SPECIAL COVERAGE
CHANDIGARH

LUDHIANA

DELHI



THE TRIBUNE SPECIALS
50 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE

TERCENTENARY CELEBRATIONS
B U S I N E S S

Nod for RNRL, R-Power merger
Boards okay 4:1 share swap ratio
New Delhi, July 4
Anil Ambani In a mega Rs 50,000-crore deal, the Anil Ambani group today announced the merger of RNRL with Reliance Power, which would now become a direct beneficiary of the gas deal signed with Mukesh Ambani-led Reliance Industries.

Deal sweet or sour?


Anil Ambani

R-Power m-cap at Rs 52,000 post merger
The market valuation of Reliance Power will be over Rs 52,000 crore post merger but this is less than half of what the company was worth when it made its debut on the stock market about two years ago.

Sunday is big business for Anil Ambani
New Delhi, July 4
Forget weekends. It is business and days of big announcements on Sundays for Anil Ambani, contrary to golf and get-togethers for the rest of the corporate world.


EARLIER STORIES



Tax Advice
Co-operative society taxable
Q: I have following queries. How AOP is formed? What is its constitutional documents like deed, MoU...? if anybody have, then pl email. How housing society, unions are treated in income tax? If a 3-4 person come together and form a joint venture with limited liability with respect to particular venture...how they will be treated in income tax?

 

 





Top








 

Nod for RNRL, R-Power merger
Boards okay 4:1 share swap ratio

New Delhi, July 4
In a mega Rs 50,000-crore deal, the Anil Ambani group today announced the merger of RNRL with Reliance Power, which would now become a direct beneficiary of the gas deal signed with Mukesh Ambani-led Reliance Industries.

As part of the all-stock deal, Reliance Power will give one share for every four held in RNRL. RNRL shareholders, including the promoters, will get Reliance Power shares worth about Rs 7,150 crore, as per the current market prices. Out of these, promoters will get shares worth over Rs 3,600 crore.

The deal comes within days of RNRL signing a revised gas supply deal with Reliance Industries (RIL) for power projects, which are under the charge of Reliance Power.

Following the Supreme Court decision on May 7, wherein its plea was rejected for cheaper gas from RIL, Anil Ambani group firm RNRL had lost much of its relevance as a business entity.

Announcing the deal, the two companies said in a joint statement: "Reliance Power's plans for setting up up to 10,000 MW gas-based power plants (will) be accelerated" and Reliance Power will "derive substantial benefit from RNRL's Gas Supply Master Agreement with RIL".

Stating that the RNRL shareholders holding 80 per cent of its capital were also shareholders of Reliance Power, the joint statement said over 80 per cent of the shareholders in the former entity got their shares free on demerger with RIL following the family settlement between Ambani brothers.

RNRL was born out of demerger of Dhirubhai Ambani's Reliance empire five years ago. The purpose of creation of RNRL was for sourcing, supply and transportation of fuels, primarily natural gas.

As per the demerger scheme, RNRL was to source natural gas from Reliance Industries and trade it to ADAG power plants, including the proposed mega 7,800-MW Dadri unit near here being set up by R-Power.

"RNRL shareholders will benefit from the proposed amalgamation, by participating in future growth prospects of Reliance Power's diversified generation portfolio of 37,000 MW and its substantial coal reserves in India and abroad", it said.

On the other hand, Reliance Power will reap benefits from RNRL's coal bed methane blocks and fuel supplies through the latter's coal supply logistics and shipping business, it said, adding that combined entity would have over 60 lakh shareholders, the largest for any entity in the world.

Referring to the Gas Supplies Masters Agreement signed by RNRL with RIL, it said Reliance would drive "substantial benefit" from it. Besides, gas prospects from RNRL's coal bed methane blocks as also its 10 per cent share in an oil and gas block in Mizoram would be an added advantage.

