Smart shopping for sabzi

Consumers are sure to be spoilt for choice as shopping for fruits and vegetables, milk and dairy products becomes a hassle-free experience. Ruchika M. Khanna looks at the impact of these retail marts which are fast coming up

These stores offer a variety of exotic vegetables and imported fruits.
These stores offer a variety of exotic vegetables and imported fruits. — Tribune photo by Manoj Mahajan

With the entry of corporates in the agri-retail business, this sector is fast evolving from the weekly market format to convenience stores, current day malls, supermarkets and hypermarkets. And this retail revolution is not going to be restricted to the metropolitans or the category I and category II towns. The booming Indian economy has opened the doors for these stores to set shop in towns like Barnala and Samrala in Punjab to Pehowa and Shahabad Markanda in Haryana.

Ask Narinder Kaur, a resident of Samrala, who is now buying her groceries from the Godrej Aadhar store in her small town. "Earlier, I would go to Ludhiana for my shopping, but now I can get a good shopping experience here itself," she says.

Her views are supported by Navdeep Kapoor, a senior official in Spice Telecom at Chandigarh. He says that with the opening of agri-retail stores, the upwardly mobile like him do not mind shopping for their veggies and fruits. "Earlier, we would rely on our servants to buy the vegetables from the neighbourhood shops or the vegetable and fruit vendors. With the opening of these stores in the city, we have started buying our weekly supply at our time and convenience.

These stores offer a variety of exotic vegetables and imported fruits to choose from. The fruits and vegetables are available at same price, and sometimes lesser price, than at the sabzi mandi," he says.

India is undoubtedly emerging as the hotspot on the global retail map, especially after the opening of the retail sector to foreign direct investment. The concept of agri-retailing was first brought to India by Mother Dairy in Delhi, in the early 1980s.

Now, with DCM Sriram Consolidated’s Hariyali Kisan Bazar, Reliance Fresh, Subhiksha, Spencers Retail, Food Bazar, Godrej Agrovet, Adani Agri Fresh and of course, Bharti-Walmart, all set to spread their wings across Indian cities, buying your fruits, vegetables and groceries will never be the same again. With these retail majors all set to woo the customers with the choicest of fruits and vegetable in air-conditioned and clean environs of a showroom, and without causing a dent in your household budget, the agri retail sector will see a metamorphosis in the coming three to five years.

Boom in retail

With the retail mart business in the country now pegged at $ 12 billion (accounting for just three per cent of the total market), it has tremendous growth potential in the fast-expanding Indian economy. Organised retail in the Rs 1,45,000 crore fruit and vegetable business, is estimated at about Rs 300 crore. In the last three months, over 60 outlets have opened across the country. Fresh food accounts for 50 per cent of the food and grocery bills in India, as compared to 15 per cent in the USA. No wonder that 4 lakh square feet of retail space has been dedicated to fresh food retailing in the country. And this is just the beginning`85

King consumer

As Rajan Bharti Mittal, Joint Managing Director, Bharti Enterprises, says, "The boom in this sector will not only benefit millions of consumers, but also farmers, small manufacturers and artisans. This sector will also offer enormous direct and indirect employment opportunities while attracting huge investments in building the supply-chain infrastructure, adding to economic growth of India, especially in the rural areas". Bharti, along with Walmart, will be investing Rs 11,000 crore to set up retail stores across the country, by 2011.

The largely agrarian economy of India has been in the doldrums, with the production per acre having reached a plateau and the area under agriculture declining rapidly. With a staggering growth rate in agriculture (2.3 per cent) and high rural indebtedness, the boom in agri-retail is expected to fuel growth in the agriculture sector, besides improving the financial condition of farmers. Punjab has gained infamy for having the third largest extent of rural indebtedness in the country, after Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu, with the highest magnitude of indebtedness in rural households in the country (with per capita debt of Rs 41, 576). In Haryana, too, over 53 per cent farmer households in are under debt, with an average outstanding per capita debt of Rs 26,007.

Seeing the boom for apple growers in Himachal Pradesh and mango growers in Ratnagiri, Maharashtra, after their produce was picked up by corporates last year, NABARD, too, is recommending that farmers gear up and form producer groups so that they can tie up with agri-retail majors for selling their produce. Krishan Kalra, Secretary General of PHD Chamber of Commerce and Industry, says that with 700 million people seeking employment in agriculture sector, and its slow growth, the only way out will be to ensure increase in productivity per acre and increase in productivity per man—which could be helped with the financial and technological assistance of the corporates entering into agri-retail.

Win-win situation

With retailing in India set to touch Rs 1. 1 lakh crore by 2010, (provided it gets an investment of Rs 20,000 crore), it would be a win-win situation for farmers. A study conducted by Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) says

development of organised retailing will lead to increased efficiency in the agriculture sector and remove intermediaries in the food supply chain. With investments in upgrading technology and agricultural practices in the entire value chain, including production, packaging, grading, storage and logistics, the current levels of wastage, ranging between 24 per cent to 40 per cent, are expected to come down drastically.

Impact on market

Though the blitzkrieg on organised retailing having caught the fancy of the economists and policy markers in the country, not a single independent study has been conducted to examine the impact of organised retail on the 12 million small shopkeeper, 40 million hawkers and 200 million small farmers.

