SPECIAL COVERAGE

CHANDIGARH

LUDHIANA

DELHI


THE TRIBUNE SPECIALS
50 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE

TERCENTENARY CELEBRATIONS
punjab
P U N J A B
Top stories | Community | Courts

TOP STORIES

Religious Congregation
DSGMC asks ex-judge to probe Ludhiana incidents
Ludhiana, December 9
The Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee has assigned to a former Judge of the Delhi High Court the task of inquiring into the alleged police ‘‘atrocities’’ on Sikhs while they were protesting against holding of a congregation by a religious leader, Ashutosh Maharaj, in Ludhiana on Saturday.

State’s annual plan compliance 10 pc
Chandigarh, December 9
Registering an all-time low in financial terms the Punjab Government has been able to register only 10 per cent compliance of the ambitious annual plan of Rs 8,625 crore. Punjab’s share of the plan is about Rs 4,032 crore and the state government has been able to spend only Rs 840 crore out of the total plan.

News Analysis
Blame game thrives after fiasco in House
Statesmanship takes back seat
Chandigarh, December 9
True to the adage accusations aggravate acrimony, reactions to unruly scenes witnessed in the Punjab Vidhan Sabha’s darkest hour ever are adding fuel to the fire.


YOUR TOWN
Amritsar
Chandigarh
Ludhiana


EARLIER STORIES


Dismiss SAD-BJP govt: Cong
Gives memorandum to Governor
Chandigarh, December 9
The Congress has demanded the immediate dismissal of the SAD-BJP government and the imposition of President’s rule in Punjab. Members of the Congress Legislature Party led by its chief, Rajinder Kaur Bhattal, met the Governor and presented him a memorandum to recommend the imposition of President’s rule in the state as an “emergency-like situation prevails following the total collapse of the government and its law and order machinery”.

House Ruckus
Majithia for action against Cong MLAs
Amritsar, December 9
“Shameful attack by Congress MLAs on their SAD counterparts in a full public view in the state Assembly yesterday has exposed not only the real face of Congress leaders, but has also shaken the Indian democratic system.”

Capt: Will back Sarna if he contests SGPC poll
Amritsar, December 9
Coming out openly in the support of Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee (DSGMC) chief Paramjit Singh Sarna, former state Chief Minister Captain Amarinder Singh has said that his party men will support Sarna if he will contest the forthcoming SGPC elections. He said they wanted to save golak money, which was being “plundered” by Akali leaders for their personal gains.



COMMUNITY

Mohan Lal Paruthi stands outside the war memorial in Fazilka. Fazilka war memorial under renovation
Fazilka, December 9
The war memorial set up by residents of this town in memory of the 82 soldiers of the Army, who laid down their lives while protecting the area during the India-Pakistan war of 1971, is these days being renovated to give it a fresh look.

Mohan Lal Paruthi stands outside the war memorial in Fazilka. Tribune photo: Pawan Sharma

Anganwadi workers stage protest
Chandigarh, December 9
Anganwadi workers stage a protest outside the Punjab Chief Minister’s residence in Chandigarh on Wednesday. Members of the Anganwadi Workers Union today caught the Chandigarh police and Punjab intelligence napping and staged a protest outside the Chief Minister’s residence here today. The drama went on for about one-and-a-half-hour during which the traffic on the road was disrupted. Agitating protesters raised slogans against the apathetic attitude of the state government.

Anganwadi workers stage a protest outside the Punjab Chief Minister’s residence in Chandigarh on Wednesday. Tribune photo: Vinay Malik

Patiala jail to have de-addiction centre
Patiala, December 9
With a view to help the jail inmates, who have become drug addicts, a de-addiction centre would be set up in the Patiala Central Jail, said Patiala Deputy Commissioner Dipinder Singh.

LIC denies info for paying more
Jalandhar, December 9
In what may be termed as a “ridiculous way” to delay information under the RTI Act, the local office of the Life Insurance of India (LIC) has returned a postal order of Rs 20 to an applicant stating that the requisition fee for seeking information is just Rs 10.

Deed wins best production award
Jalandhar, December 9
Eminent producer and Punjabi poet Jaswant Deed has won Doordarshan’s best production award in promo category for preparing a documentary programme - “Guru Manyo Granth”. The programme was spread over seven parts based on different aspects of Guru Granth Sahib.


