Good films, bad show
MAMI was a classless festival earlier but that seems to be changing. It remains badly organised though, writes Ervell E. Menezes

Downtown Girls was an old film, for festival regulars
Downtown Girls (Egypt) was an old film, for festival regulars

The 9th Mumbai Academy of the Moving Image (MAMI) festival, like its earlier versions, continues to make news for the wrong reasons. Bad organisation is one of these. After nine years, there are still teething troubles. May be it is competing with IFFI Goa in that respect but like at Goa there was a high percentage of good films.

The first two days itself saw at least six programme changes at Imax with films like Sleeping Dogs, Madmen, Kebab Connection, Lady Nitwit Chauraben, The Legend of Time and Lemming failing to land. More followed. Naming them would only waste space. So never go just in time for a film. Be there half an hour early and check the latest festival bulletin. The films have been held up at the Customs is the excuse totted by the organisers. They never run out of excuses.

This led to them providing the programme for only two days at a time as against the earlier entire schedule. Still, of the two days too, one had to check the current day for any changes. It happens nowhere else. So it reminded one of the hymn "one day at a time, sweet Jesus."

On the first working day (the festival is from March 8 to 15), that is March 9, we had a compere reading out the synopses which most had in any case and hoping "you are enjoying MAMI." But when the filmmakers actually made their presence, like for example the Spanish actress Bebe from The Education of a Fairy at Imax, there was no spotlight or interpreter. So much for their warped sense of priorities.

The press conferences are ragged with the Imax foyer not being the best place to hold these. Not surprisingly, they were poorly attended. As for the Press Room, it was an apology for the same with poor facilities and the journos had to make their own arrangements.

Concentrating on World Cinema in the top bracket is The Wind That Shakes the Barley (Ireland and others) Life in Colour (Spain), Three Days of Anarchy (Italy), Sarafina (South Africa), the opening Chinese film The Curse of the Golden Flower and Tied Hands. In the next grade is The Child (France), Several People, Little Time (Poland). The Education of a Fairy (Spain), and to a lesser extent Crossing Borders (Spain). But The Collector (Poland) is overrated and Outsourced (US) quite terrible.

But they surely drew being excellent and it is this reason that brings film buffs to "the middle of nowhere" (read Imax, Wadala). These include over a dozen hard-core film society folk (from Film Forum to Prabhat Film Society) being regulars at all festivals. Earlier it was a classless festival but that seems to be changing.

Ken Loach’s The Wind That Shakes the Barley is a deeply emotional drama set against the backdrop of the Irish struggle for freedom. It is about two brothers who end up on opposite sides and what a shattering climax! In the same mould as Some Mothers Sons and Michael Collins.

There are two excellent political films, Three Days of Anarchy dealing with the end of the Fascist regime during World War II and how they prepare to welcome the Americans as well as choose their own leaders. The other is the Spanish film Life in Colour, set against the backdrop of General Franco’s dictatorship. Thirteen-year-old Fede is the focus and life in that small Sicilian town is graphically narrated. There is a special relationship with his grandpa and the title is a quote from him. "You’ve had a bad day but tomorrow you’ll find everything okay—in colour again."

Sarafina is about the anti-apartheid stir in Soweto and how the spunky schoolgirl of the title, whose hero is Nelson Mandela, rallies round her colleagues to project what "black power" is all about. The atrocities perpetrated by the Whites have to be seen to be believed. Like the British in Ireland.

Old age is a subject that crops up in most of the films and so there are quite a few funerals. Then romance is next and the love triangle. Though The Education of a Fairy is centred on young Raul, it is the strength of the two women, ornithologist Ingrid and supermarket attendant Bebe (who eventually gets admission to the Sorborne) that is as impressive, to say nothing of the female camaraderie.

Goat Horn(Bulgaria) is said to have made waves in the film society movement of the 1970s because of the rape scene in those pre-Cable days and time of strict censorship and Downtown Girls (Egypt), which is put as "made in 2005" is much older, according to the festival regulars.

The standard excuse for MAMI is the lack of funds but with sponsorship by Reliance, one wonders why they are struggling. Good intentions and sincerity is not enough. What is needed is competence. Not smiling bimbos and needless verbiage. The audience is made up of hard-core film buffs and all they want is to go on with the action. The brochure is very well brought out which means if they want to they can get the right folks involved.

We sincerely hope that happens in the 10th instalment of MAMI, or is that asking/hoping for too much?





HOME