SPECIAL COVERAGE
CHANDIGARH

LUDHIANA

DELHI
O P I N I O N S

Editorials | Article | Middle | Oped | Reflections

EDITORIALS

Political sparring
Sonia, Mulayam playing mind games
M
rs Sonia Gandhi spent three days in Rae Bareli for "jan sampark" and assessing the overall political situation in Uttar Pradesh. Even after the creation of Uttaranchal, the state has not lost its political importance.

Meals at mid-day
SC directive to Centre and states timely
T
he Supreme Court's ruling on Thursday on the mid-day meal scheme is significant for three reasons. First, it has restrained the Centre from taking steps to transfer the administration of mid-day meals in schools to the states.



EARLIER ARTICLES

Selective amnesia
September 17, 2004
A military habit
September 16, 2004
Waiting for teachers
September 15, 2004
Advani’s dilemma
September 14, 2004
Powerless in the North
September 13, 2004
Media and society: Who wins the blame game?
September 12, 2004
A friend in need
September 11, 2004
Small is not beautiful
September 10, 2004
Nonsense and census
September 9, 2004
Avoidable growth
September 8, 2004
THE TRIBUNE SPECIALS
50 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE

TERCENTENARY CELEBRATIONS

Off track
Expedite Chandigarh-Ludhiana link
E
ven when Chandigarh, originally conceived as the capital of Punjab, was still on the drafting board, Le Corbusier had planned an 8-km rail corridor for the city.

ARTICLE

Crisis in Nepal
Transfer of power is the real issue
by Major-Gen Ashok K. Mehta (retd)
P
rime Minister Sher Bahadur Deuba’s visit to Delhi last week was confirmed only a day before, due to the compound crisis created by the Maoist blockade of Kathmandu, street protests by political formations opposed to the government and the rioting following the execution of 12 Nepali workers in Iraq, not to mention the red alert from a Maoist threat to hijack an Indian aircraft.

MIDDLE

A narrow escape
by Syed Nooruzzaman
T
he efforts aimed at improving relations between India and Pakistan remind me of an interesting incident, narrated by my father, now no more. It happened soon after India was divided, resulting in the birth of Pakistan. 

OPED

NEWS ANALYSIS
Maharashtra campaign getting shriller
Hindutva issues set to dominate
by Shiv Kumar
H
indutva will jostle with a host of local issues in the forthcoming Assembly elections in Maharashtra as the opposition Shiv Sena-Bharatiya Janata Party combine unleashes a shrill campaign in the state.

Defence notes
Gorkhas get debt of gratitude
by Girja Shankar Kaura
A
lmost six decades after World War II got over the British Government has finally recognised the services of the Gorkhas who had fought under the British Indian Army and were held prisoners of war by the Japanese.

  • Pak defence fair

  • Army Generals felicitated

 REFLECTIONS

Top


 

 

 


 

Political sparring
Sonia, Mulayam playing mind games

Mrs Sonia Gandhi spent three days in Rae Bareli for "jan sampark" and assessing the overall political situation in Uttar Pradesh. Even after the creation of Uttaranchal, the state has not lost its political importance. Of course, UP itself has witnessed massive socio-political churning after Mr V. P. Singh let loose the Mandal cat among the pigeons. A decade of political instability has destroyed or seriously damaged existing political and administrative tools of development. The institutionalisation of political corruption and patronage to crime have made Bihar look like a poor cousin of UP.

However, when Mrs Sonia Gandhi expressed concern over the bad law and order situation in UP she was not merely stating the obvious. The purpose was to make Chief Minister Mulayam Singh Yadav uncomfortable, as also to provide the cue to the party workers to follow during the campaign in the two Lok Sabha and 12 Vidhan Sabha constituencies for the October 13 byelections. Attacking the present government, or even past ones, for the poor law and order situation suits the Congress. The Bharatiya Janata Party, the Bahujan Samaj Party, the Samajwadi Party and the defunct outfit floated by Mr Kalyan Singh are directly or indirectly responsible for the present mess. The Congress has not been in power in UP since 1990 and even today it has merely extended outside support to Mr Mulayam Singh for keeping the BJP out.

