SPECIAL COVERAGE
CHANDIGARH

LUDHIANA

DELHI
JALANDHAR


THE TRIBUNE SPECIALS
50 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE

TERCENTENARY CELEBRATIONS

Govt failing its aged citizens
The population of the aged in the state is 8-10 lakh and growing. Yet the state govt has managed to set up only two age-old homes, in Bageshwar and Chamoli
Senior citizens bask in the winter sun in Dehradun.Dehradun, March 2
There was time when the responsibility of running the house and feeding family members rested on his shoulders. But not anymore. Old and shrivelled Janak at the ripe age of 86 has taken a back seat.
Senior citizens bask in the winter sun in Dehradun. A Tribune photograph


Singh is king

A Sikh girl has fun atop a statute of a lion at Nanksar Gurdwara in Raipur near Dehradun.
A Sikh girl has fun atop a statute of a lion at Nanksar Gurdwara in Raipur near Dehradun. A Tribune photo Anil P. Rawat



EARLIER EDITIONS


Lohari Nagpala oustees seek rehabilitation
Dehradun, March 2
After the work on the 600 MW Lohari Nagpala project on Bhagirathi river built by the National Thermal Power Corporation was suspended by the Central government following an indefinite fast undertaken by environmentalist Prof GD Agarwal, there is a demand to rehabilitate the residents of the eight villages who lost their hearths, homes and fields to the project.

Writ against re-adjustment of seats
Discriminatory to hill people, says Cong leader
Dehradun, March 2
Jot Singh Bisht, a senior Congress leader from Tehri Garhwal district of Uttarkhand, has filed a writ petition in the Supreme Court against the Delimitation Commission of India. The writ was admitted on February 23.

Top





 

 

 

 




 

Govt failing its aged citizens
The population of the aged in the state is 8-10 lakh and growing. Yet the state govt has managed to set up only two age-old homes, in Bageshwar and Chamoli
Neena Sharma
Tribune News Service

Annie Baron (centre) with her children at the home for the elderly in Dehradun.
Annie Baron (centre) with her children at the home for the elderly in Dehradun. A Tribune photo: Anil Rawat 

Dehradun, March 2
There was time when the responsibility of running the house and feeding family members rested on his shoulders. But not anymore. Old and shrivelled Janak at the ripe age of 86 has taken a back seat. His movements have become shaky, eliciting laughter among children of his distant family members in Doon, where he now lives.

Forsaken by his loved ones and luck, the physical changes have not diminished his enthusiasm for things happening around him.

His eyes light up while recognising the voice of a news broadcaster on his transistor.These are the only people he happens to know and who keep him posted on the happenings around him even as his own living in close proximity continue to be distant and aloof.

The aged in Uttarakhand increasingly find themselves in a similar predicament. Crumbling family structures and uncaring relatives have made them unwanted in their own homes, the situation made worse by the near absence of geriatric care centres in the state.

It is a bleak scenario for women, who labour throughout productive years of their lives but once old, have no one to turn to.

“As per the data available with the State Social Welfare Department, the population of the aged in the state is between 8-10 lakh and growing.The government provides old-age pension and medical care to BPL card-holders whose population is over 1,90,000,” said Manisha Pawar, secretary, Social Welfare.

After the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act -- 2007 came into being, the states were directed to establish and maintain such number of old-age homes at accessible places as it may deem necessary in a phased manner, beginning with at least one in each district to accommodate in such homes a minimum of 150 senior citizens.

However, the state government managed to establish only two age-old homes in Bageshwar and Chamoli.

“These homes have a capacity for 50 persons; the government provides board and lodging facilities and medical care to the inmates,” said RP Pant, additional director, Social Welfare Department.

Breaking of family ties, hitherto unknown in Uttarakhand, has brought about a sea change in the lives of the old who are now viewed a mere burden. Unable to keep pace with changes taking place in the villages, the interventions by the government seem inadequate for the needs of an aging population.

