SPECIAL COVERAGE
CHANDIGARH

LUDHIANA

DELHI



THE TRIBUNE SPECIALS
50 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE

TERCENTENARY CELEBRATIONS
image
N A T I O N

India: We’ll only talk to civilian govt in Pak
New Delhi, August 8
India has ruled out any possibility of opening a dialogue with the Pakistan Army despite the growing impression worldwide that it is the army chief Gen Ashfaq Pervez Kayani who calls the shots in Pakistan.
“We will deal only with the civilian government and civilian officials in Pakistan…there is no question of talking to the men in uniform,’’ official sources said.

Maoists accuse PC of scuttling peace talks
Hyderabad, August 8
Maoists have accused Union Home Minister P Chidambaram of scuttling peace talks and using social activist Swami Agnivesh as a “pawn” in the game to eliminate their top leaders.

Tribal woman paraded naked
Kolkata, August 8
A 19-year-old tribal woman, Sushmita Tudu, was paraded naked in broad daylight in Osmanpur village, Birbhum, around 180 km from here. The girl was ‘punished’ for marrying a Muslim boy, said sources.


EARLIER STORIES


A girl during a protest against Kashmir violence, in New Delhi on Sunday
A girl during a protest against Kashmir violence, in New Delhi on Sunday. Tribune photo

Poll debacles: CPM in introspection mode
Hyderabad, August 8
Facing toughest challenge in its history, the CPM is in a soul-searching mood to analyse reasons for the recent electoral debacles and chalk out a political strategy to regain the past glory.

Cong, BJP offer solution
New Delhi, August 8
Even as Treasury and Opposition Benches slugged it out in Parliament to fix responsibility for price rise, two suggestions on foodgrain storage -- one from the ruling Congress in the Rajya Sabha and the other from the Opposition BJP in the Lok Sabha -- may offer a solution for the future.

Azad wants youth to do more than just ‘love and marry’
New Delhi, August 8
For the first time in 40 years since Sanjay Gandhi’s controversial vasectomy campaign, the Government came to Parliament with an appeal to MPs for help to meet population stabilisation goals.

CAG raps MoD for reckless spending
New Delhi, August 8
The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) has ripped apart the Ministry of Defence for recklessly spending crores of rupees and impacting operational preparedness of the forces.
TSR jawans undergo commando training based on NSG pattern for counter-insurgency operations, in Ichacherra near Agartala on Sunday.
TSR jawans undergo commando training based on NSG pattern for counter-insurgency operations, in Ichacherra near Agartala on Sunday. — PTI 

CPM goes tech-savvy for votes
New Delhi, August 8
Frugal Leftists are now waking up to the ways of the world. In the latest move to forge lost ties with the people, the CPM has decided to arrange a live webcast of the major events related to its much-awaited extended Central Committee meeting beginning in Vijaywada from August 7.

4 dead as heavy rains lash Ahmedabad
Ahmedabad, August 8
Four persons including three children were killed while railway and air traffic was severely affected following heavy overnight rains in the city, officials said today.Ten trains were cancelled and nine others got delayed as railway tracks were submerged. The city received 130 mm rains throughout the last night, railway officials said.

IAF airlifts BSNL equipment to Leh
Chandigarh, August 8
Communication link to Leh is expected to be restored soon with the IAF airlifting vital telecommunication equipment to the devastated town on Sunday.Telephone and mobile link of the town with rest of the country was snapped following the cloudburst that hit the area on August 6.

Former Union Minister of State for External Affairs Shashi Tharoor and friend Sunanda Pushkar pose before a sign board during their Ajmer visit on Sunday.Shashi, Sunanda in Ajmer
Ajmer, August 8
With the two all set to tie the nuptial knot soon, former Union Minister Shashi Tharoor and his long-time friend Sunanda Pushkar today visited the famous shrine of sufi saint Khawaja Garib Nawaaj and a temple here today.


Former Union Minister of State for External Affairs Shashi Tharoor and friend Sunanda Pushkar pose before a sign board during their Ajmer visit on Sunday. — PTI

Naqvi held, gets bail
Rampur, August 8
BJP MP Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi along with 19 party activists were arrested here after a local court rejected their bail plea in a case of breach of prohibitory orders and unlawful assembly during the 2009 Lok Sabha polls. 

Vacate stay on Noida memorial, UP urges SC
New Delhi, August 8
Citing the coming Commonwealth Games, the Uttar Pradesh government on Friday strongly pleaded with the Supreme Court for vacating the stay on the construction of the Rs 600 crore Dr BR Ambedkar memorial at the Noida Park.

