|
Eight out of the 11 papers deal with studies and records of
local plant diversity, mainly of Rajasthan area. There is
information on the plant species diversity of Jhalawar, Hadoti
plateau, Kota-Udaipur, Ramganj Mandi and protected areas of
Rajasthan. One paper records the plant species of wetlands of
Birbhum, West Bengal. Two research papers — on ‘Indoor
environment’ and ‘Effects of seasonal variation in
photosynthetic pigments of few planted tree species of Bhopal’
— not even remotely related to biodiversity also find their
way into the volume. The articles provide general information on
biodiversity. They have a naive and all-embracing approach,
which compromises the focused, in-depth and serious writing
style necessary for scientific writing.
Biodiversity
includes all forms of biological entities, including
micro-organisms, plants, animals and genetic materials like
seeds and germ plasm. However, the absence of a single
contribution dealing with life forms other than plants, detracts
from the book’s comprehensiveness. The sweeping title of the
volume suggests an emphasis on strategies of conservation of
biodiversity, which are touched upon, but only in one or two of
the contributions.
Putting the myriad
contributions into an orderly sequence, from general articles to
specific papers and maintaining a uniform format for all of them
would have rendered the volume more user-friendly. The volume,
according to editors, aims at helping the students, teachers and
researchers in their pursuits. Discrepancies in references could
become a hindrance in achieving this objective. Capital letters
creeping up at wrong places and several grammatical, spelling
and printing errors throughout the book cause much irritation to
the reader. The universal convention of using italics while
writing scientific names of plants is maintained sporadically.
The index is replete with several mistakes and is not
exhaustive.
The highly priced
volume seems to be a hasty attempt at cashing in on the
international focus on biodiversity. Though it cannot be denied
that with 35 per cent of our country’s geographical regions
still unexplored for biodiversity, more such region-specific
studies are required. However, in order to find their rightful
place in the international scenario, it is also essential that
these publications are truly scientific in their approach,
report quality research and are highly professional in their
presentation. Sadly, the present volume misses much on this
score.
|