COURTS

HC: Trace woman who accused Capt of rape
Chandigarh, December 9
The Punjab and Haryana High Court today asked the SSP concerned to track down the woman, who levelled allegations of rape against Punjab’s former Chief Minister Capt Amarinder Singh, and find out who was behind the move to “defame respectable individuals”.

SAD (A) moves HC against SGPC
Chandigarh, December 9
SAD (Amritsar) president Simranjit Singh Mann today moved the high court claiming that the term of the SGPC’s present general house expired on August 31, yet the Home Ministry had not announced fresh elections.

Judges (Protection) Act upheld
Chandigarh, December 9
The Punjab and Haryana High Court has upheld the constitutional validity of the Judges (Protection) Act, 1985. The Bench of Justice M.M. Kumar and Justice Jaswant Singh has asserted: “There is nothing in the Act, which may be said to be violative of Article 14 of the Constitution, or otherwise of a nature of illegality; nor any such argument has been raised at the time of hearing.”




Top









 
TOP STORIES

Religious Congregation
DSGMC asks ex-judge to probe Ludhiana incidents
Kanchan Vasdev
Tribune News Service

Ludhiana, December 9
The Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee (DSGMC) has assigned to a former Judge of the Delhi High Court the task of inquiring into the alleged police ‘‘atrocities’’ on Sikhs while they were protesting against holding of a congregation by a religious leader, Ashutosh Maharaj, in Ludhiana on Saturday.

DSGMC President Paramjit Singh Sarna today said they had asked former Judge TS Doabia to conduct an inquiry and submit a report to them within seven days. They would forward the report to the Union Government and the state government for further action.

‘‘If the Judge indicts the police, then we would take up the matter in the court. The matter would be taken up with the state and union governments first. If they don’t do anything, then we would move a court,’’ said Sarna.

Stating that a magisterial inquiry ordered by the state government into the incident was a mere eyewash, Sarna said the father-son duo (the Badals) were behind everything. They were out to attract a vote bank managed by the RSS.

‘‘It is shocking that a man was killed and 11 injured, two of them seriously but the government did not do anything. They just ordered an inquiry into the episode and washed their hands off it,’’ said Sarna.

Sarna said the state government had failed on all fronts and when they thought they could not do anything, they just diverted the attention of the people by allowing Ashutosh Maharaj to hold a congregation.

Top

 

State’s annual plan compliance 10 pc
Chitleen K Sethi
Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, December 9
Registering an all-time low in financial terms the Punjab Government has been able to register only 10 per cent compliance of the ambitious annual plan of Rs 8,625 crore. Punjab’s share of the plan is about Rs 4,032 crore and the state government has been able to spend only Rs 840 crore out of the total plan.

Last year the plan expenditure was Rs 6,868 crore against an outlay of Rs 6,210 crore. The annual plan for 2009-10 had been increased by Rs 2,415 crore, a leap of 39 per cent over the previous year. While the state government had managed to show over 100 per cent compliance of the annual plans in 2007 -2008 and 2008-2009, it seems almost impossible for Finance Minister Manpreet Badal to be able to maintain his record this year. The state has already borrowed over Rs 3,800 crore this year selling off government securities to stay afloat. Just to keep itself from falling into a financial abyss the state would now be borrowing Rs 600 crore each month till the end of the financial year, hitting the upper limit of its annual borrowings of Rs 6,200 crore.

Despite these borrowings the coming months are, however, bound to be tough on the state’s pocket. Punjab’s monthly expenditure on salaries and pensions is over Rs 1,000 crore and it has to spend another Rs 1,000 crore to pay for the subsidies and the interest amount on borrowings.

On the inflow side, other than the Rs 600 crore of borrowings, the state is expecting to get Rs 1,000 crore from VAT and Rs 200 crore as its share of central taxes each month. That still leaves a shortfall of Rs 200 crore which the state has nowhere to get from. Sources add that the state government has been resorting to diverting funds from the grants received from the Government of India for various projects to pay salaries and this unhealthy practice is likely to continue.

“Development works are expected to come to a screeching halt in the coming days with no money left to do anything. It would be a miracle enough if we are able to get our salaries in the coming months,” admitted a senior state official.

Top

 

News Analysis
Blame game thrives after fiasco in House
Statesmanship takes back seat
Prabhjot Singh
Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, December 9
True to the adage accusations aggravate acrimony, reactions to unruly scenes witnessed in the Punjab Vidhan Sabha’s darkest hour ever are adding fuel to the fire. Demands varying from imposition of the President’s rule to summoning at Akal Takht all those involved in yesterday’s turban fiasco have been made to the great dismay of those who believe in adhering to healthy parliamentary practices for the sake of a throbbing democracy.