The periodic sparring between Mrs Sonia Gandhi and Mr Mulayam Singh is part of the complex political equations that the Lok Sabha verdict created. The left parties have extended outside support to the United Progressive Alliance and have at the same time let the Congress know that it would not like the UP Chief Minister to be harmed. The Congress has a similar arrangement with the Samajwadi leader in UP. So, if she pulls the plug on Mr Mulayam Singh in Lucknow, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh will be in difficulty. Only a dramatic verdict in favour of the Congress in the byelections in UP can give Mrs Sonia Gandhi the option to raise the level of political risk-taking in Lucknow and Delhi.
Top

 

Meals at mid-day
SC directive to Centre and states timely

The Supreme Court's ruling on Thursday on the mid-day meal scheme is significant for three reasons. First, it has restrained the Centre from taking steps to transfer the administration of mid-day meals in schools to the states. Second, it has fixed accountability on the states for its implementation. And third, the Centre should continue to release funds to the states. There is no denying that the concept of mid-day meal scheme is sound. Studies by Bangalore's National Institute of Advanced Studies and New Delhi's Centre for Equity Studies have proved the immense benefits of the scheme. These include, among other things, improvement in the enrolment and learning levels of the children; reduction in the dropout rate; and the removal of caste and gender bias. Above all, the scheme is an answer to the National Family Health Survey observations (1998-99) that 74 per cent of Indian children between 6 and 15 years were anaemic, affecting their mental and physical growth.

It is, however, sad that despite its success in the south (Tamil Nadu and Karnataka in particular), the scheme is not being implemented effectively in the north. The picture in Punjab, Haryana and Himachal Pradesh is not quite encouraging because of its partial implementation. Why should students in most states be deprived of the scheme when the Centre has promised steady flow of funds? In fact, the levy of 2 per cent education cess in the Union Budget for 2004-05 is in tune with Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's commitment to ensure the success of the scheme.

Some states complain of lack of infrastructure to implement the scheme. Some refuse to spare teachers for purposes of cooking or supervision. However, since the scheme will yield rich dividends, they would do well to evolve suitable solutions and implement it in the larger interest of the students. Rajasthan, for instance, has set an example. It has entrusted the task of cooking the meals to destitute women, especially widows. Panchayats, anganwadis, philanthropic and voluntary organisations can also be roped in for the success of the scheme.
Top

 

Off track
Expedite Chandigarh-Ludhiana link

Even when Chandigarh, originally conceived as the capital of Punjab, was still on the drafting board, Le Corbusier had planned an 8-km rail corridor for the city. Unfortunately more than 50 years after that the capital of two states and a Union Territory is not directly linked by rail with Punjab. The proposed 24-km rail link between the city and Morinda, which would connect with Ludhiana, has again gone off track, this time because no provision has been made in the Railway Budget for the electrification of the stretch. The project, which dates back to 1997, had earlier been delayed for a year or so because of the existence of an unauthorised colony on railway land.

It was finally cleared by the Chandigarh Administration and the land was handed over to the railway authorities. Now, bridges are being built in the area. There has been a certain amount of disruption of traffic and it is expected that there will be more dislocation before the bridges are finalised and the tracks laid. All this has to be taken in stride, since the promised gains are considerable. The train would reduce the load from the congested Chandigarh-Ludhiana highway; and make possible many more rail links. It might seem premature to talk about the electrification of the tracks even before these have been laid, but planning for such projects has to be long range. If diesel engines have to pull trains along this stretch, the delays would be a major dampener.

