The Tribune - Spectrum

ART & LITERATURE
'ART AND SOUL
BOOKS
MUSINGS
TIME OFF
YOUR OPTION
ENTERTAINMENT
BOLLYWOOD BHELPURI
TELEVISION
WIDE ANGLE
FITNESS
GARDEN LIFE
NATURE
SUGAR 'N' SPICE
CONSUMER ALERT
TRAVEL
INTERACTIVE FEATURES
CAPTION CONTEST
FEEDBACK

Sunday, March 23, 2003
Books

The subtext behind colonial actions
R. L. Singal

Work and Social Change in Asia
(Essays in Honour of Jan Breman)
edited by Arvind N. Das & Marcel van der Linden. Manohar Publishers. Pages 277. Rs 650.

Work and Social Change in AsiaAN anthology of essays by eminent scholars on social, political, anthropological and geographical themes, Work and Social Change in Asia, has been published in honour of the dedicated Dutch sociologist Jan Breman. It is quite informative and interesting. Born in a working class family in 1936, Jan Breman knew what poverty and oppression meant. Perhaps that is why he was driven to reject society that condemns people to material want and denies them fulfilment". Consequently, he devoted his life to the study of the problems faced by deprived sections of society in the Third World, particularly in India, Bangladesh, Indonesia and Trinidad. By dint of his hard work, Breman rose to be a senior professor at the University of Amsterdam.

Though this anthology has been shown to have been edited by Arvind N. Das and Marcel Linden, the former’s place was taken by Sabyasachi Bhattacharya, the distinguished social and economic historian, because of Arvind N. Das’s sudden and premature death in Amsterdam. Arvind was still planning and collecting the material for the book, which was to be presented to Prof Breman in June 2001 at the time of his retirement, but the book was published quite late 2003.

Almost all the essays in the book focus on the problems and aspirations of labourers and farmers as also those of the landlords and the rulers whose interests are often complementary but at times inimical too. The state also plays its part by providing credit facilities and other aids, but sometimes it also imposes crushing taxes, restrictive rules and regulations, as well as other impediments and controls that hamper growth.

 


The author is of opinion that at the end of the 20th century, Gujarat and its southern neighbour Maharashtra are India’s leading industrial states. Together they out-distance West Bengal, while Punjab and Haryana lag behind in economic growth. The author believes that the colonial land revenue system could be seen as an early attempt at land reform and planning. The colonial government’s tax reform was meant to increase the efficiency of agricultural production by reorganising the size and structure of the unit of production and to free the cultivator from an oppressive tax-burden.

According to the author, after the land-reform measures of the 1950s and 1960s the Adivasi cultivators made a new start, but price fluctuations, scant credit facilities, bad harvests and illness of people and cattle have started the sequence of misery again. A poor Adivasi woman has very graphically summed up the situation: "Once we derived our pride from our jati, There was land for cultivation, there was our jungle, we had our tradition, but we lost land, and so our pride". The jungle was the Adivasi’s personal estate. It was the perennial source of his livelihood, health and sustenance. It was the symbol of his pride. With its loss, he has lost his mooring. As an informant observed, "The Adivasi jungle was our home but now we are exiles in our old jungle".

There is a very revealing essay by Prabhu P. Mohapatra on the Indian Immigrant Labourers in Trinidad. These Indians had been brought into Trinidad as indentured labourers since 1845. By 1984, their number was roughly 70,000, mostly hailing from the Gangetic plains of eastern Uttar Pradesh and Bihar. They worked on 109 sugar estates. The workers were bound to work on the plantations on a fixed wage according to their contract with the employers. They were governed by a series of immigration ordinances that penalised breach of contract by imprisonment and fines.

This essay exposes the action and intentions of the colonial rulers, who instead of promoting the welfare of the indentured labourers
and feeling happy over the mutual love and trust of the two principal communities, did all they could do to negate both these desirable goals.

The other papers in this anthology too are revealing and informative. They deal with labour, capital, landlord-credit, rural-urban migration, agriculture-industry transition, etc. during the latter half of the 20th century. The book should be of interest and benefit to students of sociology, economics and anthropology, particularly to researchers, and policy-makers in these areas. It is not for the general reader.