They hold that difference of opinion is the essence of democracy, but throttling strong parliamentary conventions, irrespective of the intensity of the provocations, cannot be condoned. They wondered if taking turns on speaking on an important issue like law and order can flare up passions so much, then how would the present-day legislators respond to sensitive or emotive issues.

Statements from leaders of both the ruling alliance and the Opposition parties even today smack of blame game only. Even Chief Minister Parkash Singh Badal, known to be a mature and seasoned peacemaker, has held the Opposition responsible for yesterday’s fiasco.

Statesmanship appears to have taken a back seat as confrontational politics has been at the centre stage. Throughout the 15-minute chaotic drama, no senior political leader from either the treasury benches or the Opposition tried to play the peace card. The only exception perhaps was Punjab Transport Minister Mohan Lal who was seen separating the warring legislators, urging them to return to their seats.

Abrupt disappearance of peacemakers in the Vidhan Sabha became noticeable only yesterday when almost everyone, including the Leader of the House as well as the Leader of Opposition, remained mute spectators to the developments. At one stage, before the well turned into a free combat zone, Chief Minister Badal was seen gesticulating to his party legislators not to come to him and return to their seats. But once it started, there was no stopping anyone.

“Proceedings of the Vidhan Sabha for those 15 minutes in which the decorum was shredded to bits is in fact a true reflection of what is happening in the rest of Punjab,” is how senior Communist leader Joginder Dyal sums up the darkest chapter of the Punjab legislature.

President of the Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee Paramjit Singh Sarna went to the extent of suggesting that all those involved in the turban fiasco should be summoned at Akal Takht as the ‘turban was the pride of a Sikh’.

Top

 

Dismiss SAD-BJP govt: Cong
Gives memorandum to Governor
Prabhjot Singh
Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, December 9
The Congress has demanded the immediate dismissal of the SAD-BJP government and the imposition of President’s rule in Punjab. Members of the Congress Legislature Party led by its chief, Rajinder Kaur Bhattal, met the Governor and presented him a memorandum to recommend the imposition of President’s rule in the state as an “emergency-like situation prevails following the total collapse of the government and its law and order machinery”.

The Congress legislators, who marched to Raj Bhavan here this evening, held that even their leader was not permitted to exercise her sovereign right to speak in the House during zero hour. They also questioned the legality of summoning the House by giving it post facto Cabinet approval.

“As a matter of fact the present Punjab Government itself is not caring about and following the well-established mandates in respect of the procedures to be followed in the Vidhan Sabha.

“The Constitution of India guarantees freedom of speech to every citizen but in Punjab the voice of the Opposition as well as of the common man is being suppressed with an iron hand,” alleged the delegation.

The Congress legislators claimed that there were numerous political murders and other heinous crimes being committed in Punjab every day. Referring to the cases of Dera Sacha Sauda and Dera Sach Khand, they held that these sects were being denied their Constitutional freedom to follow, worship and practise their own religion or faith without any hindrance. They also referred to incidents of violence that rocked Ludhiana last week.

Describing yesterday’s incident as “extremely unfortunate and unprecedented in the history of the Punjab Vidhan Sabha, it immensely pains me to see that the Opposition is not being allowed to raise its voice against the atrocities being committed on the people of Punjab,” wrote Bhattal in the memorandum given to the Governor.

She further held that the SAD-BJP combine was responsible for protecting and sheltering antisocial and bad elements by tacitly giving encouragement to violence, murders and other heinous crimes for creating tension and panic among the masses thus causing unrest and instability in the state.

“Owing to an emergency-like situation, the total collapse of the government machinery and law and order crisis prevailing in the state, I, on behalf of my party, demand the imposition of President’s rule and appropriate legal action against the guilty members of the House belonging to the ruling SAD-BJP combine who were entirely to blame for this sad incident,” she said.

She also requested the Governor’s intervention to restore the faith of the common man in governance and democracy, to take harsh measures so that Punjab does not fall back to the dark days of terrorism during which the state had suffered immensely. Peace was restored after great sacrifices and it must be maintained at all costs, the memorandum said.

Top

 

House Ruckus
Majithia for action against Cong MLAs
Tribune News Service

Amritsar, December 9
“Shameful attack by Congress MLAs on their SAD counterparts in a full public view in the state Assembly yesterday has exposed not only the real face of Congress leaders, but has also shaken the Indian democratic system.”

