The Tribune - Spectrum

ART & LITERATURE
'ART AND SOUL
BOOKS
MUSINGS
TIME OFF
YOUR OPTION
ENTERTAINMENT
BOLLYWOOD BHELPURI
TELEVISION
WIDE ANGLE
FITNESS
GARDEN LIFE
NATURE
SUGAR 'N' SPICE
CONSUMER ALERT
TRAVEL
INTERACTIVE FEATURES
CAPTION CONTEST
FEEDBACK

Sunday, August 17, 2003
Books

Pakistan and its politics of terror
Parshotam Mehra

Pakistan: in the Shadow of Jihad and Afghanistan
by Mary Anne Weaver, Viking, New Delhi. Pages 284. Rs 395.

Pakistan: in the Shadow of Jihad and AfghanistanIN the wake of New Delhi’s determined bid to improve relations with its western neighbour and Islamabad’s reasonably positive response, there is a welcome thaw in an age-old hostility. Whether this leads to a meaningful dialogue would depend at least partly, on the policies and politics of Pakistan. For the record though, there has been no end to false starts and hopes belied.

And what of the nature of the regime India is seeking to befriend? Mary Weaver’s Pakistan is an honest attempt by a veteran journalist to furnish an answer. And it makes for chilling reading. A far cry from Jinnah’s progressive state founded on the principles of Islam, Pakistan has become, she avers, "one of the most frightening places" on earth. For a forbidding arsenal of 30-50 nuclear weapons, a dozen or so private Islamic armies and a militant agenda have thrown its civil society into ferment. Of greatest concern — too recent to find a mention in the book — is the emergence of a Shariah-based government in the NWFP, bordering a still explosive Afghanistan, and a parliament in Islamabad held to ransom by a formidable mullah-ridden opposition bitterly opposed to the country’s president wearing two hats: a civilian cap and an army chief’s beret.

The author has been a frequent visitor to Pakistan over the past two decades and had "unparalleled" access to its presidents, prime ministers, politicians and generals. In the event, the best part of her work is the first hand accounts of the man who rules Pakistan and the charismatic Benazir Bhutto, its former prime minister who may yet stage a comeback. Sadly, consigned to the shadows is Nawaz Sharif.

 


Early on in the narrative the author harks back to the beginning of the Taliban rule when there was "a strange confluence" of three bed fellows. Benazir Bhutto, the secular — but ambitious and flawed — first woman prime minister of the Islamic world; Pervez Musharraf, the secular general, who was her Director General of Military Operations (1993-1995) and Osama bin Laden who had re-emerged on the scene in Afghanistan. Most of the book revolves around the threesome.

Of Pakistan’s two ex-prime ministers — both twice-elected, both twice deposed, both now in exile abroad — the author had an intimate encounter with Benazir Bhutto. A tall, elegant, handsome woman with "large luminous brown eyes, arched eyebrows and swanlike neck", she "intentionally" hides her looks behind owlish glasses, numerous head coverings and bulky shawls. More, an Oxford and Radcliff educated Benazir has an extremely well-stocked mind and a "very liberalised" social life.

Described to her as "a chameleon: a man who can be anything", Weaver met Musharraf for the first time in September 2000. He wanted her, and the world at large, to believe that he was "a genuine patriot in the mold of Ataturk." More correctly, she insists, he has launched Pakistan on its present militant Islamist course.

From small beginnings way back in 1986, Osama bin Laden led a small group of a dozen or two men out of a cluster of caves in Afghanistan’s Paktia province, just a stone’s throw from the Pakistan frontier. And he has come a long way. He has managed to survive US cruise-missile attacks, an unrelenting high-tech air campaign, a succession of political crises, conspiracies and attempts on his life. Nor was that all. By 9/11 some 5,000 or more Islamic extremists from as many as 40 countries had trained in his camps and were waging new jihads in Bosnia, Tajikistan, and Kashmir and building Al-Qaida networks in Pakistan, Saudi Arabia and Egypt, Algeria and the Philippines, the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Of the 19 young men responsible for 9/11 no less than 15 came from Bin Laden’s Saudi Arabia!

Not unlike Benazir, Bin Laden too was born in a patrician family and is a western-educated management expert and high-tech engineer. Oddly though he graduated to preach terror and Islamist politics. His followers are a diversified lot: some from the madrasas and barely literate; others, professors, generals, doctors, economists.

A long time foreign correspondent with The New Yorker, Mary Weaver is also the author of A Portrait of Egypt: A Journey through the World of Militant Islam.