity and found worthy of being relied on, may form the basis of conviction.

“On the other hand, if every individual dying declaration consisting in a plurality is found to be infirm, the court would not be persuaded to act thereon merely because the dying declarations are more than one and apparently consistent,” the court said while dismissing an appeal by the mother of a deceased dowry victim demanding the conviction of her husband his mother and sister on the singular evidence of dying declarations against them.

The appellant, Mrs Laxmi, had prayed for the reversal of a Delhi High Court judgement acquitting all three respondents of the charges under Sections 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code because of infirmity in the dying declarations as the deceased was not in a fit condition to depose to the relevant persons including investigating and police officers.

Reiterating the law in Kundala Bala Subrahmanyam case (1993), a division bench of the court comprising Mr Justice R C Lahoti and Mr Justice Doraiswamy Raju said, “The dying declaration, is relevant and admissible in evidence, `provided it has been made by the deceased while in a fit mental condition’”.

Delivering the judgement, Mr Justice Lahoti postulated: “A court of facts is not excluded from acting upon an uncorroborated dying declaration for finding conviction. A dying declaration, as a piece of evidence, stands on the same footing as any other piece of evidence.”

“It has to be judged and appreciated in the light of the surrounding circumstances and its weight determined by reference to the principles governing the weighing of evidence. It is, as if the maker of the dying declaration was present in the court, making a statement, stating the facts contained in the declaration, with the difference that the declaration is not a statement on oath and the maker thereof cannot be subjected to cross-examination,” the judge added.

Upholding the High Court judgement, the judges further stated, “if, in a given case, a particular dying declaration suffers from any infirmities, either of its own or as disclosed by other evidence adduced in the case or circumstances coming to its notice, the court may, as a rule of prudence, look for corroboration and if the infirmities conscience of the court, the same be refused to be accepted as forming a safe basis for conviction.”

The deceased, Janak Kumari (25), died an unnatural death due to extensive burns in March 1982. Married in 1976, she had a five-year-old child at the time of the incident. The couple had an estranged relationship. Janaki is reported to have told a neighbour, witness in the case, that she would teach her husband and in-laws a lesson by committing suicide. This possibility was accepted by the judges.
Top

`

Prabhakar’s remand extended to July 21

Dehra Dun, July 10
Former Test cricketer Manoj Prabhakar’s judicial custody in the chit fund scam has been extended up to July 21.

Nainital Judicial Magistrate Devraj Prasad Singh, who extended the custody, also directed the Chief Medical Officer to conduct a medical examination of Prabhakar, who is undergoing treatment at a hospital.

The Chief Medical Officer has been asked to submit his report tomorrow. Prabhakar had been remanded in judicial custody on July 2 for six days in one of the three cases against him.

Accompanied by his wife Sandhya, the former cricketer was brought to the court yesterday in an ambulance. Large crowds could be seen in and around the court to have a look at him. But Prabhakar did not come out of the ambulance.

His counsel K.C. Upreti made a plea to exempt Prabhakar from being presented in the court which was allowed by the magistrate.

Prabhakar had been admitted to a nursing home in Haldwani after he had complained of pain in his fingers and legs following his arrest in Delhi on July 2 for his suspected involvement in forgery at the Apace India Chit Fund, a private non-banking financial company.

He was arrested by the Haldwani police after a local court issued non-bailable warrants against him. UNITop

 

Ball in Centre’s court: Enron, Maharashtra

Mumbai, July 10
The Enron Corporation and the Maharashtra Government today threw the ball in the Centre’s court by seeking its “greater participation” to solve the imbroglio between the multinational and the State Electricity Board (MSEB) over the USD three billion power project in Dabhol.

“Our tariff is globally competitive and once the use of liquefied natural gas (LNG) begins, it will be lower”, US energy major’s Chairman Kenneth Lay told reporters here tonight.

