The Tribune - Spectrum

ART & LITERATURE
'ART AND SOUL
BOOKS
MUSINGS
TIME OFF
YOUR OPTION
ENTERTAINMENT
BOLLYWOOD BHELPURI
TELEVISION
WIDE ANGLE
FITNESS
GARDEN LIFE
NATURE
SUGAR 'N' SPICE
CONSUMER ALERT
TRAVEL
INTERACTIVE FEATURES
CAPTION CONTEST
FEEDBACK

Sunday, December 29, 2002
Books

India in the US scheme of things
T. V. Rajeswar

Waiting for America – India and the US in the New Millennium.
Sunanda K. Datta Ray. Harper Collins. Pages 471. Rs. 595

Waiting for America -- India and the US in the New MillenniumWAITING for America spans the entire gamut of Indo-US relations since India’s independence, with detailed coverage on selective periods. The Kashmir issue before the United Nations became a matter of serious controversy between India and the USA because of the equivocal stand taken by the latter. On critical occasions, it was the Russian veto that stood between Western maneuvering and India’s stand on the Kashmir issue. This plagues Indo-US relations even today, although the USA has considerably matured in handling the Kashmir problem.

The unwillingness of the USA to supply arms and ammunition to India from the very beginning has been amply documented. Indian efforts began in 1948 when India’s Ambassador to the USA, Girija Shankar Bajpai, sought military cooperation. India was given a brush off as the USA believed that Pakistan, not India, was one of the most strategic areas in the world and that it could provide "a staging area for forces engaged in the defence or recapture of the Middle East oil reserves".

India’s quest for military assistance from the USA was renewed in the aftermath of the Sino-Indian war in the North Eastern Frontier Agency (NEFA), now Arunachal Pradesh. It was the tragic result of a series of miscalculations at the highest level in the decision making political hierarchy of India. The debacle in NEFA nudged India to seek sophisticated aircraft, arms and ammunition from the USA. While India did receive arms and ammunition, it did not get aircraft. Nevertheless an arrangement was worked out whereby India and the USA cooperated in carrying out reconnaissance flights across China by US aircraft based in India.

 


The Bangladesh war in 1972 witnessed the nadir in Indo-US relations, due to the blatant US tilt at the instance of Nixon and Kissinger. Fakir Syed Aijazuddin’s recent book The White House and Pakistan: Secret De-classified Documents 1969-74, based on documents recently made available, gives a wealth of information on the visits of Kissinger and President Nixon to China, the emergence of rift between the USSR and China and the determined efforts of the USA to push China into attacking India for rescuing Pakistan whose army was crumbling in the brief Bangladesh war. Prime Minister Indira Gandhi withstood the threats and pressures from the USA and completed the task in Bangladesh.

Datta Ray has provided a wealth of information on the gunboat diplomacy of the USA and the UK on the Middle East oil reserves. The overthrow of Mohammed Mossadeq, Iranian Prime Minister in 1951, after he nationalised the monopolistic British Petroleum in Iran, by the joint efforts of the USA and British "intelligence agencies changed the history of West Asia." It restored the hated Pahelvi royalty which later led to the emergence of Islamic fundamentalists headed by the Ayatollah.

Lord Wavell had indeed anticipated the emerging power struggle. Addressing the Royal Central Asian Society in 1949, he said that "the next great struggle for world power, if it takes place, may well be for the control of the oil reserves of the Middle East." The overthrow of Mossadeq of Iran was the first step in this direction. The Kuwait war launched by President Bush Sr. along with his Western allies, after Saddam Hussain of Iraq overran Kuwait, was largely for the control of Kuwait’s oil reserves. Adm. William J. Crowe, former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, had put the issue in correct perspective when he commented that the USA would not have bothered defending Kuwait if it had exported bananas.

The war cry of President Bush against Iraq has been termed as primarily focused on the USA’s vital interest in accessing Iraq’s vast oil reserves. Since there is no evidence that Saddam Hussain has nuclear weapons, an all-out war, for which preparations are going ahead in full steam, looks very much oil centric. Daniel Ellsberg, known as the patron saint of whistle blowers, has recently come out with a new book, Secrets: A Memoir of Vietnam and the Pentagon Papers. Constraint of space inhibits extensive quotes; suffice to cite just one: Since Sept 9, 2001 the USA has experienced the unchecked resurgence of the "imperial presidency".

Datta Ray has also dealt extensively with the post-Pokhran events and the phase of sanctions imposed on India (and Pakistan). President Clinton ruefully wondered, after India went nuclear, "if neglect had not goaded India?" He added, "Well, I think they have been under-appreciated in the world and in the USA." Clinton did try to set the balance right towards the end of his presidency, particularly after the Kargil misadventure of Pakistan.

Datta Ray should be congratulated on his monumental effort. This book deserves to be kept in the libraries of Indian embassies, institutions dealing with security studies and universities.