“No one checks the quality of food being served or the living conditions at the centres. Besides, the government doesn’t seem to be in tune with the needs of the aged. There are differences in the problems of the aged residing in villages and those in towns. It would not be an exaggeration to say that our villages are mostly inhabited by the old, the infirm and womenfolk.

Most have been left behind with the young and able moving out to towns and cities in search of work. In certain cases it may be by choice as the old may not want to leave their home and be subject to cultural shock,” said Hemlata, a social activist, who carried a study on the aged population in Uttarkhand called ‘Sandhyadeep’.

In case of cities, the situation is one of neglect and apathy. Children do not have time for their parents. The older persons have to contend with unavailable relatives. To top it all, there are no safety nets or retirement houses with medical care in the state. The government is failing it’s aged population,” said Hemlata.

The condition of the women in hills is much worse. As per the findings of a study undertaken by Dr Aabha Chaudhary, chairperson, ANUGRAHA: “As 48 per cent of old women are widows, their dependency on family members/sons for economic survival is complete. 

Even if the husband is alive, he is generally unconcerned towards the health needs of his old wife. Nearly half (49.9 per cent ) do not receive monetary help from migrated son(s) and only 10.7 per cent are visited by their son(s).”

The government spending on age-old schemes is a pithy. Besides pension schemes, the state government has not launched any scheme for the old who may not be economically weak but need monetary care to help them pay their medical bills.

“ A total of 1.5 lakh persons who are BPL card-holders receive the monthly old-age pension. Other then that, there are no initiatives taken by the state government,” informed UD Chaube, social welfare officer, Department of Social Welfare, Uttarakhand.

That the problem of the elderly may one day take a serious turn in the state has been brought out in another study carried out by Lokpriya Sharma of the International Institution of Population Sciences,Mumbai, who has done an extensive study on the problems of the aged in Uttarakhand.

“The situation is alarming in Uttarakhand in the case of ageing population which can have serious policy implications for the state in days to come. The population aged 60 years and above to the population aged 14 and below, defined as "ageing index", has increased substantially from 18.52 in 1991 to 21.20 in 2001, the study pointed out.

The health problems that the aged face are reduced physical immobility to more serious ones like the Alzheimer’s disease and other life-debilitating diseases. Experts in the healthcare sector advocate a special policy framework to provide better health facilities to the aged population in this hill state.

“The old notion of according respect to the aged stands shaken today. It cannot be counted as an insurance against old age, but affordable and free health facilities in some cases can be built in the state. Besides, looking after the aged is a specialised field. There is very little awareness about training in this sector in our country,” said Dr Aabha.

Neena Sharma
Tribune News Service

Dehradun, March 2
A popular retreat for the retiree population of the country and termed popularly as the city perfect for the grey heads, Doon has the distinction of having an old-age home that was established for the Anglo-Indian women who decided to stay back in India.

It was an emotional decision taken by eight women who had lived the greater parts of their lives in Dehradun and were not willing to forsake their homes.These women moved on to the premises donated by Mrs Spread who left for England.

Located on five acres, the rundown bungalow is located amidst lush green trees on Cantonment Road. This has been Annie Barons home for the last 60 years.The home is being centrally administered by the YWCA (Young Women Christian Association), New Delhi. It also runs a day-care centre for the elderly residents of neighbouring villages.

All of 99 years and related to the famous Wheeler family who resided in Almora, Annie Baron continues to be agile. Her close family members make annual visits, satisfied with the care that she gets in Dehradun. The family members provide funds for 
her upkeep.

“My mother is quite old now. On her insistence we gave up the idea of taking her with us,” says Hector Bonerjee, son of Annie Baron, who is on a visit here.

Living on their terms, these women were active participants in the activities of the city. “ Ms Margaret Moffet, who passed away a few years back, was at the helm of several environment movements,” says Anis-ur Rehman, project development officer, YWCA.

