SPECIAL COVERAGE
CHANDIGARH

LUDHIANA

DELHI



THE TRIBUNE SPECIALS
50 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE

TERCENTENARY CELEBRATIONS
image
N A T I O N

Tagore remembered
Functions marks 150th birth anniversary of Nobel laureate
Kolkata, May 9
Photographs of Rabindranath Tagore on display at a stall during his 150th birth anniversary celebrations in Kolkata on Sunday. A large number of functions in Kolkata and other places in the state marked Gurudev Rabindranath’s 150th birthday anniversary here today. Functions were also organised at Shilaidhah (Rajshahi) and Dhaka.

Photographs of Rabindranath Tagore on display at a stall during his 150th birth anniversary celebrations in Kolkata on Sunday. — PTI

Naxal-hit areas to get more schools
New Delhi, May 9
To improve educational facilities in 35 Naxal-affected districts, the government has prepared a multi-pronged strategy that includes setting up of secondary schools, girls’ hostels and reconstruction of buildings damaged by extremists.

 

EARLIER STORIES

Phone intercepts hint at IM role in Pune blast
Mumbai, May 9
A telephonic conversation between two suspected members of the Indian Mujahideen (IM) gave security agencies a clue about the terror group's alleged involvement in the Pune blast, the police said here today.

‘Honour killing’ victim walks in alive
Lucknow, May 9
With the sudden appearance of the “murdered” boy Ajit along with his girlfriend Anshu at Muzaffarnagar’s Nai Mandi police station today, the Uttar Pradesh Police claim of the honour killing by the girls’ family stands exposed.

Jairam Ramesh gets carried away by Copenhagen spirit
New Delhi, May 9
Jairam Ramesh Even as Indian security agencies are constantly gearing up to “deal” with Chinese aggression and “strategic” moves, Union Minister Jairam Ramesh’s statement yesterday calling Indian security establishment as “alarmist and paranoid” about China, is all set to stir the proverbial hornet’s nest.
                                                                        
  Jairam Ramesh

Army to outsource training of officers
Chandigarh, May 9
In a perceptible shift in its ideology and approach to modern-day requirements, the Army is experimenting with the concept of outsourcing the training and orientation programme of officers posted to some branches to private firms.

Maya to rescue of students
Lucknow, May 9
Chief Minister Mayawati came to the rescue of schoolchildren when she cancelled the Lucknow district magistrate’s order disallowing students in school uniform in public places during school hours.

Rift widens between BPCC chief, Tytler
Patna, May 9
All is not well in the Bihar Pradesh Congress Committee (BPCC). The ongoing cold war between BPCC president Anil Sharma and AICC leader and in-charge of Bihar affairs, Jagdish Tytler has now turned into an open rift between the two top leaders of the party.

Our MPs are paid a pittance
There is a strong case for raising the perks and perquisites of our MPs and little justification for their salary to be pegged at one-sixth of what a Secretary to the Government of India receives, writes FARAZ AHMED. The last time our MPs gave themselves a raise in salary was in 2004
While a coy government decided last week to defer a decision to increase the salaries and perks of MPs, the latter are becoming increasingly vocal in demanding a raise, admitting that they make compromises and “arrange” money from somewhere, anywhere, to survive in politics and do their job. The disappointment among the 790 MPs on Friday was, therefore, palpable.

A child artiste performing during a reality dance show on Zee Telugu television channel. Rights bodies seek ban on ‘lewd’ kids’ dance show
Hyderabad, May 9
For several weeks now, viewers of a prime-time reality dance show on a local popular television channel are being “bombarded” with images of scantily-clad tiny tots gyrating to raunchy film songs. ‘Aata (Dance)’, a controversial children’s talent hunt programme, has evoked widespread public outrage for “promoting obscenity”.

A child artiste performing during a reality dance show on Zee Telugu television channel. A Tribune photograph

Jantar Mantar
The rat connection
RJD chief Lalu Prasad Yadav may have lost power but he has certainly not lost his sense of humour. He was quick off the mark when his attention was recently drawn to reports that his one-time-friend and now arch political rival, Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar, had been bitten by a rat. 

Scorned women seek justice in Karnataka
Bangalore, May 9
It is all about timing.Two scorned women in Karnataka have turned the heat against their estranged husbands when it will matter most.Had Sumitra, a middle aged woman living in a village in Shimoga district of Karnataka, bared her heart to the media 14 years back when her husband Venkatesh Murthy deserted her, the story, even if it had appeared in the papers, would have made little impact.