Jantar Mantar
The square peg in Parliament
Chandigarh-based industrialist K.D.Singh, who was recently elected to the Rajya Sabha from Jharkhand as a JMM candidate, looks decidedly out of place in his sharply-cut Italian suits among the sea of khadi-clad MPs in Parliament.

VOICES FROM THE VALLEY
The third summer of discontent
Kashmiris more important than Kashmir
Fighting a different battle on cyber space
Groping for a future

 





Top








 

India: We’ll only talk to civilian govt in Pak
Ashok Tuteja/TNS

New Delhi, August 8
India has ruled out any possibility of opening a dialogue with the Pakistan Army despite the growing impression worldwide that it is the army chief Gen Ashfaq Pervez Kayani who calls the shots in Pakistan.

“We will deal only with the civilian government and civilian officials in Pakistan…there is no question of talking to the men in uniform,’’ official sources said.

This came amid the talk in political and diplomatic circles that India should open the channels of communication with the military leadership, given the fragile nature of the civilian government in Islamabad and its inability to take any decision on its own in ties with New Delhi.

“They (Pakistanis) say they have a democratic government running the country…we believe them. How can we deal with the Generals when a civilian government exists,’’ the sources added.

In fact, India has been attempting to strengthen the hands of the civilian leadership in Pakistan despite being well aware of the power equations in the country.

Gen Kayani, who is widely believed to have sabotaged the July 15 talks between the foreign ministers of India and Pakistan, has emerged as the most powerful man in the country after he was given an extension in his post by another three years.

Kayani is also seen as the man central to American scheme of things in Afghanistan. When Secretary of State Hillary Clinton visited Pakistan last month, she had a crucial meeting with Kayani. It was just a few days after this meeting that Prime Minister Yousaf Raza Gilani extended Kayani’s term in office.

Foreign Secretary Nirupama Rao also stated in a TV interview that India would continue to have a dialogue with Pakistan's civilian government and had no intention to establish any direct contact with its military.

Regarding Afghanistan, she said the war-ravaged nation was too independent to allow Pakistan to erode its sovereignty and the gradual progress it has made.

Top

 

Maoists accuse PC of scuttling peace talks
Suresh Dharur
Tribune News Service

Hyderabad, August 8
Maoists have accused Union Home Minister P Chidambaram of scuttling peace talks and using social activist Swami Agnivesh as a “pawn” in the game to eliminate their top leaders.

“The Home Minister has committed treachery. After naming you as an interlocutor in the peace talks, he quietly tapped the communication channel you had opened with us and ordered the police to track down our top leaders and kill them,” the central committee member of the CPI (Maoist) V Subramanyam alias Srikanth said in a letter to Swami Agnivesh who had offered to broker peace talks.

He said Swami Agnivesh’s earlier letters, dated June 26 and July 22, containing proposals for talks could not reach the top Maoist leadership as the police played dirty tricks and used the communication channels to track down and kill a top Naxalite leader, Azad.

“We feel that you are being used as a pawn in the whole process. I am afraid you are a pigeon among the cats. The cats are using you as a bait to catch us in the process. It is now difficult for me to send any reply to your letter and it is also not possible to send your leader to our comrades who have to decide (on the peace talks),” the Maoist leader said.

Top

 

Tribal woman paraded naked
Tribune News Service

Kolkata, August 8
A 19-year-old tribal woman, Sushmita Tudu, was paraded naked in broad daylight in Osmanpur village, Birbhum, around 180 km from here. The girl was ‘punished’ for marrying a Muslim boy, said sources.

The couple was forced to leave the village by the panchayat.

The police has arrested five people in this connection. Attempts were being made for locating the couple in the nearby villages. 

Top

 

Poll debacles: CPM in introspection mode
Suresh Dharur
Tribune News Service

Hyderabad, August 8
Facing toughest challenge in its history, the CPM is in a soul-searching mood to analyse reasons for the recent electoral debacles and chalk out a political strategy to regain the past glory.

As over 350 party delegates gathered for the four-day extended central committee meeting at coastal Andhra city of Vijayawada, the mood was one of anxiety, diffidence and sullenness.

The grim prospect of losing power in the strongholds, West Bengal and Kerala, weighed heavily on the minds of comrades as they began the brainstorming session to discuss the political tactical line.

The political observers say that questions are bound to be raised about the hard line approach of General Secretary Prakash Karat who is widely blamed for the party’s decision to withdraw support to the UPA-I on Indo-US nuclear deal issue. The strategy had boomeranged with the UPA returning to power for second term and the Left’s tally eroding significantly.

The West Bengal unit is understood to be peeved over Karat’s political prescriptions, arguing that his ‘visceral anti-Congressism’ had pushed the Trinamool Congress closer to Congress and thereby strengthened opposition unity in West Bengal.

