SPECIAL COVERAGE
CHANDIGARH

LUDHIANA

DELHI



THE TRIBUNE SPECIALS
50 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE

TERCENTENARY CELEBRATIONS
image
N A T I O N

Himachal moves SC
Quashing appointments of Chief Parliamentary Secretaries

New Delhi, November 14
The Himachal Pradesh Government today moved the Supreme Court, challenging the state High Court order quashing the appointments of eight Chief Parliamentary Secretaries and four Parliamentary Secretaries by holding them as unconstitutional.

Infighting hurting Shiv Sena’s campaign
in Malvan

Malvan, November 14
The rift between Bal Thackeray's son Uddhav and nephew Raj is telling on the Shiv Sena's election campaign in Malvan. Both cousins, who do not bother to hide their differences, have formed their own band of supporters who are working at cross purposes despite Bal Thackeray's call for all out war to defeat loyalist turned rebel Narayan Rane.

Raja Bhaiyya, father surrender
Kanpur, November 14
Former Uttar Pradesh minister and controversial MLA Raghuraj Pratap Singh alias Raja Bhaiyya, along with his father Udai Pratap Singh, today surrendered before the designated POTA court amid tight security here as per a Supreme Court judgement.







EARLIER STORIES
 

CPM-SP rally a warning for Cong
New Delhi, November 14
The harsh language used by the CPM at its joint public rally with the Samajwadi Party in Lucknow on Sunday is a clear warning to the Congress. The CPM has made it known that it does not trust the Congress and does not consider it as its long-term political ally.

Pranab leaves for three-day visit to Russia today
New Delhi, November 14
Defence Minister Pranab Mukherjee leaves here early tomorrow on a three-day official bilateral visit to Russia during which a major Russian concern regarding Intellectual Property Rights will be addressed successfully and an agreement on this is likely to be signed.

US has no role in Volcker report, says Mulford
New Delhi, November 14
The United States has no role in Volcker report on the controversial oil-for-food programme in Iraq and it is purely commissioned by the United Nations, US Ambassador to India David Mulford said today.

Leftist students at JNU shout slogans for Iran

New Delhi, November 14
It was an unusual homecoming for the Prime Minister, Dr Manmohan Singh, at Jawaharlal Nehru University here today. An honorary professor of Economics at the university for the past 30 years, Dr Singh, who was invited to unveil the statue of Pandit Nehru, was greeted with black flags and slogans asking him to go back.

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, HRD Minister Arjun Singh and JNU Chancellor Karan Singh after unveiling the Nehru statue on the JNU campus in New Delhi on Monday

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and JNU Chancellor Karan Singh (left) after unveiling the Nehru statue on the JNU campus in New Delhi on Monday. — A Tribune photograph

Manmohan, Kalam greet people on Gurpurb
New Delhi, November 14
President A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, Vice-President Bhairon Singh Shekhawat and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh greeted the nation on the eve of Gurpurb, exhorting people to remember the noble teachings and precious legacy of Guru Nanak Dev and help those affected in the recent tragedies on his "Parkash Utsav" tomorrow.

Dosa, Salem likely to be tried jointly
Mumbai, November 14
The CBI is likely to try the 1993 Mumbai serial bomb blast case accused Mustafa Dosa and extradited gangster Abu Salem together, agency sources said today. The trial of rest of the accused, that includes actor Sanjay Dutt, was already in an advanced stage and the judgement was likely to be delivered in a month's time, the sources said adding hence it will not be possible to try Dosa and Salem along with them. — PTI

Arrest warrants against Abu, Monica
Bhopal, November 14
A local court has issued arrest warrants against underworld don Abu Salem and his girlfriend Monica Bedi in connection with a fake passport case. Salem and Monica had got their passports made under fake names of Danish Beig and Faujia Usman from here in July 2001. — UNI

No confession from Salem: CBI
Mumbai, November 14
The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) today contended that it had not obtained any confessional statement from extradited underworld don Abu Salem, as reported in a section of media. — UNI

Bittu, Gamma released
Nabha, November 14
Former chief of the All-India Sikh Student Federation Daljit Singh Bittu was released along with Gurusharan Singh Gamma from the high-security Nabha jail this evening. The police had arrested Bittu and Gamma in 1996 from Nurpur Bedi. Bittu had been tried in 21 cases but acquitted in 19 because of lack of evidence. Recently, the duo had been granted bail in the two pending cases, including the much-publicised Ludhiana bank dacoity. — OC

Anti-smoking drive: minister seeks Shah Rukh’s help
New Delhi, November 14
If the chain-smoking superstar Shah Rukh Khan can do it, then so can most of the other chain smokers. At least this is what the Union Ministry of Health and Family Welfare thinks. It has now sought the help of the Bollywood superstar to check smoking in the country, and perhaps also figure in advertisement campaigns against tobacco use.