SLAP ON FACE OF TERROR

The exercise of forwarding case papers and judgment of 26/11 special court to the Bombay High Court for confirmation of death penalty imposed on terrorist Ajmal Kasab would take at least three months. The 1522-page judgment, proceedings of the yearlong trial, evidence tendered by witnesses and their statements on affidavits as well as the original copies of exhibits and documents tabled by prosecution would be sent to the High Court, said special public prosecutor Ujjwal Nikam on Sunday.
KASAB CASE TO REACH HC AFTER 3 MONTHS: The exercise of forwarding case papers and judgment of 26/11 special court to the Bombay High Court for confirmation of death penalty imposed on terrorist Ajmal Kasab would take at least three months. The 1522-page judgment, proceedings of the yearlong trial, evidence tendered by witnesses and their statements on affidavits as well as the original copies of exhibits and documents tabled by prosecution would be sent to the High Court, said special public prosecutor Ujjwal Nikam on Sunday. — PTI

Pathak’s mother gets parole
Koderma (Jharkhand), May 9
The mother of scribe Nirupama Pathak, who was arrested last week in connection with the alleged honour killing of her daughter, was today released on parole for three days to attend the post-death rituals.

Halappa arrested
Bangalore, May 9
Faced with allegations about soft-pedalling to the issue of rape charge made against former Karnataka Food and Civil Supplies Minister Hartal Halappa, the state police today arrested him. 

India not a nice place for mothers: Report
New Delhi, May 9
At a time when the world celebrates Mother's Day, it turns out that India scores poorly among the middle-income countries when it comes to health care and well-being of mothers.

BJP backs ban on Muivah's Manipur visit
Guwahati, May 9
The BJP supported the ban imposed by the Okram Ibobi Singh government in Manipur on NSCN (IM) general secretary Thuingaleng Muivah’s visit to his birthplace at Somdal village in the state.

MP Jindal backs khaps
Chandigarh, May 9
Notorious for their diktats prohibiting same ‘gotra’ (clan) marriages, the khap panchayats (caste councils) of Haryana have got support from Congress MP from Kurukshetra Navin Jindal who has praised them for rendering yeoman service to the society.

Muivah firm to visit Manipur
Kohima, May 9
The NSCN (I-M) today condemned the Manipur government’s decision to debar the entry of its general secretary Thuigaleng Muivah into the state and said he would certainly complete his journey.

 





Top








 

Tagore remembered
Functions marks 150th birth anniversary of Nobel laureate
Subhrangshu Gupta
Tribune News Service

Kolkata, May 9
A large number of functions in Kolkata and other places in the state marked Gurudev Rabindranath’s 150th birthday anniversary here today. Functions were also organised at Shilaidhah (Rajshahi) and Dhaka.

The main function was held at the poet’s birthplace at Jorasanko’s Thakurbari and the adjoining Rabindra Bharati University, where students, teachers and several Tagore-admirers took part in the singing of Tagore song (Rabindra Sangit), reciting of his poems and participating in dance and drama composed by him. Special seminars were also organised on Tagore’s writings and paintings and his other literary activities in which several eminent Tagore scholars participated.

On the occasion of his birthday, the heritage building of the Tagore’s birthday place was kept open for the people for paying respects to the Nobel laureate.

At Santiniketan also, where Tagore built Visva Bharati in 1921 with his Nobel Prize money, his birthday anniversary was observed in a befitting manner although a section of teachers and employees organised a separate function boycotting the main function in protest against the alleged “malfunctioning” of the university administration.

In Kolkata, the state government organised the day-long function at Rabindra Sadan, Nandan Academy and several other state-own auditoriums where several eminent artistes participated in Rabindra Sangit, recitation of his poetry, dance and drama. Several exhibitions were also organised on Tagore’s writings, arts and culture. The Congress, the Trinamool Congress and the CPM tried to utilise the name of Rabindranath in their respective ways in the civic poll campaigns.

Railway Minister Mamata Banerjee flagged off a special exhibition train from the Howrah station depicting Rabindranath’s literary activities, works and arts. The five-coach exhibition train, named Sansriti Yatra, will run throughout the year and halt at all major stations with a view to taking Rabindranath to every nook and corner of the country.

The Railway Minister said in August-September, a Rabindranath special train would run between Kolkata and Dhaka in observance of the poet’s 150th birth anniversary.

Top

 

Naxal-hit areas to get more schools

New Delhi, May 9
To improve educational facilities in 35 Naxal-affected districts, the government has prepared a multi-pronged strategy that includes setting up of secondary schools, girls’ hostels and reconstruction of buildings damaged by extremists.

The HRD Ministry has accorded top priority to these districts under the new schemes like the Rashtriya Madhyamik Shiksha Abhiyan (RMSA), Model Schools and the Girls' Hostel Programme.

Under the RMSA, which aims at universalising secondary education in the country by 2020, as many as 384 schools have been approved for the Naxal-affected districts in 2009-10.

Similarly, under the Model School Programme, 32 schools out of 327 sanctioned in 2009-10 are located in these districts. Another 21 model schools are also proposed to be set up in the seven Naxal-affected districts of Chhattisgarh. Fortyfour girls' hostels have been sanctioned for these districts. — PTI

Top

 

Phone intercepts hint at IM role in Pune blast

Mumbai, May 9
A telephonic conversation between two suspected members of the Indian Mujahideen (IM) gave security agencies a clue about the terror group's alleged involvement in the Pune blast, the police said here today.