The YWCA also runs a day-care centre for the elderly.There are 36 inmates whose needs are taken care of by the centre.They are provided free ration, pocket money and medical care.

However in the last couple of years, the peace and quietude of the city has been shattered by incidents of murder of the elderly.

“There is a growing problem of isolation and old-age homes give security to the old,” says  Anis-ur Rehman.

Top

 

Lohari Nagpala oustees seek rehabilitation
Tribune News Service

Dehradun, March 2
After the work on the 600 MW Lohari Nagpala project on Bhagirathi river built by the National Thermal Power Corporation was suspended by the Central government following an indefinite fast undertaken by environmentalist Prof GD Agarwal, there is a demand to rehabilitate the residents of the eight villages who lost their hearths, homes and fields to the project.

Suresh Bhai of the Uttarakhand Nadi Bachao Andolan, Uttrakashi, while appreciating the move to suspend the work on the project demanded that people of the eight villages who have been suffering for the past four years should be properly rehabilitated.

“People in the eight villages over the tunnel of the project which have been destabilised by its construction also need to be rehabilitated,” said Suresh Bhai.

He demanded that these people need to be rehabilitated, resettled and compensated not just for the land that was acquired but also for the forests and water resources lost.

Most of them are marginal farmers who are being pushed into poverty because of the lack of a people-friendly rehabilitation and resettlement policy in the state, even though the Central government brought a Central policy in October 2007.

“Their voices have been drowned in the victory celebrations accompanying Dr Agarwal's ‘great achievement’,” he said.

Appreciating the move to declare the Ganga as a national river, Suresh Bhai said that every river that emerges from Uttarakhand merges with the Ganga and there was a need to discuss the 220 power projects proposed on these rivers.

Suresh asked whether tunnelling of mountains was the only way to produce hydroelectricity or other methods like ‘run of the river’ should be adopted. He said that tunnelling and diverting the river are the most ecologically damaging method of producing hydroelectricity and all such projects in the state need to be reviewed at once besides figuring out the social and environmental costs of these projects.

Raksha Sutra and Uttarakhand Nadi Bachao Andolan have been repeatedly raising these issues on all forums in the state. “While the suspension of work at Lohari Nagpala is commendable, we, nevertheless, feel that this is not enough and more needs to be done,” he said.

“In the hurry to become an Urja Pradesh (energy state), the state government shouldn’t ignore the people whose lives and livelihood are dependent upon the land, water and forest resources that are being systematically devastated by the power projects,” he added.

Top

 

Writ against re-adjustment of seats
Discriminatory to hill people, says Cong leader
Tribune News Service

Dehradun, March 2
Jot Singh Bisht, a senior Congress leader from Tehri Garhwal district of Uttarkhand, has filed a writ petition in the Supreme Court against the Delimitation Commission of India. The writ was admitted on February 23.

Bisht has challenged the notification dated December 28, 2006, by the Delimitation Commission in which the commission has re-adjusted the allocation of legislative assembly constituencies.

As a result, the hill area constituencies of the state, covering a huge geographical area lose six MLAs and the Terai and urban regions covering the districts of Haridwar, Udham Singh Nagar, Nainital and Dehradun get nine extra MLAs in Uttarakhand. The delimitation was done on the basis of the 
2001 census.

Bisht argued that the 2001 census cannot be used as the basis and more importantly, population could not be the sole criteria on the basis of which the allocation is to be done.

He has argued that this has led to discrimination against the people of the hills and tribals.

Bisht pleaded that the apex court should issue a writ of certiorari or any other appropriate writ, order or direction, quashing the Notification No. 282/UTA/2006 dated December 28, 2006, declaring it ultra vires the Constitution of India in violation of Article 14 and part (i) of the third provision of Article 170(3) of the Constitution of India.

Top

 



HOME PAGE | Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir | Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs | Nation | Opinions |
| Business | Sports | World | Letters | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | Delhi |
| Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | Suggestion | E-mail |