Jawaharlal Nehru remembered
New Delhi, November 14
Vice-President Bhairon Singh Shekhawat and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh led the nation in paying rich tributes to the country’s first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru on his 116th birth anniversary today.

Videos

Rituals performed for the smooth flowing of the Ganga river.
(28k, 56k)

Goa to host 36th International Film Festival.
(28k, 56k)

Top









 

Himachal moves SC
Quashing appointments of Chief Parliamentary Secretaries
Legal Correspondent

New Delhi, November 14
The Himachal Pradesh Government today moved the Supreme Court, challenging the state High Court order quashing the appointments of eight Chief Parliamentary Secretaries and four Parliamentary Secretaries by holding them as unconstitutional.

The special leave petition (SLP) of the Himachal Pradesh Government was listed for hearing before a Bench of Chief Justice Y.K. Sabharwal and Mr Justice C K Thakker, but state’s Additional Advocate General J.S. Attri sought adjournment in view of the inability of senior advocate K.K. Venugopal engaged by the government to argue the case, to appear today.

Allowing the plea of Mr Attri, the apex court granted one week adjournment in the case, which is likely to be listed again for hearing next week.

The case assumes significance in view of the High Court’s conclusion that under the Constitution, there is no provision of appointing Chief Parliamentary Secretary (CPS) or Parliamentary Secretary (PS) as the Himachal Government has sought “correct” interpretation of Article 162 which deals with the “extent of executive powers of the state” and Article 164 on “other provisions as to ministers” in the state.

An NGO, Citizen Rights Protection Forum, on whose PIL the High Court had struck down the appointments, had also filed a caveat, pleading the apex court that it should be heard before taking any decision on the SLP. Senior advocates Arun Jaitely and former HP Advocate General Sanjay Karol, appeared for the NGO.

The state government in its SLP said under the Rules of Business of the HP Government, powers has been specifically provided to the Chief Minister to take a decision on any matter brought for his consideration and as such under the rules, he could make the appointment of CPS and PS.

It further said that under Constitution’s 7th Schedule, List-2 and Item-39, it has been specifically provided that state has the powers to legislate on any issue.

The SLP said under Article 162 much wider powers has been given to the state governments and “the Article should be read not in a narrow sense but in a broader sense.”

The appointment of a dozen CPS and PS by Chief Minister Virbhadra Singh to give MLAs the status identical to that of ministers to accommodate them in view of 91 Constitution amendment, fixing the limit of Council of Ministers in the states at 10 per cent of the Assembly’s strength, had landed in a major political controversy in the state.

The High Court had ruled that under the Constitution, the Chief Minister had no powers to make such appointments. There was no source of power with the Chie Minister to appoint the CPS and PS and administer them oath of office and secrecy, it had said..

All 12 CPS and PS had tendered their resignations after the August 18 order of the High Court.

Top

 

Infighting hurting Shiv Sena’s campaign in Malvan
Shiv Kumar
Tribune News Service

Malvan, November 14
The rift between Bal Thackeray's son Uddhav and nephew Raj is telling on the Shiv Sena's election campaign in Malvan. Both cousins, who do not bother to hide their differences, have formed their own band of supporters who are working at cross purposes despite Bal Thackeray's call for all out war to defeat loyalist turned rebel Narayan Rane.

Both leaders seldom make appearances together and the content of their speeches regarding Rane differ sharply.

"We feel sympathetic to Raj Thackeray since he is suffering the same fate as our leader," says a close aide of Narayan Rane.

Activists of the Congress party who are mostly Rane's loyalists from his days in the Shiv Sena are treating Raj with kid gloves. None of his meetings have been disrupted and his convoy moves around undisturbed.

On his part, Raj Thackeray delivers speeches that have none of his trademark acerbic remarks. His speeches are tame and the usual rhetorical mannerism he shares with uncle Bal Thackeray is missing.

Raj usually dwells on Rane's glory days in the Shiv Sena. In one of his speeches here, Raj produced old newspaper clippings where Rane is reported to be heaping praise on Sena supremo Bal Thackeray.