Over the years, lack of coordination between the administration and the railways has caused delays. Now it seems that there is lack of coordination within the railways itself. Chandigarh-Morinda-Ludhiana link needs to be activated as soon as possible. An estimated Rs 370 crore is being spent on the rail link, all that the electrification needs is a provision of an additional Rs 35 crore. This allocation must be made expeditiously for work on electrification to begin soon. Chandigarh deserves a more prominent place on the rail map of India.
Top

 

Thought for the day

Generally, people should be more specific. — Anonymous
Top

 

Crisis in Nepal
Transfer of power is the real issue
by Major-Gen Ashok K. Mehta (retd)

Prime Minister Sher Bahadur Deuba’s visit to Delhi last week was confirmed only a day before, due to the compound crisis created by the Maoist blockade of Kathmandu, street protests by political formations opposed to the government and the rioting following the execution of 12 Nepali workers in Iraq, not to mention the red alert from a Maoist threat to hijack an Indian aircraft. Not since the Palace massacre in June 2001, has Kathmandu seen equivalent paralysis. Bandhs, orgies of violence and a six-day-long curfew in Kathmandu combined to numb Nepal. For the first time, Kathmandu witnessed a communal backlash. Mosques and Muslim property were attacked. The Nepalese are furious at the lawless turn of events.

Nepal is a multiethnic, multilingual, democratic, independent, indivisible, sovereign Hindu State and a constitutional monarchical Kingdom. The rise of the Maoists and the phenomenal growth of Muslims is a post-democracy development. Muslims now comprise at least 10 per cent of the 25 million population concentrated in the Terai supported mainly by funds from Saudi Arabia. Almost one million Nepalese work in countries other than India, two-thirds in Arab and Islamic states. They spend up to Rs 1 lakh through employment agencies to get a job as waiters, peons, guards and so on. Soldiering is no longer the first love. Making a fast buck is. Their earnings constitute the largest inflow of foreign exchange surpassing tourism which has been badly hit by the Maoist war. Ironically, irate mobs, stung by the news of the execution of 12 countrymen went on an organised rampage in Kathmandu, destroying 72 out of 90 employment agencies that send young Nepalis in lure of gold and hard currency. Wherever you met ordinary Nepalis in Kathmandu they say the same thing: Hamro desh khatam chha. This does not need translation. Two to three persons being killed and bomb blasts are daily occurrences in Kathmandu or outside.

Sadly, the political landscape is scarred equally badly. The country is being run by SB Deuba, third time Prime Minister fired and reappointed by King Gyanendra who is constitutionally the sole and supreme power under the emergency provision of Article 127 of the 1990 constitution that the Maoists have sworn to eradicate. The King has played his cards cleverly dividing political formations and ruling. Considerably discredited after the Palace massacre-by-conspiracy theories, he has regained his shine thanks to the fiercely loyal Royal Nepal Army (RNA) and inept politicians. According to one poll held recently, King Gyanendra, Maoist supremo Prachanda and former Prime Minister GP Koirala in that order are the choice of the people. But the King has one serious handicap: Crown Prince Paras. He may be unwittingly helping the Maoists in their do-or-die mission of eliminating monarchy.

The political formations are severely divided. The biggest and oldest political party, the Nepali Congress is split between the larger Koirala and Deuba groups. Mr GP Koirala is heading a four-party alliance employing street power to force the King to revive Parliament whose life expired in April this year. He says the current government is unconstitutional. But so will be a House revived under Article 127 after a full bench of the Supreme Court has upheld the dissolution of the House in May, 2002. But Nepali Congress leaders argue that as the King can do no wrong, he can revive Parliament !

Prime Minister Deuba has the difficult task of running a coalition government which has the second largest political party in Nepal — Communist Party of Nepal United Marxist Leninist — led by Madhav Nepal and the top-heavy and trifurcated royalist Rashtriya Prajatantra Party (RPP). Deuba has not only to manage this coalition but also to ensure the King does not dismiss him again, not to mention the irritants posed by Mr Koirala. To cap all this, Prachanda has rejected outright Deuba’s offer of talks. Emboldened by the success of the blockade of Kathmandu, the gutsy Prachanda will return to the negotiating table from a position of strength armed with some assurance over the key demand of a constituent assembly.

The view gaining ground in Kathmandu is that elections are not possible without first addressing the issues raised by the Maoist revolution. Others feel that an election has to be held to get Nepal out of the box.