These views were expressed by former state minister and MLA from the Majithia constituency Bikram Singh Majithia while talking to mediapersons here today. He also called for a stringent action against them.

He said earlier, they attempted to attack the Speaker’s podium but were stopped by marshals after which they climbed atop the treasury Benches. “Their actions reflect their intention of making a mockery of the sanctity of the House and their intentions to avoid a debate and hear views of the government,” said Majithia.

He further said the ruckus created by Congress leaders in the Assembly had brought to the fore their “ill-intentions and false propaganda of poor law and order situation in the state”. “The MLAs indulged in vicious abuses and even came to blows, thereby, violating parliamentary procedures,” Majithia added.

Top

 

Capt: Will back Sarna if he contests SGPC poll
Varinder Singh
Tribune News Service

Amritsar, December 9
Coming out openly in the support of Delhi Sikh Gurdwara Management Committee (DSGMC) chief Paramjit Singh Sarna, former state Chief Minister Captain Amarinder Singh has said that his party men will support Sarna if he will contest the forthcoming SGPC elections. He said they wanted to save golak money, which was being “plundered” by Akali leaders for their personal gains.

Amarinder also flayed the Punjab Assembly Speaker and said the latter played a “partisan role” which, in turn, led to ruckus in the Assembly yesterday.

“It is unfortunate that the Speaker had not played a free-and-fair role. In fact, the treasury Benches are responsible for the unprecedented acrimonious scenes in the House,” he alleged.

Regarding the continuation of PPCC chief Mohinder Singh Kaypee in his present slot, he said: “Sonia Gandhi is our leader. It is up to her to make anyone as the president. I will continue to work wholeheartedly and guard interests of the party in the state”. He said he had nothing personal against Kaypee.

“The Akalis are looting the golak money and are using it for their vested interests. We want to save it and that is why we have decided to support Sarna in the next SGPC polls, likely to be held in June 2010. Moreover, Sarna is a good man and we will be doing whatever possible to oust Badal and his team from the SGPC,” said Amarinder, who is currently busy mobilising Congress workers in the Majha region.

Amarinder addressed a workers’ meet at the DCC (Rural) office here today. He had already organised a similar meeting at Tarn Taran yesterday and was scheduled to hold a rally at Gurdaspur tomorrow. He was accompanied by his OSD Major Amardip and senior Congress leaders, including, Jasbir Dimpa, Sukh Sarkaria, OP Soni, DCC (rural) chief Sukhjinder Raj Singh ‘Lally Majithia’, and Prof. Darbari Lal.

When asked what had made the PPCC to show-case itself as a divided house, Amarinder said the Congress was a united force and that he had no differences with senior Congress leader Rajinder Kaur Bhattal.

“ The SAD-BJP is there for three years and people of the state are perturbed to see three major violent incidents in Dera Sacha Sauda clash, post Vienna murder violence and most recently Ludhiana violence. There is no rule of law,” he alleged.

Amarinder alleged that certain Punjab police and administration officials were working as “Political Wing” of the ruling SAD-BJP combine and were tormenting Congress workers in “false” cases. “We are busy making lists of such officials and will be dealing with them when we came to power,” he added.

Top

 
COMMUNITY
 

Fazilka war memorial under renovation
S P Sharma
Tribune News Service

Fazilka, December 9
The war memorial set up by residents of this town in memory of the 82 soldiers of the Army, who laid down their lives while protecting the area during the India-Pakistan war of 1971, is these days being renovated to give it a fresh look.

This is being done with the donations of residents of the town who enjoy the distinction of having established the country’s only war memorial by raising funds from the public.

Mohan Lal Paruthi, a prominent person of the area, who was among the few who collected the mutilated bodies of 82 soldiers of the 4 JAT and cremated them at the war memorial in Asafwala village, was himself supervising the renovation works.

The war memorial committee had also set up a high school, a primary school, dispensary and community centre in the 5-acre complex. A war museum was also under construction.

Paruthi recalled that 82 soldiers laid their lives at Grumikhera while preventing advance of the Pakistani troops towards the Fazilka town. A couple of residents on December 18 collected the mutilated remains of the soldiers from 7am till 3 pm and thereafter performed the last rites in a mass pyre.

The war memorial was initially established on 1-acre land and later expanded to 5 acres. The state government was approached for setting up a school that has now been upgraded to high school. The pillar on which the names of martyrs have been inscribed was also being renovated.

