O P I N I O N S

Editorials | Article | Middle | Oped | Reflections

EDITORIALS

Bill of contention
Who bothers about the daughters’ rights?
T
HE Jammu and Kashmir ruling parties — the PDP of Chief Minister Mufti Mohammed Sayeed and the Congress — must be heaving a sigh of relief. The controversial Jammu and Kashmir Permanent Residents (Disqualification) Bill, better known as the Daughters’ Bill, has been put on the back burner with the State Legislative Council having been adjourned sine die by Speaker Adbul Rashid Dar.

TENtative relief
Cricket is also a business
H
APPILY, television viewers all over the country were able to watch Saturday’s Indo-Pakistan cricket match after the Chief Justice of India, Mr V.N. Khare, issued a directive to TEN Sports to give Doordarshan the rights to telecast live the first one-day international tie at Karachi.


EARLIER ARTICLES

THE TRIBUNE SPECIALS
50 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE

TERCENTENARY CELEBRATIONS

Mamata’s mamata
A marriage of convenience
B
IRDS of the same flock fly together. Small wonder that Union Coal and Mines Minister Mamata Banerjee and former Lok Sabha Speaker P.A. Sangma have joined hands to form the Nationalist Trinamool Congress. The new party has been created by merging her All-India Trinamool Congress and his group of the Nationalist Congress Party.

ARTICLE

Time for two-party system
Regional outfits a spoilsport
by Subhash C. Kashyap
W
E all talk of regional parties as against national parties, but under the election law and rules, there is nothing like a “regional party”. It seems necessary to have a conceptual clarification about the legal position first. The charter of fundamental rights enshrined in the Constitution of India inter alia guarantees freedom of association.

MIDDLE

A trinity of noble souls
by Darshan Singh Maini
D
URING one’s life, one comes across scores of persons who, for one reason or another, leave an indelible, sweet impression on the mind. Three such souls now stay in my memory in the years of long illness and twilight.

OPED

It’s Pawar vs Gopinath Munde in Maharashtra
BJP, Shiv Sena to make Telgi a campaign plank
by Shiv Kumar
H
IS party's election symbol — the clock — in hand, Nationalist Congress Party leader Sharad Pawar is all set to lead the ruling coalition in Maharashtra to next month's Lok Sabha elections. There were a few tense moments for Pawar and friends till the Election Commission's ruling last Monday awarding the symbol to Pawar's faction of the NCP.

Consumer rights
Consumer is more assertive now
by Pushpa Girimaji
H
AS there been an appreciable change in the attitude and behaviour of the Indian consumer in the recent years? Has the Indian consumer shed her apathy and become assertive? Has the Indian consumer learnt to use weapons such as protests and boycotts to send a message across that she or he cannot be taken for granted?

 REFLECTIONS

Top








 

Bill of contention
Who bothers about the daughters’ rights?

THE Jammu and Kashmir ruling parties — the PDP of Chief Minister Mufti Mohammed Sayeed and the Congress — must be heaving a sigh of relief. The controversial Jammu and Kashmir Permanent Residents (Disqualification) Bill, better known as the Daughters’ Bill, has been put on the back burner with the State Legislative Council having been adjourned sine die by Speaker Adbul Rashid Dar. He did it tactfully after a heated debate, and prevented voting on the Bill which neither the PDP nor the Congress wanted to become law at least at this stage when so much heat and dust had been raised over it.

The threat to the Mufti government, which could be seen amidst all that was going on, has disappeared. PDP chief Mehbooba Mufti, who was prepared to sacrifice her government, can now concentrate on improving her party’s prospects in the Lok Sabha elections. The Congress will also have much explaining to do for its about-turn on the Bill. The controversy is unlikely to die with parties like the BJP trying to exploit it for its electoral advantage. In any case, the drama enacted in Jammu shows that politicians of all hues are only bothered about their own interests. What happens to the interests of Jammu and Kashmir’s daughters is not their concern.

Apparently, the tactful handling of the crisis has been possible following some behind-the-scene developments. The Speaker conducted the crucial debate in the Legislative Council without caring for the wishes of his party chief, Mr Omar Abdullah. That is as it should be for the Speaker is supposed to be above political affiliations. The National Conference’s plan has gone awry. It wanted the Bill to be passed with the support of its 15 members to gain an upper hand in the Valley in the coming elections. Expelling the Speaker from the primary membership of the party exposes the desperation on the part of Mr Abdullah. But he has clearly lost the battle of wits.
Top

 

TENtative relief
Cricket is also a business

HAPPILY, television viewers all over the country were able to watch Saturday’s Indo-Pakistan cricket match after the Chief Justice of India, Mr V.N. Khare, issued a directive to TEN Sports to give Doordarshan the rights to telecast live the first one-day international tie at Karachi. But the dispute is far from over. The Supreme Court will hear arguments on Monday on the special leave petition filed by TEN Sports against the decisions of the Chennai and Mumbai high courts permitting Doordarshan the right to telecast the series. This is perhaps the first case of its kind and there are no official policy guidelines for sorting out disputes of this nature.