India and Nepal can talk about their differing security perceptions, harnessing water resources, the Bhutanese refugee problem, economic cooperation, more military assistance for RNA and the resolution of the Extradition and Mutual Legal Assistance treaties.

India and Nepal have an extradition treaty signed in 1953. However, this does not have any provisions for extraditing nationals of third countries to India or Nepal. Nor does it have any provisions for extraditing persons for “financial or terrorist” crimes. That this has implications for India’s security is obvious. During the hijack of IC 814 from Kathmandu, the complicity of the Pakistanis in the act of terrorism was not in doubt. Yet, even if Nepalese authorities had apprehended those responsible for the action, India could not have insisted on their extradition because there was no legal framework for doing so. On the other hand, Nepalese allege that India has repeatedly violated the treaty by taking advantage of an open border and sending police forces into Nepal to pursue criminals, something that has undermined Nepal’s sovereignty. Perceptions of each others’ security interests therefore differ radically. The problem in revising the treaty is that it will entail an amendment in the Constitution which requires a two-thirds majority in Parliament. But there is no Parliament !

Finally unless the question of transfer of power is settled in Nepal, it will remain a disturbed desh, not the Shangrila it once was.
Top

 

A narrow escape
by Syed Nooruzzaman

The efforts aimed at improving relations between India and Pakistan remind me of an interesting incident, narrated by my father, now no more. It happened soon after India was divided, resulting in the birth of Pakistan. Those were terrible times, not only for the families which had got uprooted but also for those scared of meeting a similar fate.

My grandfather, a teacher in a government school, got a letter from the Government of India, asking him to decide whether he would prefer to shift to the other side of the divide. Obviously, he got disturbed and brought this to the notice of a few village elders. Before he could decide what to do, he came to know that a few other people in his eastern UP village had also received similar letters. The reason was that they were all government employees.

The matter was then brought before a meeting of the village elders. It was the dead of night. There was fear writ large on every face. The village Mukhiya (my grandfather) initiated the discussion. It went like this: “Why should we go to a place we have never seen? It is like a foreign country for us. Who knows us there? The people in Pakistan may have a different lifestyle. Their language may be different. For us it is better to die and get buried near our forefathers than leave our home for a place where we will have to live as strangers.”

Every participant in the meeting, including those who had received the dreaded letter, agreed with the viewpoint expressed so forcefully. They decided to remain the citizens of India which they were already. They, therefore, narrowly escaped from getting uprooted and acquiring the hated tag of muhajirs in Pakistan.

The matter, however, did not end there. Next morning a number of zamindars (upper caste Hindus) from the surrounding villages came to our village inhabited by Muslim zamindars. People in the nearby areas had got wind of what had happened the previous night.

Their visit initially frightened everybody, but it was soon over. They knew the elders in our village and had come only to congratulate them for having taken a decision not to leave the place of their forefathers. They offered their help for any eventuality, an expression of brotherly feelings.

There might have been many such incidents, showing a strong attachment to one’s ancestral place. Pitrabhoomi or matribhoomi has a special kind of pull, influencing one’s decisions even in crisis situations. Though I live far away from my village, it is just not possible for me to forget the place with all its flora and fauna, the lush green surroundings, particularly those mango and jamun trees laden with fruit.
Top

 

NEWS ANALYSIS
Maharashtra campaign getting shriller
Hindutva issues set to dominate
by Shiv Kumar

Hindutva will jostle with a host of local issues in the forthcoming Assembly elections in Maharashtra as the opposition Shiv Sena-Bharatiya Janata Party combine unleashes a shrill campaign in the state.

Brainstorming sessions in Mumbai by the Shiv Sena and the BJP leaders have thrown up a number of ideas to milk the Veer Savarkar controversy to the fullest. Booklets extolling the virtues of the controversial freedom fighter are being put out in the market for a nominal Rs 15 each. In addition, the two parties have also planned street corner meetings to abuse Union Petroleum Minister Mani Shankar Aiyar and by extension, the Congress party.