Days after the German Bakery blast on February 13, in which 17 people were killed and over 50 injured, alleged IM operative Salman Ansari's telephonic intercepts suggested that he had received a phone call from someone, believed to be Riyaz Bhatkal, from abroad congratulating him for the blast, sources added. Uttar Pradesh ATS had arrested Salman alias Chhotu from near the Nepal border in UP in the last week of February and he is currently in the Delhi Police's custody.

"The conversation has given us an important clue to believe that it was a handiwork of IM members. Hence, the probe was initiated in that direction," an ATS official said, refusing to divulge contents of the conversation.

During the probe, in April first week, Maharashtra ATS had come to a conclusion that Yasin Bhatkal, believed to be a relative of IM founder Riyaz Bhatkal, is one of the main conspirators of the blast.

Salman received training in sophisticated firearms and timer devices at a terrorist camp near Lahore during his stay in Pakistan, the police said. — PTI

Top

 

‘Honour killing’ victim walks in alive
Shahira Naim
Tribune News Service

Lucknow, May 9
With the sudden appearance of the “murdered” boy Ajit along with his girlfriend Anshu at Muzaffarnagar’s Nai Mandi police station today, the Uttar Pradesh Police claim of the honour killing by the girls’ family stands exposed.

Angry members of the girl’s family have gheraoed the police station holding the police responsible for extracting a false confessional statement from the girl’s brother Anuj Tomar on the basis of which he was arrested on charges of Ajit’s murder yesterday.

Trying to wriggle out of an embarrassing situation, ADG (law and order) Brij Lal defended the police by claiming that it was not at fault.

“The missing boy Ajit Saini’s family had identified the decomposed body as that of their son by the clothes. On the basis of a written complaint, the girl’s family was interrogated and her brother had confessed to the killing, he said.”

“However, as the body was highly decomposed, I had directed the police to do the DNA test,” Brij Lal said.

Promptly wrapping up the case, the police yesterday had managed a confessional statement from Anuj Tomar, who admitted to have killed Saini to save the family’s honour. “Try to be in my shoes, you would have done the same”, he told the police.

Hinting at third degree methods through which the police manage statements, a cousin of Anuj Tomar told a local channel that the UP Police could even manage a statement out of a dumb person. Meanwhile, Anuj has now retracted his statement.

Interestingly, Brij Lal had told the media yesterday that on the tip off of the incarcerated brother, a body had been recovered from the Burhana area that in all likelihood was of his sister.

He had even admitted that the girl’s father Narendra Tomar had consumed poison after knowing that Anuj had been arrested. He would be interrogated once he recovered.

Top

 

Jairam Ramesh gets carried away by Copenhagen spirit
Ajay Banerjee
Tribune News Service

New Delhi, May 9
Even as Indian security agencies are constantly gearing up to “deal” with Chinese aggression and “strategic” moves, Union Minister Jairam Ramesh’s statement yesterday calling Indian security establishment as “alarmist and paranoid” about China, is all set to stir the proverbial hornet’s nest.

For the Congress this is the second major faux pas within two weeks. The duo of Digvijay Singh and Mani Shanker Aiyer had publically questioned the home ministry’s anti-naxal policy. Ramesh, has exposed the lack of unanimity in the Indian ruling combine on dealings with China, said a senior party man.

The outspoken Ramesh, it seems, has treaded onto the toes of the Home Ministry, Defence Ministry and also the External Affairs ministry - all in one go. The Congress is clearly on the back foot and too stunned to react. Party spokesperson Manish Tewari said “since the minister (Jairam Ramesh) is traveling, it would be inappropriate to comment at this moment”.

Sources in the party said this was policy matter involving security and foreign policy. Just three weeks ago the Prime Minister had made it clear that only the Home Ministry should speak on matters of internal security.

Minister of State for Environment and Forests Jairam Ramesh, who is in Beijing to attend an international conference on climate change, was quoted in newspapers as having said that he had faced some opposition from a “suspicious” security and defence establishment in India on taking forward climate co-operation with China.

Ramesh warned how the , “overly defensive” policies of the Home Ministry towards Chinese companies like telecommunications giant Huawei, recently under the scanner and facing an import ban for security reasons, could “dissipate” the “Copenhagen spirit.” The news report went on to quote Ramesh as having said that there was a large security establishment which is uncomfortable with the Copenhagen spirit.

Sources in the security establishment said there were doubts over the ownership of the Chinese telecom giant Huawei, and it is closely linked to the Chinese People’s Liberation Army. The links created hurdles for Huawei in 2008 when it wanted to acquire a stake in US telecom giant 3Com and also Canadian telecom company Nortel. Also with hackers based in China being very active, it is suspected that the Chinese equipment carries an embedded software that enables hacking. The suspicion stems from the fact that a former officer of the Chinese Army, Ren Zhengfei, owns Huawei - a company that was funded by the Chinese Government in its formative years.

