The Tribune - Spectrum
 
ART & LITERATURE
'ART AND SOUL
BOOKS
MUSINGS
TIME OFF
YOUR OPTION
ENTERTAINMENT
BOLLYWOOD BHELPURI
TELEVISION
WIDE ANGLE
FITNESS
GARDEN LIFE
NATURE
SUGAR 'N' SPICE
CONSUMER ALERT
TRAVEL
INTERACTIVE FEATURES
CAPTION CONTEST
FEEDBACK

Sunday, August 3, 2003
Lead Article

Illustration:Kuldip Dhiman

Did you know that Central India was the largest dinosaur nesting site in the world? The remains of the earliest as well as the most advanced forms of dinosaurs have been found here and India might have been the actual Jurassic Park millions of years ago, says Peeyush Agnihotri.

GEOLOGISTS go by the dictum — Present is the key to past. Thus, if fossilised dinosaur eggs and bones being dug out basketful from India are any indication, India might well have been the actual Jurassic Park millions of years ago, choc-a-bloc with lumbering sauropods and hopping theropods.

Dinosaurs sauntered around in India long ago. In fact, the country was their favourite haunt going by the fossil records. Central India has been reported to be the largest recorded dinosaur-nesting site anywhere in the world. The remains of the earliest species as well as the most advanced forms of dinosaurs have been found in India. Indian dinosaur nesting sites cover an area of more than 10,000 square km.

Paleo basics

Lest the issue gets complicated, let’s start with the basics first. Geological timescale is broadly divided into Paleozoic, Mesozoic and Cenozoic eras. The Paleozoic era spans a timescale between 250 and 550 million years ago when amphibians, fish and land plants ruled the earth. Then came the Mesozoic era spread over 185 million years (65 million years to 250 million years) encasing dinosaurs, birds and flowering plants. This was followed by the Cenozoic era that started 65 million years ago. Mammals and modern day man evolved during this time.

 


Mesozoic era itself was sub divided into Triassic, Jurassic and Cretaceous periods. Triassic period that was between 206 and 250 million years ago saw first dinosaurs evolve. Jurassic extended from 144 to 204 million years and dinosaurs proliferated. It was during this time that birds too came into being. During Cretaceous, flowering plants appeared and dinosaurs became extinct.

Nesting hub

It was the Mesozoic era when dinosaurs ruled our planet Earth. Sauropods were the large herbivores and Theropods were the carnivorous kind. Their fossils have been known to exist since 1818 but the term ‘dinosaur’ (deinos means terrifying and sauros means lizard) as such was coined by Sir Richard Owen in 1842. The actual dino hunt in true sense of terms began globally in the 19th century. Dinosaur remains have been found from China, Patagonia, USA, Mongolia, Europe and most importantly, India.

In India, a skeleton led to the identification of a dinosaur, later named Titanosaurus, that was nearly three times the height of an average man and 12 metres long.

Distribution of dinasaur eggs and nests in India
Distribution of dinosaur eggs and nests in India.

The interesting part is that though people in India kept on bumping into fossilised tooth and bone fragments of these large animals for centuries yet nobody knew about dinosaurs. Some thought that these bones, skeletal remains and tooth came from dragons. In Gujarat, tribal worshipped oblong stones, considering them to be a sacred deity, while they actually were fossilised dino eggs. The Kutch region itself has yielded more than 2,000 such eggs. In India more than 10,000 eggs have been documented with all of them occurring in ancient soil horizons and other sediments interbedded with the volcanic outpourings of the Deccan Traps. The egg fossils have been reported from Gujarat, Rajasthan, Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu and Karnataka.

Ashok Sahni, an eminent palaeontologist from Panjab University, Chandigarh, who has been associated with dinosaur studies in India, has an interesting anecdote to narrate. "In October 1982, when I was attending a seminar in Ahmedabad, a young Geological Survey of India (GSI) officer came to inquire about a spherical 18 cm object from me. Such objects were apparently unearthed during the blasting operations of the then existing ACC cement factory at Balasinor and the "cannon balls", as they were commonly known, decorated the shelves of the mine manager’s office. We recognised the "cannon ball" to be dinosaurian egg and within a year’s time, GSI unearthed several hundreds of them from the area," he recalls.

Clay-silica models depicting hatching
Clay-silica models depicting hatching

Thousands of fossilised dinosaur eggs have been reported from Pisdura, Maharashtra. Ostensibly, a nesting site for sauropods. Villagers here while ploughing also unearthed fossilised remains of cattle and other mammals. This point out to the fact that it might have been the ‘youngest’ egg find till date. Perhaps, that region was the last place to have harboured dinosaurs before they actually disappeared giving way to birds and mammals.

