SPECIAL COVERAGE
CHANDIGARH

LUDHIANA

DELHI


THE TRIBUNE SPECIALS
50 YEARS OF INDEPENDENCE

TERCENTENARY CELEBRATIONS



M A I N   N E W S

Manpreet Badal’S resignation Letter
‘I can’t contribute to SAD decline’
...some leaders do not understand elementary economics

Dear Chief Minister S. Parkash Singh Badal Ji,

Manpreet Badal addresses mediapersons in Chandigarh on Wednesday.
Manpreet Badal addresses mediapersons in Chandigarh on Wednesday. A Tribune photograph

Ever since I joined public service 15 years ago in Gidderbaha, I have looked upon you with respect and awe for your political sagacity and ability to take people along. No one in Punjab enjoys your stature, and people like me have been blessed to enjoy your association not only as your minister, but on a more personal note to be a member of what used to be a very close knit family.

I also remember the day when as a five year old, I canvassed for the first time. I stood on the dais in Gidderbaha asking people to vote for you. I even remember the exact words I spoke, “Mere taiyaji nu vote pao”. My political career may have started that day. But it was in 1995 when you chose me to take on the might of the Beant Singh Government, that I genuinely cut my political teeth. That day you and my father jointly blessed me. More important is that you taught me not to bend before injustice, and to stand up for what is right. That is a lesson, which I value and will continue to value throughout my life. It was not easy those days. As I realize now, it is not easy even today. Standing up for what is right may never be easy in times to come

There comes a time in the life of an individual, when he or she has to take a principled position which is based on what is right. This is consistent with the core values on which I base my politics. And this decision, which I take today, is supported by the lesson that I learnt from you and my father on that fateful day in 1995

During the four terms as MLA and for almost four years now as the Finance Minister of Punjab, all my decisions have been guided by just one aim - to serve the best interests of Punjab and Punjabis. All my decisions have been founded on the bedrock of one principle - that each decision and opinion has to be well thought out and should be supported by informed facts.

In serving the best interests of the State of Punjab, I have consistently refused to accept ill-informed opinions based on self-interests of conceited individuals. I have refused to compromise on the issue of principles, and I have not allowed myself to be dictated by vested parties. When I embarked upon the reform process in Punjab, these self serving interests, who are unable to look beyond their bank balances refused to take a careful look at the balance sheet of Punjab.

When I tried to take a step, attempts were made to shackle my feet. When I tried to speak, my voice was sought to be muzzled. When I tried to move, I was sought to be restrained. When I tried to serve the best interests of Punjab, personal interests tried to derail me.

But I refused to be cowed down. Because I know that my intentions are clear and my heart is in the right place. I refuse to be intimidated by a fringe of lumpen party men who wish to drown the voice of reason by their decibel levels.

The panic reaction within a section of the Shiromani Akali Dal after I spoke about unburdening Punjab of its debt is confounding. It not only speaks of a lack of political maturity, but also of a low level of self-confidence and esteem in the party. Coming from the second oldest political party in the country, which did not bend before the British during the pre-independence days and was the vanguard of freedom of expression during the emergency days - this reaction is unexpected. Is the party edifice now so weak that it can not even discuss issues; and that all party resources, the bureaucracy and police are being marshaled so that the issue that I raised should not be discussed? More than that, I am saddened by what has happened inside the party as well. Stalwarts of the party, who were famous as Generals and took on terrorists during the dark days, have today been reduced to foot soldiers. They are being forced to kowtow to new entrants who have neither political acumen nor administrative experience. Frankly, I can only pity such former stalwarts and I will not join them. I do wish them luck so that they can continue to reap the benefits of kowtowing.

I will now touch the issue of debt burden of Punjab, which I have been discussing with you all along. I am willing to stake my entire political career on the issue of Punjab finances.

I thought the attempt to remove the stigma of debt from the face of Punjab would be lauded. But it seems that a certain section in the party wants Punjab to continue to be debt ridden? I do not accept this premise. I thought that only our enemies would wish that Punjab continues to remain debt ridden. But just to reiterate, what I have told you and the council of ministers repeatedly, that if immediate remedial steps are not taken, Punjab will default on its repayments in another 2-3 years.

