The Tribune - Spectrum
 
ART & LITERATURE
'ART AND SOUL
BOOKS
MUSINGS
TIME OFF
YOUR OPTION
ENTERTAINMENT
BOLLYWOOD BHELPURI
TELEVISION
WIDE ANGLE
FITNESS
GARDEN LIFE
NATURE
SUGAR 'N' SPICE
CONSUMER ALERT
TRAVEL
INTERACTIVE FEATURES
CAPTION CONTEST
FEEDBACK



Sunday
, May 12, 2002
Books

Listening to women writers’ voices
Review by Ashu Pasricha

Women and Self by Rajni Walia Delhi: Book plus, 2001, Pages: 200, Rs 400.

FEMINIST research has unearthed a mine of unacknowledged women’s writing from the past and from diverse nations and cultures. Among women novelists, it is usually Jane Austen, who is singled out as a name worth mentioning. She is followed by other well-known women novelists, like the Bronte sisters. George Eliot and Virginia Woolf.

Virginia Woolf herself admitted in her Professions for Women, "For the road was cut many years ago by many famous women and many more unknown and forgotten have been before me, making the path smooth and regulating my steps." The problem with such a perspective is that it accords no recognition to the minor novelists and blurs the continuities in women’s writing.

When feminist research centred its concentration on women’s writing, it began by recovering and rediscovering women writers and their lost texts from those periods of history where they were held to be nonexistent. This not only aided in filling the gaps in what were previously thought to be periods of silence in women’s writing but also helped to trace a continuous thread in women’s literary productivity.

 


According to the book under review, "Women and self, proposes a feminist perspective for interpreting the literary texts of writers who profess no overt feminist aim. It examines how the novelists tap their autobiographical ‘self’ through their protagonists and fictionalise the process of the emerging empowerment within women, through their ability for reviewing self."

These chapters have offered a close, textual study of selected novels by Rhys. Pym and Brookner, preceded by an analysis of their other fiction. The aim has been to examine the self-appraisal of these novelists who tap their autobiographical ‘self’ through their female protagonists and bring into focus, the social construction of femininity in the patriarchal set-up.

Women-centered novels, written by Rhys, Pym and Brookner are bound by similar thematic patterns. The dilemma of the centrality yet inadequacy of heterosexual relations for the female protagonists, loneliness and brooding self-exploration, are some of the common themes running across their fiction. There is no idealising or sentimentalising of the female in their novels. However, in the patriarchal social structure, the woman is accorded a secondary status. She is the ‘other’ that confirms the subjectivity of the male but is excluded from the subject position, the importance of these women writers lies initially in delving within their self, to formulate the ‘female self’ as a subject in its own right.

When their novels are studied in juxtaposition, as it is done in the present book, the fiction of these writers reveals the variety of artistic response in dealing with similar concerns, which recur and coalesce as thematic patterns in their novels.

Romantic yearning, unrequited love, loneliness and self-exploration are dealt with comic resignation by Pym. Rhys deals with the issues with tragic emotional intensity by Rhys and an unflinchingly clear-eyed, tragicomic vision by Brookner.

The fiction of these women writers implicity hints at the requirement for fostering mutuality and giving primacy to the values of loving and caring, which are generally associated with women and regarded as secondary in patriarchal contexts. There is no outright condemnation of social inequities in their fiction but it’s "potentially radical aspect" is contained within its dimension of self-exploration.

A prominent strain in the novels of these women writers is the autobiographical ‘self’. Their fiction is not autobiographical in the sense of simply describing their entire lives but incorporates the woman writer’s scrutiny of the ‘feminine self’.

It illumines the frustrations, conflicts and contradictions faced by the women protagonists, because of the internationalisation of certain social prescriptions for ‘feminine’ behaviour. The book examines how the analysis of the self emerges from the protagonists’ thought process as well as from the author’s bid for aesthetic control, through her wry ironic voice with its implicit critique of aspects of the self and of the society.

The writer proposes a feminist perspective for interpreting the fiction of these writers, who have not consciously formulated a feminist commitment, without making exceptionally large claims. The analysis centres around how writers mirror the process of emerging empowerment of women, through their growing awareness and ability for appraising and re-visioning the concept of personal identity. The book is a contribution in the area of women’s writing and women studies.