But the issue is simple and clear. Taj Television, which owns TEN Sports, secured in 2002 the telecast rights for all international cricket matches to be played in that country for the next five years by paying $14.5 million to the Pakistan Cricket Board. Given the usually hostile relations with that country, nobody had then anticipated such a high-pitched match to be played in Pakistan so soon. That is why the babu-run Prasar Bharati, showing lack of imagination as usual, did not evince any interest in the business deal and TEN Sports struck a goldmine. But now the government channel, on the pretext of public interest, is trying to arm-twist TEN Sports into sharing its exclusive telecast rights. The latter is willing to do so, but only in low cable connectivity areas. However, Doordarshan demands a share in the revenue from advertisements also.

This makes little sense. If it is so keen on telecasting the cricket series countrywide, the Prasar Bharati should negotiate and buy the signal from TEN Sports. Of course, the latter cannot be allowed to exploit its monopoly position. This calls for the formulation of guidelines to avoid such disputes in future. Because of its national reach, Doordarshan cannot be kept away from covering events of larger public interest. But when it comes to events outside the country, Doordarshan has to follow global business rules, which do not permit any bullying by a stronger player. That too to make profits. Cricket is not just a game; it is a business too.
Top

 

Mamata’s mamata
A marriage of convenience

BIRDS of the same flock fly together. Small wonder that Union Coal and Mines Minister Mamata Banerjee and former Lok Sabha Speaker P.A. Sangma have joined hands to form the Nationalist Trinamool Congress. The new party has been created by merging her All-India Trinamool Congress and his group of the Nationalist Congress Party. This has been done mainly to improve their bargaining capacity vis-à-vis the ruling National Democratic Alliance of which the new party will be a constituent. In other words, there is no mistaking that it was political expediency that brought the daughter of Bengal and the son of the Northeast together. There were other compulsions also that propelled the two to take the plunge.

For quite some time, Ms Banerjee and Mr Sangma have been facing a lot of problems. Because of dissension in her Trinamool Congress, she was unable to take on the Left Front government in West Bengal in the manner she wanted to. Her plans to become the Railway Minister so that she could use the portfolio to subserve her political interests had gone awry. She is now known more for her tantrums than for her dogged fight against the Left Front government. In the process, she lost her clout with the NDA government at the Centre.

As for Mr Sangma, he lost the battle in the NCP on the day the Election Commission decided to allow Mr Sharad Pawar’s faction to retain the “clock” symbol. Suddenly, he found himself rudderless in politics. It was his desperate search for a political platform that brought him to the doors of Ms Banerjee. Their claim that they have come together to pursue the cause of regional development is for public consumption. Few will fall for it.
Top

 

Thought for the day

He who has never hoped can never despair.

— George Bernard Shaw
Top

 

Time for two-party system
Regional outfits a spoilsport
by Subhash C. Kashyap

WE all talk of regional parties as against national parties, but under the election law and rules, there is nothing like a “regional party”. It seems necessary to have a conceptual clarification about the legal position first.

The charter of fundamental rights enshrined in the Constitution of India inter alia guarantees freedom of association. Under Article 19(C), any group of Indian citizens can get together to form associations or unions of their choice subject to the laws of the land and reasonable restrictions in the interest of national security, etc.

Until the enactment of the Fifty-second Constitution Amendment Act, 1985, which added the Tenth Schedule to the Constitution, there was no mention of political parties. Even now, there is no specific law governing the setting-up or functioning of political parties or regulating their conduct.

The Election Commission maintains a register of political parties. Any association or body of citizens wishing to participate in the electoral process by putting up candidates gets itself registered as a political party with the Election Commission under Section 29A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951, by furnishing the required documents and data about the party. Thus, a few hundred political parties are registered with the commission.

Those parties that secure a certain percentage of votes in a minimum number of states or a number of seats in Parliament can be “recognised” as national parties. Those parties that are confined to a particular state or states can be recognised by the Election Commission as state parties. The recognition by the commission is solely for the purpose of allocation of symbols and is governed by the Election Symbols (Reservation and Allotment) Order 1968 (as amended from time to time).

