Booty from war
When members of the British Expeditionary Force (BEF) to Lhasa in 1903-04 picked up or acquired souvenirs as booty or at nominal payment, none could have visualised their worth in terms of “intellectual property rights”, writes Lt General (retd) Baljit Singh

The Tibetan wild ass
The Tibetan wild ass (Kyang) is now close to extermination. However, it is protected in Ladakh

On November 18, 2006, there was an endearing pen-picture of the Lhasa Apso supported by two charming photographs in the Saturday Extra supplement of The Tribune. The male dog showcased his tawny-golden, fleecy coat at its luxuriant best. There is nothing quite to match his pelt in any other dog breed of the world. And in the other photograph, the puppy, of course, was a lovable bundle of mischief.

This dog breed was not known to mankind outside of Lhasa’s precincts till 1904, when Lt F.M. (Eric) Bailey of the British Expeditionary Force (BEF) chanced to encounter one strange-looking dog, cradled snugly inside the warm woollen apparel of a venerable old Tibetan woman.

Well, the British had launched an unethical and a totally unprovoked war on Tibet under the garb of establishing bilateral commerce. So a brigade-sized force comprising three infantry battalions (Sikh Pioneers, Gorkha and Royal Fusiliers) supported by two Maxim machine guns (the most lethal killers at that time) and four pieces of mountain artillery guns had set out to persuade and/or intimidate the Dalai Lama to accept British suzerainty over his country. The ill-equipped Tibetans were so out-matched that the very first firefight north of Chumbi village was like a dress rehearsal for the Jallianwallah Bagh atrocity. In less than half an hour, the BEF recorded 628 Tibetans dead and 222 wounded with no loss to them.

And the first booty of note from this was what we now know as the "Shahtoosh". This incredibly warm, smooth and lightweight wool comes from the inner pelt of a Chirru or the Tibetan Gazelle. To begin with, the BEF had laid siege to Khamba Dzong in southwestern Tibet in 1903 hoping to bring the Dalai Lama to the negotiating table. Much like what happened to Napoleon at Moscow, the Tibetans simply refused to take note of the BEF’s presence. Tired of waiting (which was to last for more than four months), the officers took to hunting. With the shooting of Chirrus was born the idea of exploitation of its wool for the commercial manufacture of the now infamous Shahtoosh shawl. That also marked the beginning of the end of this most elegant looking of all Gazelles. The Chirru is close to extinction today.

Many a trans-Himalayan butterflies and Alpine flowers, too, were encountered by the BEF not known to science till then. Both Col Sir Francis Younghusband, the diplomatic head of the BEF, and Lieut Eric Bailey were avid collectors. Today, one of the exotic lillies from the Chumbi Valley carries Younghushand’s name. And it was often stated in catalogues in the UK that the more eye-catching blooms in home-gardens of England and Europe were a result of the seeds of alpine flowers collected to begin with by Bailey from the Himalayas and the trans-Himalayas.

As the BEF advanced towards Lhasa, short of Gyantse, they came to a glacier called "The Field of Milk" by the Tibetans. In the scheme of Nature when winter recedes, the glaciers begin to melt triggering the flowering of plants and shrubs. It was on the fringes of this glacier that Eric Bailey discovered the dainty Blue Himalayan Poppy, promptly named "Meconopsis Baileyea", though now called "Meconopsis aculeata".

Once the BEF reached Lhasa around August (?) 1904, there was no Dalai Lama to confabulate with. So while Col Sir Francis Younghusband parleyed with the Dalai Lama’s Council of Ministers, the officers of the BEF once again spent their days in polo matches and horse races with the locals having the Pota La as the backdrop. They also visited monastries and Lhasa proper as any tourist would. It was on one such idle afternoon that Eric Bailey had spotted an old lady with her pet dog outside the Norbulingka, the Dalai Lama’s summer palace in the shadow of the Pota La. After days of canvassing with Lhasa’s affluent families, Eric Bailey did succeed in obtaining honourably three or five of these dogs which science later classified as of the Apso breed.

It would appear that Colonel Bailey first introduced this breed to the kennels of the world in October 1929 when he went on "home" leave. After lunching with him, Sir Francis Younghusband wrote to his daughter that "Eric Bailey has brought home thirteen Tibetan dogs and is going to make a fortune by them!"

But the acquisition of a booty, which required nerve and daring horsemanship was the lassoing of the Kyangs, the Tibetan wild Ass. In due course two were successfully lassoed. Unfortunately one drowned during the crossing of the Sangpo river as the BEF traced its steps back to India.

The one Kyang that survived was ultimately housed at the London Zoo. Much to the chagrin of the 7 Mountain Artillery Battery gunners who had lassoed it and justly considered it as their trophy, but somehow it became a custom with the Royal Fusiliers to borrow it from the zoo for a day when they paraded through the streets of London annually, as per an old tradition. But henceforth with a difference in as much that the Kyang also paraded as their Regimental Mascot!

That Tibetan Kyang lived happily to a ripe old age siring many offsprings with a female of the species procured from Mongolia. Those Kyangs on display in the London zoo today are said to be his bloodline!

With the passage of one hundred years, we may look at the floral and faunal booty, mostly acquired by the BEF from wilderness, with a sense of equanimity. But it would be hard to forgive Lt Col A Waddell, the senior medical officer and an amateur anthropologist, for the outright plunder of priceless Tankhas and tons of sacred manuscripts from monastries. The pity of it all is that nearly half were destroyed and damaged by rain, snow and damp before reaching the London Museum. Waddell published his account and justification in his book Lhasa and its Mysteries in 1905.

But it was left to Edmund Candler of the Daily Mail, who had accompanied the BEF, to sum up the deep-down human sorrow, at the soiling of Lhasa as it were, with the arrival of the BEF there in his book, The Unveiling of Lhasa (1905) thus: "It was impossible for the least sentimental to avoid a certain regret for the drawing back of that curtain that had meant so much to the imagination of mankind... With the unveiling of Lhasa fell the last stronghold of the older romance`85"

In hindsight it can now be said that the first decade of the 20th Century marked for the Tibetans "the end of living and the beginning of survival". These words were uttered in 1854 by the anguished Red Indian Chief Seattle when he and his tribe as indeed all other Red Indians too were dispossessed of their home and hearth and became refugees in the land of their forebears. That was the result of another booty of another war, though separated by oceans and continents from Tibet but in essence of the same consequences.





HOME