The dichotomy in the political line of thinking between a ‘dogmatic’ General Secretary and ‘pragmatic’ leaders from a traditional bastion state has created a rift in the party. Smarting under a string of electoral reverses in West Bengal, the party needs to re-invent itself and come up with an agenda to arrest the downslide.

The main challenge before the Marxists is how to stop Mamata’s juggernaut, which now looks unstoppable. The draft political resolution and Karat’s inaugural address at the meeting make a fleeting mention about the poll debacles but offer no clear direction to reverse the trend.

“We have carefully looked into the causes of poll reversals and identified steps to be taken to remedy the situation,” Karat said in his address but did not elaborate.

He said the party must take all measures so that people of West Bengal and Kerala renewed their faith in the party. The draft political resolution, to be discussed over the next two days, declares the Congress as the main enemy and dubs it as the prime mover of ‘neo-liberal policies’, representing the interests of big bourgeoisie and favouring a pro-US foreign policy.

On building the third front, it said: “The emergence of a joint platform on policies and programmes will take time. What is possible and may be required now are electoral understandings with some of these (non-Congress and non-BJP) parties in the states.”

Top

 

Cong, BJP offer solution
Vibha Sharma
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, August 8
Even as Treasury and Opposition Benches slugged it out in Parliament to fix responsibility for price rise, two suggestions on foodgrain storage -- one from the ruling Congress in the Rajya Sabha and the other from the Opposition BJP in the Lok Sabha -- may offer a solution for the future.

Leader of Opposition Sushma Swaraj suggested in the Lok Sabha after Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee's reply on the price rise debate that the government consider providing loans to employees at harvest time so they could purchase and store grain in their homes. "This way people can buy the quantity they require and store it properly. While the government will be able to resolve the storage issue by building storage capacity, at home, women can also ensure food security for their households. Bringing grain closer to the user will reduce wastage," Swaraj said, adding that the Punjab Government had tried the formula this time.

In the Rajya Sabha, Congress leader Jayanthi Natarajan advised the government to ensure foodgrain storage facilities at farmers’ level. She said growers could be entrusted to take care of their grain and this would reduce the burden on state warehouses and wastage, since post-harvest losses were highest in foodgrains.

Foodgrain storage is a massive problem, as proven by recent reports of wastage in FCI godowns and also Agriculture Minister Sharad Pawar's admission that there was a shortage of around 150-200 lakh tonne of storage space in the country.

In the past four years, approximately 6 lakh tonne foodgrain has been lost due to poor storage facilities and around 7 lakh tonnes in transit. In Punjab alone, thousands of tonnes of wheat has been declared unfit for human consumption by the FCI in the last three years.

In 2009-10, a whopping 6702 MT foodgrain were declared damaged, non-issuable or unfit for human consumption. Out of this, 2273 MT of rice was found damaged in Punjab alone, also the highest in the country. 

Top

 

Azad wants youth to do more than just ‘love and marry’
Aditi Tandon/TNS

New Delhi, August 8
For the first time in 40 years since Sanjay Gandhi’s controversial vasectomy campaign, the Government came to Parliament with an appeal to MPs for help to meet population stabilisation goals.

A worried Health Minister Ghulam Nabi Azad moved a motion in the Lok Sabha to debate the matter, and said India, at current fertility rates, would not meet the population stabilisation targets even in 2070. “We were to achieve these rates by 2045 but won’t meet them even by 2070 if you don’t help us with suggestions to improve upon the new population policy,” Azad told the House, which discussed the issue well beyond 7 pm.

The government ruled out coercion to achieve the targets and said the effort needed to be voluntary. “The situation has changed in 50 years. Now men and women have avenues of entertainment they didn’t earlier have,” Azad said, quick to admonish the youth to do better things in life than “just love and marry”.

He quoted the legendary poet Faiz Ahmad Faiz to drive home the message of delay in marriage: “Aur bhi gham hain zamane mein mohabbat ke siva; rahatein aur bhi hain vasl ki rahat ke siva.”

The government further admitted on Thursday that family planning through contraception had failed as 50 per cent of the contraceptives being sent to the states were in disuse. Now the Health Ministry will deliver contraceptives door to door in rural areas in 100 districts.

Azad’s appeal to MPs mainly centred around the need to prevent child marriage, delay marriage and promote spacing among children. Over 35 per cent of the Indian girls were being married off before the age of 18. The figure in rural Bihar is 70 pc and for UP it is 59 pc. Both these states are the biggest contributors to India’s burgeoning numbers.

I’m proud of single daughter: Sushma

When Azad was referring to couples going in for multiple conceptions for the love of a male child, Leader of Opposition Sushma Swaraj rose and said she was the proud mother of a single daughter and would spread the same kind of awareness among the people.