Raj has openly called for his party to ignore Rane and concentrate on development issues during the election campaign. However, Uddhav has asked his followers to target Rane for breaking the Shiv Sena in the Konkan region.

Rane's followers have retaliated by disrupting Uddhav's convoys and have even tried to disrupt his meetings in Malvan. On the other hand Raj lives in a hotel close to the area where Rane has his own hotel.

Shiv Sainiks known for their loyalty to Uddhav are having it even worse. Datta Nalvade and Mumbai Mayor Datta Dalvi, who are close to Uddhav, were not even able to obtain a hotel room in Malvan for themselves. Dalvi's own bungalow has been loaned to Uddhav.

"Rane's people had made it clear that people like Datta Nalvade not be allowed to stay in our premises," a hotelier here told this reporter.

Uddhav Thackeray's loyalists, mainly from Mumbai, have been forced to live in the small village homes owned by their supporters.

Rane, who has accused Uddhav of having him thrown out of the Shiv Sena, has come up with posters depicting Bal Thackeray's son as a donkey.

Top

 

Raja Bhaiyya, father surrender

Kanpur, November 14
Former Uttar Pradesh minister and controversial MLA Raghuraj Pratap Singh alias Raja Bhaiyya, along with his father Udai Pratap Singh, today surrendered before the designated POTA court amid tight security here as per a Supreme Court judgement.

The former Food and Civil Supplies Minister and his father reached the court along with his supporters and later surrendered before judge of the designated POTA court S.C. Chaurasia, who is also the district judge.

Counsel for father-son duo Nand Lal Jaiswal submitted the bail applications and plea for sending them to Pratapgarh Jail, if needed.

The hearing was on in the case.

A two-judge SC Bench comprising Justices B.N. Agrawal and A.K. Mathur had on November 10 last quashed the UP government decision of revoking POTA charges against Raja Bhaiyya, his father and cousin and ruling Samajwadi Party MP Akshay Pratap Singh alias Gopalji.

The Bench had directed the father and the son to appear before the designated POTA court in Kanpur within a week and apply for fresh bail in the trial case under Section 4 (b) of the POTA for possessing arms within the specified area, the Arms Act and the Explosives Substances Act.

Transferring the trial to neighbouring Madhya Pradesh, the court had asked the Chief Justice of the Madhya Pradesh High Court to assign the case to a competent court.

Shortly after the apex court set aside the State POTA Review Committee order holding no case was made out for invoking POTA against Raja Bhaiyya and his relatives, the controversial scion of the erstwhile Pratapgarh princedom, submitted his resignation from the state Cabinet to “spare the state government and Mr Yadav any embarrassment on this count.”

Raja Bhiayya’s resignation from the ministerial job, was accepted by UP Governor T.V. Rajeswar yesterday.

The Supreme Court order was given on petitions filed by S.K. Shukla and two other residents of Pratapgarh challenging the state government’s decision to withdraw the POTA charges against Raja Bhaiya and others.

The Mayawati government had slapped POTA against the trio in April, 2003, after they were arrested along with arms and ammunition, including AK 47 and 56 rifles. Immediately after Mulayam Singh Yadav was sworn in as the Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh on August 29, 2003, the state government had initiated steps to revoke POTA charges against Raja Bhaiyya. — UNI

Top

 

CPM-SP rally a warning for Cong
Anita Katyal
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, November 14
The harsh language used by the CPM at its joint public rally with the Samajwadi Party in Lucknow on Sunday is a clear warning to the Congress. The CPM has made it known that it does not trust the Congress and does not consider it as its long-term political ally. The underlying message from the Marxists is that its support to the UPA government is a matter of compulsion and does not stem from any political conviction.

Putting the UPA government in the dock on the Iran nuclear issue, CPM leader Prakash Karat told the ruling coalition in no uncertain terms that it should rectify its stand or be prepared to face its onslaught in the coming Parliament session. Clearly on the warparth, Mr Karat described the government decision on Iran as “disgraceful” while keeping his attack focussed on Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. To add to the Congress discomfiture, the CPM shared a platform with bete noire SP leader Mulayum Singh Yadav and promised a repeat performance in the coming days.

Mr Karat’s tirade was followed by a similar attack by his colleague Sitaram Yechury, who told a BBC Hindi programme last night that the Iran issue could have serious repurcussions on the UPA government’s stability. The government, he said, was deviating from the CMP, stating that the ruling combine’s stability would depend on the government rectifying its mistakes.

