The
multi-faceted personality of Gurnam Singh
By S.S. Dhanoa
THE political history of Punjab
after 1947 has been greatly influenced by the
vicissitudes and policies of the Shiromani Akali Dal. The
credit for the partition of Punjab is claimed by the
Shiromani Akali Dal. The historians of the Shiromani
Akali Dal have called the present Punjab and Haryana as a
gift of the Akali Dal to India. The Indian National Congress that came to power after 1947
would not form a coalition with the Akali Dal but was
ready to en-bloc admit all Akali leaders into the Indian
National Congress. Quite a few of them reached the top
positions of political power in India like Sardar Hukam
Singh, Sardar Swaran Singh and Sardar Buta Singh and many
others. However, at the grassroot level both the parties
did not insist on merger, nor did the Congress leaders
find anything objectionable in having with them leaders
who had been branded as communal before they joined the
Congress.
Every time the Akali Dal
leadership went over to the Congress, new leaders
standing for the Akali Dal ideology were thrown up by the
grassroot units of the party. They would espouse an
exaggerated concern for the Sikh identity and highlight
cases of discrimination against the Sikhs even when in
many cases it was known that the grievance or alleged
transgression against the Sikh sentiments had an element
of make-believe in it. There was a vacuum in the Sikh
leadership for sometime after the 1957 merger of the
Akali Dal with Indian National Congress. Master Tara
Singh, the sole Akali Dal leader for decades, had not
opposed the merger but he did not join the Indian
National Congress. He soon set about reviving the Akali
Dal mainly on the plank of fighting for achieving a
rightful place for Punjabi language, which later changed
to establishment of the Punjabi Suba.
This was a period when the
leadership vacuum of the Akali Dal came to be filled by
the joining of Justice Gurnam Singh. He had graduated
from the Forman Christian College of Lahore and he was
called to the Bar from the Middle Temple, London. He was
a brilliant sports man and a champion athlete of Panjab
University. He had captained the university hockey team.
He was appointed judge of the High Court in 1950 , and he
retired in 1959 moving thereafter to the Akali Dal.
The birth of the Akali Dal
was from the milieu of the gurdwara reform movement and
the national freedom movement under the leadership of
Mahatma Gandhi. The Akali Dal, therefore, had a national
agenda and a particularistic agenda of presumed Sikh
interests. Gurnam Singh came to the Akali Dal at a time
when the Akali commitment for the national agenda was
very weak and the commitment for the presumed Sikh
interests was very strong. The Akali leadership changed
for the first time after decades. Master Tara Singh got
replaced by Sant Fateh Singh. The Akali Dal under Master
Tara Singh gave an impression that they were fighting for
the establishment of a Punjabi- speaking state in order
to achieve a Sikh majority state. Sant Fateh Singh gave a
call that his objective was only to have a Punjabi-
speaking state established like other linguistic states
in India. This secular stand of Sant Fateh Singh was
something close to the heart of Gurnam Singh. It was the
progressive ideology of Gurnam Singh which made Sant
Fateh Singh to decide to project Gurnam Singh as a leader
of the legislative wing of the Shiromani Akali Dal. He
was the leader of the Opposition in the Punjab
Legislative Assembly from 1962 to 1967. This was the
crucial period when at last the demand for
Punjabi-speaking state got conceded. Gurnam Singh was
able to build an acceptability for himself and for the
Akali Dal among the national leaders, which helped in
diluting resistance to the formation of the
Punjabi-speaking state. He became Chief Minister of
Punjab heading a coalition government after the elections
in 1967. His was a unique coalition government where the
Leftists and Rightists both joined to support his
government. It seems that the grassroot leaders of the
Akali Dal who were interested in petty advantages and
favours from the local administration fell foul of Sardar
Gurnam Singh because he would not interfere in the
administration at the behest of the local Akali
jathedars. This brought about an estrangement between
Gurnam Singh and Sant Fateh Singh. Combined with other
factors of political instability and internal dissension
within the Akali Dal, the government of Gurnam Singh
could not complete its term. Indira Gandhi, whose
Congress party was instrumental in pulling down the
government of Sardar Gurnam Singh, yet recognising his
merit, appointed him as the Indian High Commissioner to
Australia.
Gurnam Singh had ambitious
plans for the Punjabis in Australia but before those
plans could take shape, he died in an air crash in 1973.
The problem that Gurnam
Singh faced as an enlightened leader of the Akali Dal has
been a perennial problem with the leaders of the party. A
set of Akali leaders go for radicalising the Sikh masses
in order to create their constituency among them. The
idiom they use for this purpose is the idiom and
tradition harking back to the 18th century when the
Khalsa was on the top in Punjab. This idiom does not
easily permit them to adjust and accommodate the
compulsions and requirements of running a modern secular
state.
So far no Akali Chief
Minister has been able to complete his term of office of
five years. Badal had to face a fall when he could not
carry the Jan Sangh with him over the extension of the
jurisdiction of the Guru Nanak Dev University to DAV
institutions of Jalandhar. Barnala could not achieve the
balance between maintaining law and order in the state,
which is a primary responsibility of the state
government, and the freedom to be permitted to the
radicals and extremists among the Sikhs. Badal is again
face-to-face with the contradiction of the Akali
governance where the peace and order in the state has to
be the first priority of the state government, and if the
interests of the public so require, the particularistic
Sikh agenda has got to be placed on the back-burner. This
is a situation which is inherent in the reality that
prevails in Punjab. The decades of terrorism in Punjab
have taught the people that peace can prevail if the
majority community, i.e. the Sikhs, are free from the
feeling that some of their vital interests were being
jeopardised by the government in power. It was this
feeling which made the Punjabis vote for the Akali Dal in
the last elections.
Badal seems to understand
it well. Therefore, he has always been emphatic that
peace of the Punjab will not be allowed to be compromised
at any cost. However, the fear that Punjab is on the
brink of a precipice again seems to be exaggerated.
Punjab at present does not have an ideologue, a
charismatic leader or even a demagogue capable of playing
on the sentiments of the Sikhs to lead them to a path of
destruction. The massive support for Badals faction
among all the factions of the Akali Dal when he faced the
manoeuvring of the Akali Takht and went ahead to forge an
alliance with the Bharatiya Janata Party is indicative of
the fact that the Sikh masses are no longer prepared to
permit a destructive emotional blackmail. It is well to
remember that the problems that Badal is facing are of
the same type that came up before Gurnam Singh, whose
birth anniversary fell on February 25.
|