Top

 

CAG raps MoD for reckless spending
Ajay Banerjee
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, August 8
The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) has ripped apart the Ministry of Defence for recklessly spending crores of rupees and impacting operational preparedness of the forces.

The CAG report on Army, Ordnance factories and DRDO tabled in Parliament yesterday said that the MoD purchased vintage, non-working missiles, allowed setting up of a gun-making unit that does not manufacture guns and even “maintained” products that do not exist in the inventory.

“…the Ministry does not appear to be serious about implications… of defective equipment,” the CAG report said. Pointing out the lackadaisical attitude of the Defence Public Sector Undertakings established to provide the Armed Forces with state-of-the-art equipment, the CAG says there has been a “role reversal”.

The Ministry procured outdated missiles of 1970s worth Rs 587 crore in 2008 merely to favour Bharat Dynamics Limited. “…The missiles procured were not only of lower capabilities in terms of range, but also did not meet the Army’s long-term objective of acquiring third generation missiles which were available in the market,” the Comptroller and Auditor General said.

The CAG also commented on procurement of the Multi Barrel Rocket Launcher System (SMERCH), often proudly displayed at the Republic Day parade. The Rs 2633 crore system has critical defects. Similarly, the Ordnance Factory at Korwa in Amethi was sanctioned Rs 408 crore to produce new generation carbines -- guns with rapid firing capability -- for the Army. However, the type of carbine to be produced is yet to be decided.

Unexplainably, the Army paid for the maintenance of Unmanned Aerial Vehicles that which were not even held by it. In another case, it procured spares for a particular gun and later found those to be non-compatible and hence could not be fitted in the gun.

The CAG also pointed out at defective ammunition worth Rs 245 crore lying unused for six years. Another typical case of defective purchase was procurement of oxygen mask-embedded helmets used by chopper pilots operating at altitudes of beyond 14,000 feet. The oxygen masks had to be withdrawn as pilots experienced serious defects like insufficient supply of oxygen. The masks were purchased with an evaluation.

Appallingly, assault boats required urgently by the Army could not be procured for over six years despite a budget and adequate number of vendors. 

Top

 

CPM goes tech-savvy for votes
Aditi Tandon/TNS

New Delhi, August 8
Frugal Leftists are now waking up to the ways of the world. In the latest move to forge lost ties with the people, the CPM has decided to arrange a live webcast of the major events related to its much-awaited extended Central Committee meeting beginning in Vijaywada from August 7.

The meeting, being held to rethink the CPM’s political line ahead of elections in West Bengal and Kerala next year, will see the Leftists ponder over whether it was right to move away from the Congress over the Indo-US Nuke deal in the first place. It will also set the strategy for fighting the Congress in both states.

Normally, conservative in their tone and reticent about what they are doing, the CPM cadres, eager to catch some votes, are now going out of their way to get people to watch their functioning.

The party on Thursday said: “A live webcast of the events, inaugural session, public meeting of the extended meeting of the central committee of the CPM being held at Vijayawada from August 7 to 10 is being arranged. There will also be special stories and exclusive interviews relating to the event to be telecast over the web.” 

Top

 

4 dead as heavy rains lash Ahmedabad

Ahmedabad, August 8
Four persons including three children were killed while railway and air traffic was severely affected following heavy overnight rains in the city, officials said today.Ten trains were cancelled and nine others got delayed as railway tracks were submerged. The city received 130 mm rains throughout the last night, railway officials said.

The top portion of a temple fell on its adjoining house killing four member of the family on the spot at Dudeshwar area of the city in the wee hours today, they said.

Operations at the international terminal of the Sardar Patel Airport here have been hampered due to water logging following which electricity supply to the terminal had to be cut off as a precautionary measure, airport officials said, adding that one international flight has been cancelled.

There has been water-logging in various areas of the city which include Chandkheda, Ranip, Sabarmati and other low lying areas, municipal officials said. Six broad gauge trains originating from the city have been cancelled which include Ahmedabad-Okha, Ahmedabad- Viramgam, Ahmedabad-Veraval,Ahmedabad-Valsad, Jamnagar-Surat, Ahmedabad-Mehsana and Ahmedabad-Gandhinagar.