Top

 

Army to outsource training of officers
Vijay Mohan
Tribune News Service

Chandigarh, May 9
In a perceptible shift in its ideology and approach to modern-day requirements, the Army is experimenting with the concept of outsourcing the training and orientation programme of officers posted to some branches to private firms.

While the job of training is being offered to ‘reputed firms having a national or international footprint’ to take up such tasks on a turn-key basis, the training programmes would be handled by senior retired officers on their rolls.

Officers posted to some branches in higher headquarters are required to undergo capsule courses to familiarise them with the functioning of the branch. For example, the Master General of Ordnance’s Branch at Army Headquarters, which has initiated this project, conducts a three-day training course for all officers posted to it.

At present, such matters are dealt in-house by the services, with serving officers being deputed for the same. Outsourcing training with senior retired officers at the helm of affairs would, according to the Army’s thinking, ensure availability of skilled advice and conserve military resources and manpower.

The training programme would be designed and approved by the branch concerned and the firms concerned would be required to form a panel of retired officers expert in the required areas for conduct of training. Officers would be of the rank of colonel or brigadier and it would be mandatory for them to have had an instructional tenure at specified military colleges or training establishments as well as a staff posting at the branch concerned during their service career.

Not surprisingly, the move to outsource training and the expected participation of international firms has raised security concerns in some quarters. Screening of firms and personnel associated with training as well as assuring security of information would be mandatory.

Top

 

Maya to rescue of students

Lucknow, May 9
Chief Minister Mayawati came to the rescue of schoolchildren when she cancelled the Lucknow district magistrate’s order disallowing students in school uniform in public places during school hours.

Calling the order “wrong and impractical”, the CM annulled it with immediate effect. Lucknow District Magistrate Anil Kumar Sagar had banned the entry of students in uniforms into malls, theatres, restaurants and parks during school hours to reportedly check crime. — TNS

Top

 

Rift widens between BPCC chief, Tytler
Sanjay Singh
Tribune News Service

Patna, May 9
All is not well in the Bihar Pradesh Congress Committee (BPCC). The ongoing cold war between BPCC president Anil Sharma and AICC leader and in-charge of Bihar affairs, Jagdish Tytler has now turned into an open rift between the two top leaders of the party.

With both Sharma and Tytler trying to undermine each other’s authority and overruling the decisions taken by one another, it has become difficult for the other officer bearers of the BPCC and party leaders to comply with their respective decisions. While the Sharma camp has been charged with disobeying the decisions taken by the members of the coordination committee (constituted by Tytler) to hold a meeting of district and block presidents on April 28 by not only abstaining from the meeting but also issuing press release to all newspapers regarding cancellation of the said meeting, the BPCC Chief feigned ignorance about the April 28 meeting.

Despite all this, the Tytler loyalists held their meeting as scheduled on April 28. The BPCC president and his followers were conspicuous by their absence in that meeting. Now that the Sharma lobby convened a similar meeting of district and block chiefs of the party, it was the turn of Tytler camp to abstain from this meeting. To make the matters worse, three office bearers of the BPCC -Ashok Chaudhary (vice-president), Kaukab Qadri (general secretary) and HK Verma (spokesman) have been issued a show cause notice by the AICC secretary Sagar Raika regarding cancellation /rescheduling of the April 28 meeting. On the other hand the Sharma loyalists have charged Tytler with encouraging indiscipline in the Bihar Congress by promoting the turncoats like Sadhu Yadav (Lalu’s brother in law) and Pappu Yadav. If corrective steps were not taken on time, these elements who had joined the party on being denied tickets from the Lalu led RJD on the eve of Lok Sabha would promote the RJD culture in the Congress, said a Sharma loyalist and vice-president of the BPCC.

With both sides accusing each other of going against the protocol and encouraging indiscipline, it seems that the AICC leadership will have to intervene and replace either Sharma or Tytler in the affairs of Bihar lest the party’s bickerings would cost it dearly in the forthcoming Assembly elections due in October-November this year. 

Top

 

Our MPs are paid a pittance
There is a strong case for raising the perks and perquisites of our MPs and little justification for their salary to be pegged at one-sixth of what a Secretary to the Government of India receives, writes FARAZ AHMED. The last time our MPs gave themselves a raise in salary was in 2004

While a coy government decided last week to defer a decision to increase the salaries and perks of MPs, the latter are becoming increasingly vocal in demanding a raise, admitting that they make compromises and “arrange” money from somewhere, anywhere, to survive in politics and do their job. The disappointment among the 790 MPs on Friday was, therefore, palpable.

