The music that tugs at heart strings
Reviewed by Nirupama Dutt

Light of the Universe: Essays on Hindustani Film Music
by Ashraf Aziz
Three Essays Collective. Pages 184. Rs 350

Nargis and Raj Kapoor in Barsaat
Nargis and Raj Kapoor in Barsaat

Is the Hindi film music more literate and democratic than the earlier forms of Hindustani classical music and folk music? Was there an underlying suicidal wish in the popular romantic songs of lyricist Shailendra? Was Lata Mangeshkar’s singing de-sexed?

Such are the interesting questions raised about popular Hindustani film music by Ashraf Aziz. Indeed, film music has inspired many a writer to go into its unique persona but this time the author is rather unusual. An instructor of anatomical sciences at Howard University, Aziz was born in Tanzania and in 1965 he moved to the United States for his Ph.D He calls himself an American of Indo-Pakistani origin, with an African experience and his dedication to the binding art of the popular culture of the Indian sub-continent is complete. The Three Essays Collective brings a revised and enlarged version of this book in which the author has gone not just into the anatomy of Indian film music but into its very soul.

Building a strong case for the film song in the long introduction to the new edition of the delightfully intriguing essays, he writes: "Amongst the most extraordinary developments in 20th Century India was the creation of its equally particular soundtrack. Like the currency, the railway, the
telegraph, the postal service, the radio, the newspapers, the gramophone record, the popular cinema and its music are unifying and modernising forces in India. Despite linguistic, religious and other cultural differences, the popular film and (especially) its soundtrack bind South Asians in a common culture."

The author sees the Hindi film song of yore as inseparable from India’s struggle for Independence as it was the new medium giving voice to the history and aspirations of the colonised Indian people. He thus goes onto analyse various popular songs finding patriotism and the yearning for Independence in the most unsuspecting of Indian film songs. His is definitely a critic’s attempt to start a conversation or even an argument of the genre. A diehard Noor Jahan fan, he sees women’s liberation in her Zeenat (1945) film qawwali "Aahein na bhari," and a cry for an end to colonial rule in the evergreen love duet of Anmol Gharhi (1946) sung by her with Surinder: "Awaaz de kahan hai".

Writing about the female voice in Hindi cinema, Aziz says that the forward march of the women singers came to an abrupt end with India’s Independence in 1947 when the author says the men were asserting their dominance and the women who had come out in the struggle for Independence had to be turned home to play the second fiddle. So the strong voices of the past gave way to the very feminine and docile renderings by Lata Mangeshkar. He writes: "In India , men found a willing and ardent ally of their cause in a teenager — Lata Mangeshkar. Women were homeward bound with Lata’s entry into cinema singing." He further goes onto describe her voice as that of a small girl, who has yet to reach puberty, as it travelled lightly with effortless agility. In contrast he points out: "In Mohammad Rafi men found their macho, vocal Rambo."

The book includes a brilliant essay on "The lyrical romance of suicide as seen through the songs of Shailendra", perhaps the foremost lyricist of Hindi films who made his debut in Raj Kapoor’s Barsaat and formed a long association with him and Shankar Jaikishan, while giving luminous songs to other music directors like S.D. Burman, Salil Chaudhary and Ravi Shankar too. Shailendra came to a tragic end after he turned producer for his acclaimed film Teesri Kasam (1966), which was a commercial failure. Again Aziz finds in Shailendra’s love songs, which we have heard and found them moving, an obsession with death. He extends them to the loving lullabies: "All these gentle melodies transport the baby into sleep…. Sleep is Nature’s gentle way of allowing us a foretaste of death; in effect death is "permanent sleep". Readings of the film songs and the narrative thus is an attempt to start a conversation, and a successful one indeed. Besides conversation, his original analysis can well start a heated debate. These essays make for very interesting reading for those who would love to delve deep into the world of Hindi film songs and interpret them as they would like to.





HOME