Paruthi said the memorial had become an attraction for not only residents of the surrounding towns, but also for visitors from outside who also come here to pay respect to martyrs.

He said portraits of the martyrs and pictures of the war would be displayed in the museum.

Shashi Kant, who is also involved in renovation works, had published a booklet on the heroic deeds of soldiers.

Top

 

Anganwadi workers stage protest
Ramanjit Singh Sidhu
Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, December 9
Members of the Anganwadi Workers Union today caught the Chandigarh police and Punjab intelligence napping and staged a protest outside the Chief Minister’s residence here today.

The drama went on for about one-and-a-half-hour during which the traffic on the road was disrupted. Agitating protesters raised slogans against the apathetic attitude of the state government. Protesters reached near the CM residence in a clandestine manner dodging the intelligence agencies.

The OSD to the CM, who arrived after about an hour provoked the agitating protesters by asking them in an indifferent manner to hand him over their “paper”. The protesters objected to his behaviour and made him understand that it was not a paper, but the last memorandum to the authorities concerned. The matter was resolved following the intervention of DSP (central) Jagbir Singh, who assured them to facilitate a meeting with the CM.

The union is protesting against the adjustment of surplus employees of the Punjab State Social Welfare Board in the Social Welfare Department. They were demanding cancellation of the orders alleging that the surplus employees adjusted in their department were under qualified to supervise matriculate Anganwadi workers.

Around 100 protesters reached the city from various parts of the state last night. The women shouting slogans sat on a dharna blocking the road. Seeing the tempers rising, the security personnel began making futile promises of arranging a meeting of the representatives of the union with the authorities.

After getting information about the agitation, two police personnel reached the spot on their private scooter at 10.30 pm, and later police personnel, including women, started to come in small numbers.

After a gap of 30 minutes, a PCR Gypsy followed by the SHO of the Sector 3 police station arrived. The SHO told the protesters that he would arrest them for violating prohibitory orders. President of the union Usha Rani made him speechless by asking about the police action regarding the ruckus in the Punjab Assembly on Tuesday. To which the SHO said the Assembly did not come under his jurisdiction.

At last, the police arrested 83 protesters, along with their president, under preventive measures and released them later after producing before the SDM.

Top

 

Patiala jail to have de-addiction centre
Tribune News Service

Patiala, December 9
With a view to help the jail inmates, who have become drug addicts, a de-addiction centre would be set up in the Patiala Central Jail, said Patiala Deputy Commissioner Dipinder Singh.

The DC also announced that since the building of the hospital in jail is almost 100 years old, the district administration would be sending a detailed project for the construction of the new hospital building to the state government. He was speaking after inaugurating a PCO set up on the jail premises.

After interacting with jail inmates, Dipinder said no one was a criminal by birth and many a time circumstances push a person to commit something wrong. “Hence, we must adopt a humanitarian approach towards the inmates and they must be given the opportunity to reform and live a respected life after completing their jail sentence”, he asserted.

“The objective to open the PCO is to facilitate the jail inmates to share their joys and sorrows with their family members”, said the DC.

He said officials of the PWD have been instructed to prepare a report for the new hospital building. Once the project report is ready, it would be sent to the government for the approval. He also said that a separate psychiatry ward would be opened for the jail inmates.

Meanwhile, he has announced that the barrack in which Sewa Singh Thikriwala, a leader of the Praja Mandal movement was lodged, would be conserved as a historic place.

Top

 

LIC denies info for paying more
Dharmendra Joshi/Tribune News Service

Jalandhar, December 9
In what may be termed as a “ridiculous way” to delay information under the RTI Act, the local office of the Life Insurance of India (LIC) has returned a postal order of Rs 20 to an applicant stating that the requisition fee for seeking information is just Rs 10.

In a letter sent to the applicant, Dolly Sadera of Phagwara on December 3, the manager (CRM) of the LIC, Jalandhar, asked her to send Rs 10 only.

SK Mittal, an RTI activist, said, “No doubt the basic fee for getting information under the RTI Act is Rs 10, but usually an estimated fee, including postal charges and Rs 2 per page, is sent to different government departments for seeking information. I have got information from different departments by paying an estimated fee of over Rs 10 in advance.”

In her application sent to the senior divisional manager, LIC, Jalandhar, on December 1, Dolly Sadera, who is widow, had sought the detail of the status of a claim filed by her for a policy issued in the name of her husband, Rajesh Kumar, who died two years ago.