So far as the Election Commission and the Representation of the People Act are concerned, a party may be recognised as a national party or as a state party. There is no provision for the recognition of a political organisation as a regional party.

Ideally, parties with a national agenda, a nation-wide appeal and a wide support base are considered national parties, and parties confined to only certain areas and having only local or sub-national agendas are called regional parties as opposed to the national parties.

It would, however, be wrong to think that all the so-called regional parties are not national or that all those recognised as national parties are, in fact, not regional. For instance, the CPM and the CPI, which are among the parties formally recognised as national parties by the Election Commission on stretched technical grounds, are largely confined to West Bengal, Kerala and Tripura.

Also, the appeal, the agenda and the orientation of some of the parties denied recognition as national parties transcend geographical regional boundaries.

Under the Election Symbols (Reservation and Allotment) Order of the Election Commission, political parties may be categorised as “recognised” or “unrecognised” ones. Of the recognised parties, recognition may be either as a “state party” or as a “national party”.

To be recognised as a state party, it has to be in existence for five years, have a certain number of members elected to the House of the people or the State Assembly, or it should have secured a certain percentage of votes during the general election to the House of the people or the Legislative Assembly of the state.

Only a party which is treated as such in not less than four states or has certain number of members elected to the House of the people shall be recognised as a national party for purposes of allotment of symbols.

Notwithstanding the technical and legal positions in regard to the categorisation of parties, it is also necessary to consider the matter from the perspective of the needs of political stability, good governance and the unity and integrity of the nation. It needs little argument to assert that on all these counts as also if democracy and freedom have to survive, we need the emergence of two major national parties or alliances.

Small parties with appeals to narrower caste, communal or regional identities and parochial interests are an affront to national unity and integrity and, in the struggle of power politics, sometimes become parties of brinkmanship, bluff and blackmail. It is well known that both at the Union and states levels wherever no single party or pre-poll alliance with a common programme is returned with a clear majority and an unprincipled coalition is put together merely to share the spoils of power, all the energies of the leading alliance partner and/or the leader have to be devoted to the struggle for survival in power. It is so whether the party is the Congress or the BJP.

From the perspective of the citizens’ interests, it would be ideal if one of the two national parties — the Congress or the BJP — is in power and the other is in the opposition. That will be the surest guarantee for political stability, good development-oriented governance and national unity and integrity.

From a party angle also, it would be in the best interests of both the Congress and the BJP - the really two national parties today - to accept the legitimacy and relevance of each other and not regard either as an “untouchable”. The best way to achieve this ideal of a two-major-party system at the national level would be to accept the reform suggestion that only a party getting more than 5 per cent votes in more than half the states should be recognised as a national party competent to contest elections to the House of the people on a reserved symbol. That is not at all to suggest that there is no space for “state” or so-called “regional” parties. These will continue to have all the relevance and legitimacy for elections to the state legislatures. Hopefully, in course of time, at the state level also, a two-party system will emerge even though parties, their nomenclature and programme profiles may vary from state to state.
Top

 

A trinity of noble souls
by Darshan Singh Maini

DURING one’s life, one comes across scores of persons who, for one reason or another, leave an indelible, sweet impression on the mind.

Three such souls now stay in my memory in the years of long illness and twilight.

These three souls (all gone to the other world in the last nine years or so) walked into my life, suddenly, unawares, as it were. What they have meant to me and my wife is hard to describe. For, all three persons had one thing uniquely common — the gift of happiness, a happiness they radiated as if some inner energy had lit up their spirit.

First of all the late R.L. Wadhwa who when I came to know him was perhaps I.G. Police, Punjab Government. Later, he was elevated to the rank of Director General, and as I wrote a requiem at the time of his passing away, he was “a saint in uniform”.

Since the Sikh militancy was yet not spent, and was fairly active in some pockets of Punjab, he always had a couple of bodyguards with sten-gun as he drove to our house in Sector 11. In a few weeks’ time, our two families became close friends, and he started asking my advice regarding a novel he had written on the Partition holocaust of 1947. He also was a poet, and I had his volume of verse in English published by P. Lal (Writers Workshop, Calcutta). But alas, a domestic, fraternal fraud regarding the ancestral property in Meerut caused a massive heart-attack, and he died that evening. That 3-4 year association with him is one of our treasured memories now.

Soon after his death, or around that time, I had a severe neurological collapse which has disabled me now for over 10 years. And then, Mr Wadhwa’s surrogate, as it were, one evening stood framed in our living-room door. He was Mr H.S. Kwatra, a retired Chief Magistrate and then living in Sector 11 with his frail wife. He would call at us each evening come rain, come storm. Again, a face of deep spiritual charm. He blushed whenever he saw a love-scene on our TV. Innocent beyond measure, and a man of compassion beyond belief.