Last month, the Shiv Sena put up effigies of Aiyar for its activists to beat with slippers. Encouraged by the response from its rank and file, the regional Hindu party hopes to raise the pitch in Mumbai, Thane and the neighbouring Konkan region and make up for the loss in the Lok Sabha polls. The Shiv Sena-BJP had lost five of the six seats in Mumbai in the last Lok Sabha polls which account for 34 seats in the 288-seat Maharashtra legislature.

Though his appreciation at the larger national level is patchy in nature, Savarkar enjoys tremendous goodwill among the upper-caste people of Maharashtra. His writings still remain popular in the state and his poems set to music and sung by Lata Mangeshkar continue to be played on All-India Radio.

The BJP has also joined in to accuse the Congress Party of honouring anti-national elements in place of a ‘patriot’ like Savarkar. The party has latched onto top Maharashtra politicians providing relief to the family of alleged Lashkar-e-Toiba terrorist Ishrat Jahan Shamim Raza who was shot dead by the Gujarat police in Ahmedabad last June.

“It’s a shame that the Congress party honoured an anti-national like Ishrat, but shows disrespect to Savarkar,” says Atul Bhatkalkar, BJP spokesman for Maharashtra. According to him, the BJP will take out “Veer Savarkar rath yatra” across Maharashtra complete with an actor dressed up as the late Hindu Mahasabha leader. BJP General Secretary Pramod Mahajan was more direct. “The Congress party was using these tactics to appease a certain community,” Mahajan said. He demanded that the Congress party reinstall the plaques honouring Savarkar at the Cellular jail in Andamans.

The BJP is also playing up the resignation of former Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Uma Bharti following the non-bailable warrant issued by a court in Hubli, Karnataka. The party has already linked Bharti’s resignation with the refusal of ‘tainted’ Central Ministers like Laloo Prasad Yadav and Mohammad Taslimuddin to resign from Prime Minister Manmohan Singh’s Cabinet.

With the Congress party planning major election rallies by party president Sonia Gandhi in Maharashtra to generate a sympathy wave following her decision not to become Prime Minister, the BJP has roped in Uma Bharti to campaign in Maharashtra. “It will be direct confrontation between a nationalist and a foreigner,” says a senior BJP leader of Bharti’s campaign plans in Maharashtra. The BJP is also fielding Varun Gandhi at election rallies to take on the Congress party’s Rahul Gandhi. On the other hand the Congress party has sent out an SOS to Priyanka Vadra to shore up its defences.

Sources in the BJP say, the old favourites like Uniform Civil Code and the Ram Janambhoomi issues would be on the backburner for the forthcoming Maharashtra elections. The BJP’s allies like the Janata Dal (United) and the Telugu Desam that are part of the National Democratic Alliance are uncomfortable with Hindutva. The BJP hopes to placate them by running a shrill right-wing campaign minus the hardliners, according to sources.

It is still not clear if Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi will campaign in Maharashtra. While a number of BJP leaders are keen on him addressing rallies in Maharashtra, a section of the party are still hopeful of garnering the support of minority voters disenchanted with the Congress-Nationalist Congress Party led Democratic Front government in the state.

The Shiv Sena has, however, decided to go all out for a shrill Hindutva campaign. Shiv Sena chief Bal Thackeray and his son Uddhav who hit upon the idea to beat Aiyar’s effigy with slippers have already begun to deliver hard-hitting speeches against the Congress for “appeasing” the miniority community.

The BJP general secretary Pramod Mahajan already hit the ground running after the Lok Sabha polls by taking charge of the party organisation in the state. In Mumbai where the large North Indian community turned against the Shiv Sena — BJP following the campaign against them by the Thackerays, Mahajan’s troubleshooters have held meetings to reach out to the North Indians. BJP leaders of North Indian origin have held mohalla-level meetings across Mumbai, Thane and in the outskirts to bring them back to the saffron fold.

With surveys conducted by both the Congress-NCP front and the Shiv Sena-BJP alliance indicating a close contest, the opposition parties are also focussing on local issues. The failure of co-operative banks across the state, farmers’ suicides in Vidarbha and Marathwada, and the poor power supply situation in the state will all feature in the election campaign, say Sena-BJP leaders.

