The Tribune - Spectrum
 
ART & LITERATURE
'ART AND SOUL
BOOKS
MUSINGS
TIME OFF
YOUR OPTION
ENTERTAINMENT
BOLLYWOOD BHELPURI
TELEVISION
WIDE ANGLE
FITNESS
GARDEN LIFE
NATURE
SUGAR 'N' SPICE
CONSUMER ALERT
TRAVEL
INTERACTIVE FEATURES
CAPTION CONTEST
FEEDBACK
 

Sunday
, July 8, 2002
Books

WRITE VIEW
A chalta hai attitude mars a perfect plot
Randeep Wadehra

A Twist in Destiny
by Sujata S. Sabnis, Roli Books, N. Delhi. Pages: 335. Price: Rs. 295.

A Twist in DestinyHERE is a thriller that has all the ingredients of a bestseller----political intrigue, suspense, murder and a dash of star-crossed love. Erudite minds have speculated about the country’s destiny in case the well-kept secret of Jinnah’s fatal disease had been revealed before Partition. Sabnis assumes that in such an eventuality, Pakistan would never have been born. Thus, a united and powerful India would have entered the new millennium. In the novel, India becomes independent as a single entity comprising the present Pakistan and Bangladesh.

In the novel, Manu reveals Jinnah’s deadly secret to Nehru who, after consulting Kripalani and Patel, successfully opposes the Partition. But in 2001, a separatist organisation, Quom-e-Majlis, triggers off terrorist violence to achieve a separate Muslim homeland--- Pakistan. The Home Minister Farzana Hussain and the CBI chief Parvez Beg do everything to vanquish the separatists. Reshma Kapoor – a journalist from Rawalpindi – innocently sparks off events that climax in a surprising manner.

The denouement is competently handled. But the beginning puts one off: cliched snapshots of the 1947 Punjab, Bengal and Delhi; stereotype images of those who would not believe that the Partition was imminent, spewing rhetoric. The characterisation could have been better. The assassin’s psyche and that of the ‘master brain’ could have been explored deeply enough to make them come alive in the narrative.

 


Shoddy proofreading (barely as ‘bairly’ on p.327; back as ‘beck’ on p.233; "…is there is (sic) anything…" on p.198; there as ‘their’ on p.166 etc), inelegant phrases (wolf in a pack of hyenas…p.166; furious food for thought p.108; …that divides the sun from freakish stars…p.90; pale wan face…p.69; a wealth of unhappiness…p.64; etc), and a jerky narrative peppered with professorial pontifications can be daunting. A racy style would have been far more apt.

However, after the first fifty pages the narrative picks up.

***

India Under Strain
by Dr. T.H. Chowdary, CTMS, Secunderabad. Pages: xxii + 328.
Price: Rs. 100

India Under StrainThe country’s independence generated in the common Indian’s heart great expectations of a life free from want, violence and vicissitudes that a slave nation suffers. Dubbed as a basket case by the global community, we have made impressive progress since. But problems remain. Chowdary gives a brief historical background to our socio-cultural complexities that challenge the ruling establishment’s administrative acumen to the hilt. Even the political spectrum poses problems. Nani Palkhiwala often said, "It requires superhuman power to keep India poor." But the author suspects our Communists of plotting to weaken and even break up India.

He blames Nehru for the Kashmir problem as well as for the border problems with China, among other things. The Nehru government committed many mistakes – several of them have proved costly to the nation. But Nehru also provided emotional integration to the disparate subcultures within the country. He gave us the vision of a technologically advanced India – peace-loving yet strong; egalitarian yet prosperous; a leader of the Third World with all the salient traits of a world power.

There are many interesting chapters on the Muslim ‘problem’, the Nehruvian legacy etc. The chapter, "Who created Pakistan?" is quite interesting. He quotes several Muslim authors to argue that the Hindu Right had no role in the country’s partition. The Muslims were primarily responsible for the deed. This is rather hard to accept. He does not give much credibility to the secular school of Indian history and is deeply suspicious of communists. I’m sure our Leftist intellectuals would like to go through this book.

***

‘Hindutva’ Demystified‘Hindutva’ Demystified
by Virendra Prakash, Virgo Publications, New Delhi. Pages: 187.
Price: Rs. 295/-.

Hindutva hasn’t been merely the flavor of drawing room exchanges but political and social scientists now look upon it as a part of the global, especially European, shift towards the Right. This book appears to be a reaction to the Godhra / Gujarat carnage. Even though the emotional content is rather high, the author makes a pertinent point – Hindutva and Hinduism are two separate concepts. Politicians are trying to fuse the two to serve their own ends.

***

 

Dr. Ambedkar & Social Justice

 

Dr. Ambedkar & Social Justice
by M.G. Chitkara, APH, New Delhi. Pages: xxxiv + 259. Price: Rs. 495/-.

This book is one more addition to the ever-growing corpus on this amazing man of his times who overcame all social handicaps and became a major player on the Indian socio-political stage. He has left a lasting influence on our thought processes. Chitkara tells us his life story. The book has such irrelevant cliches like "Love thy neighbor… It is easier to love the whole of humanity than to love one’s neighbor…" Ouch!