India, at that time, was not what it is today. The Indian landmass was in the southern hemisphere then. Later, the landmass made its journey northwards nearly 60 million years ago colliding into the then Asia and giving rise to Himalayas. A place of interest is Um Shorengkew in Meghalaya where Himalayas might have buckled backwards after collision as dinosaur fossils have been excavated from here an otherwise rare occurrence from the Himalayan region.

Why India?

Sahni observes: "India has the largest number of eggs and nests from a single time interval (68 to 65 million years ago) representing the Lamenta Formation sediments which are believed to have been deposited at the time of Deccan volcanic activity. Other countries, such as China, Mongolia and the USA have several horizons from which dinosaur eggs have been isolated, but not from a single formation, as in India. What actually counts in the preservation of eggs is really not how many eggs were laid but how many of these were preserved as fossils. The process of fossilisation is selective and as we all know eggs tend to rot easily. For preservation of the Indian dinosaur eggs, it is believed that frequent flooding and covering of nests and eggs by sediments led to better preservation. There is evidence of flooding in the Lamenta sediments where nests have been found. On the surface on which the nests and eggs are exposed, we find pebbles of fairly large size, which could only have been brought there by flood waters."

Prithiraj Chungkham, a gold medalist geologist and Senior Basin Researcher currently based in Singapore, avers that dinosaurs could have travelled thousands of miles to nest or lay eggs in India.

"Findings of fossilised dinosaur eggs, along with bones, are rare where one can conclude with a very high degree of certainty that they were preserved in situ without having been subjected to any weathering and transportation. In bone-only finds, which now occur in almost all continents, there is still a possibility that the bones had suffered weathering and transportation before being preserved as it can withstand some degree of both the nature agents unlike the eggs. Thus any sedimentary horizon yielding dinosaur ‘bones-only’ does not necessarily represent the prevailing environment where the dinosaurs lived. In contrast, any sedimentary horizon yielding dinosaur eggs, with or without bones, will content useful geological signatures which will throw plenty of lights on the prevailing environmental conditions where the dinosaurs lived and died.

An intriguing question is why these dinosaur eggs sites are so rare and not widespread as the bone sites? Is it simply and only because eggs did not get preserved as easily as the bones or did dinosaurs travel thousands of miles to specific nesting sites, like the certain modern-day salmon fish, which swims all the way from the sea upstream along the rivers to specific fresh water sites to lay eggs?

Dino demise

Various theories are being postulated as to why dinosaurs became extinct. Scientists have suggested various theories from sea-level changes, vulcanism, meteorite strike to biotic extinction. What actually happened no one knows. However, the most accepted theory is that of a meteorite strike.

Rajeev Patnaik, principal investigator, Department of Science and Technology and National Geographic Project, opines that dinosaurs might have become extinct when an asteroid with a diameter of 10 km hit Central America 65 million years ago, forming the Chicxulub crater in Yucatan Peninsula, Mexico. "If we observe closely, the Indian Deccan traps are bang opposite the area of strike on the globe. This asteroid hit could have induced heavy volcanic activity in India resulting in the death of dinosaurs," he says. Patnaik is actively involved with the dinosaur gallery that is coming up in Chandigarh though he himself is a hominid expert. (see box).

Samples collected from rock strata where dino fossils have been found, indicate a very high level of iridium content, almost 30 times more than that is present under normal circumstances. There are two main sources of iridium, the main source comes from outer space in the form of cosmic dust and a second source is the Earth’s core when there are eruptions of certain types of volcano. So in any case, either dinosaurs became extinct due to a meteorite hit or due to intense volcanic activity induced by the strike.

Prithiraj adds pragmatically: "What wiped out the dinosaur? Was it meteorites from the space or extensive volcanism or drastic climate change or combination of all these calamities? Or simply was it something that dinosaurs were so dependent upon ran out of stock? Careful investigation of the dinosaur egg-bearing rocks will certainly throw lights on these questions, which will not only enlighten the scientific minds but also the general public. Discoveries of such rare sites of unique importance by our hardworking geoscientists deserves general applaud and better support from our government and financial institutes."