The two parties have already worked on mobilising cotton and sugarcane farmers in the past three years. Their leaders say the campaign for remunerative prices will benefit the two parties in the Vidarbha and Marathwada regions where the Hindutva wave hasn’t worked.

On the other hand, the Congress-NCP hopes that the sops handed to various sections of society by the Sushilkumar Shinde will work. The state government has provided free electricity to farmers and tried to waive interest on loans taken by agriculturists. However, the Election Commission has struck down some of these measures causing concern to the ruling front in Maharashtra.
Top

 

Defence notes
Gorkhas get debt of gratitude
by Girja Shankar Kaura

Almost six decades after World War II got over the British Government has finally recognised the services of the Gorkhas who had fought under the British Indian Army and were held prisoners of war by the Japanese.

Earlier last month, the British Government paid £ 10,000 each to 101 former Gorkha servicemen in recognition of their services to the British Indian Army while fighting in World War II. The British Government had announced the ex-gratia payment scheme for the Far Eastern Prisoners of War (FEPOW) last year after the media highlighted how their services had not been recognised.

It opened an FEPOW office in Kathmandu and invited applications from the Gorkhas for the ex-gratia payment. According to information here the FEPOW team had received a total of 1,400 applications from all over Nepal and had interviewed 900 of them since April last. While 101 of them have been paid now, a large number of applications are still pending as they remain to be researched and verified.

The FEPOW office in Kathmandu would remain open until the end of 2005 and even the Gorkhas living in India are eligible for the ex-gratia payment. The eligible Gorkhas living in India can forward their applications to the FEPOW office in Kathmandu and its team will interview them when the team members are in India.

Pak defence fair

Pakistan has signed a deal with a private company of South Africa, probably the first non-Islamic country, for the sale of its five Super Mashak aircraft to a private company of South Africa during its Ideas 2004 defence equipment exhibition, a parallel to India’s Def-Expo, which concluded in Karachi earlier in the week.

Ideas is Pakistan’s Defence Export Promotion Organisation’s marketing tool and promotes networking between manufacturer, senior Pakistani military officials and foreign delegations.

Pakistan will also soon start the delivery of the 20 Super Mashaks, produced at the PAC Kamra. It has already sold 10 of these aircraft to Oman and five to Iran. It will also begin the delivery of these planes to Saudi Arabia by the end of the year.

Pakistan is said to be currently exporting defence equipment worth about $80-90 million. But it aims to increase this to between $200 and 300 million.

Army Generals felicitated

Two senior officers of the Indian Army were felicitated by the award of “Eminent Engineer of the Year” by the Institution of Engineers (India). Those recognised were Lt. Gen Mathew Mammen, Engineer-in-Chief of the Army and Lt Gen V.K. Dhir, Director General of Electrical and Mechanical Engineers.

While commanding his regiment Lt. Gen Mathew Mammen was responsible for production and pumping of oil for Oil India Assam during the Assam agitation in 1982-83. As works engineer he was responsible for the project for extension of the Dabilim Airport in Goa in 1988-90 and as Director-General of Operational logistics, he oversaw the complete logistics support during the Kargil Operation.

Lt. Gen V.K. Dhir, a gold medallist in the Engineering Degree Course, was also awarded Marconi Elloit prize in his M. Tech at Carnfield Institute of Technology in the UK in 1976. 
Top

 

Very powerful indeed is the Lord’s name. It may not bring about immediate results, but it must one day bear fruit, just as we find that a seed left long ago on the cornice of a building at last reaches the ground, germinates, grows into a tree, and bears fruit, when perhaps the building cracks 
and is demolished.

— Sri Chaitnaya Mahaprabhu

I would love to be a fish living in water, if by doing so I could cherish the Sustainer-of-all and meet Him who dwells on this side and that, with my arms stretched forth for a close embrace.

— Guru Nanak
Top

HOME PAGE | Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir | Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs | Nation | Opinions |
| Business | Sports | World | Mailbag | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | Delhi |
| Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | Suggestion | E-mail |