Officially, the Congress is playing down the CPM criticism as it points to compulsions coalition politics and the upcoming assembly elections in Kerala and West Bengal where the two parties are pitted against each other to justify the Left’s outbursts. But its patience is clearly wearing thin. Having already given in to the Left’s pressure-tactics on several policy decisions, including disinvestment in BHEL, Congress insiders believe the government’s credibility will be severely dented if this situation persists.

Angry Congress leaders maintained that Left parties also had a responsibility in ensuring the smooth functioning of this government.

Top

 

Pranab leaves for three-day visit to Russia today
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, November 14
Defence Minister Pranab Mukherjee leaves here early tomorrow on a three-day official bilateral visit to Russia during which a major Russian concern regarding Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) will be addressed successfully and an agreement on this is likely to be signed.

Mr Mukherjee will co-chair with the Russian Defence Minister, the India-Russia Inter-Governmental Commission (IRIGC) on Military Technical Cooperation (MTC).

Mr Mukherjee’s visit to Russia follows soon after that of the Russian Defence Minister’s visit to India in October 2005, during the period of India-Russia joint military exercises. The IRIGC-MTC is the apex body of India’s strategic defence partnership with Russia and annually reviews the work done as per plan and sets targets for the coming year. A number of new projects are currently on the anvil between the two countries and these will be discussed at the meeting of the IRIGC to take them forward.

During his stay in Moscow, Mr Mukherjee will be meeting President Vladimir Putin.

India’s defence relationship with Russia is vast and complex having grown steadily from the small beginnings made soon after the Independence. Today the major part of our imported weapons systems and armaments, whether in the Army, Navy or Air Force are of the Soviet/Russian origin.

The Defence Research and the Development Organisation (DRDO) has extensive ties with its Russian counterparts and has jointly developed a number of projects and services, including the Brahmos missile system.

The defence public sector undertakings (PSUs) including HAL, Bangalore have numerous joint projects with their Russian partners. Among its major projects is co-manufacture of SU-30 MKI aircraft. The Indian Navy also has some big ticket items like refitting of the aircraft carrier Admiral Gorshkov, EKM submarines as also frigates manufactured under license, three of which have already been delivered. The Army continues to rely on the Russian origin T-90 tanks, which is being manufactured with the Russian collaboration by the Ordnance Factory, Avadi and looking at the Tunguska air defence system and the Smerch multi-role rocket launcher.

Top

 

US has no role in Volcker report, says Mulford

New Delhi, November 14
The United States has no role in Volcker report on the controversial oil-for-food programme in Iraq and it is purely commissioned by the United Nations, US Ambassador to India David Mulford said today.

“One has to keep in mind that the Volcker Report was commissioned by the United Nations and everybody knew that,” he said while talking to reporters here.

He said some evidence regarding the oil deal was “captured” in Iraq which was a separate process and had nothing to do with the US.

Mr Mulford disagreed when asked whether former External Affairs Minister Natwar Singh’s statement that the US had played a role in the Volcker Committee report, would have any negative impact on Indo-US relations.

“I don’t think it will have any impact on bilateral relations,” he asserted.

Meanwhile, the United States wants India to come out with a “credible plan” for separating its civil and military nuclear programme before the July 18 agreement can be presented to the Congress for approval.

Mr Mulford, talking to reporters at an informal get-together here, said if the US found the plan “credible”, it would be taken to the Congress and then only legislation could be changed.

Mr Mulford, who is going to Washington tomorrow to meet senior officials of the Congress and the Bush administration, however, did not specify the “parameters for credibility” and said the Bush administration would discuss the plan.

He also did not set a deadline for India to come out with the plan and said he hoped it would be done ‘soon.’

“Unless the US administration says that we are satisfied with the plan, they won’t present it to the Congress. The plan will be discussed and judged by experts,” he said. — UNI

Top

 

Leftist students at JNU shout slogans for Iran
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, November 14
It was an unusual homecoming for the Prime Minister, Dr Manmohan Singh, at Jawaharlal Nehru University here today. An honorary professor of Economics at the university for the past 30 years, Dr Singh, who was invited to unveil the statue of Pandit Nehru, was greeted with black flags and slogans asking him to go back.

Even as the congenial Prime Minister tried to pacify the agitated students by quoting Voltaire, “I may disagree with what you have to say, but I shall defend, to the death, your rights to say it”, the disruptive elements were not in the mood to relent.

An embarrassed administration, helpless law enforcers and dismayed audience heard the PM urge the university community to accept the truth of Voltaire’s statement and regard its inherent idea as a “cornerstone of a liberal institution”.

