The Tribune - Spectrum

ART & LITERATURE
'ART AND SOUL
BOOKS
MUSINGS
TIME OFF
YOUR OPTION
ENTERTAINMENT
BOLLYWOOD BHELPURI
TELEVISION
WIDE ANGLE
FITNESS
GARDEN LIFE
NATURE
SUGAR 'N' SPICE
CONSUMER ALERT
TRAVEL
INTERACTIVE FEATURES
CAPTION CONTEST
FEEDBACK

Sunday, February 2, 2003
Books

Signs & signatures
Black American novelists: Voices of protest
Darshan Singh Maini

BLACK American experience is such a complex tangled, intractable issue as to defy any kind of definition or discourse. Its problematics invariably drive one into uncomfortable ambiguities as well as into unhelpful sermonising and theorising. It means, at the deeper level, that no non-Black writer or artist can hope to reach down to those African roots which like a subterranean stream have kept feeding Black American consciousness for over three centuries now. White writers such as Harriet Beacher Stowe (Uncle Tom’s Cabin) and Mark Twain (Huck Finn) earlier, and Hemingway and Faulker later have sought to dramatise this dilemma in their own way, but they cannot get under the skin of the Black Americans, and not even an empathetic imagination can be fully exploited to bring out the terrible reality of being a Black in a dominant ruling White majority. Their triple alienation from their spiritual African home, from the White mainstream and, more grievously from their own selves — thus, becomes only a preserve of the Black writers.

Though Black voices of protest, indignation and assertion have been there from the earlier days of slavery and serfdom, it was only after the "Harlem Renaissance" of the 1920’s that Black writers in a concerted manner sought to create an authentic literary consciousness. The imperialism of the White imagination is challenged, and the questions of Black honour and Black identity are fully addressed. They had, even in the presence of terror such as the KKK, the White fascist cadres in the South, represented, managed to keep their African culture alive in the form of "Negro spirituals" and "blues" and "jazz", but the oral outlet did not permit them to fully voice the buffoonery and agony of their emotions. Thus "Black aesthetic" and "Negritude" came into their own. I’ve no space here for those voices of prophetic protest which rose like a column of fire, and therefore, I have elected to illustrate the argument with two supreme artists of the Black race in America — James Baldwin and Toni Morrison. Of course, no fuller discourse can ignore novelists of the calibre of Richard Wright (Native Son) Ralph Ellison (The Invisible Man) and Alex Hailey (Roots) but Baldwin and Morrison have higher order of creation, and their stringent, provocative and polemical works, thus, become a more definitive statement of the Black American ordeal.

 


James Baldwin, who died at the age of 62 in 1987, is easily the most powerful voice in the Black American novel before Nobel Laureate, Toni Morrison. Risen out of the Harlem horrors to hoist a moving discourse in American letters, he was fully conscious of his "complex fate", assuming his "aesthetic ministry", he invested his prose with awe and thunder and prophecy. Indeed, to think of him is to think of a ‘Black Hamlet’, pondering the history and destiny of him race in a profoundly anguished but eloquent voice.

In his first novel, Go Tell It on the Mountain (1953) there’s a strong evangelical strain, and we find his mindset precludes evasions, soft options and self-deceptions. Told through flashbacks, the story of a 17-year old Harlem boy, John Grimes, it becomes an amblematic surrogate for Baldwin himself. But in Giovanni’s Room (1957), the Black fate gets conflated with Baldwin’s own troubled sexuality. In the larger contest, it becomes a metaphor for the politics of sex and the politics of power. In his best book, Another Country (1962), racial, sexual and societal strains converge to form a grand metaphor of appetite and aggrandisement, and the title itself suggests a land of alienation where the moral imperialism of the White race, and the spiritual squalor and spoliation of the Blacks have combined to create a geography of vicious bodies and parts. Leaving aside his other novels, I turn to his prose piece The Fire Next Time. There’s a touch of nobility in his anger, and a touch of splendour in his song. He laments the eternal tragedy of colour, and he concludes: "God gave Noah the rainbow sign/No more water, the fire next time."

Toni Morrison is in the line of great American writers like James Baldwin, but her form, style and vision are, if anything, more powerfully structured, and her affirmations, amidst rage, tend to isolate Baldwin’s rhetoric of wrath and his avangelical, prophetic tone. The Nobel Prize came to her in the fullness of her genius widely applauded in the media and in critical evaluations. Her novels — The Bluest Eye, Sula, Tar Baby, Song of Solomon, Beloved and Jazz make up a corpus of astonishing artistry and reach. I intend, however, to add brief comments only on the two books that had the strongest appeal Song of Solomon and Beloved.

Song of Solomon is an earlier novel and it’s chiefly the story of a Black youth, nicknamed Milkman, whose father Macon Dead (mark the tragic irony of names) is a boorish Black owner of blocks of tenements, a cruel husband and overbearing father. Milkman’s revolt takes time to come to a boil, but in the end he breaks free and loose, and his tragic suicidal leap brings this harrowing tale of Black suffering to its ineluctable end. Its form is essentially that of Bildungsroman, a tale of growing up and initiation, but unlike the stereotyped German genre, it’s not a story of an individual and his self, but of a bruised self within a community, within a shared destiny. Thus, its form is fragmented and episodic, and there are sliding panels within a time-scale. Brutalisation and bastardisation of a people who have no history, no country, no future, brings Milkman into contact with a secret Black group that believes in "eye for eye", but he breaks free to discover his identity, his race’s roots. It’s in the end and multiple tragedy of love, of trust and of faith in the Church. The Biblical title only confirms it. Song of Solomon is a visionary novel and we see Morrison’s soaring imagination at its best.

Beloved, a Pulitzer-Prize winner, is the story of a young girl called Amy, nicknamed Beloved, a runaway half-white whose mixed blood creates a special type of agonising alienation. It’s as much her story as that of Sethe who turns out to be her mother in the end. Morrison’s deep penetrating psychological probings take us inside the heads of different protagonists. The varied strains make up a complex tapestry, and the story becomes circular, the reader returning to the same situations as seen from another angle. Beloved, described as "a life-affirming" and "a mesmerising story", is one of the best in Morrison’s canon.

In her critique of "American Africanism" in a polemical essay, Playing in the Dark Morrison observes that the White American imagination needs a "nigger" to vindicate its own power-structure, its unhappy ambivalence, and its dubious metaphysics of human colonisation. Hence its technique of gothicism, as in Faulkner, to complexify its spiritual unease.