SPECIAL COVERAGE
CHANDIGARH

LUDHIANA

DELHI



THE TRIBUNE SPECIALS
50 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE

TERCENTENARY CELEBRATIONS
image
N A T I O N

Cong steps up attack on Modi over Vanzara’s letter
New Delhi, September 4
A day after jailed Gujarat IPS officer DG Vanzara made explosive claims regarding Narendra Modi-led stateDG Vanzara at a court. government’s approval to fake encounters of alleged terrorists such as Sohrabuddin Sheikh, the ruling Congress stepped up attack on the Chief Minister seeking a CBI and court-led probe into the contents of Vanzara’s letter.

DG Vanzara at a court. — PTI

BJP calls it conspiracy
New Delhi, September 4
Gujarat former IPS officer DG Vanzara’s sensational letter is not expected to impact BJP’s plan to anoint Narendra Modi as its prime ministerial candidate, but it may affect the plans of those who want the announcement “as soon as possible”.

Gujarat Govt yet to decide on officer’s resignation
Ahmedabad, September 4
Rattled by suspended IPS officer DG Vanzara’s charges against Chief Minister Narendra Modi and his former deputy Amit Shah in the fake encounter cases, the Gujarat Government has kept in abeyance a decision on his resignation from the Indian Police Services, even as the state Congress demanded Modi’s resignation and called for a ‘Gujarat Bandh’ on September 6.




EARLIER STORIES

Asaram Asaram’s bail plea rejected
Jodhpur, September 4
The bail plea of self-styled godman Asaram Bapu, accused of allegedly sexually assaulting a 16- year-old girl, was today rejected by a Jodhpur court after the prosecution raised strong objection to setting him free.


Asaram

Missing coal files issue rocks Parliament again
New Delhi, September 4
Upping the ante on the Congress-led UPA government over the missing coal files issue in both the Houses of Parliament today, the BJP urged Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to volunteer for interrogation before the CBI in the interest of propriety and transparency in the matter.

No FIR for now against Delhi CM Dikshit: HC
New Delhi, September 4
In a relief to Delhi Chief Minister Sheila Dikshit, the Delhi High Court today stayed till September 19 a trial court order for registration of an FIR against her for alleged misuse of government funds for an advertisement campaign ahead of the 2008 Assembly election.

Centre mulls UT status for Hyderabad
Hyderabad, September 4
The UPA government is considering a proposal to grant Union Territory status to Hyderabad and make it the joint capital of Andhra Pradesh and the proposed Telangana state for 10 years.

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh along with wife Gursharan Kaur arrives for the 8th G20 Summit in St Petersburg, Russia, on Wednesday. Avoid policies that hurt developing world, PM tells rich nations
New Delhi, September 4
Prime Minister Manmohan Singh today said rich nations need to refrain from pursuing such economic policies which could endanger the growth prospects of the developing world.



Prime Minister Manmohan Singh along with wife Gursharan Kaur arrives for the 8th G20 Summit in St Petersburg, Russia, on Wednesday. — PTI

For troops, Pak border teams biggest threat
Along the Line of Control, September 4
Cross-border fire notwithstanding, the biggest threat for troops deployed along the Line of Control (LoC) comes from Pakistan’s Border Action Teams (BATs) —armed groups tasked to carry out guerrilla-type operations by launching surprise attacks on Indian detachments and withdrawing quickly.

Girl dies after being ragged at industrial unit
Mumbai, September 4
In a shocking incident in Nashik, an 18-year-old woman apprentice at an industrial unit committed suicide after being ragged by her batchmates, the police said here. The girl, Pranali Rahane, had slashed her wrists and hanged herself on Monday night. However, her relatives managed to cut the rope and took her to hospital. She died on Tuesday night, the police said.





Top








 

Cong steps up attack on Modi over Vanzara’s letter
Aditi Tandon/TNS

friend-turned-foe
Deputy Inspector General of Police-rank officer DG Vanzara (59) is under suspension and behind bars in a string of fake encounter cases, particularly the Ishrat Jahan case
The 1987-batch IPS officer was once considered close to Gujarat CM Narendra Modi
He resigned from service accusing the Modi government of having failed to protect jailed police officers who fought against ‘Pak-inspired terrorism’

‘cbi must take note of the letter’
The courts and the CBI must take note of this letter which shows how the Gujarat Government under Modi used police officers to their ends and then ensured they did not even get bail. There is a clear resentment against the policy of the state government

— Meem Afzal, Congress spokesperson

New Delhi, September 4
A day after jailed Gujarat IPS officer DG Vanzara made explosive claims regarding Narendra Modi-led state government’s approval to fake encounters of alleged terrorists such as Sohrabuddin Sheikh, the ruling Congress stepped up attack on the Chief Minister seeking a CBI and court-led probe into the contents of Vanzara’s letter.

