The Tribune - Spectrum

ART & LITERATURE
'ART AND SOUL
BOOKS
MUSINGS
TIME OFF
YOUR OPTION
ENTERTAINMENT
BOLLYWOOD BHELPURI
TELEVISION
WIDE ANGLE
FITNESS
GARDEN LIFE
NATURE
SUGAR 'N' SPICE
CONSUMER ALERT
TRAVEL
INTERACTIVE FEATURES
CAPTION CONTEST
FEEDBACK

Sunday, December 29, 2002
Books

Reflections on Buddhist reality
Arun Gaur

Buddhist Stories
by Paul Dahlke. Rupa & Co. Pages 330. Rs 150

Buddhist StoriesTHE present work, a set of five stories, is a reprint of the volume that was first published in 1913. The stories unravel the Buddhist reality that teaches one to overcome the perils of gold, fame, love, gods, death, and even life. This is the central motif that forms the basis of every story. Thus the issues tackled are essentially doctrinal — the transformation of the self, the recognition and cultivation of the ‘I’ (at the cost of ‘the other’), and in the end the renunciation of even this ‘I’. In between the grooming and shedding of this ‘I’ the ego confronts many experiences — archetypal as well as mundane.

Gautama of Death and Life opts for the untrodden path and eventually overcomes death. Doubt and reflection become important instruments of exploring reality. "Gone are all the gods! and we must "only seek after what is certain in ourselves." Love makes us murderers, and "all clinging brings suffering." Gautama has to journey to the great mountain for knowledge: "There you will see Mount Meru." Knowledge here comes through mystical ways and the dialectic is enigmatic: "But how shall I recognise it?" "When you see it, it will see you." When death is eventually vanquished, quizzically, the desire for such a victory also vanishes: "Death is to me even as life, and life is to me even as death." This finality is suggested by a crane hiding his head in his own feathers, floating on a crystal clear lake.

 


Out of this rugged, romantic, and lofty Himalayan journey laden with symbols we come down to the urban milieu of Architect of his Fate (epistolary in style) in Colombo. Nanda, the lover, leaves his beloved Punna in the custody of his friend Kosiya wondering: "Will my Kosiya in friendship and my Punna in love thus persistently endure?" At first Kosiya almost sounds like a braggart mouthing Buddhist propositions of a life free from desire. He even warns Nanda of receiving "crooked answers" from pestered Fate. Like John Donne, he can make fine discourses on love, but in love he is himself reduced to shambles. From "a despiser of love" he graduates to an ardent, almost foolish admirer: "How moving she is! Her coquetry is even more natural than the naturalness of coquettes." He is startled at the change in himself: "Now I continue just because I do know her!" He apotheosised the woman and in the process devalues himself to "Fool that I was!" The situation is hopeless in the end: "I am as one mangled, crushed flat beneath the iron wheels of Fate." Ironically, he falls a victim to his own tautology: "The deceiver becomes a deceived deceiver, and cannot find his way back again." Punna suffers an identical fate. From a future husband’s "spy" Kosyia for her becomes "a remarkable man." This leads to self-probing and ultimate renunciation: "I cannot belong to you any more than to any one else." This "dissolution of the questioner" is the crooked answer that Nanda gets from Fate. He realises that the world of love is a world of "frailty" and "misery" where an artificial/accidental "sudden flaring up" decides one’s fate.

Love is also a subject of exploration in the next story The Love of Humanity. The credentials of the all-encompassing love of Christian missionaries are questioned dramatically through the ideological conflict between the father Revata, a devoted Buddhist, and Silananda, the son who has turned a Christian preacher. For Revata the only "sure road begins at the personal I." Henrietta Stevenson becomes unwittingly the source of the most stinging critique of Silananda: "No amount of instruction, no Mission, can make a man of faith out of a man void of faith." That is the problem with Silananda. As a born Buddhist he cannot cultivate the Christian faith and after a miserable experience with the natives in which he only succeeds in making a fool of himself, he comes back to his roots, relinquishing his Christian pretensions, perceiving that Buddhist "passivity" and "egoism" are not what he had derisively taken them to be in the past.

Besides judging others, the theme of overcoming death through the renunciation of even ‘I’ is taken up in the final story Renunciation. Maung Hpay, the magistrate in the town of Akyab in Burma, encounters his moment of crisis when a chip knocked off his tooth forces him to reflect; "So passes away our body." But his preparation for the eventuality by bestowing lavish gifts on the pauper goes haywire when one of his gifts causes a murder. From there the question arises: "Are men justified at all in sitting in judgment upon others?" Abandon everything, even one’s self, to possess all. His final reflection, at the Monastery at Moulmein, is: "Thus I must be annihilated." Only then he is able to cast an indifferent eye on life and death and is able to sleep even with Tik Polonga, the deadly snake, in his lap.

The stories assemble Biblical adages and parables. Through an explication of symbols there is an attempt to impart knowledge of the Buddhist doctrine to the reader.

If one is to select the best story in the given collection Architect of his Fate would be our choice because it makes us reflect upon the phenomenon of love.