Short Takes
Slum child and the Mahatma
Reviewed by Randeep Wadehra

Slum Child
by Bina Shah
Tranquebar. Pages: 288. Rs. 295

Slum ChildThere is no dearth of great stories revolving around a young protagonist’s attempts at escaping from oppressive environs and poverty. Charles Dickens’ Oliver Twist is a classic template for this genre, not to forget his Great Expectations. This journey from poverty to comfort or relative luxury has fascinated writers and readers alike. In the subcontinental context, the movie Slumdog Millionaire has proved to be an immensely popular narrative featuring slum-child Jamal’s successful but perilous escape from poverty. Similar is the mix of dark and luminescent shades in Bina Shah’s gripping novel featuring child-woman, Laila, as protagonist, who lives in Issa Colony, a Christian majority slum in Karachi. Laila’s mother, Zainab, works as a maid in the house of the Ansaris located in the posh Defence Colony. Zainab’s first husband walks out on her when she gives birth to the second daughter, Laila; her first daughter, Jumana, is stricken with tuberculosis. Zainab begets three sons through her second husband Irfan.

Laila’s world crumbles when her sister dies and mother loses her sanity. When she discovers that Irfan was planning to push her into prostitution she runs away. She gets unexpected help from a reformed drug addict and a young Pathan in reaching the Ansaris’ house. They provide her with financial security but new problems crop up.

This story of a young Pakistani Christian girl provides us with glimpses of the state of minorities in general and Christians in particular in the highly stratified and Islamised Pakistani society. But, in that forest of prejudices and humiliations, Laila meets kind and helpful people like Ansari "Madam," too. Shah has handled her characters quite skillfully – not allowing mawkishness to creep into sensitive situations. The storyline remains poignantly matter of fact and keeps one engrossed. This novel has all the makings of a classic in the subcontinent’s literature.

Reading and Reappraising Gandhi
by Ram Chandra Pradhan
Macmillan. Pages: xiv+290. Rs. 210

Reading and Reappraising GandhiFrom being a flesh-and-blood reality, Mahatma Gandhi has gradually acquired all trappings of a mythological icon. Not his doing, of course. Yet, his thoughts and actions have been undergoing constant analyses by various scholars; and ordinary folks, too. Was he a moralist-idealist or a pragmatist; a visionary statesman or a street-savvy politician? There is any number of people who worshipfully put him on the pedestal and deify him. But there are others who rail against him – pointing out various failings, both in his personal and public realms. However, with passage of time – as new social, political as well as economic contexts arise – the need to reinterpret the Mahatma becomes pertinent. As a result, a rich corpus of analytical writings on the Mahatma has come into existence. This volume takes a comprehensive look at the various writings on (some of them quite recent) and by the Mahatma. This book would be quite useful for ordinary readers as well as students of Gandhian studies.

My Life My Times
by Jagjit Singh Lyallpuri
Unistar. Pages: 270. Rs. 300

The Indian subcontinent’s political story is so vast and complex that often some of its very interesting subtexts get ignored. We are aware of the main story of the struggle for Independence launched by the Congress party under the leadership of Mahatma Gandhi. The roles played by other political entities like the Muslim League, the Singh Sabha, Hindu Mahasabha, Communists, Akalis etc, have been well- documented.

Yet, new additions to the narrative keep happening, as evidenced by this interesting volume. Jagjit Singh Lyallpuri dwells upon the various events that took place before and after India’s Independence, the Communist movement’s rise and its subsequent weakening due to splits, the Akali politics etc, providing valuable literature for students of Punjab’s politics, along with its national context.






HOME