"The courts and the CBI must take note of this letter which shows how the Gujarat Government under Modi used police officers to their ends and then ensured they did not even get bail. There is a clear resentment against the policy of the state government," Congress national spokesperson Meem Afzal said. He was referring to Vanzara's letter which states that Gujarat cops were "simply implementing the state's policy on anti-terrorism.”

In another breath, the Congress trashed suggestions of its hand behind the sudden anti-Modi revelations over the past three days.

"We do not indulge in conspiracies. It has been said that threads of this (read anti-Modi) conspiracy can be traced to 10 Janpath. That's a lie. The BJP should look within and it will find roots of these developments in its own house. Everyone knows of the ongoing infighting in the BJP," Congress spokesperson Meem Afzal said.

While the sting showing Modi's nod to subversion of the justice system to protect Shah in Tulasiram Prajapati fake encounter case surfaced two days ago, leading to a PIL in the Supreme Court, Vanzara's letter (written from Sabarmati Central Prison) surfaced yesterday.

Asked why the Congress was putting its trust in the claims of Vanzara, himself an accused in several fake encounters, including Sohrabuddin Sheikh and Ishrat Jahan, Afzal said the party was simply seeking cognisance of fresh facts just as everyone else was.

"A serious claim has been made by Vanzara. He refers to state's hand in encounter killings. We are demanding a thorough probe into the veracity of these claims and in the meanwhile the resignation of Gujarat CM," Afzal said.

The Congress reiterated its demand for the resignation of Modi citing the sting CD that recorded a conversation between BJP MPs Prakash Javadekar and Bhupendra Yadav who are caught saying Modi has given a go ahead to the "plan of protecting Shah in the Tulasi Prajapati case".

Prajapati, an OBC, was the sole witness to the fake encounter of Sohrabuddi Sheikh, who was gunned down in December 2005. Amit Shah, the then Home Minister of Gujarat, is facing trial in these cases.

"The BJP loses no time in seeking the resignation of our ministers and even the PM on small matters. Now it must ensure that Narendra Modi resigns over these serious charges in the sting," Afzal said.

Top

 

BJP calls it conspiracy
Vibha Sharma/TNS

New Delhi, September 4
Gujarat former IPS officer DG Vanzara’s sensational letter is not expected to impact BJP’s plan to anoint Narendra Modi as its prime ministerial candidate, but it may affect the plans of those who want the announcement “as soon as possible”.

BJP leaders dismiss Vanzara’s letter-bomb as “baseless”, in fact calling it a “conspiracy” by the Congress considering its timing. But there are apprehensions that the explosive charges in it could be used as evidence against Shah, against whom cases are alive in the trial court.

BJP’s political opponents made the most of the Modi-related development. The Rajya Sabha saw a massive ruckus with the SP, the BSP, the Left and BJP ally-turned-foe JD(U) leading the attack, demanding his resignation and causing several adjournments.

As soon as the House met for the day, some Congress members displayed banners that read “Chief Minister Gujarat Must Resign” but soon other parties took over, raising slogans against the “terrorist Gujarat Government”.

Demanding that they may be allowed to raise the issue in the House, they insisted that the former police officer’s letter was a proof that Modi was in full knowledge of all that was happening in the state at that time.

They relented, allowing Rural Development Minister Jairam Ramesh to move the Land Acquisition Bill, after efforts by the government’s floor managers and a statement by the Chair that if they wanted a discussion on the issue they could give a notice.

BJP members vociferously defended Modi in the House, saying that matter pertaining to states should not be discussed in Parliament. But the party refrained from giving any official statement on the central leadership’s view on Vanzara, leaving the issue to the Gujarat BJP.

“He is just a frustrated man,” a senior leader commented. A point of view is that Vanzara, in his attempt to leave a window open, has not really said much against Modi.

“It is Shah that Vanzara is aiming at. The BJP can use it to tell voters that Modi is being targeted by the Congress. It also signifies that Modi always stands by justice, ” he said.