Whereas, nine other trains like Kutch express, Saurashtra Mail, Bhavnagar Express, Saurashtra Janta Express, Ashram Express, Somnath Express, Rajdhani Express are running two to four hours behind schedule. Four meter-gauge trains have been cancelled due to water logging on railway tracks. Meanwhile, Ahmedabad-Dubai flight of Emirates has been cancelled, while other domestic flights have got delayed. The passengers were seen traversing through knee-deep waters at the airport carrying the baggage on their head. — PTI

Top

 

IAF airlifts BSNL equipment to Leh
Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, August 8
Communication link to Leh is expected to be restored soon with the IAF airlifting vital telecommunication equipment to the devastated town on Sunday.Telephone and mobile link of the town with rest of the country was snapped following the cloudburst that hit the area on August 6.

The major portion of the required BSNL equipment was airlifted by a Chandigarh based IL-76 from Delhi. Two AN-32s from the Chandigarh-base carried additional equipment. Another IL-76 airlifted heavyduty bulldozer and debris-clearing machines from Chandigarh to Leh.

Based upon the requirements projected by the Jammu and Kashmir Government, medical items provided by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, relief material and 5,000 blankets were airlifted from Delhi by the IAF. 

Top

 

Shashi, Sunanda in Ajmer

Ajmer, August 8
With the two all set to tie the nuptial knot soon, former Union Minister Shashi Tharoor and his long-time friend Sunanda Pushkar today visited the famous shrine of sufi saint Khawaja Garib Nawaaj and a temple here today.

Seeking blessings before the wedlock, the two offered chader and roses at the shrine, performed Puja at the Pushkar Sarovar and visited the Brahma temple.

"Pray for our happiness and peaceful life. We need a lot of blessings," Sunanda, a Dubai-based businesswoman, told mediapersons.

To a queston on their soon-to-be-held marriage, the former Minister of State for External Affairs who quit his post in the wake of IPL Kochi row, said the the date would be fixed soon.

On Sunday, Tharoor, a former UN diplomat-turned-MP, and Sunanda visited Shirdi and the revered Shani Shingnapur shrine in Maharashtra's Ahmednagar district and performed rituals sitting side-by-side. Reports say the marriage between the two will be held at Elavanchery near Palakkad in Kerala on August 22.

On controversies dogging the upcoming Commonwealth Games, Tharoor said the mega sporting event should be seen in a positive way. The infrastructure developed for the Games would enhance the country's pride and status, he said.

The former Minister did not say anything when asked about alleged diversion of funds meant for Dalit welfare for the Commonwealth Games. — PTI 

Top

 

Naqvi held, gets bail

Rampur, August 8
BJP MP Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi along with 19 party activists were arrested here after a local court rejected their bail plea in a case of breach of prohibitory orders and unlawful assembly during the 2009 Lok Sabha polls. 

They were, however, freed nearly five hours later after being granted bail by Acting District Judge Gopal Shankar Pathak. Naqvi and 19 BJP activists earlier yesterday surrendered before the court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate with a plea for bail but their application was rejected and they were sent to judicial custody. The case relates to a demonstration by BJP workers led by Naqvi at Patwai area of Rampur parliamentary constituency at the time of campaigning for the last Lok Sabha polls during which they allegedly breached the prohibitory orders in force and barged into a police station. Naqvi and others were charged under various sections of the IPC and Criminal Law Amendment Act. — PTI

Top

 

Vacate stay on Noida memorial, UP urges SC
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, August 8
Citing the coming Commonwealth Games, the Uttar Pradesh government on Friday strongly pleaded with the Supreme Court for vacating the stay on the construction of the Rs 600 crore Dr BR Ambedkar memorial at the Noida Park.

The memorial would be an “eyesore and a national shame” at the time of the international meet to be held here in October unless the state government was allowed to carry out the finishing work, senior counsel KK Venugopal pleaded with the three-member Forest Bench headed by Chief Justice SH Kapadia.

The memorial’s dome and equipment were getting rusted since the stay imposed by the apex court on October 9 last year on a PIL, he said after agreeing to a court’s suggestion for restricting the area of construction and visitors’ facilities to 35 per cent so that the tree cover would spread over 65 per cent of the park, adjacent to the eco-sensitive Okhla Bird Sanctuary.

Amicus curiae Harish Salve also agreed with the Bench, which included Justices Aftab Alam and KS Radhakrishnan, that the project may be cleared on 65-35 basis for which the state government would have to plant 6,000 trees, the number felled for constructing the memorial.

However, Jayant Bhushan, appearing for the PIL petitioners, said this would encourage denudation of trees in a similar way by others. 

Top

 

Jantar Mantar
The square peg in Parliament
Anita Katyal

Chandigarh-based industrialist K.D.Singh, who was recently elected to the Rajya Sabha from Jharkhand as a JMM candidate, looks decidedly out of place in his sharply-cut Italian suits among the sea of khadi-clad MPs in Parliament.