The general view among the geological fraternity is that dinosaurs died and birds evolved from them. So do dinosaurs now exist as birds? Or have they been buried down forever as fossils. That’s a dino-sized enigma concealed under zillion layers of rocky strata.
Top

 

“Rampant mining hampers research”

 Ashok Sahni
Ashok Sahni

RAMPANT mining is hampering the study of Indian dinosaurs and their nesting sites, according to Ashok Sahni, an eminent paleontologist, who is actively associated with the dinosaur studies in India.

"For villagers, fossils hold no significance and site digging goes on unbridled. This has been brought to the notice of Deputy Commissioners of respective places, who too are equally seized of the matter, yet nothing substantial has been done to stop it.

Sahni says though there are laws and Acts to stop this yet enforcing them has become difficult. "Earlier, a meagre sum was paid to the site’s caretaker but that could not stop the digging operations," he says.

Sahni, who holds a Ph.D degree in geology from the University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, and is currently a Professor in the Department of Geology, Panjab University, Chandigarh, says the finding of a juvenile skeleton from the nest indicated that parental care was prevalent among dinos.

The professor, who is going to present a paper on biomechanics and orientation of dinosaur eggs at Montpeiler, France, this month says evidence from fossil site does not point towards site fidelity among these lumbering creatures. In simple terms, it means dinosaur did not return to a chosen spot to lay eggs. He says that had it been so fossilised eggs would have been found in vertical layers.

Top

 

Dinosaurs in Chandigarh

Models adorn the floor in the dinosaur gallery of the Chandigarh museum
Models adorn the floor in the dinosaur gallery of the Chandigarh museum. — Photo Parvesh Chauhan

Dinosaurs may have proliferated in Central India but a gallery on these humungous creatures, the first of its kind in North, is fast coming up in City Beautiful. A section of Government Museum and Art Gallery, Sector 10, Chandigarh, will be totally dedicated to these mesmerising beings.

The project started a year ago when experts from CAS in Geology, Panjab University, and Lt Gen. JFR Jacob, the then Governor of Chandigarh, expressed a keen desire to have something of this kind in Chandigarh to make people, especially school kids, aware about such colossal reptiles. The Museum Advisory Committee then gave a go-ahead to this venture.

Rajeev Patnaik, who is actively involved with the project as an artist as well as visualiser, explains: "The gallery will have all information related to dinosaurs. Models and fibre-glass replicas have been made and actual fossils from the personal collection of top palaeontologists will be exhibited."

Patnaik, an inculcated palaeontologist and an inborn artist, has made Archaeopteryx, the fossil bird that evolved from dinos, himself using clay and sculpting material. He painstakingly studies the dinosaur bodies and sculpts out mini-dinosaurs strictly according to scale and dimensions. "This is an arduous job and each model may take weeks to finish," he says. Some dinosaur models have also been brought from Kolkata while local artists are being involved in making some more of them.

Two-dimensional frames depicting the paleoenvironment during the Mesozoic era are already on display. So is a 10-foot- long, dinosaur-fossilised imprint. The thrust is on recreating the whole ambience that existed nearly 100 million years ago. Fossilised eggs adorn the showcase along with clay-silica models of eggs depicting how baby dinos wriggled out of them.

Dinosaur footprints are being given a finishing touch on a cement track and fibreglass models of Sauropods, Barapasaurus, Indosuchus, Kotasaurus and Tyrranosauros, still under polythene wraps, will be put up for public viewing shortly.

"Dinosaurs existed in terrestrial environment and therefore a lot of fossils have been found from the Deccan plateau. In Himalayas and North India, marine fossils abound since Himalayas were once under the sea. Therefore, this area is bereft of dinosaur remains and eggs," Patnaik says.

This gallery is scheduled for inauguration by October, according to V.N. Singh, director of the museum.
Top

Home

A few interesting facts

  • Dinosaurs were reptiles and young ones hatched from eggs.

  • The oldest known dinosaur is Eoraptor that inhabited the Earth 228 million years ago.

  • The tallest dinosaur was Brachiosaurus nearly 26 m tall.

  • The smallest dinosaur was Mussaurus that stood at 37 cm.

  • The plant-eating Hadrosaur had nearly 960 cheek teeth.

  • Diplodocus had a 43-feet long tail.

  • The largest dinosaur egg discovered is of Hypselosaurus that measures one foot.

  • The first fossilised egg was found in France in 1869

  • Dinosaur brains were just 1/2,50,000th of their body weight

  • There are 500 described dinosaur genera.

  • The oldest Indian dinosaur fossil has been found in Andhra Pradesh.

Top