HOLLYWOOD HUES
A dull entertainer

Trust Hollywood to flog a dead pirate. Director Gore Verbinski is all at sea and the mindless script doesn’t help, writes Ervell E. Menezes

Dead Man’s Chest
A still from Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s Chest

Johnny Depp is easily one of Hollywood’s most effective actors. And along with Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightly, they churned out a delightful buccaneering adventure Pirates of the Caribbean. But did that make Hollywood happy? No. They had to do it again, as they only can, and this overlong, avowedly supernatural sequel Dead Man’s Chest is an insult to the freshness of spontaneity of the parent film.

Trust Hollywood to flog a dead pirate. The first film was a tribute to the pirates and sword-fencing films of the early 1950s, films like Crimson Pirate, and their ilk. Johnny Depp breezed through that film like a breath of fresh air. In Dead Man’s Chest after the initial burst he struggles with the ghosts of those ancient mariners (made to look like monsters). So do his co-characters Will Turner (Orlando Bloom) and Elizabeth Swann (Keira Knightly) who are mere pawns. Dispensable.

The synopsis claims the curse of the Black Pearl has been lifted, an even more terrifying threat looks over its captain and scurvy crew." Rubbish. It turns out that Jack owes a blood debt to Davy Jones (Bill Nighy), ruler of the Ocean Depths, who captains the ghostly Flying Dutchman, which no other ship can match in speed and stealth. They have to find his chest, but before that the key to it.

Outlandish, sorry outoceanic stuff. There are some good gags for starters, like the cart wheeling windmill but once they dabble with those "monstrous mariners" the film takes a nosedive. The flamboyant soothsayer (Namie Harris) provides some dramatic relief but not Will’s dad Bootstrap Bill (Stellan Skarsgard) who is neither here nor there. The squeakish parrot cries "don’t eat me," and the swift monkey scurries about but the movie is virtually at a standstill. Director Gore Verbinski is all at sea, pun quite accidental, and the mindless script doesn’t help one bit.

The asides to "a bottle of rum" of Treasure Island are well taken as is the gag of sliding down the sail with a knife, a la Burt Lancaster in Crimson Pirate, but they are just straws in the wind of this very dull entertainer. Like so many of these modern Hollywood mega-films, this one goes on and on, as if to provide quantitative entertainment. Thirty minutes could easily have been clipped of the 150. It’s not like buying rice. Phone Booth was only 87 minutes long but more satiating than anything over 120 minutes.

If you’ve seen the original film, steer clear of this sequel. It’s better to relish that flavour, even in retrospect, than venture to this apology of a sequel.





HOME