The Tribune - Spectrum

ART & LITERATURE
'ART AND SOUL
BOOKS
MUSINGS
TIME OFF
YOUR OPTION
ENTERTAINMENT
BOLLYWOOD BHELPURI
TELEVISION
WIDE ANGLE
FITNESS
GARDEN LIFE
NATURE
SUGAR 'N' SPICE
CONSUMER ALERT
TRAVEL
INTERACTIVE FEATURES
CAPTION CONTEST
FEEDBACK

Sunday, April 13, 2003
Books

Malraux and the romanticism of lonely struggles
Shelley Walia

Antimemoirs
by Andre Malraux. Rupa.
Pages 448. Rs 295.

Jawaharlal Nehru and André Malraux
Jawaharlal Nehru and André Malraux 

THE Antimemoirs originated largely out of Malraux’s travels in India and China in 1965. It shows his obsession with the bleak destiny of Western man, here a repetition of the theme that he had taken up in his masterpiece Man’s Fate. The answers to this obsession he sought in art as well in his many experiences and discussions with statesmen and artists around the world.

The chapter on his meeting with Nehru is exceptionally gripping in so far as it shows Malraux’s understanding of Eastern thought and Gandhi’s role in the freedom struggle. It was difficult for him to grasp that Gandhi could convince multitudes without raising his voice, unlike the European orators. He admires the Gandhian genius for creating the symbols of the spinning wheel, or salt, to shape the future through an appeal to ancient feelings. With his long discussions with Nehru, he finally understood not only Gandhian philosophy, but the difference between Western thought and Eastern: in spite of sin, in spite of the devil, in spite of the absurd, in spite of the unconscious, the European thinks of himself as acting in a world in which change is a value, progress is conquest, destiny is history.

The Hindu, on the other hand, thinks of himself as acted upon. The West regards as truth what the Hindu regards as appearance. And in his wanderings around Chandigarh with Le Corbusier, Malraux is shown the bronze hand that seemingly looked like a cross between an emblem and a giant weathervane, but in reality the lines of fate on it symbolised the fate of India. Here lies India’s adoption of the modern and the traditional, "the spinning-wheel revolving in houses a stone’s throw from reactors."

 


In the early 70s, I read with immense enthusiasm his The Conquerors, Man’s Fate, Days of Hope, The Walnut Trees of Altenburg and all provided me close encounters with the history of our times. And like the Greek tragedy, I concluded that Malraux was not concerned with the state machinery and its politics, but mainly with the rise and fall of Man.

As a philosopher, he was one with Sartre or Camus, who consider the nobility of Man as far supreme to any other quality. When we consider Andr`E9 Malraux in the light of this tale in the first person, we are enticed, more often than not, to recall his fervent contribution to all the great causes of our century, his active role as the Minister of Culture alongside General de Gaulle, between 1958 and 1969, and also the last journey, towards the end of his life, when he travelled to Bangladesh confounded by war as the envoy and forerunner of a "kindred spirit" that did not yet bear the pseudo nomenclature of "humanitarian aid."

For over 50 years Malraux was closely caught up in French intellectual life, as philosopher, statesman, novelist, and soldier. He fought for freedom throughout his life: against French colonialism in Indochina, fascism in Spain and Nazism in Germany. He explored Khmer Indochina in the early twenties and met many Communist revolutionaries in China, in 1925. In the 30s, he censured Nazi despotism in Days of Contempt and violently criticised Spain’s fascism in Days of Hope (1937). His political convictions and sincere activism lead him to fight alongside Spanish Republicans during the Civil War.

The Antimemoirs is not only a warm memoir, but a meticulous commentary on his travels around the world, meeting world leaders, as well as an investigation of art that brings out its worth in contemporary times. The existentialist view that the individual can give significance to his life through dedication to a cause finds expression here. As a writer he denounced the misery of Man and exalted his greatness. But he was also an aesthete and art critic, and introduced the French public to the wealth of civilisations and cultures outside Europe.

When Picasso died on April 8, 1973, in Mougins, South of France, Malraux, his close friend, was invited by Picasso’s widow, Jacqueline Roque, to have a last look at his collection and write on her husband’s art. It is here that, surrounded by Picasso’s powerful last paintings "painted face to face with death" and his art collection destined for the Louvre, Malraux reminisced his friend’s defiant life and the transmutation of his art. It was a defence of modernism where Malraux examines African art that influenced Picasso so deeply. Rather than trying to establish its exact meaning, he looks at it through the master’s discovery and appropriation of it.

In viewing him as an art critic, we sometimes overlook him as a novelist and storyteller. His work reflects the romanticism of lonely struggles "blending with the exaltation, seemingly paradoxical at first, of group solidarity, all couched in a breathless, staccato style interspersed with quick-fire dialogue." His quest for the aesthetic, his painstaking dedication at repeatedly returning to the bas-reliefs on the Khmer temples at Angkor, Cambodia, are a tribute to his stature as an art critic and historian.

The Museum Without Walls (1952-54) is an example of a deep-seated desire to bring about a subtle juxtaposition of the primitive and the modern, of the noble and the primitive. His attraction for the Asiatic broadened the Museum Without Walls: the Japanese art from the Dark Ages, Sumerian art, pre-Columbian and Buddhist sculpture and the art of India, Mexico and Iran transcends time and space, and is a struggle and defence against war and death: "the real Museum is the presence, in life, of what ought to belong to death." His major work on art criticism The Voice of Silence elaborates his theory that art is "humanity’s only permanent expression of the will to triumph over fate."