The combined entity would have a net worth of over Rs 16,000 crore, including RNRL's networth of around Rs 1,900, it said. The merger would be subject to approvals of the Bombay High Court and other regulatory authorities, it added. — PTI 

Deal sweet or sour?

New Delhi, June 4
RNRL shareholders must be feeling shortchanged, as they will get one share of R-Power worth Rs 175.1, 45 per cent less than the combined value of Rs 254.6 for four shares they exchange under the merger deal approved today.

In the last trading session, Reliance Power closed at Rs 174.50 a piece, whereas shares of RNRL ended at Rs 63.65. Market analysts have given a mixed opinion about the deal. While some brokers said the deal was good for both ADAG firms, some said R-Power shareholders had an upper hand.

RNRL shareholders, including promoters, will get R-Power shares worth about Rs 7,150 crore, as per the current market prices. Out of these, the promoters would get shares worth over Rs 3,600 crore.

"In terms of business value, the merger deal is good for RNRL... (who) will have more share in ADAG's power projects. Till present, the scrip is more like a trading firm, but post-merger, its value will grow," Angel Broking vice-president, Research, Sarabjit Kour Nangra said.

However, some analysts said the deal value was not so lucrative for RNRL shareholders and would be sweet only after the share price of R-Power breached the combined value of four shares of RNRL.

"RNRL shareholders would have been at better position if the share exchange ratio value was more sweet," said a broker. — PTI 

Top

 

R-Power m-cap at Rs 52,000 post merger

The market valuation of Reliance Power will be over Rs 52,000 crore post merger but this is less than half of what the company was worth when it made its debut on the stock market about two years ago.

R-Power commands a market cap of about Rs 42,000 crore at present, whereas RNRL market value stands at little over Rs 10,000 crore.

The two entities today announced the merger of RNRL with R-Power.

The current valuations peg the market cap of the combined entity at over Rs 52,000 crore. At the end of Friday's trade, the market cap of R-Power stood at Rs 41,979 crore and of RNRL at Rs 10,394 crore.

However, the combined market value of the two ADAG firms compares poorly with the Rs 1.23 lakh crore m-cap that R-Power commanded on February 11, 2008 -- the day it got listed on the stock market after a Rs 11,500 crore IPO, the biggest so far in India's history. — PTI

FOR

In terms of business value, the merger deal is good for RNRL... (who) will have more shares in ADAG's power projects

AGAINST

RNRL shareholders would have been at better position if the share exchange ratio value was more sweet

Top

 

Sunday is big business for Anil Ambani

New Delhi, July 4
Forget weekends. It is business and days of big announcements on Sundays for Anil Ambani, contrary to golf and get-togethers for the rest of the corporate world.

While June 18, 2005 -- the day of separation for Anil from Mukesh Ambani with the division of the Reliance empire -- was a Saturday, it was a Sunday five years later on May 23, 2010, when he announced a patch-up with his elder brother, burying their contentious non-compete agreements.

Since then, there has hardly been a Sunday when he did not pull out his top lieutenants and officials from the comfort of their homes to do business and engage the media for a big exposure in Monday newspapers before the stock markets commence trading for the new week -- a trend that group officials feel is a legacy from the days of his father, Dhirubhai.

Even during the bitter fight with Mukesh, before and after the family settlement, invariably big news came out from ADAG on Sundays -- based on the belief that a lean business day could help get better space in the media.

Commenting on the trend, brokerage firm SMC Global vice-president Rajesh Jain said: "The group probably tries to play safe so that the announcement does not impact the stock prices with a sudden jerk.

"Announcements on a market holiday usually are considered safe, as traders get time to absorb the under-currents of the announcements and then react when the market opens on the next day," he added.

Today also, again a Sunday, boards of two Anil Ambani group companies, Reliance Power and Reliance Natural Resources Ltd, met in Mumbai to decide on their merger.

On the previous Sunday -- June 27 -- the group announced a big-bang Rs 50,000 crore merger deal of RCom's tower assets with GTL Infra to create the world's largest telecom tower firm.