The joint committee of both Houses of Parliament on salaries and allowances of MPs, chaired by Lok Sabha member Mahant Charan Das, had submitted its report to Speaker Meira Kumar only a few days ago. BJP’s SS Ahluwalia, who heads the five-member Rajya Sabha contingent in this panel, handed over the other copy to Rajya Sabha Chairman Hamid Ansari. There are 15 members on this panel, formed specially to deliberate on the salaries and allowances awarded to the MPs. Union Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee, who is to decide on the matter, sought more time to study the recommendations before making a commitment. The Minister, too, might have felt a bit uncomfortable with the MPs’ proposal to give themselves a five-fold hike in their salary at one go. At present an MP draws a salary of Rs 16,000 only and the committee has recommended that this be hiked straight away to Rs 80,000.

Along with the salary, the MP gets Rs 20,000 as constituency allowance. Another Rs 14,000 is paid to him for maintaining two secretarial staff members, one in his constituency and the other here in Delhi. In addition Rs 4,000 per month is given to him for buying stationery and Rs 2,000 for faxing, postal services and such other sundry needs. So at the end of the day he takes home Rs 56,000. “Whether we maintain two or 20 people in our staff or whether we go once or every other day to our constituency is no concern of Parliament,” commented an MP wryly.

“In the USA, a member of the House of Representatives is paid to maintain a staff of 25 personnel. A member of the Senate is given the allowance to maintain a staff of 75 persons. That is why they can concentrate on research and study. Here, an MP leads the life of a beggar. That is why they don’t work. You can’t expect them to work when they are paid pittance of a paltry sum for doing all the work,” remarked senior BJP MP Yashwant Sinha.

Another JD-U MP, reluctant to be identified for fear of his supporters getting alienated, bemoaned what he had to go through to maintain his contact and popularity in his constituency. He said, “It costs at least Rs 2,000 a day for hiring a car to go to our constituency. So that means we cannot go to our constituency for more than 10 days. But more than that we have to maintain a virtual guest house in our houses for people from our constituencies. We feed them, aid them in getting medical or any other aid they want and often they tell us they have no money to buy a ticket back home, so we have to buy them a rail ticket back home too.

“Rice costs at least Rs 25 a kg and you should come to our kitchens to see how much rice is cooked in our homes every day, whether we are here or back home. How do we meet all these expenses?”

Besides, there is also the issue of protocol and an MP who is naturally on a higher pedestal in respect of the protocol feels even worse after the Sixth Pay Commission, where the salary of the secretary of Government of India has gone up to Rs 80,000. The committee has, therefore, asked for at least a rupee more than the secretary’s salary.

But there are some like the Left MPs and even some others who are not happy with this business. For one they point out that the last increase came only six years ago in 2004 and so it is too early to ask for another raise. Besides, as CPM politburo member Sitaram Yechury said on record, “We don’t like MPs giving themselves a hike.” He instead felt that there should be some other body which should deliberate on this issue and decide. “That is why we sent no members from our parties in this committee.”

There are still others, again not willing to be quoted, who mentioned even other reasons opposing the proposal. A Congress MP from Punjab said, “Instead of getting a salary hike what we need more is the support system for doing our work, more secretarial staff, an office building could be built to house the MPs’ offices and all the necessary paraphernalia should be maintained by the state.

But some others from the Left feel, “It’s not just a question of propriety of giving ourselves a hike. We should not compare with a secretary’s salary. We are here to serve the people and so why should we hanker after salaries. We should be able to make some sacrifices.

He, however, admitted that there is a difference between a Left MP or MLA and others. On the one hand, a Left MP has to hand over the larger portion of his salary to the party. And over the years parties like the CPM have had it so good also because of sending so many MPs to Parliament and MLAs to assemblies. On the other, as for constituency expenses or entertaining visitors from constituencies are concerned, this too is largely taken care of by the party at its headquarters.

But then the counter argument came remarkably from a senior bureaucrat. “The secretary,” he pointed out, “gets Rs 80,000 salary, plus DA, plus HRA plus transport allowance and a whole lot of perks, which do not go to a MP. And for all that the secretary draws from the Government of India, he is largely not accountable to anyone. In fact, hardly anyone can enter the hallowed precincts of his room. On the other hand, the MP has to entertain at least a few hundreds every day, offering them at least a cup of tea, if not food to all, and then getting their work done. So, an MP deserves much more than a secretary and not just one rupee,” he felt.

Who’ll fix the salaries and allowances of MPs
Fixing the salaries and perks of legislators has been a thorny issue not only in India but abroad as well. Seeing the pattern abroad, it would perhaps not be a bad idea in India to appoint a high-level independent commission to consider changes in the salaries and facilities of MPs. Ashok Tuteja draws a comparison between the existing system in some affluent nations

France

The salaries of MPs are calculated in relation to the salaries of the highest paid employee of the civil service and the amount is reviewed regularly and automatically as the civil service remuneration is revised.

Japan

In Diet (Parliament), members are paid no less than maximum salary of a regular govt official. They also get government subsidy to employ two secretaries and receive financial aid for correspondence.