After his first week in the Upper House, a senior BJP leader steered him aside and told him gently that it might be a good idea to switch to “desi attire” or else his expensive wardrobe would become a subject of idle gossip among members and the media. Singh was obviously not convinced as he continues to be seen in Parliament in a suit.

A multi-millionaire, known for his collection of high-end cars, Singh, however, had other pressing concerns. He was more keen on getting advice on which car he should use for his daily trip to Parliament from another Rajya Sabha member, himself an owner of expensive foreign cars. The industrialist was clearly unhappy when told that the senior MP preferred to use his Indian car to drive to Parliament. Singh protested, saying that his usual mode of transport is a Rolls Royce. No wonder, unlike other newly-elected members, Singh is in no hurry to get the sarkari accommodation generally allotted to first time MPs.

And why should he be ? After all, the jet-setting MP, who transits frequently through Delhi, has reserved a special suite at the Maurya Sheraton Hotel, 365 days a year.

Right and ‘left’ time

Ever since he took over as Rajya Sabha chairman, Hamid Ansari, has been making a conscious effort to introduce an element of discipline in the Upper House. He constantly urges wayward members not to stray from the subject they are speaking on and does not hesitate to tick them off when they launch forth into unnecessary sermons instead of asking pointed queries.

He has also installed an electronic display board to remind members about the time they are taking to make their speech and whether they are going beyond their allotted time. The countdown begins the moment a member begins his speech with the display board ‘s columns showing the “time lapsed” and the “time left”. However, when Ansari found that members continued to make long winded speeches despite the time limit imposed on them,he was told by several MPs that they were under the impression that the words “time left ” actually referred to the time allotted for Left party members. The display has now been changed from “time left” to “time remaining” to ensure there is no further scope for confusion.

A costly miss

More on Amit Shah. The former Gujarat home minister , who also doubles as vice-chairperson of the Gujarat Cricket Association (GCA), was conspicuous by his absence at last week’s meeting of the finance committee of the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) for obvious reasons. The terse written message from Shah saying “ he was unable to attend the meeting due to unavoidable circumstances,” naturally evoked a sniggering response from other committee members. Not only is Shah spending time in jail, he also lost out on the Rs.50,000 allowance, given for attending BCCI’s committee meetings.

Top

 

VOICES FROM THE VALLEY
The third summer of discontent

Ehsan Fazili

When the state government on July 27 finally constituted a Commission of Inquiry and approved ex-gratia payments for the kin of those killed, in addition to job to one member of the family, it made little impact on the ground situation. It was deemed too little and came too late.

This is the third consecutive summer of discontent in the Valley. It was the Amarnath land agitation that paralysed the state for over two months in 2008 while the next year, the alleged rape and murder of two women in Shopian disrupted normal life in the Valley.

This time, however, there is a qualitative difference. "This is like the sweeping Azadi sentiments of early 1990's", observes a Bank employee, when the central government and security agencies had to face and fight armed militants in the absence of an elected government. This time an elected state government is facing public wrath with police and CRPF fighting the stone throwing youth across the valley.

The Chief Minister Omar Abdullah is faulted for delaying his first public appearance on Thursday (August 5) when he visited Sher-e-Kashmir Institute of Medical Sciences (SKLIMS) to meet the injured undergoing treatment in the hospital. The Chief Minister's statements that " Peace must be restored" and " the cycle of violence must be stopped" are mimicked by people who believe they added fuel to the fire.

"A moderate approach with an early decision to sanction ex-gratia or jobs to the next of kin would have helped,", says Mansoor Ahmed.

The young Chief Minister, before assuming office on January 5 last year, had promised that his priorities would include development, good relations with Pakistan and providing at least one job to every household in the state. While the state is said to have over half a million unemployed youth, another observer Nizamuddin is quick to point out, " a 13 year old boy pelting stones has nothing to do jobs. He is swayed more by sentiment".

The common man is sandwiched between the two sides. "They (separatists) call for bandh and this side (government) imposes curfew restrictions", said a policeman on duty, which has been facing the brunt of the irate mobs along with the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF).

The coalition government, in its endeavour to contain the situation, failed to get the support of the opposition People's Democratic Party (PDP), which refused to attend the All-Party meet called by Chief Minister Omar Abdullah on July 12.

The PDP even declined Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's plea to attend the meeting. Mehbooba Mufti had earlier urged the Chief Minister to convene a special session of the state legislature. The opposition BJP, which did attend the meeting, did not agree with the resolution with regard to conducting enquiry to ascertain the circumstances leading to the death of civilians. This was one of the six resolution passed at the meeting though they did not make much of an impact on the situation.

More measures are needed to assuage the anger over the recent killings in Kashmir. But the overriding sentiment among political parties in the Valley is that if dialogue can resume with Pakistan, it is time to resume dialogue with Kashmiri separatists too, stalled over the past several years.