Earlier on June 20, 2010, the Anil Ambani group announced a joint venture between Reliance Broadcast Network with US media giant CBS for capturing the television market in the country.

In the same month, RCom announced on June 6, again a Sunday, that the company was looking for buyers to purchase a 26 per cent stake in the company.

Exactly a week before, Anil had gone to Tirupati on May 30, staying en route at Mukesh's guest house, to seek the deity's blessings for the peace that was ushered in between the two brothers after their years-long bitter rivalry.

The decision for his group's only IPO, that of Reliance Power, was also taken on a Sunday -- September 30, 2007.

As part of the efforts to revive R-Power shares that tanked despite being India's biggest ever IPO at over Rs 11,500 crore, Anil Ambani again announced on a Sunday (February 25, 2008) the issue of free bonus shares.

It was again a Sunday (May 9, 2010) when Anil wrote a morale-boosting letter to his all group employees post the Supreme Court judgment that ruled against RNRL's petition to get gas from RIL as per a family agreement.

In the midst of a years-long legal fight over gas, on yet another Sunday (October 11, 2009), Anil made a passionate appeal for peace with Mukesh, though the very same day, RIL said the litigation was not a family matter. — PTI

Big Sundays

Sept 30, 2007: The decision of R-Power IPO was taken

Feb 25, 2008: Announcement of free bonus shares.

May 23, 2010: Ambanis announce scrapping of a non-compete agreement.

May 30: The group and CBS Corp to form JV

June 6: RCom board approves 26 per cent stake sale

June 27: Anil announces deal to merge Rel Infra with GTL

July 4: Boards of RNRL and Reliance Power approve merger

Top

 

Tax Advice
Co-operative society taxable
by SC Vasudeva

Q: I have following queries. How AOP is formed? What is its constitutional documents like deed, MoU...? if anybody have, then pl email. How housing society, unions are treated in income tax? If a 3-4 person come together and form a joint venture with limited liability with respect to particular venture...how they will be treated in income tax?

Javed Kazi

A. An AOP can be formed by entering into an agreement for the purposes of such formation. The documents for constituting AOP will be the agreement entered into by the parties to form such an association. The agreement is to be prepared on the basis of specific requirements and there cannot be a readymade format.

In case the housing society is a co-operative society, it will be taxable as a co-operative society. A society under the Societies Registration Act 1860 is assessable as an AOP. The concept of mutuality, if applicable, may enable such societies to avail exemption from the taxability. In case of union, the documents which have been executed for the formation of the union will have to be perused so as to ascertain the status under which a union will be taxable. The agreement entered into between the joint venturers will determine the status of the assessable entity.

Income from centre

Q. A person (not doctor) has opened an ultrasound centre and has employed a radiologist to perform ultrasound on salary. No treatment or medicine is given. Proprietor of ultrasound centre is a retired person and is not a qualified doctor, whether it will fall under business or professional for income tax purpose.

Anila Prasad

A. The income in respect of ultrasound centre should be assessed as income from business because the owner is not carrying on any professional activity as he is not a qualified professional himself.

Reimbursement

Q. Kindly clarify whether any income tax is payable on the medical reimbursement received by a retired govt. employee for the treatment of his daughter from a private hospital at the rate approved by the director health, Punjab. If so, what rates for the current financial year?

K.K. Sharda

A. The amount received by an assessee from an ex-employer towards reimbursement of the expenditure incurred on the treatment of his family member shall be taxable in view of the provisions of Section 17(3)(iii) of the Act. The relevant clause brings “any amount due or received, whether in lump sum or otherwise, by any assessee from any person after cessation of his employment with that person” within the ambit of salary income.

The amount so received will also be liable to deduction of tax at source at the average rate applicable to the salary (pension) income of the assessee concerned. 

Top

 





HOME PAGE | Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir | Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs | Nation | Opinions |
| Business | Sports | World | Letters | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | Delhi |
| Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | Suggestion | E-mail |