Top

 

Deed wins best production award
Tribune News Service

Jalandhar, December 9
Eminent producer and Punjabi poet Jaswant Deed has won Doordarshan’s best production award in promo category for preparing a documentary programme - “Guru Manyo Granth”. The programme was spread over seven parts based on different aspects of Guru Granth Sahib.

Working here as an assistant station director, Doordarshan, Deed was given this award at a function held recently in Hyderabad. The best cameraman award has gone to Satyan and Jeet Raj, who were associated with Deed to produce the programme.

This is for the seventh time that Jaswant Deed has won such an award.

Top

 
COURTS
 

HC: Trace woman who accused Capt of rape
Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, December 9
The Punjab and Haryana High Court today asked the SSP concerned to track down the woman, who levelled allegations of rape against Punjab’s former Chief Minister Capt Amarinder Singh, and find out who was behind the move to “defame respectable individuals”.

Clearly unconvinced regarding the authenticity of the allegations of rape, Justice Ranjit Singh also asked the SSP to submit his report.

The directions came on a petition for protection filed by Shamsher Singh Jagera. Describing himself as president of organisation for protection of human rights, he had moved the high court expressing apprehension regarding his personal safety on the ground of being attacked by the ex-Chief Minister’s supporters as he had held the Press conference where the allegations of rape were levelled.

Capt Amarinder Singh had earlier claimed before the media that Jagera had been booked for rape in 2003. He had also claimed the woman had earlier made a similar accusation against a sitting judge.

As the petition came up for hearing this morning, the Judge observed: “It is not understandable as to how the petitioner is concerned with the allegations of rape made by a stranger woman. It appears that the petitioner is resorting to mudslinging by making allegations just to defame respectable persons”.

“Sometime ago, allegations of this nature were made against a judicial officer, who was dealing with some case. These allegations were subsequently found to be false. The woman, who made the allegations, was later not available and not traceable”, the Judge said.

“Perhaps, the same woman has been made to stand to make these allegations, which the petitioner is wanting to highlight through Press. He is now abusing the process of the court by filing the petition. These modes and methods need to be discouraged.”

Issuing notice to the Punjab advocate-general for December 15, the Judge also directed the SSP to take appropriate legal action against the petitioner, if it was found that the allegations were false and made with oblique purpose or motive. 

Top

 

SAD (A) moves HC against SGPC
Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, December 9
SAD (Amritsar) president Simranjit Singh Mann today moved the high court claiming that the term of the SGPC’s present general house expired on August 31, yet the Home Ministry had not announced fresh elections.

Mann also prayed for restraining SGPC office-bearers from incurring expenses on different projects, floating new projects, giving grants, etc. excepting making payments of salaries and other expenses till the new general body is constituted.

Submit revised affidavit, AG told

Finding deficiencies in an affidavit submitted by the state of Punjab in response to Punjab’s former DGP’s plea Sarbdeep Singh Virk for grant of blanket bail, Justice H.S. Bhalla today directed additional advocate-general Reeta Kohli to submit the revised affidavit by way of reply.

The case will now come up tomorrow.

Top

 

Judges (Protection) Act upheld
Saurabh Malik
Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, December 9
The Punjab and Haryana High Court has upheld the constitutional validity of the Judges (Protection) Act, 1985. The Bench of Justice M.M. Kumar and Justice Jaswant Singh has asserted: “There is nothing in the Act, which may be said to be violative of Article 14 of the Constitution, or otherwise of a nature of illegality; nor any such argument has been raised at the time of hearing.”

The Bench also imposed a cost of Rs 20,000 on the petitioner, a Jalandhar-based advocate, for making a frivolous claim. The petitioner, Sat Paul, had earlier sought directions to the Union of India and other respondents for declaring the Act ultra vires of the Constitution.

In his petition, Paul asserted that he had filed a complaint on October 27, 2009, in the court of Jalandhar chief judicial magistrate against district judge. But the complaint was not entertained by the CJM on the ground that it was not maintainable in the view of Section 3 of the Act.

According to Section 3, an additional protection has been extended to judges for any act committed or anything done by them in the course of acting, or purporting to act, in the discharge of official or judicial duty or function.

Speaking for the Bench, Justice M.M. Kumar asserted they did not know what object was sought to be achieved by the petitioner by levelling irresponsible, baseless and frivolous allegations. The conduct of the petitioner was contumacious.

Top

 





HOME PAGE | Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir | Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs | Nation | Opinions |
| Business | Sports | World | Letters | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | Delhi |
| Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | Suggestion | E-mail |