Top

 

Kashmiris more important than Kashmir
Aditi Tandon

Gulzar Ahmad Wani describes himself as the child of conflict. He was born in Baramulla in 1987, the year that saw Kashmir plunge into its gravest ever crisis. From that time on, secession became the order of the day in the Valley as disgruntled cadres of the hardline Jamaat-e-Islami -- including the present chief of Hijbul Mujahideen Syed Salahuddin -- took to guns alleging rigging of the 1987 elections in the state in favour of Farooq Abdullah of the National Conference.

"Our lives have been spent in bloodshed and frustration. Ours is a troubled generation. We are not like our fathers who will sit at home and let things be. We want answers and we want them now," he asserts.

"I am not justifying what the Kashmiri youth are doing, but what they are doing must be seen in context. They are in despair and have nothing to fall back upon. While Chief Minister Omar Abdullah had promised to end human rights violations, killings are only increasing by the day. He has failed to deliver," says Gulzar, who was bright enough to clear the All-India CBSE exam for entry to Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya of Baramulla (there is only one Navodaya per district and the competition is real tough). He took his LLB from Jamia Milia Islamia.

Others who have enrolled for IAS coaching at the Hamdard Study Circle here rise in his support. Mohd Aijaz from Poonch (a mechanical engineer from IIT Delhi), Wasim Malik from Anantnag (a law graduate), Rifad from Doda and many others rush to explain the ongoing crisis which, they say, will end only when the Centre and the state offer a political solution to Kashmir. To that extent, they agree with CM Omar Abdullah, who recently said that the valley needs a political package and not an economic one (over the years though, Rs 24000 crore have been pumped into Kashmir without much visible change in ground).

The Kashmiri youth however want to know what the Centre is waiting for. "For years together, the Kashmiris have thrown their weight behind the Centre and the state government in the hope of resolution of this crisis. But every time peace returns, the promise of talks also vanishes. On top of that, security force presence remains at stifling levels. When the Army admits it has reduced the levels of militancy to a minimum, why does the Centre need 6 lakh troops in the Valley? Forces can surely be withdrawn from densely populated areas," Wasim Malik argues.

Strangely, Kashmir, despite its history of violence, has no students' union. But Mohd Aijaz says every district level protest has some familiar leaders who must be spoken to when arriving at a solution to the crisis.

Today, J&K suffers from a lack of governance (Transparency India has rated it among the most corrupt states where 6 lakh youth are registered as unemployed), with Omar facing the accusation of lacking both "sensitivity and aptitude" to handle the crisis.

"He had an opportunity in 2008 when the Valley, in a significant turnout, voted for the NC-Congress alliance. That chance has been lost. In fact, Omar's installation as CM was the first deception of the Kashmiri people who had voted for his father. How could Farooq Abdullah forget that in the 2002 state polls when he projected Omar as the chief ministerial candidate, the National Conference lost half of its seats in the Valley and Omar lost the Abdullah family constituency of Ganderbal to the PDP? Still in 2008, Omar was installed as the CM. As expected, he could never connect to the people," Mohd Sayeed Malik, Kashmir affairs expert points out.

As Gulzar puts it, "The Centre must realise that Kashmiris are more important than Kashmir."

Top

 

Fighting a different battle on cyber space
Tejinder Singh Sodhi

Social networking sites like Facebook, YouTube and Orkut are abuzz with 'cyber protests in Kashmir'. They are being used by the more educated and possibly more well to do youth than the stone pelters in the Kashmir Valley. Some of them describe themselves as 'cyber warriors'.

The wikipedia, the largest online and interactive encyclopaedia, has also become a popular site for them to spread their 'message' and many new articles including, "Quit Kashmir phase I' and 'Quit Kashmir phase II' have come up since June 11, when the present unrest erupted in the Valley.

"A large number of educated youth who cannot come out on roads to take part in the protest have adopted these means ," the creator of community 'We protest the killing of innocent Kashmiris' told The Tribune while requesting anonymity. The community has more than 300 members and surprisingly enough, a large number of the members seem to be residents of other Indian states and from different religious backgrounds.

Many such cyber communities have come up and most of them seem to be running hate campaigns against the Abdullahs. A contributor to one such site writes, "one Abdullah (referring to Sheikh Mohammad Abdullah) for his political interest brought the Indian Army in Kashmir on October 27, 1947, while another Abdullah (referring to Dr Farooq Abdullah) to confirm his position in Kashmir brought the Gun in Kashmir (referring to the eruption of the armed insurgency in the valley in late 80's when Farooq was the chief minister) and now Omar Abdullah has brought more forces to quell the voice of the Kashmiri people who are holding peaceful protests against their oppression'.