While the government functionaries and industry leaders dismiss all fears of this leading to unemployment, experiences from countries like USA and UK, where organised retail occupies 70 – 90 per cent of the total retail business, suggests that they have a direct influence on the small and unorganised players in the market. A recent study conducted in the USA, measured the impact of Wal-Mart’s retail boom on prevailing poverty. Even when the poverty rates were down across USA, states were the retail major had set up its operations had led to displacement of workers from small shops; and, destruction of local entrepreneurship.

As organised retail becomes a reality in India, a section of economists fear that unfettered FDI in retail could further compound existing poverty. With FDI in agriculture sector being allowed without first dealing with the agrarian crisis in the country, many fear that the objective is to transfer the unwanted and risky technology of genetic engineering on plants and animals in India. "We must ensure that agriculture is not sacrificed at the cost of industry," says Rajesh Krishnan, Campaigner for Greenpeace.

However, industry rubbishes these fears and says that a boom in agri-retail is the only way to revive a slackening growth in agriculture sector. A study by the Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) and Pricewaterhouse Coopers (PwC) suggests that the development of organised retail will generate an additional eight million jobs, directly and indirectly. The study, The Rising Elephant: Benefits of Modern Trade to Indian Economy, suggests that by year 2020, India will lead in the retail sector.

Allaying fears of FDI in retail creating unemployment by wiping out the kiryana stores, the study said that only those working in one lakh mid- category stores were likely to be displaced in the mid-term, as against the workforce employed in 12 million retail outlets across the country. In the long run, the metamorphosis in this sector would lead to the redeployment of this workforce also.

What they say

R S Chauhan, President of Apple Growers Association of India and leading orchardist in Kotkhai, Himachal Pradesh:

The entry of corporates in the agriculture sector will benefit the farmers, who will get the best price for their produce. The corporates in the apple belt of Himachal Pradesh, who arrived last year, took the produce at good prices from the farm gate. Farmers were saved the unscheduled expenses of packaging and transporting produce.

Dr S S Johl, leading farm economist and former Vice Chairman, Planning Board, Punjab:

When corporates enter the market as a purely marketing and farm produce collection centre, the farmers stand to benefit. These corporates advise the farmers on best grade of produce, quality and effective farm practices to ensure quality, which enables farmers to get renumerative prices.

Avtar Singh Dhindsa, leading floriculturist and Chairman of Chamber of Punjab farmers:

The boom in agri-retail will help not just the big farmers, but also small farmers who can be clubbed into producer groups and then sell their produce to corporates.


Major players in the North

The following companies are engaged in contract farming and source their produce from these farmers, after advising them on the best farm practices, seeds and fertilisers.

Godrej Agrovet already has 33 Aadhar stores across the country, which it plans to increase to 45 very soon. The company started its fruits, vegetables, dairy and poultry retail business through their Nature’s Basket stores. While seven Nature’s Basket stores are already functioning in Mumbai, the group plans to add another eight in Mumbai itself, before its sets base in Delhi, Gurgaon, Hyderabad, Chennai, Chandigarh, Amritsar and Ludhiana, says R S Vijan, Executive Vice President, Godrej Agrovet.

Subhiksha, the discount retail major, plans to open 104 retail outlets in Punjab and Haryana. Subhiksha, which has four channels— fruits and vegetables, pharmaceuticals, FMCG and telecom stores — to market its goods proposes to have all four categories of stores in the region. A sum of Rs 50 crore has been earmarked for the expansion of these stores in the first phase. R Subramanian, Managing Director of Subhiksha, says they have over 450 stores spread across Delhi, Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, Gujarat, Maharashtra and Tamil Nadu, and have made an outlay of Rs 500 crore for expansion so as to have 1,000 stores and a pan-India presence by the end of 2007.

Reliance Fresh has already earmarked Rs 27,000 crore for its retail business. The company currently has 71 stores under the brand name Reliance Fresh. In Punjab, the company plans to open 32 Reliance Fresh stores, while in Haryana, they propose to set shop in Ambala, Yamunanagar, Karnal, Panipat and Kurukshetra.

ITC Choupal, the first agri-retail venture to open shop in City Beautiful, has become quite popular. At present, ITC has three stores at Chandigarh, Hyderabad and Pune. Its outlet in Chandigarh, with over 150 footfalls a day.

Bharti Retail plans to invest $ 2-2.5 billion by 2015 in its pan-India operations. It is looking at approximately 10 million square feet of retail experience across all cities in India, with a population of over one million. It plans to employ 60,000 people. The company will launch its retail outlets in multiple consumer friendly formats, including hypermarkets and supermarkets. They will serve all regular shopping requirements of an Indian household—fruits, veggies, meat and poultry, dairy products, staples, processed foods besides other FMCG and consumer durables.

Adani Agri Fresh launched operations in Himachal Pradesh last year, when it procured a major chunk of apples from the hill state. The orchardists in the largest apple growing state in the country got a much better price from the agri-major and they were also spared the hassle of packaging their produce and transporting it to big markets in Delhi, Mumbai, Ahmedabad and Kolkata. They have already made an investment of Rs 110 crore in the hill state for setting up controlled atmosphere packaging and storage units. This year, the company plans to invest Rs 160 crore to set up its own cold chain of refrigerated vehicles for transporting apples, kiwi, almonds and peaches.

— RMK





HOME