While the party dismissed Vanzara as a “non-issue”, it is apprehending more attacks on Modi in the days to come. Though the pro-Modi camp believes Vanzara’s letter will bring the party together, his detractors offer a more practical view point. “Delhi abhi door hai,” a leader quipped, adding: “Wait and watch”.

RSS and BJP leaders are expected to meet over the weekend to discuss the most important issue pending before the party.

While the clamour of “Modi for PM” is growing in the party, Vanzara’s letter seems to have added a new dimension to the scenario. Sources say the RSS leadership is trying to assess the damage caused by Vanzara’s charges and is working on a strategy to build a case for him under its “September plan”. A meeting of RSS and BJP leaders is scheduled over the weekend to finalise the strategy, they say.

Top

 

Gujarat Govt yet to decide on officer’s resignation
Manas Dasgupta

Ahmedabad, September 4
Rattled by suspended IPS officer DG Vanzara’s charges against Chief Minister Narendra Modi and his former deputy Amit Shah in the fake encounter cases, the Gujarat Government has kept in abeyance a decision on his resignation from the Indian Police Services, even as the state Congress demanded Modi’s resignation and called for a ‘Gujarat Bandh’ on September 6.

Sources in the state Home Department confirmed receipt of Vanzara’s 10-page “letter of resignation” -- a virtual chargesheet against Modi and his erstwhile Minister of State for Home Amit Shah (presently the BJP in-charge of Uttar Pradesh) - and said it had been forwarded to the chief minister’s office for a decision.

The Home Department maintained that since the chargesheet had already been filed against Vanzara in the Sohrabuddin Sheikh fake encounter case -- though it could be revised since the Supreme Court had directed clubbing it with the fake encounter case of Tulsiram Prajapati -- the suspended IPS officer seizes the right to resign, nor could he seek retirement on superannuation till the case was decided by the court.

The state cabinet, which met in Gandhinagar today under the chairmanship of Modi, is also learnt to have discussed in detail the possible repercussions of Vanzara’s open letter and decided to keep the resignation in abeyance till further scrutiny of the technical issues raised by the home department.

Legal experts, however, said technically the chargesheet filed in the Sohrabuddin encounter case no longer holds ground and the entire process would start afresh in view of the Supreme Court’s directive to club the two cases.

Claiming that no political party would have allowed a chief minister to continue in office even for a day if he faced charges such as those against Modi in various cases, state Congress president Arjun Modhvadia said the developments in the last three days had exposed Modi’s “politics of murder” and his and his government’s involvement in large scale corruption, and demanded his resignation immediately.

He said the law and order situation in the state had deteriorated to such a level that criminals were finding Gujarat their safest haven because of police inaction as the Modi government had totally ruined the morale of the police force. The party gave a call for a state-wide bandh on Friday to press for Modi’s resignation.

Top

 

Asaram’s bail plea rejected

Jodhpur, September 4
The bail plea of self-styled godman Asaram Bapu, accused of allegedly sexually assaulting a 16- year-old girl, was today rejected by a Jodhpur court after the prosecution raised strong objection to setting him free.

The District and Sessions Judge (Rural) Manoj Kumar Vyas dismissed the bail plea after two days of hearing arguments by Asaram’s counsel K K Manan and perusing prosecution's detailed reply.

The court rejected the defence counsel’s arguments raised over the FIR, medical report and statement of the girl who was sexually assaulted, Additional Advocate General Anand Purohit told reporters.

Asaram (72) was sent to jail on Monday after he was remanded in 14-day judicial custody by a court here. Asaram was arrested in Indore following an FIR lodged by the victim that she was sexually assaulted by him.

Asaram’s counsel alleged that the police had worked under the pressure of media and prepared FIR in a hurry. He contended that the FIR against Asaram does not stand as there are several lacunae in it.

He has been booked under sections 376, 342, 506 and 509 of the IPC, section 8 of the Prevention of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO) and sections 23 and 26 of the Juvenile Justice Act in connection with the alleged assault. The defence claimed that the victim was not minor as was being claimed and in fact was an adult. So, the charges under POSCO against Asaram also do not stand. — PTI

Top

 

Missing coal files issue rocks Parliament again
BJP says PM must offer to be questioned
Aditi Tandon/TNS

COAL MINISTER MISSING
Coal Minister Sriprakash Jaiswal was missing from Lok Sabha during discussions on missing files, prompting widespread criticism from the Opposition

New Delhi, September 4
Upping the ante on the Congress-led UPA government over the missing coal files issue in both the Houses of Parliament today, the BJP urged Prime Minister Manmohan Singh to volunteer for interrogation before the CBI in the interest of propriety and transparency in the matter.