But slogans refused to die down even when the visiting dignitary described the university as a “vibrant, pulsating academic life brimming with ideas and thoughts— just like it should be in an outstanding institution”.

It was ironic that while the PM chose to uphold the freedom of expression, pointing out that a university teaches man how to deal with difference of opinion, the protesters continued to prevent him from speaking.

While the police was rushed to the stands to maintain order, representatives of the Students’ Union and the university administration tried in vain to control the mob.

Members of the All-India Students Association (AISA), the Democratic Students’ Union and the Progressive Students Union affiliated to the Communist Party of India-Marxist Leninist (CPI-ML), who disrupted the PM’s speech, were protesting against the government’s economic and defence policies. They blamed the government for bringing in “killer patent laws and being stooges of the Bush administration”.

The SFI-AISF, allied to the CPI (M), urged the PM to reverse India’s position on Iran at the coming IAEA meeting and prevent Indo-US joint military exercises.

In January this year, JNU had faced a similar situation when the president of the Students’ Union, AISA’s Mona Das refused to present a bouquet to the President, Dr Abdul Kalam, on the grounds that he was part of India’s nuclear programme.

Dr Kalam had come to deliver a lecture on "Evolution of an enlightened citizen-centric society" on January 12, 2005. Haryana Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda’s car was also vandalised here last week when he came on the campus.

Top

 

Manmohan, Kalam greet people on Gurpurb
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, November 14
President A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, Vice-President Bhairon Singh Shekhawat and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh greeted the nation on the eve of Gurpurb, exhorting people to remember the noble teachings and precious legacy of Guru Nanak Dev and help those affected in the recent tragedies on his "Parkash Utsav" tomorrow.

"Guru Nanak Devji’s teachings of love, brotherhood and sacrifice are more relevant today. May this auspicious occasion be an opportunity for all of us to work for bringing warmth to those affected in recent mishaps," Dr Kalam said in his message.

Greeting the nation on the occasion, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said Guru Nanak’s message of fraternity and universalism, particularly his emphasis on the creation of a caste less society, had acquired a crucial dimension in today’s world.

"Guru Nanak always exhorted his disciples to oppose tyranny and oppression. His teachings blended Hindu and Muslim theology, which gives the message of an underlying unity of all religions," Dr Manmohan Singh said, expressing hope that the Guru's life and teachings would continue to guide the path of humanity for all times to come.

In his message, Vice-President Bhairon Singh Shekhawat said the life and teachings of Guru Nanak were a precious treasure of India's glorious spiritual heritage. "Let us derive inspiration from his life and deeds and re-dedicate ourselves to his enlightened teachings," he added. 

Top

 

Anti-smoking drive: minister seeks Shah Rukh’s help
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, November 14
If the chain-smoking superstar Shah Rukh Khan can do it, then so can most of the other chain smokers. At least this is what the Union Ministry of Health and Family Welfare thinks. It has now sought the help of the Bollywood superstar to check smoking in the country, and perhaps also figure in advertisement campaigns against tobacco use.

Shah Rukh, by his own admission in countless interviews in film magazines and on national TV channels, has been a real-life chain-smoker. In “reel life” as well, he has portrayed numerous cigarette-smoking characters and reportedly been shown smoking on the screen as many as 109 times in the past 12 years of his film career.

But on the eve of his fortieth birthday on June 2, the chain-smoking star pledged to give up smoking. How much has he succeeded in this rather well-meaning endeavour only he can tell, but this prompted Health Minister Anbumani Ramadoss, a rather vociferous anti-smoking crusader who blames Bollywood for encouraging smoking among teenagers, to write him a congratulatory letter and seek his help in checking the menace in the country.

In his letter, the Health Minister expressed confidence that superstar’s gesture would help enlighten youth about the ill-effects of cigarette smoking .

Top

 

Jawaharlal Nehru remembered
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, November 14
Vice-President Bhairon Singh Shekhawat and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh led the nation in paying rich tributes to the country’s first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru on his 116th birth anniversary today.

Dr Manmohan Singh, Mr Shekhawat, UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi, senior Cabinet ministers and a large number of distinguished persons visited Shantivan here and placed wreaths on the Pandit Nehru’s samadhi.

Others present on the occasion included Delhi Lt-Governor B.L. Joshi and Chief Minister Sheila Dikshit. 

Top

HOME PAGE | Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir | Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs | Nation | Opinions |
| Business | Sports | World | Mailbag | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | Delhi |
| Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | Suggestion | E-mail |