Mr Lay said he had a constructive meeting with Maharashtra Chief Minister Vilasrao Deshmukh and that it “was in common interests for both the parties to solve the issue amicably”. PTI
Top

 

Trial run of India-B’desh train service today

Kolkata, July 10
The passenger train service between India and Bangladesh will have its trial run tomorrow with regular service expected after the General Elections in the neighbouring country around October next.

Eastern Railway sources said the fare structure, frequency of service and related matters would be decided after the successful trial run.

The trial run by the Bangladesh Railways would take place between Bangabandhu and Sealdah in Kolkata via Darsana in Bangladesh and Gede in India. The trains would cover a distance of about 180 km to reach their destinations in the countries.

Subsequently, the service would be extended to Kamalpur near Dhaka after the public sector Indian Railway Construction Company (IRCON) completed the 100-km-long broad gauge railway line from the Bangabandhu station to Kamalpur on the outskirts of the country’s capital town. UNITop

 

 

Panel too holds doctor guilty
Amarjit Thind
Tribune News Service

Sriganganagar, July 10
The Rajasthan State Consumer Redressal Commission has upheld the decision of the District Consumer Redressal Forum holding a doctor responsible for “negligence” in the treatment of an infant in 1991, which subsequently resulted in mental retardation. However, another doctor was absolved of all charges by the commission.

Tragically, Deepika (10) died the day the judgement was delivered at Jaipur a few days ago. The shocked parents are today trying to come to grips with the incident. They are planning to take “the negligent doctor to the court so that he would not be able to play with the life of any more patients. The hands which were supposed to save her life resulted in her death,” says her distraught father, Mr Lajpat Rai.

According to Mr Rai, a teacher at Government Senior Secondary School, Sribijaynagar, near here, Deepika was a few days old when she fell down. He took her to the residence of Dr Charanjeet Sharma, Medical Officer, Seth Kesar Chand Hospital. The doctor changed Rs 25 as fees and asked him to bring back the child to the hospital the next day.

He examined her the next day and “without conducting any further tests injected her thrice with DTP polio.”

Following this Deepika developed high fever and was again taken to the doctor at his residence where he prescribed 60 mg of gardinal in tablet form to be administerd to the child for a month. But the condition of Deepika deteriorated. She started having fits, and was again taken to the doctor who referred her to Dr Shyam Sunder Tantia at Sriganganagar.

Dr Tantia conducted an EEG test and concluded that “she was suffering from epilepsy” and further advised him that “the treatment, gardinal, should be continued for at least five years.”

Mr Rai complied with the instructions of the doctor but the condition of Deepika continued to deteriorate. As she grew older she started showing signs of being a mental patient.

On the advice of family members and friends, he moved an application against the doctors in the District Consumer Forum which ruled in his favour and awarded damages of Rs 25, 000 each against Dr Tantia and Dr Sharma. He challenged the order in the state commission which held that while Dr Tantia had conducted the EEG and was of the impression that the fits could be that of epilepsy, there was no evidence to show that the doctor advised him to keep his daughter on gardinal.

The commission held that the consultant physician of the child was Dr Charanjeet Sharma who had prescribed these tablets for Deepika on January 23, 1992. Dr Tantia carried out the necessary tests on March 12 , 1991.

But, there was sufficient evidence against Dr Sharma since he took the fees at his home for carrying out an examination at the hospital the next day. He also prescribed a strong dose of 60 mg of gardinal for Deepika, a mere infant at that time.

After administering the polio vaccination, the child could have developed fever in normal course but after that he, as an experienced medical consultant, should have exhibited more professional skill and care in the treatment of the child.