The demand came after the government, following a series of meetings, bought peace with the BJP by agreeing to a discussion on the matter in Parliament.

"The PM must come forward and volunteer to be probed in the missing coal files issue. If he wants his name to be cleared, he must come forward. The coal allocation scam is the most serious of all scams we have known in the past. Here the PM's role is under doubt," Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha Sushma Swaraj said leading submissions on the issue around 2.30 pm when the House assembled after severe disruptions on the matter.

Led by the BJP, the Opposition in both Houses (in the Rajya Sabha BJP's Arun Jaitley led the charge) demanded immediate registration of an FIR in the missing files issue saying the files were "stolen".

Parties said the inability of the government to register a case was causing suspicion about its intentions. "If you don't register a case, your intentions will be doubted. An FIR must be immediately lodged because these files are not simply missing. They are stolen," said Sushma, citing 189 missing coal files which the CBI had sought from the government during the ongoing coal allocation scam probe which the Supreme Court is monitoring.

The BJP referred to some media reports to say the Attorney General (AG) had submitted a list of missing files and most of these pertained to influential Congress leaders. Mentioning another newspaper report, the BJP said a senior CBI officer has stressed the importance of questioning the PM in the coal allocation issue to determine the truth and considering this report the PM should offer to be probed.

Except RJD's Prabhunath Singh who talked of prosecuting the CBI officer who dared to point a finger at the PM, all opposition parties demanded immediate action on the coal file issue. UPA's outside supporter SP also took the occasion to ask the government whether the CBI "was acting at someone's behest".

The TMC, however, wanted the coal files of all block allocations since 1993 investigated.

Top

 

No FIR for now against Delhi CM Dikshit: HC
Legal Correspondent

New Delhi, September 4
In a relief to Delhi Chief Minister Sheila Dikshit, the Delhi High Court today stayed till September 19 a trial court order for registration of an FIR against her for alleged misuse of government funds for an advertisement campaign ahead of the 2008 Assembly election.

The Delhi government had approached the HC seeking quashing of the August 31 order of the trial court. The HC has asked BJP leader Vijender Gupta, the complainant, and Delhi Police Commissioner to respond to the government’s appeal.

Appearing for the Delhi government, Additional Solicitor General (ASG) Siddharth Luthra had contended that Gupta had filed the complaint solely relying on the Lokayukta report and without producing any material to substantiate the allegations.

Top

 

Centre mulls UT status for Hyderabad
Suresh Dharur/TNS

Hyderabad, September 4
The UPA government is considering a proposal to grant Union Territory status to Hyderabad and make it the joint capital of Andhra Pradesh and the proposed Telangana state for 10 years.

“The proposal is on the table but no final decision has been taken. There is a valid argument for making Hyderabad a Union Territory,” a Congress source said.

The idea is gaining currency in the backdrop of continued mass agitation in the Rayalaseema and coastal Andhra regions, jointly referred to as Seemandhra, against bifurcation of the state. Hyderabad remains the main sticking point with people from Seemandhra unwilling to give up their claim on the bustling state capital.

Top

 

Avoid policies that hurt developing world, PM tells rich nations
Ashok Tuteja/TNS

New Delhi, September 4
Prime Minister Manmohan Singh today said rich nations need to refrain from pursuing such economic policies which could endanger the growth prospects of the developing world.

In a statement here before leaving for St Petersburg to attend the G-20 Summit, he noted that there were encouraging signs of growth in industrialised nations while there was a slowdown in emerging economies which were facing the adverse impact of significant capital outflows.

“I will emphasise in St Petersburg the need for an orderly exit from the unconventional monetary policies being pursued by the developed world for the last few years, so as to avoid damaging the growth prospects of the developing world,” the Prime Minister said.

Manmohan Singh observed that the G-20 has emerged as the premier international forum for discussing global economic issues and its 8th Summit was taking place against the backdrop of persisting challenges and vulnerabilities in the global economy.