I would rather spend a few difficult years today, than allow opportunities for an entire generation to be wiped out just because some leaders do not understand elementary economics-i.e. you can only spend if you have the money. Scores of farmers committed suicide during the past decades because of the debt trap. And now, a few self-concerted individuals want Punjab to follow the same route. I will not accept this.

The stakes for Punjab are very high. It is a question of the very survival of the well being of the state, as well as that of the next generation. My personal stakes are very low. It is a question of Punjab’s honor and I shall continue to strive for its rightful place under the sun.

Positions are not important, prestige is. Ministries are not important, honor is.

Keeping in view the above-mentioned facts, I hereby resign from the position of Finance Minister of the Punjab.

Dear CM Sahib, I am proud of the day in Gidderbaha in 1995, when after 17 years, my victory was responsible for the revival of political fortunes of the Shiromani Akali Dal. Today, I cannot contribute to its decline.

Jai Hind.

Yours sincerely,

(Manpreet Singh Badal)

Sardar Parkash Singh Badal,
Hon. Chief Minister, Punjab
Copy to His Excellency,
the Governor of Punjab

Back

 

 

Manpreet couldn’t do much to boost Punjab’s economy
Ruchika M. Khanna/TNS

Chandigarh, October 13
He has always been a lone ranger in the populism-dominated Akali politics. But in his political alienation over the debt waiver issue and his stand against politics of subsidies, Manpreet Badal has succeeded in bringing the economic reforms agenda in the forefront of Punjab’s political arena.

Manpreet may have lost his job as Punjab’s Finance Minister over the issue, which he claims is very close to his heart, but he has succeeded in raising the issue of fiscal mess of the state as the main talking point, not just in the corridors of power but also among the electorate on the streets.

By raking up the issue in the recently concluded Punjab Assembly session, Manpreet managed to do what no other Finance Minister had been able to do before him -- that is to create a political consensus on the issue of debt waiver. Right from his bete noire and cousin Sukhbir Badal to former Chief Minister Amarinder Singh and the state BJP leadership, everybody has voiced their opinion in favour of the debt waiver, though there may have been a difference of opinion on the preconditions suggested by the Centre.

Manpreet’s three-and-a-half-year tenure as Finance Minister, however, has not been the most glorious for salvaging Punjab’s sagging economy. In fact, he has often been accused of raising the highest debt in the form of external commercial borrowings, taking the total debt of the state from Rs 48,000 crore to Rs 71,000 crore.

Former Punjab Finance Minister Surinder Singla also accuses him of putting in state guarantees for non- productive loans (like the ones taken by the now disbanded PSEB), thus adding to the state’s debt burden.

Back

 

 

Day of intense action

n Several political leaders who left their respective constituency for Chandigarh to know firsthand about the political developments in the state capital were told by the SAD high-ups to return back, lest their presence is taken as support for Manpreet.

n The CM waited anxiously to know what Manpreet was up to. Badal Senior was hopeful that Manpreet would adopt reconciliatory posture. But when his nephew decided to hold a press conference, in which he indicated he would challenge his cousin Sukhbir’s leadership, the CM signed the suspension letter.

n Initially, both the SAD government and Manpreet tried to play one-upmanship by harping on what materialised first -- the sack or the resignation letter. Manpreet, however, put an end to it by saying “it does not matter what come first. The reality is I had enough of it and have nothing to do with them (read SAD leadership)”.

n As a show of strength, several supporters from Manpreet’s constituency Gidderbaha had been campaigning at his house all night while he was away to Delhi to meet the BJP leadership.

n Manpreet’s residence wore isolated look in the morning, with only a few people showing up to express solitary with him.

Back

 

 

 





HOME PAGE | Punjab | Haryana | Jammu & Kashmir | Himachal Pradesh | Regional Briefs | Nation | Opinions |
| Business | Sports | World | Letters | Chandigarh | Ludhiana | Delhi |
| Calendar | Weather | Archive | Subscribe | Suggestion | E-mail |