And when in 1999, he too died, I felt desolated, and even wrote a poem on him, and also a long essay. One thing he always emphasised was the theme of ingratitude. He had suffered from some close family members and friends, and he was prepared to consign such persons to the lowest circle in Dante’s Divine Comedy.

The last person, Retired High Court Judge, Justice Surinder Singh, himself a poet of considerable merit and erudition with several books to his credit, took over exactly when Mr Kwatra joined his sweet, frail spouse in heaven. His entry was so timed as to create an idea of God’s “design”, for his daily visits, full of poetic recitation, juicy jokes and anecdotes from his life soon became our daily diet. And his departure late last year has left me in a state of friendlessness — and loneliness. So, he has joined the earlier two callers, and now the “Trinity” of my conception converses above, sending me signals of arrival, so to speak.
Top

 

It’s Pawar vs Gopinath Munde in Maharashtra
BJP, Shiv Sena to make Telgi a campaign plank
by Shiv Kumar

HIS party's election symbol — the clock — in hand, Nationalist Congress Party leader Sharad Pawar is all set to lead the ruling coalition in Maharashtra to next month's Lok Sabha elections.

There were a few tense moments for Pawar and friends till the Election Commission's ruling last Monday awarding the symbol to Pawar's faction of the NCP. "We had spent five years popularising the symbol across the country," beamed Pawar after the EC's ruling. Party sources say there was a contingency plan to come up with an alternative symbol to fight the polls despite there not being enough time to make it popular among voters.

In the five years since Pawar, Tariq Anwar and Purno Sangma wrote their famous epistle to Sonia Gandhi questioning her credentials to become India's Prime Minister, the clock embossed on the tricolour has sprouted across Maharashtra. Pawar, in whose famed memory rests the name of every local level Congress Party leader, has been busy encashing his IOUs from old colleagues.

The old Congress Party retains its strength only in pockets of Maharashtra with even some of its top leaders indebted to Pawar. The families of Chief Minister Sushilkumar Shinde and Pawar have been quite close for years despite the uneven nature of their political relationship. Even before the Congress Party leadership decided to tie up with the NCP, both Shinde and Pawar had already begun discussing a pre-election alliance.

With Shinde backing the move at the highest level, Sonia Gandhi has agreed to let Pawar lead the battle in Maharashtra. Both parties have amicably carved up most of the 48 seats among themselves. Pawar has also got the small restless partners in the Democratic Front government to stay within the fold so that their votes are not split to the benefit of the Shiv Sena-Bharatiya Janata Party combine.

Still it is early days yet and the saffron combine is feeling for loose chips on the edifice that the DF is building. BJP General Secretary Pramod Mahajan and his brother-in-law former Maharashtra Deputy Chief Minister Gopinath Munde scored a significant victory by wooing the Maratha Mahasangh, a caste-based outfit in the state.

The Mahasangh, which aims to turn the Maratha community into a major votebank in Maharashtra, has so far thrown in its lot with the Congress and the NCP. According to Shashikant Pawar (not related to Sharad), president of the Mahasangh, the community accounting for 30 per cent of the population in Maharashtra has not gained anything despite contributing successive Chief Ministers to the state.

The Wednesday coup was the second victory for the saffron duo having bagged the proponents of a separate Vidarbha state last week. The Vidarbha region of Maharashtra was seen as a bastion of the Congress till the nascent Vidarbha Aghadi allied with the Sena-BJP. Farmers' leader Sharad Joshi and local industrialists like newspaper baron Banwarilal Purohit have floated the Vidarbha Aghadi to work for a separate state to be carved out of Maharashtra.

The Vidarbha region has 11 Lok Sabha seats and the BJP, by aligning with the Aghadi, hopes to split the Congress-NCP votes. The Shiv Sena, which has been vocally opposing the proposal to carve Vidarbha out of Maharashtra, is keeping quiet on the issue. "The BJP will be giving a few seats to the Aghadi from its quota," says a Shiv Sena leader. Till the Aghadi came into the picture, the BJP was to contest 26 seats, leaving the rest of the 48 seats in Maharashtra to the Sena.

But the biggest trump card Mahajan and Munde hope to play is the fake stamp paper racket masterminded by forger Abdul Karim Telgi. In all 65 people, including former Mumbai Police Commissioner Ranjit Sharma, are in jail for links with Telgi. Former Deputy Chief Minister and NCP leader Chhagan Bhujbal had to quit after fingers were pointed at him for alleged links with Telgi.