It was important that G-20 encouraged and promoted policy coordination among major economies in a manner that provided for a broad-based and sustained global economic recovery and growth.

India, he said, has been an active participant in this endeavour as co-Chair of the Working Group on the “Framework for Strong, Sustainable and Balanced Growth”.

“At the Summit, I will once again emphasise that the G-20 should ensure primacy of the development dimension in its deliberations, focus on job creation, promote investment in infrastructure as a means of stimulating global growth and create potential in developing countries to sustain higher growth in the medium term. There is also an urgent need to reform institutions of global political and economic governance,” the PM added.

He said St Petersburg is also the place where the idea of the BRIC grouping was born in July 2006. As per the practice during the last few G-20 Summits, an informal meeting of BRICS (Brazil, India, Russia, China and South Africa) Leaders would be held on the margins of the G-20 meeting to exchange views on the agenda of the summit.

The main theme of the 8th G-20 Summit is starting a new cycle of growth through quality jobs and investment, trust and transparency and effective regulation. Besides India, the G-20 brings together countries such as Argentina, Australia, Brazil, Canada, China, France, Germany, Indonesia, Italy, Japan, Mexico and Russia.

Top

 

For troops, Pak border teams biggest threat
Vijay Mohan/TNS


Guerrilla warfare experts
Border action teams (BATs) are armed groups tasked with carrying out guerrilla-style operations by launching surprise attacks on Indian detachments and then withdrawing quickly
They have been carrying out frequent operations along the LoC, the two most well known being the beheading of an Indian soldier in January and the killing of five soldiers last month
The teams comprise terrorists, jihadis, criminals or fundamentalists

Along the Line of Control, September 4
Cross-border fire notwithstanding, the biggest threat for troops deployed along the Line of Control (LoC) comes from Pakistan’s Border Action Teams (BATs) —armed groups tasked to carry out guerrilla-type operations by launching surprise attacks on Indian detachments and withdrawing quickly.

BATs have been carrying out frequent operations along the LoC, the two most well known being the beheading of an Indian soldier in January and the killing of five soldiers last month. Besides covert attacks, BATs, according to BSF officers manning the LoC, are also involved in sniping at Indian forward defended locations (FDLs), as fortified positions on the LoC are called, and planting mines and IEDs on the Indian side of the LoC.

BATs comprise terrorists, jihadis, criminals or fundamentalists, who are not just expendable, but the employment of whom can also be plausibly denied. It is these elements which carry out the actual killings. Operational support and training is provided by the ISI and Pakistan army’s Special Services Group (SSG), which is reported to maintain a separate detachment for the same. Logistic support is made available by local army formations. SSG elements are also known to accompany BATs, providing fire support and technical assistance.

“Though they undertake significant risk in launching their operations, they are not in a position to assault our FDLs once their presence has been detected. On coming under fire, they are forced to fall back,” said the commandant of a BSF battalion, who claims to have foiled five BAT attempts in the past 11 months in the Rajouri-Poonch sector.

While some BATs have been successful in carrying out their missions on the LoC or to a limited depth in Indian territory, the BSF and the army have also managed to foil many such attempts. “There have been many instances of cross-fire, where intruders have been forced back, but at times it is difficult to ascertain whether it as a BAT action or infiltration attempt,” an officer said.

Operations by BATs are organised and well planned, often involving months of recce and patient observation to identify targets and spot weak links.

Top

 

Girl dies after being ragged at industrial unit

Mumbai, September 4
In a shocking incident in Nashik, an 18-year-old woman apprentice at an industrial unit committed suicide after being ragged by her batchmates, the police said here. The girl, Pranali Rahane, had slashed her wrists and hanged herself on Monday night. However, her relatives managed to cut the rope and took her to hospital. She died on Tuesday night, the police said.

In her suicide note, Rahane named 10 of her batchmates, including four girls, for mercilessly ragging her which forced her to take the extreme step.

Rahane, who was trained at an Industrial Training Institute was undergoing apprenticeship as a trainer at a unit of Bosch India. She had been selected for further training at the company’s headquarters in Germany. In his statement to the police, Pranali’s father alleged that she was mercilessly ragged by her batchmates over this. On the basis of her statement, the police has now arrested all the persons. — TNS

Top

 





HOME PAGE | Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir | Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs | Nation | Opinions |
| Business | Sports | World | Letters | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | Delhi |
| Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | E-mail |