Another brazenly communal comment maintains that Omar was only 12.5 percent Kashmiri since his grandfather married a Gujjar lady, his father a Christian and he himself a Sikh." In most of such hate communities on Facebook, Omar Abdullah is addressed as Omar Singh.

Another such community is named 'Bekaar Jamaath' (Idle group) with a fan following of 5,591 and has also prepared its 'official website' www.bekaarjamaath.co.nr. The community has a presence on all the social networking sites and has its own blogs, while the moderator of the community asks people to share news about their places and even keeps track on the movement of Syed Ali Shah Geelani.

The sites also carry digitally morphed pictures and in one such community, 'Free Kashmir', a user has posted a morphed picture of a Rs 1,000 currency note in which the picture of Mahatma Gandhi has been replaced with the picture of the Chairman of the hardline faction of the Hurriyat Conference Syed Ali Shah Geelani and the 'Reserve Bank of India' has been replaced with the 'Reserve Bank of Kashmir'.

There are digitally manipulated photographs of the Chief Minister, some of them offensive and showing Omar Abdullah with fangs, and also of Union Minister Farooq Abdullah offering prayers at some Hindu temples and dancing with models.

The users are also taking pictures with mobile phones and uploading the footage of police firings on Youtube.

Top

 

Groping for a future

FARRUKH SALEEM (18) , Qamarwari, Srinagar : "I am a day older than Gandhiji," he says with a chuckle. Born on October 1, 1989, the eldest of three siblings, becomes sombre when asked about his future in Kashmir. " Dark, completely dark," he states solemnly. He adds with a wry smile, " We only know how to chat…there is no unity …and we sit back and watch things happening as mute spectators," he complains and points out that unemployment, corruption and drug addiction continue to keep the future bleak.

His favourite political figure ? " No one ! I hate them all." What does freedom mean to him ? " Peace of mind, liberty to do what my heart says and justice for the meek and the poor," he states with a flourish.

NAIM ANJUM (17), Uri : "Life is difficult in Uri. There is army everywhere and it is like hell to breathe in the air that is filled with terror," says Naim, son of a driver. He blames the politicians for the prevailing uncertainty and says, " Now we are strangers in our own place and have to prove our identity to those who have illegitimately occupied our homeland". Yet he hopes to join the civil services. He would like an end to violence and bloodbath and to corruption and unemployment…

ASIF SHABIR (20), Sopore : An optimist he does not agree with those who see no future in Kashmir. " How can you say so when you are 'normal' and I am not ?" asks the partially handicapped young man. One day or the other, he believes, Kashmir will get independence and hope, he says, must be kept alive and recites the following lines :

" Mushkilan azmaeshan hund sun samandar zindagi,

Subhanas mehshar ti shaamas shor-e-mehshar zindagi,

Zinde roz tithkan yithkan zindan manz rozak shumaar,

Lagawani arsh malak jibrael ( AS) sind par, zindagi."

(Life is a deep sea of difficulties and challenges;

TANVIR YOUSUF (25), Anantnag : An IT student who has become a Medical Representative, he strongly feels about the inadequacies of the education system. " We lack basic facilities, good schools and teachers; lack of resources make us incompetent to the outside world," he quips. But he wants Kashmir to remain a part of India and says, " It is better to be a part of a developing country than to start from scratch like a novice; while human rights violations are due to the Indian armed forces, to some extent we are ourselves responsible for the mess we are in."

AFREEN NIYAZ (17), Srinagar : She wants Kashmir to " get free from the clutches of Indians" but blames Kashmiri people for corruption, for whiling away time gossiping, doing nothing for society and for making Kashmir a living hell. She wants to become a dietician and believes that her generation can make a difference.

ZARQA SAKEENA (18) : Her grouse is that Kashmir is just not 'secure': " You never know what is going to happen next." Educational institutions in the state, she points out, do not provide quality education and hence the Kashmiri youth are unable to compete at All India levels. "we stand nowhere," she states and adds that 'the need of the hour' is for the youth to become activists and 'serve the motherland".

AMBREEN ANJUM (20), Srinagar: " I don't want to take up arms but making people aware at national and international levels is also important," says the student , who was selected by the Government of India for a fellowship in the US. Political instability in Kashmir has been stifling, she says and adds hopefully that once the Kashmir issue gets resolved, all the problems would disappear.

(Compiled from the Netlog of Suzeina Mushtaq)

Top

 





HOME PAGE | Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir | Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs | Nation | Opinions |
| Business | Sports | World | Letters | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | Delhi |
| Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | Suggestion | E-mail |