While the Sena and the BJP are planning to make Telgi a major campaign plank in the cities, they have other issues like unremunerative prices to cotton and sugarcane farmers for their rural constituents. Both parties have been leading protests and agitations in rural Maharashtra in the hope that elections to the state legislature and the Lok Sabha would be held simultaneously.

However, their campaign seems to have dulled considerably with the DF government not dissolving the House despite tremendous pressure brought on it. The term of the Maharashtra legislature is due to expire in November this year and Shinde insisted that his government had the mandate to last out the term. The Election Commission also chose to skirt a minefield, though barely six months would remain in the life of Maharashtra's current legislature after the Lok Sabha poll.

Meanwhile, the Shiv Sena is going about its election exercise quietly. Balasaheb Vikhe-Patil, its MP in the 13th Lok Sabha, joined the Congress thereby giving the Sena a jolt in Ahmednagar. Undaunted, Shiv Sena leader and heir apparent Uddhav Thackeray is quietly looking at strong candidates to take on the Congress-NCP alliance.

The Shiv Sena is likely to field its Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Nirupam against Congress MP Sunil Dutt in Mumbai North-West while former minister Leeladhar Dhake may take on former Maharashtra Chief Minister Abdul Rehman Antulay in Raigad.

Shiv Sena sources say the party may field several new faces.

The coming elections will also see parties like the Bahujan Samaj Party and the Samajwadi Party trying to play spoilers. Leaders of both parties have indicated that they would contest more than half the seats in Maharashtra.

In other words, the two may provide the base needed for malcontents from the main parties spoiling for a fight against their official candidates.
Top

 

Consumer rights
Consumer is more assertive now
by Pushpa Girimaji

HAS there been an appreciable change in the attitude and behaviour of the Indian consumer in the recent years? Has the Indian consumer shed her apathy and become assertive? Has the Indian consumer learnt to use weapons such as protests and boycotts to send a message across that she or he cannot be taken for granted? Have Indian consumers learnt the art of lobbying, experienced the strength of collective bargaining?

Certain recent instances of consumer behaviour make me feel quite optimistic about the changing attitude of the Indian consumer and today, as we celebrate the World Consumers Rights Day with the rest of the world, I thought I must write about this positive development that augurs well for the future of the Indian consumer movement.

Remember the year the onion prices in Delhi hit the roof? That was the time several consumer groups gave a call for boycott of onions. Stop buying onions and the prices will automatically fall, they said. No one listened. The queues in front of Super Bazar vans, which were selling onions only lengthened.

Then came the Consumer Protection Act of 1986 and the heated debate over whether medical professionals could be hauled up for negligence under the law. Even as doctors rose as one and lobbied against it, the Union Ministry of Consumer Affairs received hundreds of post cards from consumers saying that medical professionals should not be excluded from the purview of the consumer courts.

This was an issue that elicited strong reactions from consumers, but on their own they would not have thought of writing to the government or lobbying with their elected representatives. In fact, the letters were not the result of a spontaneous reaction. It was prompted by consumer groups that printed these letters and got the signatures of consumers and even mailed them to the ministry.

But today, there seems to be a discernible and even a dramatic shift in consumer behaviour. When it came to the introduction of conditional access system, urban consumers rose in protest. So strong was their opposition to it, that even consumer groups were forced to come together on the issue. And for once, the government had to listen to consumers. Earlier, consumers in certain localities took the extreme step of seeking disconnection of their cable connections in protest against arbitrary hikes in cable charges and took the matter to the local police.

Does it mean that Indian consumers — at least the urban middleclass — have started taking issues concerning their health and safety more seriously? Or was it just a knee-jerk reaction spurred by media reports? I would like to believe that for the first time, Indian consumers did flex their muscles, be it CAS or cola and the message that went out was that consumers can no longer be taken for granted.

This column will henceforth appear in Spectrum
Top

 

Blessed are the twelve months, the seasons, the lunar and the solar days, the hours, the minutes and the seconds when the Lord meets us spontaneously.

— Guru Nanak

Ahimsa magnifies one’s own defects, and minimises those of the opponent. It regards the mole in one’s own eye as a beam and the beam in the opponent’s eye as a mole.

— Mahatma Gandhi

The measure of a master is his success in bringing all men round to his opinion twenty years later.

— Emerson

As Bhakti emphasises humility, obedience, readiness to serve, compassion and gentle love, as the devotee longs to surrender himself, renounce self-will and experience passivity, it is said to be more feminine in character.

— Dr S. Radhakrishnan
Top

HOME PAGE | Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir | Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs | Nation | Opinions |
| Business | Sports | World | Mailbag | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | National Capital |
| Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | Suggestion | E-mail |