The members were also unanimous that “without conducting further tests the doctor prescribed the medication for a mere infant. Thus, he was negligent in rendering professional services to the child.” His appeal was dismissed with costs of Rs 1, 000.Top

 
NATIONAL BRIEFS

FOLLOW FREEDOM FIGHTERS: GOVERNOR
GANDHINAGAR:
Gujarat Governor Sundersinh Bhandari has called on the youth to inculcate the spirit of sacrifice as practised by the freedom fighters during the British rule. Laying a foundation stone for a memorial of martyrs of 1857 mutiny, at Tajpur village in Ahmedabad district on Monday, he said the youths should take a lesson from these martyrs. PTI

DAIS COLLAPSES, REDDY UNHURT
HYDERABAD:
Congress spokesman S. Jaipal Reddy escaped unhurt while three others sustained injuries when a dais where he was seated collapsed at Amanagallu village in Mahabubnagar district, on Monday reports said. The mishap occurred when Mr Reddy occupied a seat along with other local leaders on the makeshift stage erected for addressing meetings in connection with forthcoming local bodies elections. PTI

WOMAN COMMITS SUICIDE ON “GADAR”
NASIK: Enraged over the inability of her husband to take her to see the Hindi blockbuster “Gadar”, a young woman allegedly committed suicide by hanging herself here on Sunday. The police said on Monday that Ramsingh Malkhamsingh Yadav (25), staying in Mangesh Chawl, promised his wife Mamta (22) to take her to the movie on Saturday, but due to some work, could not reach home in time. Angry over the issue, Mamta allegedly ended her life by hanging herself with a saree. PTI

CONTROVERSY OVER GAY CLUBS
LUCKNOW:
A controversy has erupted here following the arrest of some people believed to be running gay clubs under the guise of a non-governmental organisation (NGO) dealing with HIV/AIDS awareness programme. The NGO, “Bharosa Trust,” denying its involvement in gay activities on Monday said it was only creating awareness of HIV/AIDS among the people of the state. UNI

PLAN TO RELOCATE ASIATIC LION OPPOSED
VADODARA
: International Society of Naturalists (INSONA) General Secretary Dr G.M. Oza has opposed the proposed relocation of the Asiatic lion from its present abode at the Gir National Park to the new Palpur Kuno Habitat of Madhya Pradesh. Reacting to the Ministry of Environment and Forests’ plans to initially shifts 15 Gir lions to the new habitat, Dr Oza also emeritus member of the World Conservation Union’s special survival commission, stated in a press note that the foremost need in the beginning of the 21st century was to preserve the habitat of the Asiatic lion in its present home the Gir National Park. UNI

PLAN TO RENOVATE BUDDHIST SITES
PATNA:
In a joint effort the Union Tourism Ministry and the Bihar Tourism Department, an ambitious programme has been chalked out for renovating Buddhist sites of Nalanda, Vaishali, Patna and Rajgir in the state. Bihar Minister of State for Tourism Suresh Paswan said here on Monday that the programme entailing an expenditure of Rs 20 lakh had the proposal of constructing entrance gates, cultural notice boards, cultural models and other works. The Centre would provide Rs 13.32 lakh, while Rs 6.68 lakh would be given by the State Tourism Department. UNI

ACTOR SARAT KUMAR DMK NOMINEE FOR RS
CHENNAI:
Tamil filmstar R. Saratkumar will be the DMK’s nominee for the July 23 biennial elections to the Rajya Sabha from Tamil Nadu party President M. Karunanidhi said here on Tuesday. Saratkumar, who unsuccessfully contested the 1998 Lok Sabha election from Tirunelveli as the DMK candidate, had extensively campaigned for the party in the May 10 poll to the State Assembly. PTI

FREEDOM FIGHTER RAHANE DEAD
NASIK:
A freedom fighter and former vice-president of the Bhagur Municipal Council died at Bhagur, about 11 km from here, on Monday following old age, family sources said. He was 82. Born on January 20, 1920, at Janori in Dindori taluka of Nasik district, he took active part in Nanded movement against Hyderabad Nijamshahi. He also worked with the Congress and took part in 1942 ‘Quit India’ Movement and was jailed twice. He is survived by two sons and two daughters. PTI
Top

Home | Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir | Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs | Nation | Editorial |
|
Business | Sport | World | Mailbag | In Spotlight | Chandigarh Tribune | Ludhiana Tribune
50 years of Independence | Tercentenary Celebrations |
|
121 Years of Trust | Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | Suggestion | E-mail |