The most interesting incident
on earth
By Gur
Rattan Pal Singh
SOCRATES, (469-399 B.C.) born in
Athens in the well-to-do family of Athenian sculptor
Sophroniscus and midwife Phaenarete, has been an
enigmatic character in the history of philosophy and
literature. He spent a lot of his time conversing with
young men of promise, politicians and workmen about their
callings and notions of right and wrong. Teachers from
all walks of life from Xenophon, the military
general, to Plato, the intellectual and aristocrat
had the privilege of listening to Socrates, who
steadfastly preached his mission of life : how to lead
men to the truth. He recognised only one good : knowledge
and only one evil : ignorance.
Socrates wrote nothing
and yet he has been immortalised through facts about his
life and the enunciation of his doctrines mainly
contained in the dialogues of Plato and the memorabilia
of Xenophon. In two consummate biographical dialogues
"The Apology" (recounting the
trial and condemnation of Socrates) and "Phaedo"
(a portrayal of Socrates last hours and death)
- Plato brilliantly portrays the life, character and
doctrines of Socrates, his teacher, at whose feet he
learnt philosophy during the most impressionable years of
his life (407-399 B.C.)
In 399 B.C., Socrates
was indicted on two counts - corrupting the youth and
neglecting the gods whom the entire city worshipped. He
was accused of practising religious novelties such as
creating other divinities of his own. Socrates treated
these charges with utmost contempt and took up a strong
defence justifying his teachings. After the prosecutors
had presented the case, Socrates rose to reply and his
speeches and those of his friends are a part of
Apology. Despite the impressive and eloquent plea,
the jurors found Socrates guilty, though by a close vote,
and death was decreed.
With the end of the
trial, Socrates addressed some last words to those who
had condemned him, rebuking them and warning that
strident notes of moral dissent and criticism could not
be silenced merely by putting men to death.
He told his friends:
"No harm can befalled a good man in life or in
death. Death is either an eternal and dreamless sleep or
a journey to another better world. In either case, it is
not an evil but a good. Also - whether life or death is
better, is best known only to God. O Athenians, you can
believe Anytus or not, you may acquit or not, but I shall
not alter my conduct, no, not if I have to die a score of
deaths. You can assure yourselves of this that, being
what Isay, if you put me to death, you will not be doing
greater injury to me than to yourselves. The hour of
departure has arrived, and we go our ways I to
die, and you to live. Which is better God only
knows".
The prosecution had
asked for the penalty of death and now it was up to the
accused to make a counter-proposition. Though a smaller
but substantial penalty would have been accepted.
Socrates took a strong stand that incensed the court. The
self-invited and certainly not accidential death sentence
was voted by a majority and he felt well contented.
The execution was
delayed for 30 days, during the Delian festival, but
Socrates refused to avail himself of the plans made for
his escape. He drank with alacrity hemlock; a deadly
poison, in the spring of 399 B.C. While doing so, he
continued his discourse on philosophy while friends stood
around him and wept.
According to James K.
Feibleman, after the death of Socrates, Athenians felt
such remorse that they closed their schools temporarily,
put Miletus to death and banished the other accusers.
Then they honoured Socrates with a bronze statue. This,
of course, did not bring him back to life, but it did
much to widely spread his teachings, the task which was
left to his pupils.
Socrates courted the
death sentence contemptuously, declining the alternative
of exile, thereby becoming an ideal of unparalleled
attraction to the Greek youth. Before and at the time of
his death, he displayed a remarkable presence of mind,
coolness, bravery and an exemplary power of endurance.
In the opinion of the
nineteenth century Danish religious philosopher Soren
Kierkegaard, a precursor of existentialism,
Socrates execution was the inevitable requital for
his life, the most interesting incident on earth. The
more genuine a mans life is the greater miseries
and pains he has to endure.
Socrates, according to
Jaspers, solicited his own death, his execution was not a
juridical murder but a juridical suicide.
Gustav Kafka described
the condemnation of Socrates as a blameworthy act of
"reactionary democracy". Living Socrates was
less inconvenient and formidable for his contemporaries
than the dead one. This unpleasant truth dawned upon his
political rivals only after his dramatic and spectacular
death which was the inevitable result of his loyalty to
his mission. Death came to Socrates as a gift, as a
favour, and not as a punishment, immortalising him for
all times to come.
The dialogue contained
in Crito takes place sometime between the trial
and the death of Socrates. He is visited in his cell by
his old friend Crito who implores him to escape and save
himself. Socrates rejects the proposal, as he argues that
he would be reversing the conduct of his past life and
mocking his statement at the trial that he would prefer
death to exile.
Although Socrates was a
non-conformist and a critic of the state, he recognised
the authority of law as well as of his own conscience.
According to him, to suffer a wrong is an evil but to
inflict one is much worse.
The third work; Phaedo,
records the last hours of Socrates in prison before his
execution. When talks regarding death and the
relationship between the soul and body continued a little
too long, the attendant who was to administer poison
informed Socrates that the discussion was to be avoided
as it would increase heat and, thus, interfere with the
effect of poison.
The attendant apparently
wanted to avoid administering a second or even a third
dose. Socrates asked him to mind his own business and be
prepared to give the poison twice or even three times, if
necessary.
The final preparations
started with a bath. In order to save the women the
trouble of washing his corpose, Socrates took a bath and
later held a meeting with Xanthipee, his wife, children
and friends to give them the last gems of his wisdom.
Now the hour of sunset
was near and the jailer entered and told Socrates to
drink the poison.
He, however, pleaded:
"I am sure that you will not be angry with me; for
others, as you are aware, and not I, are to blame."
Then bursting into tears, he turned away and went out.
Socrates thanked him for
his good wishes and complimented him for his services in
the jail. When the cup of hemlock was brought, Socrates
asked the jailer that since he was experienced in matters
of execution, therefore,could he tell him how to conduct
himself.
The jailer told Socrates
that he had only to walk about until his legs were heavy
and then to lie down and the poison would act.
He then handed over the
cup of hemlock to Socrates, who in the easiest and
gentlest manner with the least fear of death drank the
cup.
Socrates friends
wept, but the great man retained his calm and protested
why there was all that hue and cry? He told his friends
that he had sent away the women mainly to ensure that
their laments would not come in the way of his dying in
peace.
Socrates continued to
walk until his legs began to fail and then he lay on his
back according to the instructions of his executor. The
man who gave him the poison looked at his feet every now
and then and after a while he pressed his foot hard and
asked him if he could feel the pressure. Socrates
answered "No".
The jailer then informed
him that when the poison reached the heart, that would be
the end.
Socrates was beginning
to grow cold. He uncovered his face and spoke his last
words:"Crito, I owe a cock to Asciepius; will you
remember to pay the debt?"
"The debt shall be
paid", replied Crito," Is there anything
else?"
There was no answer to
that question. Such was the end of Socrates about whom
his friend, Phaedo, truely observed: "He was the
wisest, justest and best."
One is yet to find a
better compliment than the one given by Socrates
most devoted and learned disciple, Plato: "Thanks
God I was born a Greek, not a barbarian, a free man, not
a slave, a man, not a woman, and above all, I was born in
the age of Socrates."
|