Active vs. Passive Mutual Funds: Which Strategy is Right for You?
You are with your friend chatting about investment. He excitedly shares how his mutual fund investments generate decent returns and mentions “active” and “passive” approaches. He discusses how one fund manager always adjusts the portfolio while another mirrors the index. You find yourself nodding, but inside, you are unsure about the difference between the two approaches and are only aware of the breakout trading strategy. Active or passive — which one is the right fit for you?
What are Active and Passive Mutual Funds?
As the name implies, in an active mutual fund, fund managers actively decide to buy and sell investments, aiming to outperform a specific benchmark (like the Nifty 50 or Sensex in India). They look for undervalued assets, changing market trends, and other strategic insights to generate higher returns. The idea here is that, by being actively involved, these fund managers can make investments that beat the general market, giving investors an "edge" when they invest through the options trading app.
Conversely, passive funds, also known as index funds, mirror a market index. They don’t have a team deciding which stocks to buy or sell. Instead, they invest in the stocks that make up a specific index and adjust only when the index changes.
Strategies for Active Mutual Funds
Stock Picking
Fund managers research and pick individual stocks they believe will outperform. They start by assessing company fundamentals, analysing industry trends, and forecasting growth potential to select stocks with the best prospects.
Sector Rotation
This strategy concerns shifting investments between sectors based on economic cycles and market forecasts. For example, fund managers might allocate more to growth sectors, like technology, during economic growth. At the same time, in a downturn, they may favour defensive sectors that are always in demand, like FMCG or healthcare.
Market Timing
This strategy requires fund managers to attempt to predict the perfect times to enter or exit markets. This approach is based on economic indicators, interest rates, or other market trends to maximise gains and minimise losses.
Bottom-Up Analysis
This approach analyses individual companies instead of broad economic or sector trends. Fund managers study a company's fundamentals—like revenue growth, profit margins, and management quality—to find undervalued stocks with the potential for strong returns.
Contrarian Investing
Contrarian fund managers invest in unpopular or undervalued sectors that they believe are poised for a bounce in the future. This approach often involves investing in stocks or sectors others avoid in anticipation of future growth.
Growth Investing
In this, fund managers look for companies actively increasing their market share, revenue, or influence. Although these stocks may seem pricey today, the expectation is they will perform even better long term.
Event-Driven Investing
This strategy involves capitalising on corporate events, such as mergers, acquisitions, or restructurings, which may impact stock prices. Fund managers leverage these events to benefit from temporary market inefficiencies.
Risk Management
A vital part of any active strategy involves spreading investments across various sectors, regions, or asset types to lower volatility exposure to any stock or sector. The primary aim is to balance returns and risk effectively.
Strategies for Passive Mutual Funds
Sampling Approach
For large indexes with numerous components, managers may use sampling instead of buying every stock in the index. They select a representative subset of securities that closely matches the index’s performance, lowering transaction costs and improving efficiency.
Tracking Error Minimisation
Tracking error represents the deviation between the fund and the benchmark index. Fund managers monitor and make necessary adjustments to reduce tracking errors and ensure the fund remains closely aligned with the index.
Dividend Reinvestment
Dividends from the fund’s holdings are reinvested to maximise returns. Fund managers typically reinvest these dividends in line with the index or use them to purchase undervalued stocks within the index.
Optimising Cash Reserves
Fund managers maintain a small cash reserve to handle investor redemptions without disrupting the fund’s structure. However, this reserve is minimised to ensure the fund’s performance mirrors the index as closely as possible.
Cost Control
Since passive funds focus on replicating an index, fund managers aim to keep costs as low as possible, avoiding frequent buying and selling. Lowering transaction costs directly benefits investors by preserving more of the fund’s returns.
Difference Between Active and Passive Mutual Funds
| Aspect | Active Mutual Funds | Passive Mutual Funds |
| Management Style | Actively managed by professional fund managers who decide to buy and sell securities based on research, market conditions, and economic trends. | Passively managed to copy the performance of a specific index, such as the Nifty 50, with minimal trading. |
| Objective | Aim to outperform the market or a specific benchmark index by selecting investments expected to perform better than the market average. | Aim to match the performance of a specific index by holding the same securities in the same proportions as the index. |
| Cost | Generally have higher expense ratios due to active management, research, and frequent trading. | Typically have lower expense ratios because they require less management and trading. |
| Performance | Performance can vary significantly depending on the fund manager's skill and market conditions. Some active funds may outperform their benchmarks, while others may underperform. | Performance closely tracks the benchmark index minus fees and expenses. Passive funds generally provide more predictable returns. |
| Risk | Higher risk due to active decision-making and the potential for human error. The performance highly depends on the manager’s ability to make successful investment choices. | Lower risk as they aim to replicate an index, thus eliminating the unsystematic risk associated with individual stock selection. |
| Flexibility | Fund managers adjust the portfolio in response to market changes, economic forecasts, and new investment opportunities. | Limited flexibility as the fund must adhere to the index composition it tracks. |
| Tax Efficiency | Less tax-efficient because of the frequent buying and selling of securities, which can generate capital gains. | They are more tax-efficient as they have lower turnover rates, resulting in fewer capital gains distributions. |
| Popularity | Preferred by investors seeking to outperform the market and willing to pay higher fees for potential higher returns. | Increasingly popular among investors looking for low-cost, predictable returns and broad market exposure. |
Which Fund Type Suits Different Investment Goals?
Short-Term Goals
If you are looking for growth in the short term, active funds may be worth considering. They have the potential for higher returns, which could align well with a shorter investment horizon.
However, the associated risk and higher fees should also be considered, as active funds don’t guarantee performance.
Long-Term Goals
Passive funds may be a good choice for long-term objectives like retirement or a child's education because of their low-cost structure and steady returns. Over time, passive funds generally perform well, especially since the stock market has historically trended upwards in the long run.
Income Generation
Some investors prefer to earn a regular income from their investments through a stock app. For this, active funds may be more suitable, as they can focus on dividend-paying stocks and other income-generating assets.
Passive funds, in contrast, may not actively pursue income-focused stocks.
Conclusion
Deciding between active and passive mutual funds is not about picking a “better” option but choosing what aligns with your unique goals. Active funds may offer higher returns if you are comfortable with more volatility and costs. On the other hand, passive funds provide low-cost, market-matching returns for a steady growth path. You must first open Demat Account from a reputed broker like HDFC SKY to benefit from any strategies.
Disclaimer: This article is part of sponsored content programme. The Tribune is not responsible for the content including the data in the text and has no role in its selection.