Canada

A special Act provides that Parliament would appoint a panel to review compensation to parliamentarians after every general election. The panel recommendations are reviewed through an enabling bill in Parliament.

S. Africa

An independent commission makes recommendations on salaries and allowances of law-makers. Parliament can pass legislation only after considering the recommendations of the commission.

Germany

Members of Bundestag (Parliament) get remuneration adequate to ensure their independence. Their salary is taxable but the members receive tax-free monthly salary to cover expenses like accommodation, travel, etc.

Pakistan

The hefty salaries enjoyed by Members have been an issue for long despite country's poor record in nurturing democratic forces. Many feel that the MNAs don't deserve to be paid hefty salaries.

Top

 

Rights bodies seek ban on ‘lewd’ kids’ dance show
Suresh Dharur
Tribune News Service

Hyderabad, May 9
For several weeks now, viewers of a prime-time reality dance show on a local popular television channel are being “bombarded” with images of scantily-clad tiny tots gyrating to raunchy film songs. ‘Aata (Dance)’, a controversial children’s talent hunt programme, has evoked widespread public outrage for “promoting obscenity”.

Such was the sense of revulsion against the show that several social organisations, women and child right groups approached the State Human Rights Commission seeking a ban on it for violating child rights.

“This reality show has crossed all limits of decency and is a clear violation of child rights. Such programmes are the result of the greed of TRP-hungry channels,” said PA Devi, a social worker, who filed a petition with the AP State Human Rights Commission (APSHRC), along with other organisations, including the Progressive Organisation for Women (POW) and the MV Foundation.

The provocative dances and lewd gestures by the child participants would leave a deep negative impact on viewers, particularly those of the impressionable age, the activists argued.

However, the organisers of the show claimed that it was meant to spot and nurture dancing skills among children in the age group of 6 to 14 years. “It is the most popular children’s reality dance show and will test their performances in both Indian and Western dance forms. The participants, selected from all over the state, are divided into three groups, each named after a region of the state,” the producers of the show claimed on their website.

After going through the complaints from several NGOs and watching a CD of the show, State Human Rights Commission chairman Justice Subhashan Reddy said he was “disturbed” over the way children were being portrayed in the programme. Agreeing with the petitioners’ contention, Justice Reddy found fault with the parents for encouraging their wards to participate in such reality shows. “It is the responsibility of the parents to protect their children,” he said.

The chairman warned the show’s producers that the programme would be taken off air if necessary changes in its format were not carried out.

The children participating in the show were made to practice for 14 hours a day and were being subjected to physical and mental abuse, POW leader P Sandhya alleged.

The organisers are also flouting the Supreme Court’s directive that children below 8 years should not participate in reality shows.

“We want the Commission to issue suitable guidelines to the government to evolve rules for monitoring the content and production processes of children’s participation in TV shows,” said K Venkat Reddy, national coordinator of the MV Foundation.

“These shows totally demean children’s dignity and freedom. Further, they put tremendous pressure on children participating and competing in front of a studio audience and millions of television viewers at home. They face elimination rounds and the judges’ harsh and adverse comments are harmful for their tender minds. The negative psychological impact of such shows on children is tremendous,” said student counsellor PS Sharada.

On their part, the parents of the participants in the show defended its format saying that everything on the show was a matter of personal choice. They said they were simply encouraging their children’s interest of participating in the competition.

The MV Foundation urged the State Human Rights Commission to set up an independent mechanism to monitor the content and production processes of children’s participation in TV shows. “Until then, all such reality involving children should be withdrawn,” it demanded. 

Top

 

Jantar Mantar
The rat connection
Anita Katyal 

RJD chief Lalu Prasad Yadav may have lost power but he has certainly not lost his sense of humour. He was quick off the mark when his attention was recently drawn to reports that his one-time-friend and now arch political rival, Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar, had been bitten by a rat. 

 Lalu's reply: "This is a clear indication that even Lord Ganesha is unhappy with Nitish Kumar's administration ....this was his way of conveying his disillusionment."

 Lalu Prasad Yadav And for those who were perplexed with this answer, the former Bihar Chief Minister promptly offered a brief lesson in mythology. "You know, a rat serves as Lord Ganesha's mount (vahan)." He then went on to persuade mediapersons to publish this story in their newspapers , adding that in his inimitable style. "I know you will not believe me but you can always check with Lord Ganesha."

Close to their heart

J.JayalalithaaAIADMK members never shy away from declaring their undying loyalty to their undisputed party leader J.Jayalalithaa. Since getting an audience with her is a rare honour, it is not unusual to find party cadres carry her photograph on their person to feel constantly reassured that they are not too far from her. For instance V.Maitreyan, AIADMK leader in the Rajya Sabha, always carries Jayalalithaa's picture in the breast pocket of his shirt. He also makes sure that the picture is face-up so that it can be easily recognised through the sheer fabric. He, however, denies that it is mandatory for all AIADMK members to carry their leader's photo. "I am doing it of my own volition...I want to make sure that she is always near me," he says, adding that for good measure that he carried the picture even when he went to the UN. Talk about sycophancy scaling new heights.

