SHORT TAKES
Soldiers, poets and prisoners of hate
Reviewed by Randeep Wadehra

The Soldiers’ 2nd Innings 
by Maj Gen Surjit Singh (retd) & 
Lt Col Kanwal Dev Singh (retd)
MacMillan.
Pages: xx+139. Rs 495.

A majority of the soldiers in our Armed Forces, especially in the Indian Army, retire young. This is as true of the commissioned officers as it is of the personnel belonging to the Other Ranks (ORs). While a significant number of ORs — aka jawans — retire while in their thirties, officers generally retire in their forties and fifties. The latter, as this book admits, are economically secure while the former have to struggle in Civvy Street for their survival.

Written partially in anecdotal style, this book’s chapters, Angry Old Soldiers and In Search of a Solution to the Problem, deal with one-rank-one-pension-related issues. Another chapter, SWOT Analysis and Classification of Jobs, gives details of the careers that officers can take up post-retirement. There are separate chapters on career opportunities in the corporate sector in India as well as abroad. The book also outlines various pros and cons of writing wills. It also describes their different types, like joint wills, mutual wills etc, with their respective advantages and disadvantages.

How one wishes there was a separate chapter on career prospects for ORs whose educational profile has improved vastly over the years. There are impressive numbers of law, engineering and management graduates among these personnel who do not have the advantage of possessing "brass credentials" to impress recruiters in the civil sector and thus need guidance as well as inputs.

A Poetic Panorama
by Prof. RN Kaul
UBSPD.
Pages 70. Rs 105.

Poetry is truly "the Cinderella of the Arts". It has suffered much and has still managed to survive, occasionally finding happiness and even prosperity when noticed by a ‘prince’ like Vikram Seth. But, while novels and short stories have attracted the best of talent and public acclaim, poetry has generally remained a supplicant ever since its former patron — the royalty —became extinct. In India, English poetry’s status is worse than that of a scullery maid. Kaul is a brave soul to practice this art when no publisher would touch a poetry manuscript even with a barge pole.

I quote below some of the lines from Kaul’s anthology:

When the mind’s mirror is pelted/By one’s own genes/ It gets cracked; (The Mind’s Mirror)

Tear the veil apart/ To shreds let it fall/ Widen the hole/ Let me look beyond/ And see the eternal light; (The Eternal Light).

However, most of his poems are barely above the ordinary. Indian poetry in English needs to be, in the late British poet Mathew Arnold’s words, "A criticism of life under the conditions fixed for such a criticism by the laws of poetic truth and poetic beauty".

Prisoners of Hate
by CV Murali.
Cedar Books.
Pages 259. Rs 195.

Communal violence has become a regular feature of our daily life. The politics of grievance, competitive parochialism and other such factors have been vitiating our societal environs for a long time now. Islamic terrorism is only the latest manifestation of this hydra-headed monster. But how does this phenomenon affect the individual in the street? We really don’t have much literature — fiction or non-fiction —to come to any conclusion. Therefore, this novel is a welcome addition to the meager corpus. It tells us the story of three individuals Farhan, Sanjay and Madhav reacting to the contemporary violence-ridden society. At least three generations of their respective families have had experiences over the time spanning pre-independent India to post-independent India, which was partitioned at birth, leaving behind trails of death, destruction and enduring animosities.

While Murali has competently explored the protagonists’ mindscapes, his intervention as a sutradhaar is really not required in the narrative.





HOME