N E W S I N ..D E T A I L |
Monday, August 2, 1999 |
weatherspotlight today's calendar |
Indira feared coup from Sam NEW DELHI, Aug 1 (PTI) Field Marshal Sam Manekshaw has made a startling disclosure that Prime Minister Indira Gandhi was apprehensive in 1970 that he was trying to stage a coup and take over from her. The 85-year-old former Army chief told Karan Thapar in "Face-to-Face" programme on BBC television that Ms Gandhis stock politically was very low in 1970 and that he couldnt go to cocktail parties as he was always being questioned about a possibility of his taking over the reins of power. Even a US diplomat had asked him at a party, "When are you taking over", he remembered when queried if stories that he was going to take over were true. He said one day a worried Ms Gandhi asked him to come to Parliament House and "looked me straight into my eyes and said you are my problem". Shaken up, Field Marshal Manekshaw, the hero of the 1971 Indo-Pak conflict, said "I put my nose next to hers and said what do you think?" "She said you cant. Do you think I am so incompetent (Manekshaw replied). I didnt mean that Sam. You woundnt," he recalled Ms Gandhi as having argued. The former Army chief said he related a "little jingle" to the Prime Minister that "you mind your own business and I"ll mind mine. You kiss your own sweetheart and Ill kiss mine. I dont interfere politically as long as nobody interferes with me in the Army". Asked if that set her fears at rest, he said, "thats right". Field Marshal Manekshaw said it was after the 1971 conflict that Ms Gandhi elevated him to the rank of Field Marshal but did not offer him the job of Chief of Defence Staff to go with it. But she did offer him the post of High Commissioner in the UK and the office of Maharashtra Governor, both of which he declined, he said. Asked about setbacks during the war in which he had brought Pakistan down to its knees in 13 days, he said on the fifth day of the conflict he told Ms Gandhi that "everything had gone wrong. The Navy lost the Khukri. The Air Force lost a lot of aircraft on the ground. My advances in Bangladesh were halted". "She looked at me and smiled and said you cant win everyday, Sam. And then she turned around and said anyway we will not tell anybody ... Let everybody know that nothing has happened". On his equation with Ms Gandhi, he said, "Well, she and I got on well. She trusted me and I trusted her. I never kept anything back from her and she never kept anything back from me". He said he chose December 4, 1971, to launch the offensive against Pakistan as four was his lucky number. Asked as to what extent did he win in Bangladesh, Field Manekshaw said "Pakistan Army in East Pakistan fought very gallantly. But they had no chance. They were a thousand miles away from their base. And I had eight or nine months to make my preparations. I had a superiority of almost 50 to one...". He said it was true that he had written a personal letter to Pakistani Captain S.R. Malik for defending his garrison in Kamalpur in Bangladesh "stoutly" despite "hard" Indian attempts to capture it. "We did not succeed until about the third attempt....", he revealed. The former chief said he had even recommended Captain Maliks name for a gallantry award to the Pakistani Army Chief during his (Manekshaws) visit to that country later. To a question why he did not migrate to Pakistan as he belonged to the Frontier Force Regiment, he recalled that Mohammad Ali Jinnah "did ask me. But I said I have finished commanding. I am now an Indian, I have married an Indian girl and now I am here". Asked what would have happened if he had gone to Pakistan, the Field Marshal said in a lighter vein "I should have won the war....I would have thrashed you". Referring to his days in the 1930s during World War II "Burma campaign", he said "the Japanese had put nine bullets into my stomach. My lungs, liver, kidneys, intestines everything was perforated. Nobody thought I would live". In the early 1960s, he said the then Defence Minister V.K. Krishna Menon did not like him and "did everything to get me out of the Army" including ordering a court of inquiry against him. He said when he first met Menon, he asked him what did he think of then Army Chief Gen K.S. Thimayya. "I was a Major-General. I said I am not allowed to think about him. He is my Commander-in-Chief. Menon said I can get rid of him (Thimayya) tomorrow. "I in my breezy way said good. Today you are asking me as a Major-General what I think of my chief. Tomorrow you will be asking Brigadiers and Colonels what do they think of me. It is the surest way of ruining discipline. Dont do it, Mr Minister," he said. Field Marshal Manekshaw said he was exonerated by the court of inquiry comprising three Generals but denied promotion for 18 months. "Then the Chinese
came to my help. Krishna Menon was sacked...," he
added. |
| Nation
| Punjab | Haryana | Himachal Pradesh | Jammu & Kashmir | Chandigarh | | Editorial | Business | Sports | | Mailbag | Spotlight | World | 50 years of Independence | Weather | | Search | Subscribe | Archive | Suggestion | Home | E-mail | |