Power of the unseen
Great film-makers love to stroke the audiences’ imagination by not showing everything to them, writes Vikramdeep Johal

Mia Farrow, the unwitting mother of Satan’s child in Rosemary’s Baby
Mia Farrow, the unwitting mother of Satan’s child in Rosemary’s Baby

A master director stamps his class not only with what he shows on screen but also with what he does not. Leaving something to the viewers’ imagination, instead of revealing or explaining it all, is a gamble very few film-makers are keen to take.

Alfred Hitchcock’s first American film, Rebecca (1940), deservingly ranks among the greatest classics of cinema. Its unique feature is that the title character never appears in the movie, even though the whole story revolves around her.

Based on Daphne Du Maurier’s Gothic bestseller, this suspense drama is about an aristocratic widower, Max De Winter (Laurence Olivier), who falls in love with a "Plain Jane" (Joan Fontaine) and brings her after marriage to his country mansion. The innocent girl has to contend with the surreal presence of Max’s dead wife, Rebecca, a woman famed for her beauty and wit. To make matters worse, the sinister housemaid, Mrs Danvers (Judith Anderson), remains loyal to her deceased mistress.

Hitchcock could have shown Rebecca in a flashback sequence, but he chose not to do so, thereby intensifying her mysterious aura. It’s all up to the spectator to visualise how alluring she was.

Actor Robert Montgomery turned director with Lady in the Lake (1946), playing the lead role of detective Philip Marlowe himself. This film is best remembered for the extensive use of the "subjective camera", a technique in which the viewer sees things only through the eyes of the narrator or protagonist. Montgomery remained "invisible" for the better part of the movie, and he was seen only when he looked into a mirror! When somebody punched him, the fist was aimed straight at the camera (and at the surprised viewer).

Renowned Spanish surrealist Luis Bunuel loved to tease or mislead his audiences. Belle de Jour (1966) is the story of Severine (Catherine Deneuve), a masochistic married woman who turns to prostitution on the sly. In one scene, an East Asian customer opens his little box and shows it to the girls at the brothel. We never see what’s inside it, but the prostitutes do, and they recoil in horror. Severine, however, just can’t take her eyes off it.

In his autobiography, My Last Breath, Bunuel recalled that countless people — especially women — had asked him what was in the box. "Since I myself have no idea, I usually reply, ‘Whatever you want there to be,’" he wrote.

In the last scene of Roman Polanski’s spine-chiller Rosemary’s Baby (1968), Mia Farrow comes to know that the child she has just given birth to has been fathered by none other than Satan. Desperate to have one look at her baby, she stares into the cradle. The sight horrifies her, to say the least, but we don’t get to see the devil’s offspring. Subtle strokes like this one have made Polanski’s first Hollywood film a horror classic, even though it has virtually no bloodshed or grotesqueness.

John McTiernan’s sci-fi thriller Predator (1987), starring Arnold Schwarzenegger, packed a punch as long as the monster from outer space remained camouflaged in the jungle. What a big letdown it was on becoming visible—just an ugly and clumsy alien thirsty for human blood. Its menacing power, made stronger by its invisibility, was all gone. Like most directors, McTiernan succumbed to the temptation of showing rather than hiding.





HOME