Smoke signs

When former Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister and high-profile AICC general secretary Digvijay Singh wrote a column in a leading economic daily taking on the all-powerful Home Minister P. Chidambaram for his handling of the Maoist problem and even accused him of "intellectual arrogance", it was assumed that it was written with the concurrence of Congress president Sonia Gandhi. As general secretary in charge of Uttar Pradesh, Digvijay Singh is perceived to be close to the party president and Rahul Gandhi since he interacts with the Nehru-Gandhi scion on a regular basis on UP affairs. It was, therefore, quite surprising when Digvijay Singh was made to wait for over a week before he could get an appointment with Sonia Gandhi. But it was only after he publicly regretted having written the column that he was granted an audience with the Congress president.

Congress helpline

Jagdambika Pal, who is better remembered as a one-day Chief Minister of Uttar Pradesh, has acquired the reputation of being an energetic speaker who grabs every opportunity to jump to the rescue of any Congress member being targeted by the opposition in the Lok Sabha. The story of the unputdownable Pal has become something of a private joke among his colleagues from his home state. They never tire of advising other Lok Sabha members that next time they are in trouble, all they have to do is do dial " 000", now christened as the Pal helpline. Last see and heard, Pal was undeterred as he continued to wage battle for his fellow party members.

Top

 

Scorned women seek justice in Karnataka
Shubhadeep Choudhury
Tribune News Service

Bangalore, May 9
It is all about timing.Two scorned women in Karnataka have turned the heat against their estranged husbands when it will matter most.Had Sumitra, a middle aged woman living in a village in Shimoga district of Karnataka, bared her heart to the media 14 years back when her husband Venkatesh Murthy deserted her, the story, even if it had appeared in the papers, would have made little impact.

However, it is quite different now. Murthy, a businessman, has come under the spotlight after he and his wife Chandravati accused Karnataka minister Hartal Halappa of raping the latter. Sumitra, whom Murthy deserted after having two children with her, to marry Chandravati, has assured that her estranged husband also gets his share of bad publicity, now that he has become a well-known character as a result of the scandal involving the minister.

Halappa, who has resigned from the cabinet in the wake of the scandal, has gone into hiding fearing arrest and has applied for anticipatory bail. The Shimoga police has been widely accused of not making any serious effort to nab the former minister. However, the same police has already interviewed the scorned Sumitra. The first wife, who has not been formally divorced by Murthy, has also filed a complaint with the police against her estranged husband and the latter may soon find him behind the bars and his marriage with Chandravati, who according to Sumitra was his younger brother’s sweetheart, declared invalid.

While the case of Sumitra has helped the government to discredit the complainant against one of its ministers, it has own share of problem too, coming from another scorned woman.

Vijayalakshmi, a resident of Tumkur district, has complained to the State Human Rights Commission that BJ Puttaswamy, political secretary of Chief Minister BS Yeddyurappa, cheated her after marrying her in 1980s.

Vijayalakshmi, 55, in her petition to the commission, said Puttaswamy married her at a temple. She was not told that Puttaswamy was already married by then. She lived with him for few years in Mysore and then returned to her village. For a couple of years Puttaswamy paid her maintenance and then stopped it.

Top

 

Pathak’s mother gets parole

Koderma (Jharkhand), May 9
The mother of scribe Nirupama Pathak, who was arrested last week in connection with the alleged honour killing of her daughter, was today released on parole for three days to attend the post-death rituals.

Koderma Jail Superintendent Martin Ranjan said Subha Pathak was allowed to go to her Jhumritilaya home to attend the last rites of her daughter following a local court's permission. — PTI

Top

 

Halappa arrested

Bangalore, May 9
Faced with allegations about soft-pedalling to the issue of rape charge made against former Karnataka Food and Civil Supplies Minister Hartal Halappa, the state police today arrested him. 

Halappa, who has been accused of raping his friend’s wife, was arrested after he appeared before the CID today at Shimoga following a notice served by the investigative agency on May 6. He was held following questioning that went on for about three hours. 

CID DIG Charan Reddy said Halappa would be kept at the Shimoga prison today and produced before the court tomorrow. He denied the allegation during interrogation by the CID.

The CID, which has been assigned the case by the state, had pasted a notice at Halappa’s residences in Shimoga and Bangalore, asking him to appear before it tomorrow.

Halappa had filed a plea for anticipatory bail in a Shimoga court on May 6. The case was to come up for hearing on May 11. Halappa had quit his post as the minister on May 2. — TNS

Top

 

India not a nice place for mothers: Report

New Delhi, May 9
At a time when the world celebrates Mother's Day, it turns out that India scores poorly among the middle-income countries when it comes to health care and well-being of mothers.

The country is ranked 73 in the list of 77 nations rated for the “best place to be a mother”, according to a report by child rights organisation Save the Children. What is more shocking in the “State of the World's Mothers 2010” report is that India is rated much lower than a host of conflict-ridden African countries like Kenya and Congo.

Cuba tops the Mother's Index ranking followed by Israel, Argentina, Barbados, South Korea, Cyprus, Uruguay, Kazakhstan, Bahamas and Mongolia. Among the neighbours, China is at 18th place, Sri Lanka at 40, while Pakistan lags behind India at 75th place. Bangladesh, featured in the list of 40 least developed countries, is ranked 14.

The report analysed a total of 166 countries, among which Sweden is placed at the top while Afghanistan is at the bottom.

The report has highlighted the shortage of trained health workers, mostly in the semi-urban and rural villages that house majority of Indian population, as the main reason behind the country's sorry state of health care system.

Shireen Vakil Miller, Director of Advocacy, Save the Children, pointed out that though the India's flagship National Rural Health Mission (NHRM) has prioritised female health workers from the communities, there still remains an acute shortage and training requirement.

The report also placed India at number one in the list of 12 countries that account for two-thirds of under five and maternal deaths in the world. According to a latest UNICEF report, the country accounts for 1.95 million child deaths (under five years of age) every year, which translates into 5,000 deaths every day, or one in every 20 seconds -- the highest in the world. The complications related to pregnancy and childbirth also kill 67,000 women annually.

The report also emphasised the need for more investments, especially for the child and women, to further improve the health care system in the country.— PTI

DISMAL STATE

l The country ranks 73 in list of 77 nations for the “best place to be a mother”

l Conflict-ridden nations like Kenya and Congo better than India

l The report by child rights organisation Save the Children points out shortage of trained health workers, mostly in the semi-urban and rural villages

l It also places India at number one in the list of 12 countries that account for two-thirds of under five and maternal deaths in the world.

Top

 

BJP backs ban on Muivah's Manipur visit

Guwahati, May 9
The BJP supported the ban imposed by the Okram Ibobi Singh government in Manipur on NSCN (IM) general secretary Thuingaleng Muivah’s visit to his birthplace at Somdal village in the state.

“We support the Manipur government’s decision to ban the entry of Muivah into Manipur as it may spark communal tension. His speech can provoke tension,” BJP organising secretary (North-East) P Chandrashekhar Rao said here.Terming the NSCN (IM) the “main culprit” behind insurgency in the North-East, the BJP leader said, “Muivah’s main agenda is to disintegrate Manipur.” — TNS

Top

 

MP Jindal backs khaps

Chandigarh, May 9
Notorious for their diktats prohibiting same ‘gotra’ (clan) marriages, the khap panchayats (caste councils) of Haryana have got support from Congress MP from Kurukshetra Navin Jindal who has praised them for rendering yeoman service to the society.

In a letter to khap representatives, Jindal acknowledged the existence of these panchayats since the time of rulers like Ashoka and Harshvardhan and said these panchayats had always given a “new direction” to the society.

Declaring his support to them, he showered encomiums over these panchayats saying that they had been rendering yeoman service to the society by resolving people’s problems even before the present legal system came into existence.

The khap panchayats at a meeting (Mahapanchayat) held at Pai in Kaithal district on May 2 had put all elected representatives in the state on a one-month notice to support their demand for amending the Hindu Marriage Act seeking a ban on same gotra marriages. They had also threatened to gherao Jindal in Kurukshetra tomorrow, in case, he did not extend support to their demand.

Jindal said he supported their demand and regretted he could not attend the Mahapanchayat. “I and my family have always respected the society’s traditions, customs, beliefs and culture,” Jindal said in his letter, extending full support to the khaps.

Jindal’s letter to the khaps has come at a time when the INLD has already favoured the demand to amend the law and ban the marriages within the same gotra and villages.

Various caste panchayats in Haryana had launched a campaign against same gotra weddings after a Karnal court on March 30 awarded death penalty to five persons and sentenced two others, including a khap leader, to life imprisonment in connection with the murder of a couple who had married despite having a common lineage. — PTI

Top

 

Muivah firm to visit Manipur

Kohima, May 9
The NSCN (I-M) today condemned the Manipur government’s decision to debar the entry of its general secretary Thuigaleng Muivah into the state and said he would certainly complete his journey.

“We have undertaken this journey of peace...respecting the wishes of the Naga people, but it is unfortunate that the Manipur government has opposed Muivah’s visit... and we condemn the irrationality of the state government,” the NSCN (I-M) said in a statement. Muivah, camping at Viswema village near Nagaland-Manipur border since May 5, would definitely visit his native village Somdal. — PTI

Top

 





HOME PAGE | Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir | Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs | Nation | Opinions |
| Business | Sports | World | Letters | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | Delhi |
| Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | Suggestion | E-mail |